BCN Newsletter: 25 March 2013 

 

Welcome to the latest edition of the BCN Newsletter! 

 

We begin with the first part of a Spotlight on the Ministerial Conference that took place in November 2012 in Sofia, Bulgaria, focused on ending the placement of children under 3 in institutional care in Eastern Europe and Central Asia. In this issue,  two key documents produced by UNICEF for the conference are highlighted:

  • Rights-based Regional Situation Analysis on children under 3 in formal care.
  • Briefing on Keeping Families Together using Social Protection.

 Also in this issue:

  • India: An update on the Integrated Child Protection Scheme and new research on community perceptions about foster care in Rajasthan.
  • Nepal: A new article on cost effectiveness of models of care for children affected by HIV and AIDS.
  • Post 2015 MDG Agenda: A new interagency brief on the links between child protection, health and survival.
  • UN CRC: Care related Concluding Observations Bosnia and Herzegovina, Canada, Namibia, and Albania.

And of course, many upcoming events, conferences, webinars and job opportunities!

Questions? You can reach us at contact@bettercarenetwork.org. Thank you for your continual subscription and partnership in promoting positive and appropriate alternative care options for children!

  

All the best,

The BCN Secretariat

 

IN THIS ISSUE
SPOTLIGHT on SOFIA Ministerial Conference
Eastern Europe and Central Asia: Children under 3 in formal care
Eastern Europe and Central Asia: Keeping Families Together
India: The Integrated Child Protection Scheme
Foster Care in India
Nepal: Cost effectiveness study
Protect my future: the link between child protection and health and survival
CRC Concluding Observations
In the Media: 'Baby boxes'
New Events
Upcoming Webinar
Consultancy and Jobs
General Information

SPOTLIGHT

The SOFIA Ministerial Conference on ending the placement of children under 3 in institutional care in Eastern Europe and Central Asia

A major ministerial conference on ending the placement of children under three in institutional care was held in Sofia, Bulgaria on 21 and 22 November 2012. Organized by the Government of the Republic of Bulgaria in collaboration with UNICEF, it brought together representatives of twenty governments from Eastern Europe and Central Asia, experts from the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child, international and local NGOs and the academic world to discuss strategies and emerging good practices to support vulnerable families and prevent baby abandonment and the placement of children below the age of three in institutions. BCN will be highlighting resources and learning from this important conference over its next two newsletters, starting with a major rights based regional situation analysis of children under three in formal care and a briefing on making social protection more effective for children by keeping families together.

For more information about the Sofia Conference, please visit: http://www.unicef.org/ceecis/media_20824.html

SOFIA 2012

Children under the Age of 3 in Formal Care in Eastern Europe and Central Asia

A Rights-based Regional Situation Analysis 

Through a comprehensive statistical analysis and literature review, this major UNICEF report provides a child rights-based up-to-date review of the situation of children under the age of three in formal care. It examines regional and country level trends in the use of institutional care and family based alternative care options, in particular foster care. While major progress has been achieved in the reform of childcare systems in the CEECIS region ever since the 1990s, analysis of statistical data from the TransMonEE Database that contains government data from 21 countries shows that reform has not yet been translated into the capacity of social protection systems to prevent family separation. 

It is estimated that there are more than 600,000 children in institutional care in the region and that the rate of children in formal care today is higher than it was at the beginning of the transition from the Soviet period. The report finds that the rate of children under the age of three in institutional care in CEECIS countries has been slowly decreasing since the year 2000 but that this decline has been uneven. Three countries (Bosnia and Herzegovina, Tajikistan, and The former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia) are experiencing an alarming increase in the rates of institutionalization of young children, and four countries (Belarus, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Bulgaria, and Russian Federation) have extremely high rates. The report reviews the evidence on the immediate and root causes behind children's separation from their families, highlights promising interventions and describes the steps States and other actors should take in order to prevent family separation, enable family reunification, provide adequate care and protection and, ultimately, make the institutionalization of children under the age of three a thing of the past.  

