The Law Offices of Steven D. Rubin, APC
 
Table of Contents
Featured In This Issue
Black Holes, Taxes and Discharges
Federal Tax Liens and Third Parties ... Where's the cake?
Xenophobia (Spelled FATCA)
Death and Taxes: Are Fantasy Football Winnings Taxable?
Quick Links
Featured In This Issue

(Black Holes, Taxes and Discharges) 
  
 
 
In this issue is an article that discusses the 
discharge-ability of income taxes in bankruptcy. By bankruptcy I mean a "Chapter 7" personal bankruptcy. By taxes I mean personal income taxes. Every tax lawyer gets asked the following question on a somewhat regular basis: Can I "discharge" (as in "do away with") my taxes by filing bankruptcy? 
  
  
Rubin Tax Law eNews Reporter
THE ELECTRONIC TAX NEWSLETTER OF THE LAW OFFICES OF STEVEN D. RUBIN, APC
 
March 2014
  
The Law Offices of Steven D. Rubin, APC
1912 Broadway, Suite 105
Santa Monica, CA 90404
Tel (310) 453-7812/ Fax (310) 496-1686
Top
Dear Clients, Colleagues and Friends,
  
Welcome to the March 2014 issue of the
Rubin Tax Law eNews Reporter. This electronic tax newsletter intends to address tax topics that our clients, colleagues and friends have made known to us to be of interest and importance to them. The Rubin Tax Law eNews Reporter does not attempt to offer solutions to individual problems but rather to provide information about current developments in those areas of the law encompassed by our law practice. Readers in need of legal assistance should retain the services of competent counsel.
   

Black Holes, Taxes and Discharges

 

  

By Steven Rubin
  
Vintage Guitar   
 
   

I took the following out of Wikipedia:

"A black hole is a region of spacetime from which gravity prevents anything, including light, from escaping."

Based on the foregoing, the following is from Steve-pedia:

"Non-discharge-ability is a region of bankruptcy/tax law from which the law prevents certain debts, including tax debt, from being discharged." (Ok, so it's not perfect ... I tried).

This article addresses the discharge-ability of income taxes in bankruptcy. By bankruptcy I mean a "Chapter 7" personal bankruptcy. By taxes I mean personal income taxes (that small donation to the national trust that you make each April 15th). Every tax lawyer gets asked the following question on a somewhat regular basis: Can I "discharge" (as in "do away with") my taxes by filing bankruptcy? As is so often the case in law and life the answer is yes and no.

Let's start with some of the tax claims that are non-dischargeable:

(1) Any tax for which the related tax return is not filed. Folks, this is about as close as we get to what we lawyers call a "bright line test" in this area. If you haven't filed a tax return for the taxes you want discharged then the taxes are non-dischargeable. It doesn't get more simple than that.

(2) Any tax for which the related return is filed late (after considering extensions granted) and is filed within two years before the bankruptcy petition date. Again, pretty straightforward.

(3) Any tax for which the related return is fraudulent or for which the debtor willfully attempts to evade or defeat the tax. If the IRS concludes that you are playing games, or worse yet, playing the "evasion" game ... then the taxes are non-dischargeable (although you may have bigger problems).

(4) A tax debt not scheduled on the current income and expense summary (these are bankruptcy filings on which you are supposed to list your debts, including tax debts) within sufficient time to allow the IRS to file a timely proof of claim (unless the IRS has actual knowledge of the bankruptcy case).

Now let's take a look at some of the tax claims that are dischargeable.

Under Chapter 7, only the tax debts of an individual debtor are potentially dischargeable. Taxes incurred by corporations or partnerships in a Chapter 7 liquidation proceeding are not dischargeable. A debtor may discharge a federal tax liability for a tax year for which a return is due more than three years before the bankruptcy petition's filing date. In other words, the tax liability needs to be "stale." Conversely, "fresh" taxes are not dischargeable, i. e., income taxes for a taxable year for which a tax return was last due (including extensions) within three years before the filing of the bankruptcy petition.

In this way bankruptcy/tax law creates symmetry between non-dischargeable and dischargeable tax claims. This symmetry allows the IRS the benefit of certain time periods to pursue its collection efforts. Thus, if a tax claim relates to a tax year for which a tax return could have been filed within three years of the bankruptcy petition, it cannot be discharged in a Chapter 7 case.

