DotAfrica logo with no labels
Press Contact:
Thomas Kamanzi, Newsletter Editor
18 November 2011
dotafrica special legislative request


DCA Exclusive Commentary: 

ComputerWorld Kenya


"Re: "ICANN engagement in Africa bears fruit"


"There was no unanimity regarding the adoption of the resolution to have DotAfrica included in the Top-Level Reserved Names List,  so as to give special legislative protection that will benefit the AU, and give it extraordinary powers to separately negotiate and delegate these names outside the ICANN programme " - DotConnectAfrica.



ComputerWorld logo -DotConnectAfrica


Computerworld Kenya


Our attention has been drawn to the recent article written by Rebecca Wanjiku: "ICANN engagement in Africa bears fruit" published in the on-line edition ofComputerworld Kenya.


A close reading of the article conveys the impression that:  

  1. "the ministerial meeting agreed that the .africa gTLD should be reserved" which means
  2. "that organizations that want to bid to manage it must be sanctioned by the AU.
  3. Furthermore, your story indicates that "ICANN's new gTLD application process provides for countries and regions with interest in certain names to reserve them."

We believe it is important to clarify these matters so as to properly inform your readers.


1)    The proposal to include DotAfrica gTLD in the List of Reserved Names is a tactic to make this string and similar strings in any language to be unavailable in this ICANN gTLD round so as to give special legislative protection that will benefit the AU, and give it extraordinary powers to separately negotiate and delegate these names outside the ICANN programme.  Even though DCA opposed the draft resolution, the final resolution was later adopted without any regard for dissenting viewpoints by the Experts Meeting of the African Ministerial Round-Table and a communiqué submitted to ICANN.  Therefore, it must be noted that the official request contained in the communiqué still has to be reviewed by the ICANN Board, the only relevant authority that has the power to approve or deny the request to include DotAfrica in the List of Reserved Names.


2)    DCA has argued that the current name strings in the Top-Level Reserved Names List that are in the approved version of the ICANN new gTLD Guidebook does not include DotAfrica, and that any approval of this extraordinary request by the AU will necessitate an amendment to relevant sections of the Applicant's Guidebook (such as Section - Reserved Names and Other Unavailable Strings). For this reason, we believe that it is quite problematic to change the rules very late in the game. So far, only the names for the Olympic movement and the International Red Cross movement are gTLD strings ineligible for delegation during this initial application round. DCA believes that the multi-stakeholder process that led to the negotiation of the current version of the Applicant's Guidebook is already completed, and this cannot simply be changed since this poses a serious threat to the entire principle of the multi-stakeholder process that contemporary Internet governance is built on.


3)    DCA has also argued that the DotAfrica name string is not at risk, and as such could be applied for under the open and transparent new gTLD programme of ICANN. Our belief is that those who have advocated for the inclusion of DotAfrica in the List of Reserved Names are only doing so to enable them bypass the ICANN process, and obtain the mandate for DotAfrica through a separate process negotiated directly with the African Union. We believe that the proponents of this approach lack the confidence to apply directly at ICANN and are only hoping that the AU will assist them in their illegitimate agenda to hijack DotAfrica. One only needs to read the verbal statement attributed to Vika Mpisane in your article to agree with our opinion. Mpisane was quoted as saying: "AU is only interested in making sure that .africa benefits Africa's Internet community." What are we to make of this? Is the AU here to serve the interest of the African Internet Community? We think this is simply the desire of a self-serving cabal that is pushing the AU in a certain direction that would enable the cabal achieve its objectives since the so-called leaders of the African Internet community are also the members of the AU Task Force on DotAfrica.


4)    DCA believes that the political influence and diplomatic machinery of the AU should not be used to further the aims of those who want to gain secret control of DotAfrica. If the African Internet community is indeed interested in the ownership of DotAfrica then let it apply directly through the legitimate auspices of the ICANN new gTLD programme and not use the AU to ask for special legislative protections on its behalf.


In the ICANN multi-stakeholder model of Internet governance that is now in operation, no single party has a greater say than another.


5)    We at DCA believe that ICANN will see through this ruse and not approve the request to include DotAfrica in the Top Level Reserved Names List.   When that happens, the DotAfrica issue will then attract only serious applicants and become independent of the special interest group that wants to acquire it by electing to operate outside the ICANN process


6)    We think that your article is mistaken in its stated opinion that "ICANN's new gTLD application process provides for countries and regions with interest in certain names to reserve them."  If taken literally, it implies that that the AU is interested in Africa as a 'region' and that the ICANN process allows for this name to be reserved.  So far, to the best of our knowledge, DotAfrica is the only prospective new gTLD name string that has attracted this type of extraordinary request.  We have gone through the relevant provisions in the guidebook, and we did not find any proof to support your stated opinion. The Applicant Guidebook does not in any way suggest that countries and regions can ask for names to be reserved since the countries already have their 2-code country-level codes for country-level domains.