SOFIA 2012

Keeping Families Together:

Making Social Protection More Effective for Children

This edition of Insights produced by UNICEF summarizes findings and recommendations of studies on the impact and outreach of social protection systems in Albania, Kazakhstan, and Ukraine. All three countries operate social assistance programmes for children and families and are in the process of establishing social services, but high rates of child placement in formal care still persist.  Although all three countries have established clear legislative frameworks for developing comprehensive social protection systems, families are still not receiving effective support because targeted social assistance programs intended to alleviate poverty are not reaching the majority of needy households and non-institution based social services are only being accessed by a small number of parents and caregivers due to lack of information and effective service delivery mechanism. Reasons identified include, lack of awareness about eligibility for assistance, applications for means-tested social assistance are too complicated, a lack of transparency and fairness about access, parents, staff and decision-makers lack knowledge about social services, centre-based social services being usually in towns and difficult for vulnerable families to reach, while weak outreach leads to low-take up by those who need it most.

Some of the interesting solutions being developed in those countries are highlighted and the authors make comprehensive recommendations relevant to many of the countries in the CEE/CIS region. Among other things, they point out that better impact can be achieved at low cost by better coordinating and integrating existing social protection interventions. They recommend using the existing infrastructure and reach of social assistance, health and education structures to extend the reach of social services and also ensuring that there is a nationally agreed minimum package of social protection services and social assistance for all who need it, regardless of where they live in the country and what vulnerabilities they face. 

 

 

NEW POLICY UPDATE

INDIA: The Integrated Child Protection Scheme

In its latest Annual Report (2011-2012), the Indian Ministry of Women and Child Development reports on progress in the child protection and welfare sector, including the implementation of the Integrated Child Protection Scheme (ICPS), a strategy adopted and launched by the central government in 2009-2010. Of particular relevance to children without adequate parental care, the ICPS specifically articulates the need to move away from over-reliance on institutional care and towards responses that support family based care, starting from interventions and policies that would strengthen "the family capabilities to care for and protect the child" to providing a range of family based alternatives, "including sponsorship, kinship care, foster care and adoption."

 

The Ministry reports that the Memorandum of Understanding to implement the ICPS has now been signed between the Government and all States/UTs in the country, except Jammu & Kashmir. Guidelines for the sponsorship of children to enable their deinstitutionalization and reintegration into their families were finalized and a pilot project conducted in 2 States (Orissa and Gujarat). The report also states that provisional guidelines for foster care or orphaned children by Kin and Kith were under testing in 3 States.  In addition, Guidelines for the provision of after care services to children leaving institutional care who are without family support were also developed in 2011-2012. Of note, however, the Ministry also provided funding in this period for 125 Specialized Adoption Agencies (SAAs) and 638 Homes of "various types", that provide "comprehensive rehabilitation services to children including food, clothing, day and night shelter, education, medical facilities to 29,518 children". Assistance was also provided to 25 Homes to improve the quality of infrastructures, and grants for the constructions of 13 new Homes were released. Further, 65 open shelters were also funded under the ICPS during the same period which provide, among other things, vocational training, bridge to education, food to children living on the streets.

 

For further information about the Integrated Child Protection Scheme, please visit:

http://bettercarenetwork.org/BCN/details.asp?id=30591&themeID=1001&topicID=1006

 

To view the full Annual Report from the Indian Ministry of Women and Child Development, please visit:

 http://bettercarenetwork.org/BCN/details.asp?id=30594&themeID=1001&topicID=1006

 

NEW RESEARCH

Foster Care in India: An Exploratory Survey of the Community Perceptions and Prospects for Implementation of Foster Care in a Developing Nation 

This article presents the findings of an exploratory survey of community perceptions about foster care in Udaipur City, Rajasthan, India. This study was conducted in order to assess the prospects for implementing foster care as an alternative to the dominant system of institutional care available to orphaned and abandoned children in India. 653 families participated in a mixed-methods based assessment of receptivity to foster and adoptive care. The vast majority of respondents (97%) were not familiar with the concept of foster care prior to the study, but once provided with information, over 90% stated that foster care could be implemented in Udaipur and more broadly in India. However, only 32.5% of the respondents reported willingness to provide foster care to a child, citing factors such as timing ("not the right time in life"), social pressure/judgment, family opposition and financial issues as the top factors that would influence a decision whether or not to foster.

  

The results are discussed in light of governmental calls for non-governmental organizations and other stakeholders to participate in the construction of a more robust child welfare system, which would include foster care. The authors point out that while respondents reported seeing foster care as a positive theoretical concept, there were a number of factors that could heavily impact individual decision-making about participating in this system. These would need to be better understood and addressed by policy makers and service providers involved in developing the foster care system. The results of this study have applied significance for organizations and practitioners seeking to implement care alternatives for orphan and abandoned children in India.

