Report banner
Published by former Mayor George Gardner                     June 24 2015
The Report is an independent publication serving our community
By email weekly and at http://staugustinereport.net
Contributions are appreciated
Button subscribeButton archiveButton bedtimebutton donate
Prince of Peace Church

City bans on performers 

are headed back to court

   St. Augustine's bans on activities along St. George and adjoining streets are going back to court through four artists represented by St. Augustine Constitutional Rights Attorney Tom Cushman with assistance from  First Amendment expert William J. Sheppard of Jacksonville.

Lopez Cushman    Bruce Kevin Bates, Elena Hecht, Kate Merrick, and Helena Sala filed suit June 18 in US District Court in Jacksonville, alleging "that the City of St. Augustine, Florida has violated and is seeking to violate the constitutional rights of Plaintiffs by ordinances with the intent and effect of unconstitutionally restraining and chilling Plaintiffs' visual artistic expression in traditional public fora, which is protected by the First Amendment to the United States Constitution."

   Fifteen years ago Constitutional Attorney Michael Kahn developed an ordinance banning vending and performances on St. George Street and, after winning court approval, has warned city officials through the years not to tinker with it lest it be overturned.

   City commissions since have expanded the ban to streets around St. George, but also relented to allow at least occasional historic reenactments, such as a limited number of changing of the guard events.

   Attorney Cushman, addressing the City Commission in January, said, "I believe there's a way the city, the artists, the citizens can all benefit" from revisiting the ban ordinances. City Attorney Isabelle Lopez says she can't comment on that effort because "this matter is now in litigation."

450 logo

Town halls hype

Celebrate 450!

   The first of three town hall meetings opened yesterday for residents "to receive the latest details and to pose questions relating to your area" on plans for the 5-day Celebrate 450!
September 4-8.
   On hand at the Casa Monica ballroom was the organizing team led by Police Chief Loran Lueders, who took on project command for the long weekend.

   Two more town halls are planned, July 7 at 6 pm in the Visitor Information Center and July 14 at 5:30 at The Blackfly Restaurant on Anastasia Boulevard.

   The weekend will feature American pop, rock and country music stars on stages throughout the historic district.

Valdes Dow property
Tour St Aug
Trolley adv
Bedtime adv

Special Event Venues

await second hearing

   A Special Event Venue ordinance almost made it through the City Commission Monday night, then the persistent parking issue raised its head.

   Too loose or too restrictive? Commissioners decided it needs a closer look and tabled the ordinance to its July 27 meeting.  

   Commissioners previously tweaked the ordinance on such venues including meeting off-site parking requirements and protection against impacts on historic or cultural resources on the site.

    The issue arose last year when a Davis Shores property owner proposed use of his "castle" property on Flagler Boulevard to be a "small event venue."

PUD zoning goes to 

town hall meeting

   Contentious planned unit development zoning (PUD) goes to a Planning and Zoning Board (PZB) town hall meeting tomorrow, 5 to 7 pm in the Alcazar Room at City Hall.

   The Planning and Building Department will present a draft of potential revisions for review and public comment. Included:

  • Describing potential public benefits
  • Requiring infill and redevelopment projects to provide streetscape analyses
  • Separating preliminary and final development plan reviews
  • Establishing "community" areas for properties outside of defined neighborhood areas
  • Extending staff review time before an application has to go to the PZB to 60 days instead of 30 days.
  •    "This issue has been discussed at several meetings of the PZB," Planning and Building Director David Birchim says. "Many ideas for improving the section of the code have been discussed." 

       The current focus on both sides of the issue is the plan by David Corneal to convert the former Dow Museum of Houses into a multi-unit hotel.

    In the mailbag

       I am interested in the event parking in downtown St. Augustine.  My home is near Flagler College and my daily life is affected by auto and pedestrian traffic.  Is there a resident committee or problem solving group that I can participate in? 

       I am also motivated to save the cost of replacing the grass at Francis Field.  We don't need to repeat the mistakes of "Gentlemen of The Road" event planning but use what we learned to make better decisions.  

       Our county EMS has excellent experience and training in staging for events and disasters.  They would also be an excellent resource.

