2010 Hillsdale News FLAG
IssueTopIssue #141r2
Posted March 1, 2015    
Also in This Issue
* Food Front considers two board candidates from Hillsdale
* Solar Expo set for May 3
* Norm's Garden to close on Barbur

Join Our Mailing List Write e-mail address HERE!

Write your e-mail address or that of a Hillsdale neighbor in above box 

topofcommentary
Views of the News 

Our future is NOW in Hillsdale   

Olympia TypewriterSingle decisions that shape a community for decades are rare and often hard to pinpoint.

Years ago, the Kalapuya people, who gathered camas root and wapato in the Willamette Valley and fished in the Willamette River, discovered a "passing through" place through the mountains that stood between their vital, seasonal sources of food.

Archeologists will tell you that their route from the west followed Fanno Creek to its headwaters (where the aptly named "Watershed Building" stands) and then down the canyon where thousands of commuters travel to this day on Capitol Highway. The rest of the trail is still evident in the remains of Slavin Road.

That ancient decision eventually put our community on the map: Capitol Highway became the main route to Salem...hence the highway's name.

Another formative decision was made by the pioneering Wardin Family, which in the early 1950s decided to sell the bulk of their Fulton Park Dairy to the Portland School District. Significantly, the family decided to retain their commercial strip along Capitol Highway. Wardin descendants own it and manage it to this day.

Again, a single decision shaped Hillsdale.

Another landmark decision, as recently as the mid-1990's, was the reconfiguration of two designated neighborhoods sharing a border demarcated by Capitol Highway. In a vote, residents decided to merge parts of the old neighborhoods (Wilson Park and Bridlemile-Robert Gray) into a new one, HIllsdale.  The decision put Capitol Highway and the commercial area, The Hillsdale Town Center, at the "heart" of Hillsdale.

I cite these formative decisions because we now face another one that could define our future.

Will Hillsdale be connected by light rail tunnel directly to OHSU, placing our neighborhood two stops away from downtown Portland?

Neighbors are grappling with that question at Hillsdale Neighborhood Association meetings (see accompanying story in this issue). The next meeting will be Wednesday, March 4 at St. Barnabas, Church, 2201 SW Vermont, at 7 p.m.

At the meeting, the pros and cons will be listed. In the last month, more "cons" have emerged. The discussion should be informative, lively - and possibly historic.

While opinion in Hillsdale is important, the ultimate decision will be left to a Southwest Corridor Plan Steering Committee of regional elected and appointed leaders. A major obstacle to approval of the 2.35-mile-long tunnel is the estimated $1.3 billion price tag.

As more details about the tunnel options emerge, my own view has shifted. Like several others, I initially thought the tunnel would be a real asset for Hillsdale, but now I have my doubts. They largely echo those cited in the accompanying story.

The least expensive "High-capacity Transit" route follows Barbur Boulevard. Hillsdale's frequent Beaverton-Hillsdale Highway bus lines will continue because the Southwest Corridor Plan doesn't include state-of-the-art high-capacity-transit service to Beaverton. Under the Southwest transit plan, if it is approved (and that's also a big "if") the Town Center's transit facilities would be improved to provide new connections to a Barbur HCR line.

I doubt future historians will look back on a "no" decision about a Hillsdale tunnel and long for "what might have been."

Indeed, lightning-fast technological change and "history" may render Light Rail, buses and automobiles obsolete. Diminutive, self-guided, on call, fuel-cell-powered transit pods, anyone?

Rick Seifert
Editor

Clarification

Lisa De Graaf, the new chair of the Hillsdale Neighborhood Emergency team, says that If there is a major earthquake here, neighbors should be aware that the Wilson High School football field is a City-designated BEECN (for "Basic earthquake emergency communication node"). It's the place to go in Hillsdale after a major earthquake in order to seek emergency assistance if phone service is down or to report severe damage or injury.

De Graaf encourages families in the neighborhoods to have a plan and have on hand necessary supplies. Hillsdale NET will help organize and guide neighbors to obtaining emergency preparedness resources.

A story about NET in the last issue didn't include this information.

Return to top of commentary

Letters to the editor are always welcome. Write  editor@hillsdalenews.org
Hillsdale News Sponsors  Salon Dirk 2-11 ad

Ready your skin for summer!   


 Spa Haircolor Salon Dirk site

Jeff Devine sponsorship ad

Visit Devine web site



Contact HERE for more information
 

   




Your store, Your values!

