City Coat of Arms
Published by the Department of Public Affairs, City of St. Augustine. Florida    August 8 2011

City to review limits on artists

  

   City officials will review limits on visual artists in public places in response to a plea by Vice Mayor Leanna Freeman Monday.

   "I've always felt we could treat them better than we have been," she said at the close of Monday's regular City Commission meeting. "I'd at least like to see more areas available in the Plaza for visual artists."

   In a series of legal battles in past years, the city reduced artist and commercial interests to ten spaces in the market building, selected by lottery. City Attorney Ron Brown said, "You can set up locations in other areas of the Plaza, but I caution, you are limited on what you can allow within those locations."

   He explained, "The limits in the Plaza affect constitutionally protected expressive activities and commercial activities without legally recognized expressive content. The issue is broader than visual artists. ... The City can provide more spaces but cannot limit by content which expressive activities occur in those spaces."

  City staff will seek ideas from commissioners and prepare a report for a later meeting.

Cathedral sidewalks and lighting 

Cathedral quality

   The sidewalks in front of the Cathedral Basilica have a fresh dressing of coquina mix, along with in-walk lighting to illuminate the façade at night.

   Cathedral Facility Manager Kevin McKeefrey calls it "Cathedral quality" for the icon of St. Augustine's Spanish Catholic heritage.

Sign on for Report
 
Previous Issues

Height a serious matter

in preservation district

   "We have a responsibility to take it very seriously," City Commissioner Nancy Sikes-Kline said Monday after hearing reports that the Historic Architectural Review and Planning and Zoning boards appeared to dismiss a request to consider lower building heights in Historic Preservation District Three (HP3), the area north of Hypolita Street.

   The City Commission had asked for recommendations from the lower boards on a proposal to limit building heights to 27 feet from the current 35 feet. Resident Robert Hall said the greater scale is inappropriate for colonial representation.

   While the boards were concerned the change would violate property rights and bring lawsuits, Hall suggested current properties could be grandfathered.

   Mayor Joe Boles was concerned that the City Commission request for review was packaged with a proposed amendment to allow alternate building styles in HP1, south of the Plaza.

   "This is just the kind of confusion that got us into trouble with previous legislation," he said, referring to a modification in HP1 several years ago that was erroneously extended to all three preservation districts.

   City Manager John Regan recommended the matter be set aside "until we can do some consensus-building in the community."

 

Protection of original seawall first

   Responding to concerns that a proposed $7 million seawall project south of the Bridge of Lions would destroy the original coquina seawall, City Manager John Regan said Monday, "When this plan was developed, first was protection of the original seawall, and second was flood protection."

   It is the flood protection that justifies the grant application to the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), citing, "significant damage to the St. Augustine Seawall during Tropical Storm Faye in 2008."

   Plans call for exposing more of the original seawall as a new, stronger, barrier is built twelve feet further out into the bay. 

   Noting concerns that the city would be obligated to fund $2 million of the $7 million project, Commissioner Bill Leary noted, "All we're doing tonight is joining in a memorandum of agreement. We haven't got the grant at this time."

St. Francis House preps for added beds

    St. Francis House plans to bring its safety requirements into compliance by October 1 in order to provide eight beds under contract with city police and the sheriff's department.

   Police Chief Loran Lueders told city commissioners Monday the design has reduced from 15 to eight the number of beds that can be available to law enforcement to direct persons found camping on public property.

   The city and sheriff's department would split the $36,000 annual cost for the additional beds.

Moorings plan, archive digitizing advance

   City commissioners Monday advanced to public hearing in two weeks an ordinance for the Mooring Fields Pilot Program, with an amendment requiring registration with the Municipal Marina every six months rather than one year for non-live aboard "wet storage" of boats outside the city's mooring fields.

   Mayor Joe Boles pushed the amendment, arguing boaters in the mooring fields are helping support the city, while those outside pay nothing.

   And Tom Caswell of the University of Florida got commission endorsement on a grant application to archive "11,000 maps, drawings, photos, and documents" on the city's history. He said all the information would be available on line and will feature "geo-referencing, which means you can Google, say, the Fatio House, and all its information on it will come up."

