Report banner
         Published by former Mayor George Gardner      September 17 2014   
The Report is an independent publication serving our community
Button subscribeButton archiveButton bedtimebutton donate
Now online at staugustinereport.net
7-Eleven cartoon

Pleas, rally, anger

at 7-Eleven project

Two hour meeting. No change in FDOT position to permit as submitted.

   Got FDOT commitment to work on solutions with City to relieve congestion in that area. Will hold a public meeting with possible options in December.  

Vice Mayor Nancy Sikes-Kline, after meeting Tuesday with Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT)District 2 Secretary Greg Evans

   A trip to Lake City, a rally September 28, a flurry of emails about and to the Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) - parts of an eleventh hour effort to block development of a 7-Eleven convenience store and 12-pump gas station.
  • City Manager John Regan and Vice Mayor Nancy Sikes-Kline traveled to Lake City to make a case to FDOT District 2 Secretary Greg Evans,
  • Bob Yerkes, an attorney and President of the Porpoise Point Homeowners Association, got County Commissioner Rachael L. Bennett involved, to fire an email to Evans and later press him at a meeting,
  • And organizers of a rally of nearly 40 two weeks ago called for another Sunday September 28, from 4-5:30 pm at the congested San Marco Avenue/May Street intersection, site of the proposed 7-Eleven.
  •    Yerkes suggested, "Given the fact that a PD&E (Project Development and Environmental assessment) is presently being prepared by the DOT regarding a roundabout at this dangerous location, I urge each of you to contact the DOT and request them to not issue the required roadway permits until this study is completed and a determination is made whether the 7-11 planned development property is required for this project and/or whether access to this site after the completion of this project will just be too dangerous."

    Sasha Martin of Vilano pushed more arguments: "The fuel tanks have to be buried in the ground that is flooded with almost every rainstorm that lasts an hour or more!  and it DOES NOT MAKE SENSE to issue a permit until plans and IMPLEMENTATION to fix the "F" status of the intersection."

    And it's rumored FEMA, the federal emergency agency, may be taking a look at that flooding.

    Brown retirement

    Retiring?

    Not so much

       City Attorney Ron Brown receives a parting gift from City Manager John Regan at Brown's retirement ceremony Monday at the Visitor Center, hours before a web site appeared, lawronbrown.com/

    with offices at 71 South Dixie Highway.

       Leaving city hall after nearly eight years Brown, 65, returns to private practice where he represented numerous condominium and homeowners' associations across North Florida, as well as local governments of Hastings, St. Augustine Beach and St. Johns County.

       Prior to joining the city, Brown practiced law in St. Augustine for 17 years as a partner in Dobson and Brown, P.A.

       He's been succeeded by former Assistant City Attorney Isabelle Lopez, who, joined the city in 2011 and in 2013 was named to Florida Trend's Government and Non-Profit Florida Legal Elite list.
    kline bw
    valdes adv
    Shaver adv

    A case to update zoning

    Flagler Blvd. project Jake Firth wanted a few variances to make his "Castle of Lions" at the point of Flagler Boulevard and Alcazar Street in Davis Shores into a "small events venue."

    Pleading the case before the city Planning and Zoning Board recently, Firth's attorney Jeremiah Mulligan found the concerns are far greater than a few variances, as a dozen residents including a representative of the North Davis Shores Neighborhood Association (SANDS) spoke out about dealing with commercial zoning in a residential neighborhood.

    "I want to minimize the damage commercial property will do to our residential properties," said one neighbor.

    "It is apparent the zoning code is inappropriate and not compatible with surrounding uses," said another.

    "There are a lot of uses commercial zoning can allow that are not a vague as a small events venue," said board member John Valdes. "What is a small events venue?"

    The board denied the variance package, but the specter of unintended consequences like the proposed 7-Eleven project impacting a north city neighborhood brought to light again the need to revamp a 38-year-old zoning code designed for 1976 neighborhoods with mom and pop businesses. 

     

    Course correction

      City manager to hold     additional 450 funds

       The 2014-15 city budget passed first reading last Thursday and is expected to pass final reading September 25 at 5:05 pm in the Alcazar Room at City Hall, after an adjustment apparently to mollify two commissioners who opposed a $938,000 budget for next year's 450th anniversary celebration.

       Announcement that City Manager John Regan will hold added funds from an earlier trimmed $799,000 budget appeared to have little effect on Vice Mayor Nancy Sikes-Kline and Commissioner Leanna Freeman, who both voted no on passage of the city budget at that first reading.

       That $139,000 will not be available to the city hall 450 trio and assistants (the two commissioners objected among other things to the 450 staff budget growing from some $200,000 originally to more than $400,000) without approval by Regan.

    Big ticket items will go to the City Commission for approval.

     

    Homework for Town and Gown's future 

    It was note-taking time for City Manager John Regan at a recent Town and Gown session to open dialog between the city and Flagler College, while college President Bill Abare deflected community concerns over student neighborhood rentals, college growth and consuming property off the tax rolls, pleading the college's financial burdens and preservation need of its historic buildings.

    In this first of a planned ongoing series of city/college sessions, Regan said "We're here as the city and college to listen."

    Plans for the next session have not been made.

    City candidate forum

    to be at River House

    The October 7 city candidate forum will be held at River House, Neighborhood Council President Rhey Palmer says.

    "We were searching for a larger location," Palmer noted, "because the Galimore Center was standing room only for the Primary candidate forum."

    The forum will begin at 6:30 pm.

    Candidates for the November 4 General Election are:

  • Mayor: Joe Boles and Nancy Shaver
  • Commission: Todd Neville and John Valdes
  • Commission: Grant Misterly and Nancy Sikes-Kline
  • Palmer says the format will be like the first one, but with questions directed toward specific candidates based on their platforms.