 

 For further information and to access the abstract, please visit: http://bettercarenetwork.org/BCN/details.asp?id=30559&themeID=1002&topicID=1013

 

NEW RESEARCH
Cost-effectiveness of models of care quality for childern affected by HIV and AIDS in Nepal 
This new study aims to identify and assess the cost effectiveness for existing models of care for Children Affected by HIV and AIDS (CABA) in Nepal. The study performed a cost effective analysis for types of care and support models available to CABAs in order to provide program managers and childcare professionals comparative economic evidence of the cost of caring for these children. Comparative analysis for cost effectiveness was done in terms of quality and overall modes of care delivery, using government minimum standards guidelines as a framework.

 

The study identified only three types of care models prevalent in Nepal: comprehensive care model, home-based care and support, and community-based care with income generation activities. Community-based care with income generation was found to be the most cost effective care model. It imparted children with better socialization by retaining children's social and familial contexts and environments, and with professional skills through its income generating activities. However, the authors note that a single model of care cannot provide the continuum needed for these children, and other care models and safety nets should be employed to reach as many CABAs as possible in Nepal. Despite HIV/AIDS being a priority one disease in the government's health agenda, government run child care homes did not accept children with HIV/AIDS.  The authors call for the promotion of community based childcare models with income generation activities, and for the creation of a networking system that builds on the success of previous networks for the identification and placement of these children in appropriate care models.

 

  
NEW POLICY BRIEF
Protect my Future: The Link between Child Protection and Health and Survival

This inter-agency paper was written by Family for Every Child, Better Care Network, Consortium for Street Children, Save the Children, SOS Children's Villages, and World Vision, for submission to the United Nations consultation: 'Health in the Post-2015 Development Agenda.'  The paper demonstrates the interdependence between goals on health and child survival and the protection and care of children and argues that for the mutual benefits of both these areas, the framework that will replace the MDGs in 2015 should both continue to include a focus on health and child survival, and encompass particular goals and indicators on children's protection.

 

Maternal health and HIV have major impacts on child protection outcomes. The continuing rates of maternal mortality leave children growing up without a mother. Whilst these boys and girls are often cared for by fathers or extended family, they can be both less likely to survive and more vulnerable to child protection risks. The vast majority of children outside of parental care in the developing world are looked after by their families, most commonly grandparents. Despite their best efforts, a lack of external support means that older caregivers are not always able to provide the best care their grandchildren need to survive and thrive. The paper asserts that improving the quality of alternative care will make MDG targets on infant mortality and nutrition more achievable. Many children placed in alternative care experience poor care quality that it threatens their survival. The authors argue that it is imperative for future health and survival goals to include targets reflecting equity in access to health care, especially for the children without adequate care and protection, and a post-MDG framework that encapsulates prevention of violence, exploitation, abuse, and neglect of children as well as provision for a safe family environment

 


COUNTRY CARE REPORTS

Care related Concluding Observations by

the Committee on the Rights of the Child

Spotlight on recently adopted Concluding Observations by the Committee on the Rights of the Child in its examination of State Party reports, with a particular focus on sections addressing Family Environment and Alternative Care.  

 

In this edition, we highlight four countries examined during the 61th Session of the Committee held from the 17 September to 5 October 2012: Bosnia and Herzegovina, Canada, Namibia, and Albania.

 

To access the Concluding Observations on Bosnia and Herzegovina, please visit:

http://bettercarenetwork.org/BCN/details.asp?id=30527&themeID=1001&topicID=1006

 

To access the Concluding Observations on Canada, please visit:

http://bettercarenetwork.org/BCN/details.asp?id=30526&themeID=1001&topicID=1006

 

To access the Concluding Observations on Namibia, please visit:

http://bettercarenetwork.org/BCN/details.asp?id=30528&themeID=1001&topicID=1006

 

To access the Concluding Observations on Albania, please visit:

http://bettercarenetwork.org/BCN/details.asp?id=30580&themeID=1001&topicID=1006

 

IN THE MEDIA

Child Abandonement and the Use of 'Baby Boxes'

The use of 'baby boxes' or hatches has received a lot of attention recently, with number of babies left in hatches reported to be on the rise across Europe. At least 11 of the 27 countries of the European Union now operate baby boxes. Two recent reports in the media highlighted some of the issues and controversies, with a focus on Germany.