 Visit Food Front site

Hypnotherapist ad 

 Debbie Taylor-Lilly's site here

  

UPS sponsorship

  

Hillsdale UPS store site here  


 
Visit Hillsdale Veterinary Hospital

Transit options attracted a large group at February's neighborhood association meeting. In the lower left is Metro Council member Bob Stacey, co-chair of the SWCP Steering Committee.
SW Transit Corridor plan: 
Underground options questioned, criticized 

As Hillsdale finds out more about options for high-capacity mass transit in the Southwest Transit Corridor, more folks are looking skeptically at the possible tunnel routes through or beneath the Hillsdale Town Center.

And differences are surfacing, which is hardly surprising given the complexities, costs and uncertainties involved.

Early opinion last year at the Hillsdale Neighborhood Association and the Hlllsdale Business & Professional Association favored a Light Rail tunnel under the Town Center. As it turns out the route would have a 145-foot-deep-underground stop in the Town Center. The 2.35-mile-long tunnel, currently estimated to cost $1.3 billion, would go directly to OHSU and then Downtown.

During and after a well-attended presentation at the February 4 Hillsdale Neighborhood Association meeting, several residential property owners aired serious concerns about the long tunnel and about an alternative much shorter and shallower "cut-and-cover" tunnel route through the Town Center.

The neighborhood association will resume the discussion at its Wednesday, March 4, meeting (7 p.m., St. Barnabas Church, 2201 SW Vermont St.)

Association president Mikal Apenes said wide discussion is needed. "It was clear from the February meeting that we, as a community are a long way from forming a consensus on what would be the best route for Hillsdale. Several of the attendees are just learning of this project. Newer residents, in fact, all residents of Hillsdale, should have the opportunity to learn about the project and voice their concerns and opinions. Which route Hillsdale supports should not be left to the two dozen or so regular attendees of our meetings."

On Monday, March 9, the Southwest Corridor Plan Steering Committee, consisting of top elected and transit agency officials, will meet at the Tigard Public Library to hear issues that have been raised here and elsewhere in Southwest Portland. For directions and more about the meeting go HERE.

On July 9th, the powerful Steering Committee will be asked to act on a staff recommendation as to whether to continue including the Marquam Hill-Hillsdale bored tunnel, or the shallow, short-cut-and-cover" tunnel. (The short tunnel is called "cut and cover" because it involves simply digging a deep trench for transit and then covering it so that vehicular traffic on the street can travel above.)

The tunnel alignments would the use Light Rail rather than large, articulated buses featuring dedicated lanes.

The other option is to avoid the Town Center entirely and simply build Light Rail or "Bus Rapid Transit" down Barbur Boulevard. Marquam Hill could be served indirectly via elevators either from Barbur or an optional Naito Parkway extension route, said Noelle Dobson, a Metro public affairs specialist.

Another option is a short tunnel to Marquam Hill coming off Barbur in the Lair Hill area. (See map, below right)

Tunnel-versus-surface decision

The July decision "is more a question of tunnel versus surface access," Dobson said.

She added that the Steering committee always has the discretion to say it needs more information or is not ready to make a decision.

The construction of the shallow "cut and cover" tunnel under Capitol Highway in the Town Center would likely have a short-term, but negative impact on small businesses. Yet another potential route for the shallow tunnel would be under the Rieke soccer field with a stop at Sunset and Capitol Highway.

Some 50 neighbors showed up at the meeting on Feb. 4 to hear Tri-Met and Metro staff explain the numerous options under consideration. The entire Southwest Corridor project would stretch from downtown to Tigard and Tualatin. Those two communities have also raised objections to the entire project through ballot measures.

Whether it uses big articulated buses or Light Rail, the project, which would be completed in 20 to 25 years, is intended to provide alternative transit to the use of I-5, already approaching capacity during rush hours.

Among those objecting to the tunnel routes through the Hillsdale Town Center was Wilson Park resident Carol Brimhall. Following the Feb. 4 meeting, she listed her concerns to Metro staff in a letter. The neighborhood is already jammed with park-and-ride cars, hindering patronage at local businesses, she wrote adding that an additional transit station will worsen the problem. 

She noted that Hillsdale is already served by seven bus lines. Residents wanting a faster commute could connect with a Barbur-only HCT line.

Cost is another issue. What will the tax burden be? she asked. Who will pay for the tunnel? Answers to the questions aren't yet available. Brimhall suggested that if OHSU wants the tunnel, it should pay for it.

Officials overseeing the planning hope that the Federal government will pick up half the tab of the entire project. Excluding the tunnel, the project is estimated to cost $1.8 billion.

Brimhall and others raised seismic concerns as Hillsdale straddles a fault and has numerous underground streams. The entire West Hills are in a "potential landslide zone."

