David Casaletto, Executive Director, Ozarks Water Watch
I remember being amazed when I discovered there are no natural lakes in Missouri. Now there are natural oxbow lakes, lakes that remain in old river channels after the river changes course, and we also have natural sinkhole ponds or lakes formed from collapsed cave systems. What we don't have in Missouri is the type of natural lakes resulting from past glaciation that are so plentiful in the Great Lakes states and Canada.
The largest man-made lakes in Missouri.
The location of these man-made lakes becomes a real problem when EPA and DNR attempt to develop lake numeric nutrient criteria, in other words, what is that number when the lake is then declared to be polluted. I have been involved in this struggle for around 10 years now and it is still ongoing.
As shown above, Mark Twain Lake can be impacted by sediment.
Most all of our reservoirs were constructed in the mid 1900s long after the landscape had been altered, mainly for agricultural purposes, especially in the northern half of Missouri. The location of the reservoirs are all man made decisions and therefore none of the lakes can be identified as having natural reference conditions. EPA requires Missouri to follow national water quality standards that support "designated uses" such as Aquatic Habitat Protection, Human Health Protection, Whole Body Contact Recreation and Drinking Water Supply.
City of Springfield water supply pumping station at Stockton Lake.
The problem is that some of the "Designated Uses" do not coincide and are in fact often at odds with each other. In particular, the designated use for Aquatic Habitat Protection for aquatic life depends in many cases on a relatively high availability of nutrients to supply the food chain. In contrast, suitability of lake waters for Drinking Water Supply and Whole Body Contact favors lower nutrient content, which would produce lower levels of algae and increased water clarity. It is a case of who wins out, fish or people....
The aquatic food chain starts with algae.
Finding that balance between water clarity and aquatic habitat and giving it a hard and fast number is a tough job, yet that is what EPA is telling the states they must do. And no matter what number is ultimately arrived at, not everyone or maybe not anyone will be happy. It will be an imperfect compromise that will be our best guess at how to find that balance.