NPR: Spread Of 'Baby Boxes' Alarms Europeans

In this new radio report by NPR  a representative from an organization that runs the first baby hatch that opened in Germany in modern times explains the process of placing a baby in a hatch and how the system operates. Kevin Browne, director of the Center of Forensic and Family Psychology at Britain's Nottingham University has spent years researching baby abandonment and submitted his findings on the issue to the United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child. Browne argues that baby boxes are considered dangerous because they don't uphold children's rights or parental rights, and they promote the unsafe birth of children in the community rather than with medical and health support in hospital environments. He also highlights that it is not always mothers that leave babies in those hatches but can be other individuals doing so without the consent of the parent. The report also hears from a German lawyer who has written a book about baby boxes. He highlights that although women abandon babies in maternity units far more often that depositing them in baby boxes, some women are deterred from doing this because it is too complicated and they don't trust the authorities to protect their anonymity. 

To access the NPR report, please visit:

http://bettercarenetwork.org/BCN/details_news.asp?id=30563&themeID=1000&topicID=1000

Meanwhile, Germany is moving to address some of the concerns, as can be seen from this recent BBC article:

BBC NEWS: Germany to allow hospital births under false name 

The German cabinet has agreed a bill allowing women going through unwanted pregnancies to give birth in hospital under a false name. The draft law is aimed at reducing unsafe births and giving mothers an alternative to abandoning unwanted newborns in so-called baby boxes. The number of babies left in hatches has been on the rise across Europe. Last year, the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child warned that it "contravenes the right of the child to be known and cared for by his or her parents". Under the new confidential birth draft law, mothers giving birth in hospital would be able to provide a false name on the birth certificate. The baby would then be given up for adoption. Children would still be able to learn their mother's identity after turning 16, according to the bill.  The proposal would become law in May 2014 if passed by parliament.

 

To access the full report, please visit:

 http://bettercarenetwork.org/BCN/details_news.asp?ID=30529&themeID=1000&topicID=1000

NEW EVENTS

 Launch of a new resource on Supporting and Strengthening Child-Caregiver Relationships
 
PEPFAR, in partnership with USAID's AIDSTAR-Two Project and the Human Sciences Research Council (HSRC) of South Africa, is announcing the launch of a new resource, Supporting and Strengthening Child-Caregiver Relationships on Tuesday March 26 2013 at the Hotel Palomar in Washington, DC. 
 

The objective of this launch is to:

    • Share findings from a literature review of global parenting research
    • Discuss the potential for adapting research findings in low income HIV-affected settings

The launch will take place from 9:00 am - noon EST and is open to the public (although space is limited). If you cannot join in person, participation is also possible virtually via a live webinar.  

 For more information about the event and participating in the Webinar, please visit: http://campaign.r20.constantcontact.com/render?llr=a5ybrycab&v=001T68Z-93cJFbO-58Y2pQUxqHkPnIFm5g_3jVMTQlIj3-L9lzG__3J0OM4GQMV4giJEqiMUHnz2tHY_xz0wIbVhKA2S6mikLTuWV-9mxtp28RRqzUvOUWLnYH-3NTzXkO8hVDwHUhXjMA%3D

 

 

Half Day of General Discussion with the Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD)

  

The Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities will host its Half Day of General Discussion on "Women and Girls with Disabilities" at OHCHR, Room XX, Palais des Nations, Geneva on April 17th, 2013 at 12:00-1:00pm and 3:00-6:00pm.

 

The event will be presented in three different sessions:

 

Session I: Intersectionality of gender and disability

Session II: Violence against women and girls with disabilities

Session III: Sexual and reproductive rights and women and girls with disabilities

 

Keynote speakers include Rashida Manjoo, UN Special Rapporteur on Violence against Women, and panellists from UN Women, UNICEF, State Parties implementing best practices, and DPO/NGOs active in this area.

 

For further information about the event and the work of the CRPD, please visit:

http://www.ohchr.org/en/hrbodies/crpd/pages/crpdindex.aspx

  

 

The 2013 RELAF Seminar "Strengthening the Advances: 

Creating tools for the accomplishment of the Right to live 

in a family and in a community." 

  

Relaf has announced that its 2013 Seminar will be held during the first week of October in Guanajuato, Mexico. The event will be organized with the cooperation of the Mexican Network for the Right to live in a Family and a Community, the government of Mexico and UNICEF. Relevant international and regional organizations have also showed their support. The event will be a space of exchange between the relevant actors of the field of alternative care.