Brimhall emphasized that she supports high capacity transit and that a Barbur route offers an "excellent option."


Bad vibrations

Some homeowners in Wilson Park also wonder what tunnel vibrations, during and after construction, would mean to their neighborhood. Tunnel construction also requires underground blasting.

Tunnel-boring equipment
Another critic is Hillsdale orthodontist Richard Garfinkle, who has been active in the community's civic affairs for decades and prior to  the Feb. 4 meeting was generally supportive of the tunnel option. Garfinkle and his son, Judah, also an orthodontist, recently moved their office from Sunset Boulevard in the Town Center to a location on Bertha Boulevard. The office is next to at least one of the route options under consideration for HCT.

Garfinkle said in an e-mail to the Hillsdale News that he has been reconsidering pros and cons since the meeting. "I was surprised by my conclusions..." he said.

He said he likes the idea of government building needed infrastructure and the tunnel idea looks "sexy." But now he wonders what an alignment through Hillsdale's Town Center would do for business and the community.

He noted that Metro experts at the meeting anticipate very little population growth in Hillsdale and neighboring Bridlemile. He echoed Brimhall in noting how well Hillsdale is served by transit now.

He wrote: "We don't need a tunnel to get us one stop north and up or down the hill to OHSU from here. Nor to downtown...." And, he added, Hillsdale doesn't commute "heavily to the south."

A relatively short, shallow cut-and-cover tunnel is built in four stages.

He offered that "Hillsdale is not now nor will it ever be a destination with a capital 'D'. The SW Transit through the Town Center will stimulate very few 'get offs' INTO Hillsdale."

Instead bus service through Hillsdale needs to be "reconceptualized." He suggests "a local web-like approach" with possible "on-call service."  "We need to be able to get down and up the West Hills and connect to the SW Transit Corridor."

Some have suggested that transit technology is changing so fast that any decision made today will be obsolete by the time construction is complete.

But others see potential in Hillsdale becoming a center for medical offices, a kind of OHSU west, if the tunnel is built connecting the community directly to Marquam Hill.

Waiting for engineering details

Dave Aulwes, a Tri-Met senior transit corridor designer, tried to answer some of the questions being raised but noted that details will have to wait until mid-April when a report from geo-technical engineers is expected.

As presently designed, a Hillsdale Town Center stop would be 145 feet beneath the surface requiring passengers to use an elevator. For comparison's sake. the current Light Rail tunnel, the "Robertson Tunnel" at the Zoo station in Washington Park, is 260 feet deep.

He said that the portion of the tunnel under Wilson Park would be between 155 feet and 100 feet underground.  Construction time  for the entire tunnel is now "conservatively" estimated to be five years. That's how long it took to build the the 2.93-mile-long Robertson Tunnel in the mid-'90s.

The actual start date for construction is estimated to be somewhere between 10 and 20 years from now, said Metro's Dobson.

Alwes said that those who worked on the Robertson tunnel recall that "tunneling activity was definitely perceptible from above" but "there were no instances where building or other properties were determined to be damaged as a result of the tunneling operation."

For more on the plan go to www.oregonmetro.gov/southwestcorridor, for information about Steering Committee meeting dates and locations. For more information, contact Dobson, Noelle.dobson@oregonmetro.gov or
(503) 797-1745.

Food Front considers two Hillsdale board candidates

Following resignations of half its membership in four months, the Food Front board has interviewed two potential members from Hillsdale. Presently the three-members board has no representatives from this community.

As of a Feb. 26 board meeting open to Food Front members, the board hadn't determined how many new members to add - or when. Under its by-laws it could add as many as six or none at all, maintaining a minimum of three.

The interviews with candidates Ted Coonfield and Dave Hawkins were in closed executive session. No one else has so far stepped forward to apply for the board.

Those appointed by the board could serve immediately but would have to be confirmed by Food Front owner/members in a vote at the annual membership meeting in September.

Sales up in Hillsdale

Meanwhile, in an inaugural issue of a Food Front "Owners' Business Update," Food Front management reported that sales at the HIllsdale store in January were up by 3.9 percent over a year ago. In another positive sign, the customer count in Hillsdale was up 37.5 per day.

But sales were down 5.2 percent at the flagship Thurman Street store. The end of disruptive remodeling at the West Burnside Fred Meyer store accounted for some of Food Front's loss, according to the update.

Food Front has lost money for six consecutive years, and last fall its top management faced public criticism from some past and present staff who claimed they were unfairly treated. An outside consultant also reported to the board that staff morale and complaints needed to be addressed.

