Report banner
Published by former Mayor George Gardner                     July 22 2015
The Report is an independent publication serving our community
By email weekly and at http://staugustinereport.net
Contributions are appreciated
Button subscribeButton archiveButton bedtimebutton donate
Bunting on City Hall

Revolt Against Tourism

As we glide under a bridge on the city canal tour, our guide announces that we have entered a quiet zone. "This is a residential area," she says, nodding toward balconies where Danes are enjoying coffee - or maybe wine. "I'll resume talking in five minutes."

Revolt on tourism

Outraged by tourists' boorish and disrespectful behavior, and responding to the complaints of their constituents, local officials around the world have begun to crack down on tourism, and the tourism industry, even in the face of opposition from their national governments, which want the tax revenue from tourists.

The "quiet zones" are emblematic of the Danish philosophy toward tourists: They should blend in with the Danish way of life, not the other way around.

Nine million tourists last year visited Denmark, which has fewer than six million people.

Barcelona, a city of 1.6 million that receives over seven million people a year, represents the turn toward regulation. The city's mayor announced a one-year ban on new tourist accommodations, citing the swarms of students who have all but taken over the Ciutat Vella, or Old City, of Barcelona.

In Thailand a Chinese tourist was recently caught on video ringing and kicking sacred bells at a Buddhist temple as if he was in a game arcade.

   Read a New York Times report by Elizabeth Becker, a former New York Times reporter and the author of Overbooked: The Exploding Business of Travel and Tourism.

Spanish King and Queen

Royal sightseers

   Just like so many visitors to St. Augustine, Spain's King Felipe VI and Queen Letizia plan to include sightseeing when they visit the city in mid-September.

   Spanish Ambassador Ramón Gil-Casares and Consul General Cristina Barrios of the Spanish Embassy said the Royal Couple have indicated an interest in St. Augustine's historic sites during a conference last week with city officials.

   They are expected to be here for the Spanish-United States Council session in mid-September.

   Mayor Nancy Shaver, who will serve as the chief representative of the city during the visit, said, "We are pleased and genuinely excited that the King and Queen of Spain have scheduled St. Augustine and its 450th Commemoration as a priority visit. It tells us just how much our little city and unique history are important to the world."

Valdes Dow property
Tour St Aug
Trolley adv
adv EMMA

Dow PUD goes to

commission Monday

   There will probably be very few of the things we're talking about today (if apartments). The Worcester House porch will not be built. The wall will not be built. You can't do it. There's not enough return on investment. Many of the things that we are proposing for the inn will not be there.

Project Architect Don Crichlow

   The City Commission takes up the question of a planned unit development (PUD) for the former Dow Museum of Houses Monday after a foreshortened Historic Architectural Review Board (HARB) last Thursday approved an Opinion of Appropriateness for the proposed Cordova Inn.

   Old Island Hotels will have to return to HARB for a Certificate of Appropriateness if the commission approves its plans. First reading of an ordinance for the PUD will be Monday.

   Only three of five board members voted Thursday, historic architect Paul Weaver recusing himself and the fifth seat vacant.

   It's the second win for the hotly contested PUD. The Planning and Zoning Board recommended approval, but with conditions on special events and parking. HARB too had concerns - mass and scale, modern site features like a stage, pool and courtyard, and archaeological resources and utility placement - but the board will get a second bite if the plan advances through the commission. 

   Residents Pat Reilly and Cece Reigle sound off pro and con here. 

Army Corps Murden

Two needs, one dredge

   The Army Corps of Engineers Dredge Murden is beginning a dredge project on the St. Augustine Inlet, the dredge material going "near shore" adjacent to the southerly critically eroded section in Vilano Beach.

   General Services Director Jim Piggott says the $2 million federal project will continue "on a 24 hour per day schedule 7 days per week until the end of August."

   The Corps "hopes to remove 100,000 to 150,000 cubic yards of sand from the inlet channel and place it just outside the breakers at Vilano Beach. They also plan to monitor this material placement going forward to determine how it reacts to storms and currents," Piggott says.

 

VA clinic site

search renewed

   Bill Dudley, chair of the County Veterans Council, says the VA is "now considering the county's original offer to be considered as a possible site for the permanent location for the future CBOC (clinic)" after word VA negotiations with one contractor collapsed.

   "(Assistant County Administrator) Jerry Cameron was contacted by the VA assuring him that (the county) proposal will be given every consideration for the new permanent site," Dudley says.

   The VA Congressional Relations Office notified Congressman Ron DeSantis,"Due to unsuccessful efforts to achieve an operating lease for the St. Augustine, FL, CBOC, VA has cancelled the current procurement and is evaluating all options to move forward, including re-solicitation with an expanded delineated area. 

   "There will be no interruption in healthcare due to this cancellation. VA is planning to activate an interim clinical space in September 2015." 

   The county has continued to offer space to the VA, but was told earlier that procurement regulations prevented accepting the offer.


 

Preparing for Art & Craft Festival

   In the 450th year of St. Augustine, the St. Augustine Art Association will celebrate the 50th year of its annual Art & Craft Festival.