 

The 2013 Seminar will take stock of the advances achieved in the field of alternative care, and identify the goals that are still pending in the region. Among the highlighted themes: the Regional Initiative for the de-institutionalization of children under the age of three; the effective implementation of the Guidelines; the Articulated Project between Relaf and ISS; the presentation of the "Report on Discrimination in residential care institutions"; and the training for the realization of the workshops with children and their carers.

 

For further information, please visit: http://bettercarenetwork.org/BCN/Events.asp

 

UPCOMING WEBINAR:

Social Service Workforce Strengthening Webinar Series 

The Global Social Service Workforce Alliance presents its 9th Social Service Workforce Strengthening Webinar Series, 

Professionalizing the Social Services Workforce: The Role of Licensing, on Thursday March 28th, 2013 at 8:30-10:30am EST (Washington).

 

Countries are making efforts to professionalize their social service workforce. In some cases, this means introducing regulations, such as requiring exams, licenses and professional development courses to practice social work. A number of questions arise as to the benefits and challenges of this approach, including who should be regulated, what type of education and training they should have, along with what to do with the number of para professional workers who expend a great deal of time and work in social service related efforts.

 

The webinar will offer an opportunity to hear from two experts in this area who are leading national social work associations and councils: Phillip Bohwasi, Chairman, Zimbabwe Council of Social Workers and Tata Sudrajat, President, Indonesian Association of Professional Social Workers and Family Based Care Senior Program Manager, Save the Children. Participants will have the opportunity for discussion with the speakers as well as other participants through the webinar format.

 

For more information about this upcoming webinar and how to participate, please visit:

http://bettercarenetwork.org/BCN/Events.asp

 

CONSULTANCY AND JOB POSTING

Consultancy Opportunity: Child Protection Exchange Forum Coordinator

 

Save the Children is looking to commission a consultant to take on the role of the Exchange Forum Coordinator for a six-month period from May-October 2013. 

 

Save the Children coordinates an interagency learning initiative on community based child protection mechanisms and child protection systems. This work involves hosting and coordinating the Community Child Protection Exchange Forum - www.childprotectionforum.org - a global community of practice to share knowledge and experience on community based child protection mechanisms and child protection systems across agencies and practitioners in the child protection sector.

 

This is a part-time role and it is expected that the consultant will work for three days per week over the six month period.  However, the workload may vary from week to week depending on the level of Forum activity therefore some flexibility in working pattern will be required.

 

Expected start date is 1 May 2013

Application deadline is 9 April 2013

 

For a full description of the terms of reference, please see: http://bettercarenetwork.org/BCN/details_news.asp?id=30578&themeID=1002&topicID=1016

 

 

UNICEF Turkey's Team of International Consultants for "Strengthening the Internal Audit for Child Care Services

and Establishment of Self-Assessment System" (ToR-TURA-2013-16)

 

UNICEF Turkey is seeking a team of international consultants for "Strengthening the Internal Audit for Child Care Services and Establishment of Self-Assessment System." The proposal should be sent with a Personal History Form (P-11), financial proposal, and technical proposal in separate folders to both esavur@unicef.org and fyapar@unicef.org.

 

Application deadline is 5 April 5 2013, 5:00pm.

 

Please visit the following link to access the full Terms of Reference (ToR), Personal History Form, and further evaluation criteria:

 http://www.unicef.org.tr/en/content/detail/29/tender-announcements-from-unicef-2.html

 

GENERAL INFORMATION

 

The newsletter participants, currently 3,230 in total, are working on issues related to the care and support of vulnerable children across Europe, Africa, the Middle East, Asia and the Americas.  The purpose of the newsletter is to enable members to exchange information on matters of mutual concern. If you would like to share a document, raise a specific issue, or reach out in any other way to the Network, please send the information to us at contact@bettercarenetwork.org.  In the interest of keeping messages consolidated, we will manage announcements on the newsletter and send out a few messages each month.

 

We would like to involve as many people as possible who are concerned with better care issues in the Network. Please advise anyone who would like to be added to the newsletter to send us a message at contact@bettercarenetwork.org with"newsletter request" in the subject line. Alternatively, visit the homepage of the Better Care Network website at http://www.bettercarenetwork.org and click on the upper right box where it says, "click here to sign up for our email announcements." Thank you.