    Questions we'd like candidates to answer can be emailed to rheypalm@comcast.net, with "Candidate Forum" in the subject line. Deadline is September 21.  

    General Titshaw cannon firing

    Major General Titshaw fires replica eighteenth century cannon during Friday's National Guard ceremonies. 

    Photos: Michael Isam

    449th muster is last for Guard's

    retiring Adjutant General Titshaw

    By Michael Isam

    Setting of plaque
    Guard and Militiaman with plaque
    General Titshaw
    Titshaw

    From opening formation to cannon firing by the adjutant general, Florida Living History reenactors joined the Florida National Guard and Florida Department of Military Affairs Friday to commemorate 449 years since the first recorded militia formation to protect St. Augustine.

    That first muster was September 16, 1565, ordered by Pedro Menendez as he gathered his troops for an assault on the French Fort Caroline 40 miles to the north.

    The anniversary was highlighted by two features - the planned naming of the parade field to Patriots Field and the unexpected announcement by Major General Emmett R. Titshaw, Jr., Adjutant General of Florida, that he'll be retiring next March.    It was Titshaw who began the militia ceremony five years ago.
       Titshaw oversaw the placement of a canister containing soil from 19 locations where the Florida National Guard has served, covered with a bronze plaque naming the field, and then was asked to fire a replica eighteenth century cannon to conclude the ceremonies.

     

    Timucuans smarter than we thought

    Timucuan circle Those Indians who greeted Pedro Menendez in 1565 - not quite the ignorant savages we might have thought.

    "The levels of literacy of these early people are shown to be higher and more independent from European influences than previously thought," according to a Flagler College intro of professors of religion and anthropology in its fall Ideas & Images free series opening tomorrow at 7 pm in the Flagler Room in Ponce de Leon Hall.

    Flagler College Professor of Religion Dr. Timothy Johnson will discuss the efforts of Spanish missionary Fray Francisco Pareja. Through Pareja's works, the Timucua were engaged in an education system that combined texts in Spanish, Latin, and Timucuan.

    University at Albany-SUNY Professor of Anthropology Dr. George Aaron Broadwell will continue with a set of bilingual Timucua-Spanish Christian materials that date from 1612-1635. Broadwell discovered that the Timucua versions of the texts have subtly different content than the Spanish parallels.

    The conclusion, argues Broadwell, is that the Spanish were not sole authors of the texts - unnamed Timucua writers were actually co-authors.

    The series will continue October 9 with New Discoveries on St. Augustine's Early Black History and its Connections to Cuba, by Gertrude Conaway Vanderbilt Professor of History Dr. Jane L. Landers, and November 12 with Rebels and Runaways: African-Americans in St. Augustine during the Civil War, presented by Valdosta State University History Professor Dr. Larry Rivers.

    Visit the website.  

     

    History's Highlight  

    Spanish account of Matanzas

    357 days to St. Augustine's 450th anniversary

     

        From National humanities Center

      Account by Francisco Lopez de Mendoza Grajales, Chaplain of Pedro Menendez

       On Friday, the 28th September (following the Fort Caroline attack), and while the captain-general was resting after all the fatigues he had passed through, some Indians came to camp, and made us understand by signs that on the coast toward the south there was a French vessel which had been wrecked. Matanzas

       We set off immediately to descend the river to the sea, in search of the enemy. When we had reached the sea, we went about three leagues along the coast in search of our comrades. It was about ten o'clock at night when we met them.

       Not far off we saw the campfires of our enemies ... on the other side of the river, and we could not get at them.      The general marched his troops forward to the river, and we arrived before daylight. We concealed ourselves in a hollow between the sand-hills, with the Indians who were with us; and, when it came light, we saw a great many of the enemy go down the river to get shell-fish for food. Soon after we saw a flag hoisted, as a war-signal.

       Our general, who was observing all that, said to us, "I intend to change these [clothes] for those of a sailor, and take a Frenchman with me (one of those whom we had brought with us from Spain), and we will go and talk with these Frenchmen. Perhaps they are without supplies, and would be glad to surrender without fighting."

       As soon as he had called to them, one of them swam towards and spoke to him; told him of their having been shipwrecked, and the distress they were in; that they had not eaten bread for eight or ten days; and, what is more, stated that all, or at least the greater part of them, were Lutherans.

       Immediately the general sent him back to his countrymen, to say they must surrender, and give up their arms, or he would put them all to death. A French gentleman, who was a sergeant, brought back the reply that they would surrender on condition their lives should be spared.

       Our brave captain-general answered "that he would make no promises, that they must surrender unconditionally, and lay down their arms, because, if he spared their lives, he wanted them to be grateful for it, and, if they were put to death, that there should be no cause for complaint."

       Seeing that there was nothing else left for them to do, (they) brought all their arms and flags, and gave them up to the general, and surrendered unconditionally.

       Finding they were all Lutherans, the captain-general ordered them all put to death; but, as I was a priest, and had bowels of mercy, I begged him to grant me the favor of sparing those whom we might find to be Christians. We found ten or twelve of the men Roman Catholics, whom we brought back.

       All the others were executed, because they were Lutherans and enemies of our Holy Catholic faith. All this took place on Saturday (St. Michael's Day), September 29, 1565. 

       Image: Menendez and Ribault (lower right) at Matanzas

     

       The St. Augustine Report is published weekly, with additional Reports previewing City Commission meetings as well as Special Reports. The Report is written and distributed by George Gardner, St. Augustine Mayor (2002-2006) and Commissioner (2006-2008) and a former newspaper reporter and editor.  Contact the Report at gardner@aug.com or gardnerstaug@yahoo.com