In response to the financial and administrative problems, the Food Front board invited the National Cooperative Grocers (NCG) organization, based in Iowa City, Iowa, to advise and guide Food Front.

NCG sent Peg Nolan to share many of general manager Holly jarvis' duties temporarily. At the board meeting Nolan explained that while she, not Jarvis, now represents management to the board, Jarvis  maintains her role as general manager. Once Nolan leaves, she said, it will be left to the board to decide on Jarvis' position. How long Nolan will remain has not been determined.

In an interview with the Hillsdale News, Nolan listed several changes she and managers are implementing at Food Front's two stores. Among them are making sure items are in stock, tidying up, upgrading equipment, ensuring more timely financial reporting and cutting labor costs. Nolan said that staff is being better informed and being involved more through a team approach.

She said that the changes are getting Food Front closer to meeting its financial projections.

Food Front still needs to increase the number of sales to owners, who number 10,000. At cooperatives nationally about 65 percent of sales are to owners, she said, adding that at Food Front's two stores the number is 50 percent.
Hillsdale Solar Expo set
New installations to help Hillsdale's schools

If you have been thinking about installing photovoltaic solar panels , Sunday, May 3, could provide you with a tipping point.
 
Working with a small cadre calling itself the Hillsdale Solar Coalition, Hillsdale resident Andrew Ragland has been pulling together Solar Expo plans with Erica Meyers, the business manager of Wilson High School. Ragland is a Fellow with the Portland-based SAGE Foundation and is on the board of the Hillsdale Community Foundation.

The exact location of the Expo hasn't been determined, but organizers would like it to be near the Farmer's Market.
 
The idea behind the Expo is simple:  Multiple solar installations will drive down the average installation cost per home.  Hillsdale Solar Coalition plans to redirect the savings to Hillsdale's public schools.

The more installations result from the Expo, the more donations in percentage and dollar volume go to the schools, said Ragland.
 
Ten installations may generate $5,000 for the schools, but 20 installations could yield as much as $20,000 in funding, Ragland said.
 
Homeowners with quality sun exposure can expect an annual return in excess of average historical stock portfolios while generating energy free of carbon emissions, he added.
 
The May 3 Solar Expo is being designed to walk the potential solar adopter through all stages of the development process while providing a clear indication of expected costs and benefits.

Local students, faculty and others will assist interested residents through the process.
 
For more information, go to www.hillsdalesolar.com

BRIEFLY
 

Norm's Garden to close

after 20 years on Barbur



After 20 years on Barbur Boulevard across from Colonel Sanders (KFC) and the Burlingame Fred Meyer, Norm's Chinese Garden restaurant will close in May, said co-owner Mei Fan.

The new tenant for the site may be a Taco Bell, she said, although she hasn't received final word from the property owner. Norm's (her husband is Norman Fan) lease runs out in May, and Mei said that the couple hadn't planned to renew it in any case.

The present building, at  7710 SW Barbur, is likely to be torn down to make way for the new, Fan said.


Sunday Parkway skips SW this year

There won't be a Sunday Parkway event in Southwest Portland this year.

The popular event that brings thousands of pedestrians and bikers to Hillsdale, Multnomah Village and Gabriel Park is being replaced this year by a Parkway event celebrating the September opening of the new Tilikum Crossing Bridge.

Linda Ginenthal, program manager for Parkways, said that September, the normal month the Parkway has been held in Southwest, offered the only time to "showcase" the bridge. She noted the event will "show off the huge new investments that the Portland Bureau of Transportation and TriMet have made in new infrastructure to get people over to the new bridge by walking and biking."

There has been no determination of whether the Southwest Parkways will resume in 2016. Diane Dulken, spokesperson for the Bureau of Transportation, said the Parkways team is focused on 2015 now, but, she added, there's a big demand for the events throughout the city.

The goal is to make pedestrians and bicyclists more aware of routes available to them every day, she said.

The Tilikum Bridge Parkway event will be Sunday, Sept. 27, from 11 a.m. to 4 p.m., will cover 8.5 miles and will include Sellwood.

The bridge, whose construction began in mid-2011, will have no truck or auto traffic but will be a key element in the new Orange Light Rail MAX line running to Milwaukie. The Portland Street Car, TriMet buses, and emergency vehicles will also use the bridge.

The estimated cost of $136.6 million is being paid by federal grants, Oregon Lottery revenue and Tri-Met.

