S&C Business Card Back 590-118
Spotlight Master Logo 600
backtotop
January 23, 2014
Volume 10, Issue 1
In This Issue
Brown & Brown Has Acquired ICA
Group Management Services, Inc. Merged with Odgen Benefits Administration, Employee Benefit Concepts, and Variable Protection Administrators
First Insurance Company of Hawaii Acquired Brandvold Ku, Inc.
VeriClaim Has Acquired Property Claims Services, Inc.
NCA Group Acquired TURCO Claim Services, Inc.
HealthPlan Holdings, Inc.Has Acquired Administrative Services, Inc.
Crawford & Company Acquired Lloyd Warwick International Limited.
Selected Sherman & Company Transactions



For more information about our services or to learn how we can help you explore your strategic alternatives, please contact us:  
Managing Director & CEO
(212) 897-9444

Senior Vice President
(704) 943-2672

Associate
(704) 943-2668

Join Our Mailing List
Spotlight on Third Party Administrators

Third party administrators ("TPAs") and insurance claims adjusters undertake labor-intensive field work, administrative duties, and processing functions on behalf of insurance carriers, insurance funds, managing general agents/underwriters, and occasionally other TPAs. TPAs and adjusters also provide clients with advisory services where the primary input is human capital.  Most individuals employed in the industry have undergone significant training, in addition to possessing other qualifications, making each TPA and adjusting firm unique and desirable to different acquirers. 
 
 
According to Duff & Phelps, the operating environment for TPAs has been challenging through the economic downturn, but with signs of recovery growing stronger through 2012 and into 2013, results began to improve.  Adjusting firms had a strong 2011, which was noted by industry sources as one of the highest loss years on record, but muted 2012, with the exception of Sandy, and first half 2013 catastrophe activity has left many adjusting firms well short of 2011 revenues.¹ ² 
 

There has been considerable M&A activity within the TPA and adjusting space over the past year.  Acquirers with excess capital in search of non-risk, fee-based companies have generated significant market interest in TPAs and independent adjusting firms.  Private equity has shown increasing interest in the sector, and there has been greater consolidation among regional and local players.  As recent M&A trends would suggest, TPAs with diversified product offerings and solid business results receive strong valuation multiples in the market.

 

Part of the solid valuations noted in the market relate to the observed scarcity of larger deals, as the number of large service providers is small comparatively.  The TPA/adjusting market is fragmented and the companies are typically spread out regionally.  There are regional leaders, but few national competitors.  The goal for some acquirers has been to bring regional players together in order to create a platform with national scope.

 

IBISWorld's Third-Party Administrators & Insurance Claims Adjusters Market Research Report indicates that carriers are also becoming more comfortable outsourcing work.  They also note that the percentage of claims adjusting done by third parties continues to rise as insurance companies look for ways to cut their expense ratios in a competitive environment.  Carriers have begun to realize that they can expect service levels from TPAs that meet their clients expectations.³  

 

The market demand in 2013 for niche and/or comprehensive claims solutions and the scarcity of good targets has led to strong valuation multiples and increased deal volume for TPA and loss adjusting firms.  We have highlighted some of the transactions that have occurred over the past year in the deal summaries below. 

 
Source: 
  1. Business Services: Third Party Administrator Insights, Industry Insights (2012, January) Duff & Phelps
  2. Healthcare Services Sector Update (2013, February-November) Duff & Phelps
  3. Third-Party Administrators & Insurance Claims Adjusters Market Research Report, NAICS 52429 (2013, June 27) IBISWorld

 

TPA Deal Volume  

 

 Brown & Brown Acquired ICA

 

Brown & Brown, Inc. (NYSE: BRO), through its subsidiaries, acquired ICA, Inc., a provider of insurance claims adjusting and related services, including third party administration. Brown & Brown, Inc. offers a broad range of insurance and reinsurance products and related services. This acquisition expanded the company's insurance claims adjusting operations throughout the United States.  The transaction closed on January 2, 2014. Financial terms of the transaction were not disclosed.