So, just as "A black hole is a region of spacetime from which gravity prevents anything, including light, from escaping," "non-discharge-ability is a region of bankruptcy/tax law from which the law prevents certain debts, including tax debt, from being discharged."

Yes, I know, the foregoing analogy may be somewhat tortured, but I think you get the point. Just like gravity, the mixture of bankruptcy and tax law is powerful stuff.

 


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Federal Tax Liens and Third Parties ... Where's the cake?

  
By Steven Rubin
  
 
 

  

When I was growing up I loved going to birthday parties. Cake, ice cream, games, toys, presents, boy was that fun. Then I got a little older, and I had a bar mitzvah party. Cake, presents, girls (strategically seated at the various tables to accommodate the youthful desires of my boyfriends), and boy was that fun. Then came a few wedding parties. Cake, presents, girls (more grown up), and boy was that fun. But when I entered into law school, I learned about a new kind of party; one with no cake, no presents, and no girls. In fact, this new kind of party really wasn't a party at all.

You see, I took contracts. And in contracts, generally, there are the "parties" to the contract ... you know, the ones who sign the contract and agree to some arrangement or deal. I learned that when discussing contracts and their underlying transactions, from time to time it became necessary to refer to people (or entities) that did not sign the contract and therefore were not "parties" to the contract. My law school professors taught me that we would refer to these people as "third parties." Not fourth parties, not fifth parties, but third parties. Ok, so why the brief trip down memory lane?

Well, let's set the table a little more. Every April 15th, every warm blooded American citizen (and many others) enters into a written contract of sorts. It's called a Form 1040 Individual Income Tax Return. You sign it, right? Who are the "parties" to this contract? That's right, you and Uncle Sam. I know, Uncle Sam does not sign, but trust me, he's a party. Now, except for you and dear old Uncle Sam, everyone else in known galaxy and beyond is a "third party" where your income taxes are concerned. So why is this important?

Well, have you ever noticed that one of the first things the IRS does when you are unable to full pay your taxes to Uncle Sam is file what is called a "Notice of Federal Tax Lien." What's the rush you might wonder? Doesn't the IRS automatically have a lien against all your property? In many instances, and generally speaking, the answer is yes. But it is not only you that the IRS is thinking about as they rush to mail you the "Notice of Federal Tax Lien." It is those doggone third parties (all those people and entities that are not named you or Uncle Sam). You see if a third party wants to purchase real or personal property from you, and there is a Notice of Federal Tax Lien on file that secures the amounts owed to the IRS, then the third party cannot complete the purchase without addressing the amounts owed to the IRS. If that Notice of Federal Tax Lien is not filed, then generally speaking the third party can complete the purchase without addressing the amounts owed to the IRS, and thus the IRS may lose out on a great chance to get paid. Now you know why the IRS is so quick to file that "Notice of Federal Tax Lien."

Stated more succinctly: Federal tax liens arise automatically upon assessment but are not valid against third parties until the IRS files a lien notice. But wait ... there is more.

When a bankruptcy is involved, as between the bankruptcy estate and the IRS, the bankruptcy estate may be able to retain a debtor's property over the claim of the IRS where a notice of lien has not been filed. Furthermore, "exempt property," (property that generally cannot be reached by a debtor's creditors), may be subject to IRS collection following the close of the bankruptcy proceedings if the federal tax liability is non-dischargeable, or if the taxes are dischargeable but secured by a pre-petition notice of federal tax lien. Furthermore, once filed, the federal tax lien passes through bankruptcy unaffected, provided that the underlying tax liability is not fully satisfied in the bankruptcy proceedings. In fact, the federal tax lien can survive bankruptcy even if the underlying tax liability/debt is itself discharged (kind of like how some insects can survive a nuclear explosion).

So you see, to the IRS, this "Notice of Federal Tax Lien" is a really, really, really important document. It is how the IRS makes sure that not only the taxpayer, but everyone who deals with the taxpayer, has to take into account amounts owed to the IRS by the taxpayer.

There may be no cake or presents, but the IRS sure likes third parties.