The dates of the other 2015 Parkway events are:

East Portland Sunday Parkway
May 10, Mother's Day ~ 11a.m. - 4 p.m. (7 miles)

North Portland Sunday Parkway
June 21, Father's Day ~ 11a.m. - 4 p.m. (9.5 miles)

Northeast Portland Sunday Parkways
July 26, 2014 ~ 11a.m. - 4 p.m. (8 miles)

Southeast Portland Sunday Parkway
August 23 ~ 11a.m. - 4 p.m. (7 miles)

SW Trails seeks public support

for Red Electric Trail

 

SW Trails, the well-know pedestrian advocacy group in Southwest Portland, is urging area residents to write letters of support to make the proposed Red Electric Trail a top priority for the City. 

 

Don Baack, SW Trails founder and president, recently wrote, "Despite our best efforts, the City Bureau of Transportation has not classified the Red Electric as a top priority."

 

The proposed trail, which would also serve recreational and commuter bicycle riders, would extend into Washington County and follow the railroad grade of the old Red Electric commuter train. To find out more about the trail go to http://redelectric.org/

The SW Trails appeal also includes making bike and pedestrian improvements on Dosch Road and Marquam Hill Road.

The organization asks residents to e-mail:

PSC@portlandoregon.gov and  TSP@portlandoregon.gov


datebooktop
Date Book    
     
Tuesday, March 3

Tax Talk during a Taxing Time

6:30 p.m. to 7:30 p.m., Hillsdale Library. H&R Block will offer general tax advice and answer tax-related questions. Registration required; register online, in the library or by calling (503) 988-5234.

Wednesday, March 4

To Tunnel or not to Tunnel

7 p.m., St. Barnabas Episcopal Church, 2201 SW Vermont. The Hillsdale Neighborhood Association invites further comment on Metro's various planning options for "High Capacity Transit" in the Southwest Transit Corridor. The eventual plan will be important to Hillsdale's future. See story above. 
  
Saturday, March 7

The Joy of Litter-picking  
 
9 a.m. Meet at the Food Front "veranda" for one hour of fun litter patrolling with the "Usual Suspects." Post-clean-up, volunteers are treated with breakfast sandwiches, courtesy of Food Front. Plus there's often the ever-surprising "Pick of the Litter" show-and-tell. 
 
Saturday, March 14
 
Walk: Tryon and Marshall Parks

9 a.m. to noon. Meet behind the Wilson High bleachers. From there, w alkers will carpool to the  Lewis & Clark Law School.  The walk will be 5.5 miles with 700-foot elevation gain.  The route includes a small section along Tryon Creek Park, part of Marshall Park, and a trail in a new area bought by the City from Riverview Cemetery.  Prepare for muddy sections. Bring a snack and water and dress for the weather. Well-behaved dogs on leashes are allowed. 
For more information or to volunteer to lead a walk, contact Sharon Fekety at fekety@hevanet.com. Co-sponsored by SW Trails PDX and Hillsdale Neighborhood Association.

Saturday, March 21

Olmsted documentary: 
Designing America
 
2 p.m. to 3:30 p.m. Hillsdale Branch Library. Film explores how Frederick Law Olmsted designed numerous urban parks, including Lithia Park in Ashland, Central Park and Golden Gate Park. After the film, its producers will focus on the Olmsted legacy in Portland, including Terwilliger Parkway.

Saturday, March 28

End of Life Care

2 p.m. to 3 p.m., Hillsdale Branch Library. Providence Hospice presents an overview of the services and benefits that hospice can provide. Followed by a Q & A. Registration required; register online, in the library or by calling (503) 988-5234.

 
Until Sunday, March 29

SW HOPE food drive  
 
"SW HOPE: Feed the Hungry" community food drive continues. The drive involves more than 60 faith and other community partners to collect food and funds in support of Neighborhood House's Emergency Food Box Program. 
The 2015 campaign has set a goal of raising 175,000 pounds of food or the cash equivalent.  Cash donations are the most effective way to support the program. Supporters can also make food and cash donations at Neighborhood House, located at 7780 SW Capitol Hwy., or online at www.swhope.org.   
For more information contact Neal Nyssen, Neighborhood House Emergency Food Box Program Coordinator, at (503) 246-1663 x5118 or nnyssen@nhweb.org, or go to www.nhpdx.org.

 

Friday, April 10

Book Celebration benefits 
CPAH, Affordable Housing 
 
6 p.m. to 10 p.m., Oregon Zoo's Cascade Crest Banquet Center. Seventeenth annual "HomeWord Bound" benefit for Hillsdale-based Community Partners for Affordable Housing (CPAH). To buy tickets or for more information, go to https://cpahinc.ejoinme.org/?tabid=544529 
 
Click to go to top of Datebook