Group Management Services, Inc. Merged with Ogden Benefits Administration, Employee Benefit Concepts, and Variable Protection Administrators

 

Group Management Services, Inc., a professional employer organization that provides payroll, human resources, benefits, and risk management services, merged with third party administrators Ogden Benefits Administration, an employee benefits third party administrator for self-funded employers, Employee Benefit Concepts, a provider of health insurance, and Variable Protection Administrators, a provider of insurance services.  The acquisition enables GMS to offer customers an alternative to Adjusted Community Rating in order to mitigate premium increases, thus lowering healthcare costs for employers.  The transaction closed on October 1, 2013 and the total consideration was undisclosed.

First Insurance Company of Hawaii Acquired Brandvold Ku, Inc.

 

First Insurance Company of Hawaii ("FICOH"), a subsidiary of  global insurer, Tokio Marine & Nichido Fire Insurance Co., Ltd.,  acquired specific assets of Brandvold Ku, Inc., a claims adjusting third  party administrator on August 28, 2013.  FICOH, a P&C insurance company, will transition key employees, client relationships, and double its client volume.  Financial terms of the transaction were undisclosed.
VeriClaim Acquired Property Claims Services, Inc.

 

VeriClaim, Inc., a subsidiary of T&H Global Holdings, LLC, a provider of specialized insurance claims services to insurers, insurance brokers, corporations, and public entities, acquired Property Claims Services, Inc. ("PCS") on August 26, 2013.  PCS is a provider of loss adjusting and claims handling services to the P&C insurance market.  The acquisition strengthens VeriClaim's loss adjusting presence in the South and Central U.S. and expands its P&C capabilities.  The total consideration was undisclosed. 

NCA Group Acquired TURCO Claim Services, Inc.

  
NCA Group ("NCA"), a commercial and residential insurance adjusting company, acquired TURCO Claim Services, Inc. ("TURCO") on August 1, 2013.  TURCO is a provider of loss adjusting and claims management services throughout North America.  The acquisition bolsters NCA's large commercial loss adjusting capabilities and daily claims services in Indiana, Illinois, and Ohio.  The financial terms remain undisclosed. 

HealthPlan Holdings, Inc. Acquired Administrative Services, Inc.

 

HealthPlan Holdings, Inc., a business process outsourcing company for the benefits industry, acquired Administrative Services, Inc. ("ASI") on March 19, 2013.  ASI is a third party administrator offering claim processing, pension processing, call center management, contribution accounting, case management, and consulting services to Taft-Hartley, state governments, and large employers.  The transaction added key client relationships and expanded the company's client development capabilities.  The total consideration was undisclosed

Crawford & Company Acquired Lloyd Warwick International Limited

 

Crawford & Company (NYSE: CRDA; CRDB), an independent provider of claims management solutions, acquired a majority interest in Lloyd Warwick International Limited ("LWI") on March 7, 2013.  LWI is a specialist loss consulting company that offers onshore and offshore energy expertise.  The acquisition of LWI was in line with Crawford's strategy of growing its portfolio of services and building on its existing capability to handle offshore claims in the energy market.  The financial terms of the deal remain undisclosed.

Below are some selected transactions


Mapflow
92-Global Excess V2 149x203
AQS 149x203
SBLI v2 149x203
96_RiskMeter V3
PCM US Risk
100_Meadowbrook 200x273
Seibels-The Members
Apollo
Nova Pro
Auto Club

Sherman & Company is a boutique investment banking firm focused solely on the insurance industry.  Our services include:  Mergers & Acquisitions, Capital Raising, Valuations, Strategic Advisory & Fairness Opinions, and Regulatory Services.

For more information about our services, contact us either by phone  

(704) 943-2600 or email. 

 

6302 Fairview Road, Suite 320
Charlotte, North Carolina 28210
(704) 943-2600 
 
200 Park Avenue, 17th Floor
New York, New York  10166
(212)  897-9444
 
Securities transactions are offered through Sherman & Company LLC, member FINRASIPC.