 

 

Back to Top 

 

 

 

 

 

  

 

Xenophobia (Spelled FATCA)

 

 

By Steven Rubin
   

 

    

Xenophobia. I have always loved that word. Just saying it makes me feel smarter. My handy Webster's dictionary tells me it means "fear or hatred of strangers or foreigners." I know we are taught not to take candy from strangers. But hey, strangers can be fun, like meeting new people at a party. I do not know whether the IRS knows what the word means, but judging from the 2010 Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act (FATCA) I think the IRS is Xenophobic.

 

First, effective July 1, 2014, a US entity that makes virtually ANY type of payment to a "foreign financial institution" (FFI) will be required to withhold AND REMIT 30% of the payment to the IRS, unless the FFI is documented as exempt from the requirement. How does the FFI become exempt? I am glad you asked. By identifying for the IRS all of its account holders who are US taxpayers. So, either you withhold and remit to the IRS effectively disclosing your relationship with the FFI, or you first confirm that the IRS already knows about it. The IRS may not be sitting at our kitchen tables yet ... but that doesn't mean they can't smell what's cooking.

 

Then there is the Bank Secrecy Act (BSA). The BSA requires that US taxpayers file an annual report with Uncle Sam of any foreign financial accounts with an aggregate value of more than $10,000 at any time during the year. These reports are commonly called "FBAR" (Report of Foreign Bank and Financial Accounts). An FBAR must be filed electronically each year by June 30 by each US person who has a financial interest in, or signature or other authority over, a bank, securities or other financial account in a foreign country, which exceeds $10,000 in value at any time during the calendar year. So what is the penalty for willfully failing to file an FBAR? I am glad you asked:

 

The willful failure to file a FBAR is a FELONY, punishable by a fine of not more than $250,000 or imprisonment for not more than five years, or both.

 

No, that foregoing sentence is not a typo. If you have signature authority on a foreign bank account with a balance that exceeds $10,000 in value for even one day during the calendar and you willfully fail to file an FBAR you are committing a felony.

 

There are many other civil and criminal penalties relating to the failure to disclose foreign bank accounts ... but this should be enough to catch your attention.

 

Xenophobia. Now don't you feel smarter just saying it!

 

 

 


 

 

Death and Taxes: Are Fantasy Football Winnings Taxable?

 

  

 

 

 

  
By Steven Rubin
  

 

 

Benjamin Franklin said, "The only things certain in life are death and taxes." Right again Ben.

Recently I was contacted by an individual who told me he had started to win a lot of money playing fantasy football. He wanted to confirm whether these winnings were taxable, and if so, was there any established method for minimizing the tax bite. Well, turns out this is a very new development and there is between zero and very little guidance out there.

Here is what little we do know. The Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act of 2006 states that Fantasy Leagues such as Fantasy Football are NOT gambling. So the tax laws that relate to gambling are not availing or necessarily helpful. Are Fantasy Football winnings taxable income? You bet (pun intended). Where do you report such winnings? The consensus appears to be on line 21 of the Form 1040 US Individual Income Tax Return. The Fantasy Football League (FFL) winner can expect to receive a Form 1099-Misc from the FFL if his winnings are $600 or more. So the FFL winner can expect that the IRS will be looking forward to his reporting those winnings on his taxes.

Now often, in a situation such as this, the FFL winner may take the position that his FFL activities are a business so that he can offset his winnings with all manner of business expenses like any other business. Whether FFL's themselves are businesses is a question that does not appear to have been tested yet. As for the question of whether there is such thing as a professional fantasy sports player, this seems rather unlikely. If you take that position on your taxes and get audited do not be surprised if that position is aggressively challenged by the IRS.

Bottom line, if you are going to assert that you are a professional fantasy sports player, and deduct "ordinary and necessary" business expenses from your fantasy football winnings, you may want to set aside an amount equal to the tax you would pay if such position were audited and disallowed by the IRS for at least as long as the period of time that the IRS can audit your returns, generally three years from the later of the due date for the return or the date the return was filed.

Just a thought. Go team!

 

 

 

Copyright 2014 by The Law Offices of Steven D. Rubin, A Professional Corporation. To request addition to or removal from our mailing list contact Steven Rubin at The Law Offices of Steven D. Rubin, A Professional Corporation, 1912 Broadway, Suite 105, Santa Monica, CA 90404, phone (310) 453-7812. The Rubin Tax Law eNews Reporter does not attempt to offer solutions to individual problems, but rather to provide information about current developments in those areas of the law encompassed by our law practice. Readers in need of legal assistance should retain the services of competent counsel.