7)  Finally, in the ICANN multi-stakeholder model of Internet governance that is now in operation, no single party has a greater say than another.  Even so, your article inadvertently gives the impression that the views of one party, in this case, the AU-sponsored African Ministerial Round-Table overrides any contrary opinion on the subject.  


The multi-stakeholder principle is supposed to ensure that all voices are heard, and all viewpoints considered. As a matter of fact, there was no unanimity regarding the adoption of the resolution to have DotAfrica included in the Top-Level Reserved Names ListMoreover, DCA had also pointed out that African Ministers were absent at the meeting, and as such the resolution that was presumably passed in their name could not be considered authentic. 


"DotAfrica needs to be freed now from the prison of the Cabal that is hell-bent on hijacking it."


Make your comments or hear what others have to say:  click here... 

Forward to a Friend

 Before Africa does


let it do


Excerpt from Key Note Address: DCA Executive Director at AITEC ICT Summit

French Press 


Related Articles on dotafrica issues:


    -Say "NO" to the Masquerade 'African Agenda' for Dakar and the Illegal Cabal Supporting It!

   -You Asked, We Clarified: The Justification for our NO Campaign

   -Say NO to DotAfrica CABAL (Whither DotAfrica amidst Confusion, Promiscuity and...)

   -Say NO to African Registry Consortium  (ARC)

   -Our Score Card- Regarding our NO Campaign

-Beware: DotAfrica has been hi-jacked by new gTLD cuckoos  

-DCA REJOINDER: Misleading and Unfair reportage on dotafrica - The Daily Champion Newspaper 

-The Daily Champion: AFTLD, DCA battle for the Soul of DotAfrica

   -The Daily Champion: Ministers seek framework for DotAfrica Project 

   -DCA REJOINDER:African Union requests proposals domain registry
   -ComputerWorld Kenya: African Union requests proposals for .africa domain registry

   -DCA Response to AU TaskForce/Infrastructure & Energy "Briefing Note on .africa"  

   -Yes2DotAfrica Campaign say "NO" to African Union "EOI" 

   -African Union Yanks .Africa Bid Support - Seeks Registries 

   -DCA Commentary: Response to the African Union Commission Communiqué  

   -Say "NO" on Nii Quaynor, Vice Chair of African Union ".africa" Task Force

   -"Corruption" claims as .africa fight heats up.

   -DCA Alarmed over AU Unofficial mandate over dotafrica registry 

   -DCA to Challenge AFTLD on DotAfrica Domain 

   -DCA REJOINDER: AfTLD seeks mandate to manage .africa   

-ComputerWorld Kenya: AfTLD seeks mandate to manage .africa 

-Yes2dotAfrica Campaign Successful at ICANN 40, SanFrancisco, CA 

-Vote 'NO" on AfTLD to manage the .africa TLD 

-Competition for .africa heats up 

-DotAfrica project alleges Sabotage from AU 

-DCA REJOINDER: African Union and the .Africa debate 

-ComputerWorld Kenya: African Union Joins the .Africa debate 

-Vote "NO" to Candidate Pierre Dandjinou for ICANN Board  

-Yes2dotAfrica campaign announced in Kenya 

Join Our
yes2dotafrica logo

Taking Africa to the Promised  land! Country at a time!!


  Join our PanAfrican Social Media followings:

   Find us on Facebook DotAfricaDotAfriqueDotAfriqya

Follow us on TwitterDotAfrica; DotAfriqueDotAfriqya
View our videos on YouTube DotAfrica Videos 

 Sign the petition for "Yes2dotAfrica"  here 




Our  Fulfilled Promise 


Our increasing successes and accomplishment so far!!


DotConnectAfrica  ...Connecting the dots in Africa  ...Bridging the Digital Divide


Our Campaign Archives
Our Press Room

[email protected]

. Forbes Magazine names DCA's Foundation & Strategic Advisory Member and  Former ICANN Board Member, Njeri Rionge "Africa's Most Successful Women" more...

. BizCommunity
covers DCA's "yes2dotafrica" campaign: "
Dot Africa campaign to brand continent" more...

. Radio Netherlands Worldwide:
A Dotafrica Generation soon to be born: more... 


. Sophia Bekele DCA founder and former ICANN gNSO policy advisor was noted by The Economist, Sept 15, 2010, as "leading the dotafrica initiative":  Can "Africa" get a make-over? more...


. Brains behind .africa, Diplomat East Africa more...  


. DCA is endorsed by African Union (AU), the Economic Commission for Africa (ECA), and the Internationalized Domain Resolution Union (IDRU)   

DCA in the News more.

About DotConnectAfrica:

DCA is a not-for-profit, non-partisan org incorporated in Mauritius Africa & will sponsor, establish & operate a TLD registry with global recognition & regional significance dedicated to the needs of Pan-African &African community. DCA Reg.ID.CT8710DCA90
Press Contact: Thomas Kamanzi, Newsletter Editor [email protected] DotConnectAfrica,