       Why not use remote parking and school buses to transport to the VIC (visitor center) downtown? They can use the parking areas at the court house complex and miscellaneous Youth Groups and Scouts to collect the fees. 

       They can charge a per person fee for transport to cover the costs and the parking volunteer groups can have a cut to help support their groups?


    Quotable

       I imagine if I was angry I probably had parishioners that were angry and confused - so it was a natural thing to do. It was important to do this.

    Reverend Ron Rawls, St. Paul AME Church pastor, 

    at vigil for Charleston's Emanuel AME Church shooting victims

    FDOT study is 10 step process

    FDOT steps    Last week's public workshop on alternative ideas for relieving congestion at San Marco Avenue and May Street was "somewhere between step 3 and 5" of a 10-step process the Florida Department of Transportation follows for highway project development.

       Project Manager Steve Browning says, "we wanted to see what feedback we received first before doing the environmental analysis and defining the alternatives further.

       "The intent of the PD&E (Project Development and Environment) process is to study each valid alternative to the level of detail necessary to accurately assess any potential impacts associated with the proposed improvements and to make a recommendation of the preferred alternative(s)," an FDOT flyer explains.

       Next up, refining alternatives based on public comments and feasibility, then bringing the preferred alternative to a public hearing, final recommendation and acceptance.

       FDOT hopes to have the study and design work completed this year with construction next year.

       Send your comments to Project Manager Steve Browning

    An idea for sunny Florida

    Doyle and visor    In 1999, St. Augustine resident Mike Doyle got tired of being blinded by the sinking sun each day he drove home at rush hour.

       He cut out a simple visor from cardboard that would fit behind his rearview mirror. It worked.

       More than a decade later, Mike decided to bring "this indispensable product to market so other drivers could enjoy this same advantage," he says on his website.

       SunStop Visor was born, with a number of improvements over its cardboard parent, including durable, flexible foam,  easy attachment and useable on most cars and pick-up trucks.

       The price, $9.95, is easy, but friends suggested jazzing them up, so in addition to charcoal and white, Mike is working on animal, fashion, Scottish clan tartan and St. Augustine souvenir designs.

    History's highlight

    The Spanish horse 
    77 days to St.  Augustine's 450th anniversary

         Among the horses pulling our carriages there is likely a bloodline to the original Spanish horses brought here by Spain's early explorers. 

    Spanish horse      They were aboard Ponce De Leon's ships on his second voyage to the New World in 1521. Along with a small herd of cattle, they were the first to ever land on what is now the continental United States.
         In 1565 St. Augustine Founder Pedro Menendez had cattle and horses shipped from Spain to begin producing beef for the garrison. However his effort to bring horses on his founding voyage was tragic. From the memoir of Father Francisco Grajales, principal priest on that voyage:
         "In the port of St. John's of Porto Rico, the general purchased twenty-four horses and a ship to transport fifty men, whom the King had commanded to be taken from this island. The very day we set sail, this ship sprung a leak, and the danger of foundering was so imminent that, in order to save the men, it became necessary to lighten her by throwing overboard a large quantity of merchandise.
         "Seeing that this produced but little effect, it became necessary also to throw over the horses. Twenty-three were either lost in this way or died during the voyage, so that but one arrived in Florida."
         Spanish horses did the heavy pulling in our earliest days, were prizes for British raids in the 1700s, and were the most common type of horse throughout the Southeast and all of the regions west of the Mississippi.
         The leading breed in 1750 and 1850, the pure Spanish horse in North America was almost extinct by 1950, the American Livestock Breeds Conservancy tells us. Almost all Spanish stocks were crossbred with or replaced by horses of larger size, including thoroughbreds, other riding horse breeds, and draft horses.
         Only in recent years has attention been paid to preserving the pure Spanish horse, with numerous associations formed beginning in the late 1950s, today registering more than 200 horses annually with a breed population of over 2,000.

     

       The St. Augustine Report is published weekly, with additional Reports previewing City Commission meetings as well as Special Reports. The Report is written and distributed by George Gardner, St. Augustine Mayor (2002-2006) and a former newspaper reporter and editor.  Contact the Report at gardner@aug.com or gardnerstaug@yahoo.com