   The call is out for artists to secure a space for the November festival - this year Saturday and Sunday, November 28-29.

   While holiday shoppers can browse creations in fine art and crafts, the artists as well can enjoy cash prize awards in numerous categories, overnight security and on-site ATMs at Francis Field, an artists' breakfast, trained volunteers and more.

   Application deadline is August 14. Call 904.824.2310 or visit  staugustineartfestival.com/.

 

Last Saturday events

   The community has taken to adopting days of each month for their events, like this Saturday - the last of the month. Along St. George Street and at Government House from 6:15 - 7:15 pm witness the Changing of the Guard by the 1740 Spanish Garrison, while from 5 - 9 take in Uptown Saturday Night along San Marco Avenue.


 

Commentary

   Why park and shuttle's on back burner

   She told the psychiatrist she didn't want to tell her husband he's not a chicken because she needed the eggs.

parking pinch    Count on traffic jams continuing into the foreseeable future. The revenue generated by in-city parking - and fines when frustrated motorists try to "create" a parking space - is the major source of income for the city hosting a steadily growing number of visitors.

   To suggestions of alternative people moving in the past, City Manager John Regan has cautioned, "be careful not to impact our parking revenue."

   The most obvious alternative is peripheral parking and shuttle, with plenty of open land along Ponce Boulevard US 1 north and three privately held transit systems - Sunshine Bus, green trolleys and red trains. But there have been no public overtures to the Council on Aging's Sunshine Bus or the sightseeing trains and trolleys. 

   Study of park and shuttle in other cities would likely turn up an effective alternative, profitable for the city and agreeable to the thousands of regular day visitors bordering on road rage as they venture into the ancient city.

 

History's highlight

'They Seem a Noble Race'

49 days to St.  Augustine's 450th anniversary

   Beginning a series of highlights before St. Augustine's 450th anniversary September 8.

   

   Before Columbus, before Balboa, before Ponce de Leon, Pizarro and Menendez there were the Indians - some 10,000-plus years before.

Timucuan Chief Outina  St. Augustine was founded at a Timucuan Indian village in 1565. Bands of Indians both traded with and harassed early settlers in the 1600s, and joined defenders and attackers of the young settlement in the 1700s. Osceola, Florida's best known Indian leader, was imprisoned at the Castillo during the Seminole War in the early 1800s, as were western Indians in the late 1800s.

   "They seem to be a noble race," Pedro Menendez remarked in notes to his king, Philip of Spain, after his first encounter. Fishermen, hunters and farmers, he would later report. "They possess human physical characteristics, but were clothed only in loincloths of animal skins, their hair done in topknots, and their flesh covered with tattoos."

   He learned that the tattoo colors and arrangement indicated rank within the tribe.

   Early garrison officers reported these Indians were so quick that they could wait until the flash of an arquebusier's weapon, then dodge into the woods, and each could unleash four to five arrows in the time it took a Spaniard to reload. 

   Uneasy peace with Indians marked the first 300 years of St. Augustine. Survival of the garrison had to be laid in great measure to divine providence. When the English corsair Sir Francis Drake raided virtually defenseless St. Augustine in 1586, Indians living in the area snuck into the abandoned town and took anything of value they could carry. After Drake burned the town to the ground, the Indians returned with the townspeople and helped them rebuild.

   Florida's Indian population was estimated at 350,000 in 1513. Warfare, slave trading and especially European-borne disease dropped the number to almost none in the 1700s, but it swelled again in the early 1800s as northern settlers forced Indian migration to this virgin area rich in fish, game and farmland.

   These scattered bands were not, at first, united, but came to be called as a group Seminoles, or wild people, by the whites.

   Eventually joining forces to hold their homeland, the Seminoles engaged the young United States in its longest and most costly Indian war, a war to remove them to the west. That war was never won, simply declared ended by the American government.

   St. Augustine's Castillo de San Marcos, renamed Fort Marion when the U.S. took over the territory in 1821, was prison to numerous captured Indians during the Second Seminole War of 1835 to 1842. Among its prisoners was Florida's most famous Indian leader, Osceola. (In 1942 the original name, Castillo de San Marcos, was restored by an Act of Congress.)

   In the late 1800s, many leaders of the plains and western Indian tribes were moved here, away from their tribes out west - Kiowa, Comanche, Cheyenne, Arapaho and Chiracahua Apaches.

   The Indian confinement at St. Augustine and its Castillo play a major role in U.S. history, as it was here that Army Captain Richard Pratt began an Indian education program, which led to new Indian policies and the establishment of the Carlisle Indian School in Pennsylvania.

   Image: Timucuan Chief Outina, Theodore Morris, Florida Lost Tribes

   Excerpts from The Indians in St. Augustine Bedtime Stories. Click for further information on this fascinating historic series.

 

   The St. Augustine Report is published weekly, with additional Reports previewing City Commission meetings as well as Special Reports. The Report is written and distributed by George Gardner, St. Augustine Mayor (2002-2006) and a former newspaper reporter and editor.  Contact the Report at gardner@aug.com or gardnerstaug@yahoo.com