People. Our business, your bottom line.
    Vol. 4, Issue 6, June 2016   
On the surface, the relationship dynamics in the non profit world between the organization's leader and the board should be pretty straight forward and mission focused. However, surprisingly, in many ways, the relationship is often more complex, complicated and nuanced than in a business entity.
 
In HCA's Executive Advisory practice we encounter situations that challenge even the most adept leaders on both sides of the relationship so the focus of this issue is to provide some wisdom on just how an executive director (ED) or CEO can have the most productive board with the most productive relationship.
 
Our article provides observations and ideas for EDs to consider in building and maintaining effective boards and should provide food for thought for chairs and directors to allow them to contribute to healthy and effective board governance.
 
Contributing their views are three experts in non profit board dynamics and governance - April Young, Anthony Cancelosi and Eileen Ellsworth.
 
Board Construct
 
There are some common structural problems and challenges often found within non profit boards:
  • Too many members - a very common problem
  • Non-engaged directors
  • "Fuzzy" governance practices
  • Mission-oriented with fiscal "naivety"
  • Lack of business sense
  • Entrenched individuals or clique of members
  • Resistance to change
  • Directors are unpaid volunteers
A combination of these could seriously impact the ability of an ED to effectively execute the strategy and plans to carry out the mission of the organization.
 
Some Basics
 
Let's take a look at some very fundamental concepts that should be addressed in every non profit organization. These probably seem so fundamental as to be obvious but, unfortunately, often need to be revisited and assessed.
 

Mission - There should be absolute agreement among the board members as to the existing specific mission. Oftentimes board members will steer the organization toward their "personal mission" which will cause confusion for and conflicts with the management team.

 

Strategy and Operating Plan - Again, this is all about alignment. An agreed-upon strategy and strategic plan gives the ED the "cover" required to be in full control and to act. It will help avoid competing agendas. Eileen Ellsworth believes there often needs to be a reminder that a cornerstone of a healthy organization is to have "a focused approach to develop a common understanding of where we are going and why."

 

Board Role - Understand the specific board focus - operational, fundraising, or both. Management typically wants a board to help more than advice. Help comes in the form of leveraging connections, opening doors, engaging their own company's employees and, most importantly, fundraising. The board should be there for advice and perspective on "thought" issues too, along with approval of revisions to strategy and the strategic plan.

 

Program vs Administrative Spending - The board and the ED must grapple with this highly sensitive issue which can create headaches and external challenges for social and charitable organizations.
Tips

The ED and the chair should work in tandem to accomplish these actions:
  1. Set the number of board members from at least 7 to no more than 20. Smaller is better for operational effectiveness but the adding of the "right members" for fundraising and contacts could justify a larger group. Another negative with large boards is the staff time required.
  2. Have fixed terms. Layer the terms so that small groupings rotate each year.
  3. Have a succession plan with an ongoing pool of qualified prospects.
  4. Prepare a position description for the director role, along with a specific discussion of the mission, values and strategy with a copy of the strategic and/or operating plan.
  5. Define general board member expectations and specific ones where appropriate, i.e., contacts, capacity to give, fundraising, etc.
  6. Require each board member to make a personal contribution.
  7. Personally screen each prospect with an eye on the fit from a mutually beneficial perspective and to determine the level of passion for the mission.
  8. Create a formal "onboarding" program for new directors.
  9. A heavy representation of private sector board members seems to be most preferable. Oftentimes the business directors are more willing to confront and make tough decisions regarding programs and people.
  10. Establish committees that have real goals and deliverables and be sure that each board member participates. Channel interests into relevant committees. Within a larger board, establish an executive committee. Again, be mindful of the required staff time to support an active committee.
What the ED Can Do

Work the board extensively with passion, energy and purpose. Communicate, communicate and communicate.

Invest time in getting to really know your new board members, individually and personally. Determine their particular interests, what value they can bring and how much time they have to contribute. Lay out your expectations with specificity.

Work the board extensively with passion, energy and purpose.



Meet with your chair on a regular basis. Be transparent and build the needed trust to allow for a healthy and productive "partnership." Engage directors as frequently as needed. Solicit input and leverage off their value and purpose, i.e., opening doors, donor relationships, mission activities, etc. Listen to suggestions and follow-up and close the loop. Be heavy on the "personal touch" and make people feel valued. Be humble as there will certainly be some "big egos" on the board. Work them, don't fight them.

Preparation is essential. Respect everyone's time. Give appropriate effort and reflection in preparing for board meetings. Have an informative board book and have roles for key staff members. Allow each senior leader to make an occasional presentation (in addition to the CFO who should attend all meetings). Have a timed agenda and stick to the schedule. Follow up immediately on unfinished discussion areas and report back on action items. Be a concise communicator and an active listener. Carefully consider all suggestions and ideas and give feedback to the directors who contribute.

Large companies, especially CPA, law and consulting firms, will tap managers and executives to serve on non profit boards as a professional development activity or to serve a community service role for their employers. Be sure to carefully vet this type of prospect to be sure that they are aligned with and committed to your mission. Get the fit right and don't compromise.

Never forget that your directors are volunteers and come with the best of intentions. Their contributed time takes away from their own jobs and most are there for the good of the organization and its mission. Manage them with care and appreciation while managing your team and yourself with patience.

The Bottom Line

April Young suggests that "the ED must build a coalition with the board - a shared interest in the success of the organization." She cautions the ED to guide, manage and influence a board whose "passion for the issues will override practical business sense." The ED must manage the egos to "strike the critical balance between mission and reality."

..."the ED must build a coalition with the board - a shared interest in the success of the organization."





All in all, non profit boards should operate in a manner similar to business boards but requiring perhaps a healthier dose of "emotional intelligence" and relationship management.


 
Click here to see previous issues ofThe Human Capital Advisor in our Archives. 

   
 
 

 




Meet the HCA team members who provide a range of advisory services to non profit EDs and boards...  
 
Partner


Managing Director



Other HCA team 
members include:
 
GUEST CONTRIBUTORS 

*ANTHONY CANCELOSI 
President and CEO, Columbia Lighthouse for the Blind; former technology CEO; member of non profit and commercial boards

*EILEEN ELLSWORTH
President, The Community Foundation for Northern Virginia; member of non-profit boards

*APRIL YOUNG 
Managing Director, Hercules Capital; chair and director of  numerous commercial and non profit boards


*****


NON PROFIT 
ROUNDTABLE
presented by
Human Capital Advisors
and
Holland & Knight

Wednesday, July 27
for
Non Profit CEO/ED
Noon to 2pm
(there is no charge)

Informal - Interactive
Confidential - Leave with
Solutions

For more information, contact HCA CEO Advisor and Moderator

 

***** 




BOOK OF THE MONTH
pile_of_old_books.jpg
This month's recommen-
dation is The Nonprofit Board Therapist: A Guide to Unlocking Your Organization's True Potential by Dennis C. Miller.



 


























Tell us what human capital issues you'd like to read about in The Advisor. We welcome your ideas and comments on current articles and future topics.
  
Click below
Human Capital Advisors
 |www.HumanCapitalAdvisors.com
1320 Old Chain Bridge Road
Suite 250
McLean, VA 22101