   Here's the website with archives scanned in so far.

Visitor Center revamp for exhibits

  Remodeling of the Visitor Information Center as an event venue and a review of city codes for better use of the promenade between the visitor center and parking facility were focal points in a two-hour City Commission workshop before Monday's regular City Commission meeting.School groups rest in visitor center pavilion

   "Remodeling of this space is the most realistic way to create exhibit space," City Manager John Regan said as he promised to have architectural and business plans prepared for redesign of existing space.

   At an estimated cost of $400,000 to $500,000, City Commissioner Leanna Freeman said, "I'm not comfortable unless it makes sense" in return on investment. "We don't have money for our Spanish Quarter but now we're talking about spending money on the visitor center."

   Plans for the visitor center opened on a note that as a "limited public forum" area, use of the promenade could not include revenue-generating alcohol sales - a provision that scuttled plans for a revised Days in Spain celebration in September.

   While city officials work on possible revisions, Days in Spain promoter Stuart Gamsey promised to work on revising another historic event, Ponce de Leon Days, traditionally celebrated in the spring.

History's Highlight

'Common to see ships aground on this bar'

4 years, 1 month, 1 day to St. Augustine's 450th anniversary 

   The continuing need for dredging of the St. Augustine inlet is reflected in historic accounts of crossing the St. Augustine bar. The following is from research by Dr. Sam Turner of the Lighthouse Archaeological Maritime Program.  

  

   In the mid-eighteenth century, it was not uncommon for arriving and departing vessels at St. Augustine to be obliged to wait between one to two weeks in order to have the necessary conditions of wind and tide to cross the bar.

   A quick passage over the bar could go a long way to making a voyage profitable. The crew of a vessel required to wait two weeks without the bar would consume a great deal of provisions thus adding to the cost of the voyage. If the same vessel was obliged to wait two weeks before leaving on its outbound leg that would make a total of one month's additional provisions for the entire crew.    Sloop in St. Augustine harbor ca. 1750

   In cases where profit margins were close, such waits could be very detrimental to a vessel's financial bottom line.

   One traveler, Johann Schopf, a German surgeon serving with British forces during the Revolutionary War, described the bar and its channels and some of the prevailing conditions at the time.

   "Ordinarily there are but 3, often only 2 channels where it can be crossed, and these at ebb-tide with only 4-4 1/2 ft. of water, and at high tide with not more than 8-9.

   "These channels which of themselves admit nothing but small and light vessels, are besides narrow and crooked, and what is worse they shift so generally after stormy weather, on account of the quick-sand which forms the bar, that a seaman, quite familiar with them, after a brief absence from Augustine cannot without risk take the old course to which he had been used.

   "The pilots therefore, as often as they come out to bring in a ship, must examine the passage anew. ... It has become so common at St. Augustine to see ships aground on this bar and this coast generally, that disasters of the sort have almost ceased to arouse sympathy or wonder."

   Toward the end of the British Period in 1782, after the fall of Savannah and then Charleston to Patriot forces, a great many vessels bearing loyal British refugees made for the loyal colony of St. Augustine.

   In a number of cases vessels had to wait offshore for the weather to improve before attempting to cross the dangerous bar into the harbor, and often vessels were cast away when they neglected to take on board competent pilots.

   In one particularly horrendous case, nine transports were lost on the St. Augustine bar in late December, 1782. The traveler Johann Schopf reported in his journal that following the fall of Charleston over one two-day period no less than sixteen vessels bearing Loyalists went to pieces on the bar with a significant loss of life.

 

   Image: Sloop in St. Augustine harbor, ca. 1750, from the St. Augustine Historical Society.

The St. Augustine Report is published by the Department of Public Affairs of the City of St. Augustine each Tuesday and on Fridays previewing City Commission meetings. The Report is written and distributed by George Gardner, former St. Augustine Mayor (2002-2006) and Commissioner (2006-2008) and a longtime newspaper reporter and editor.  Contact The Report at gardner@aug.com