Errata Studies, Vol. 1-7
Timothy Topolewski
Timothy Topolewski is both a respected wind band director and a wind band scholar as well (and he hand-crafts professional level batons as well - ask me about those some time). He served as the co-editor along with Fred Fennell on the current, full-score edition of Lincolnshire Posy that has become the staple of the repertoire. Over the last several decades he has taken upon himself a monumental project.
The music printing and publishing world in the pre-computer age was a very different beast. Sometimes a special typewriter-like machines were used to individually typeset the parts from a full score. Sometimes stencils or stamps were used for each individual note and marking. Sometimes they were hand written. In all of these cases, human error allowed for a number of inconsistencies and mistakes to occur in both the score and the parts. Many of us have had the situation where the band just isn't playing a passage correctly, only to find out there's a wrong note, phrasing, or other error in the part.
Timothy has taken printed score and parts to standard works of wind band and wind ensemble literature, then carefully goes through the entire piece one note at a time, comparing the score to the parts, and finds every inconsistency. Every. Single. One. He then lays them all out for you, score errors and parts errors. Often it's an obvious transcribing mistake and he'll note what the correct note, dynamic, phrasing, or articulation should be. In the few cases where the answer is not clear cut, he simply points out the inconsistency and leaves it to the director to resolve it.
This is all standard repertoire, so anyone conducting one of these works should have the errata list beforehand so you can make all your corrections before the parts even get handed out. There are currently seven volumes:
Vol. 1 - Chester Overture; Four Scottish Dances;Incantation and Dance; Al Fresco; Symphony No. 3; Sketches on a Tudor Psalm; Symphony in B Flat; Elsa's Procession to the Cathedral; Circus Polka
Vol. 2 - Enigma Variations; Kaddish; "March" from Symphonic Metamorphosis; Octet for Wind Instruments; Overture to Candide (Beeler); Sinfonietta; Suite Francaise; Symphony for Band (Persichetti); Theme and Variations, Op. 43a; Trittico
Vol. 3 - Serenade Op. 7 (Strauss); Rondino (Beethoven); Petite Symphonie (Gounod); Serenade No. 1 (Persichetti); Histoire du Soldat (Stravinsky); Octet (Beethoven); The Good Soldier Schweik Suite (Kurka); Hill Song No. 2 (Grainger); Serenade Op. 44 (Dvor�k)
Vol. 4 - The Hounds of Spring Overture; Variations on a Korean Folk Song; La Fiesta Mexicana; Huntingtower Ballad; Psalm for Band; Esprit de Corps
Vol. 5 - Chorale and Alleluia; Do Not Go Gentle Into That Good Night; Symphonic Dance #3 "Fiesta"; Havendance; Watchman, Tell us of the Night; Symphony No. 5 "Finale" (Shostakovich/Righter); Lincolnshire Posy - Percy Grainger (Fennell edition - yes he found errors even in the revised edition); Eternal Father Strong to Save
Vol. 6 - Canzona (Menin); Toccata for Band (Erickson); Fantasia for Band (Giannini); Kentucky 1800; Emblems
Vol. 7 - Toccata Marziale. Yes, the whole volume is JUST about Toccata Marziale. It's based on the eariler, pre-Battisti edition of the work, although it is my understanding that the Battisti edition focused more on cleaning up the score rather than the parts.
Vol. 8 (FORTHCOMING) - Russian Christmas Music; Salvation is Created; Galop (Shostakovich/Hunsberger); Flight (Smith); Beowulf (McBeth); Armenian Dances Part 1 and 2. He's more than half way done on these. When it's ready I'll be sure to announce it here.
|