The HML Post 
 
 
Greetings!
 
Welcome to the March 3rd, edition of the HML POST

Highlights of the 92nd annual Meeting of the HML, Click here.
Check out HML's Cornerstone on "FLIPBOARD."   (The public schools are the "Cornerstone" of our democracy.)

  

South Carolina and Common Core: A Next Step  by Paul Thomas in The Becoming Radical

After the hearing, I (Paul Thomas) concluded that John Hill of the Alabama Policy Institute had it right when he wrote: "Although both sides of the Common Core debate make arguments worth consideration, both the potential benefits and pitfalls related to Common Core have been the subject of exaggeration and error."

This is why Palmetto Policy Forum recently released a paper we believe cuts through the Common Core fog, outlining an eight-point plan to return unquestioned control of education standards to S.C. parents.

  

Duncan, Civil Rights, & Highly Qualified Teachers  by Peter Green in the Curmudgucation News

Assistant Secretary Deb Delisle did some talking shortly after the State of the Union address about the new 50-state strategy regarding highly qualified teachers, presenting a kind of coming attractions trailer of possible policy. Fans of reformy stuff will remember that NCLB put a deadline on putting a highly-qualified teacher in front of every student in the country, and NCLB waivers initially kept that requirement in place, but the Obama administration has since quietly dropped that.  

  

Why test-based school reform isn't working - by the numbers   by Valerie Strauss in the Washington Post.

Award-winning Prinicipal Carol Burris of South Side High School in New York has been exposing the problems with New York's botched school reform effort for a long time on this blog. (You can read some of her work hereherehere,  here, and here.) In the following post she looks at irrefutable data to show that the test-based reforms are taking public education down the wrong road.  

  

Research  -  Peer Contexts: Do Old for Grade and Retained Peers Influence Student Behavior in Middle School?  by by Clara G. MuschkinElizabeth Glennie & Audrey N. Beck  in the Teachers College Record

This study analyzes the association between the presence of old for grade and retained peers and the propensity for seventh graders to engage in deviant behaviors and receive an out-of-school suspension. Then, we examine whether some students are more vulnerable to peer influences associated with having retained and older peers.

  

Why Americans Are So Polarized: Education and Evolution  by Avi Tuschman in the Atlantic Monthly  

A familiar explanation for our deepening partisan divide is Bill Bishop's Big Sort hypothesis. He contends that over the past 40 years, Americans have been sorting themselves into communities where people increasingly live, think, and vote like their neighbors. In 1976, for example, just more than a quarter of Americans resided in counties where presidential candidates won the election by a margin of 20 percent or more; but by the year 2004, nearly half of Americans lived in these more politically homogeneous counties.  

  

 How to Analyze False Claims about Charter Schools  by Diane Ravitch on the Ravitch Blog.

They do not have a "secret sauce," the phrase once used by Mayor Rahm Emanuel to describe the Noble Network of Charter Schools, each of which is named to honor a very rich patron.  They do have a secret recipe, however, for manufacturing the illusion of success.  Be wise. Think critically. Read carefully.

Here is expert advice:

Reports and stories about charter schools are in the media every day. The majority of these stories praise charters, while often demeaning public schools. We propose that every reader of such stories ask the following questions before taking the claims of such articles seriously.


Testing to, and Beyond, the Common Core  by Linda Darling Hammond in NAESP's The Principal 

After more than a decade of test-driven, high-stakes accountability in the No Child Left Behind era, many educators and policymakers in the United States are looking to move toward a more thoughtful approach. Rather than maintaining a system that uses narrow measures of student achievement to sanction poorly performing schools, the push is now to implement next-generation learning goals that encourage higher-order thinking skills.   The driving force behind this shift is the Common Core State Standards (CCSS) for English language arts and mathematics. Forty-five states and the District of Columbia have adopted the standards. State-led initiatives-such as the Next Generation Science Standards and Common Career Technical Core-are next in line.

 

The Myth Behind Public School Failure    by Dean Paton in the YES Magazine Blog

Until about 1980, America's public schoolteachers were iconic everyday heroes painted with a kind of Norman Rockwell patina-generally respected because they helped most kids learn to read, write and successfully join society. Such teachers made possible at least the idea of a vibrant democracy.  Since then, what a turnaround: We're now told, relentlessly, that bad-apple schoolteachers have wrecked K-12 education; that their unions keep legions of incompetent educators in classrooms; that part of the solution is more private charter schools; and that teachers as well as entire schools lack accountability, which can best be remedied by more and more standardized "bubble" tests. 

 

 

Interest in the "Inverted U" was started after reading Malcom Gladwell's recent book, David and Galiath (2013).  Gladwell present the case that "too much of a good thing" as it relates to class size. His point is that as the class size is lowered, achievement is better, but only to a point.  If class size becomes too small, then there is a marginal or negative effect on learning. Other words, "too much of a good thing can be result in a negative result."  Is it practical to apply the "Inverted U" theory to other educationally related issues?

 

 

 

This Week in History, 1969: Tinker v. Des Moines Case Wins Free Speech Rights for Students  by Mary Beth Tinker  in AlterNet.org

A 6th grader in Texas with the user name "Gummy Bear" pops onto my laptop screen. She's doing a National History Day project about "rights and responsibilities" that highlights the Supreme Court case Tinker v. Des Moines that I was a plaintiff in.  She wants to know why I wore a black armband to school in 8th grade in 1965, and why the court ruled on February 24, 1969, that neither students nor teachers "shed their Constitutional rights to freedom of speech or expression at the schoolhouse gate."

 

If you want kids to fail, stop making failure so horrible    by Matt Bruenig  In This Week

If you want kids to fail, stop making failure so horrible.  Children can't be expected to take risks when the societal consequences are so crushing.  Much as we like to pretend otherwise, failure is likely.  It is important that people take risks. Innovation depends on it.  That's the generic sentiment that sloshes around the cult of entrepreneurship and small business, a cult that has managed to seep into so much of our mainstream economic discourse. According to this sentiment, we need people out there doing novel things that will mostly fail but occasionally lead to significant breakthroughs that generate new goods, services, and processes that improve our lives. 

All of the past issues of the HML Posts are available for view and search purposes at 
 

http://www.hmleague.org/hml-weekly-blog/

  

See these and other related articles in the "Cornerstone" Internet magazine.

 

 


Reprinted with permission.
 
 
About Us
The Horace Mann League of the USA is an honorary society that promotes the ideals of Horace Mann by advocating for public education as the cornerstone of our democracy.

 

Officers:
President: Gary Marx, President, Center for Public Outreach, Vienna, VA
President-elect: Charles Fowler, Exec. Director, Suburban School Admin. Exter, HN
Vice President: Christine  Johns-Haines, Superintendent, Utica Community Schools, MI
1st Past President: Joe Hairston, President, Vision Unlimited, Reisterstown, MD
2nd Past President: Mark Edwards, Superintendent, Mooresville Graded Schools, NC

Directors:
Laurie Barron, Supt. of Schools, Evergreen School District, Kalispell , MT
Martha Bruckner, Supt., Council Bluffs Community Schools, IA
Evelyn Blose-Holman, (ret.) Superintendent, Bay Shore Schools, NY
Carol Choye, Instructor, Bank Street College, NY
Brent Clark, Exec. Dir., Illinois Assoc. of School Admin. IL
Linda Darling Hammond, Professor of Education, Stanford U. CA
James Harvey, Exec. Dir., Superintendents Roundtable, WA
Eric King, Superintendent, (Ret.) Muncie Public Schools, IN
Steven Ladd, Superintendent, Elk Grove Unified School District, Elk Grove, CA 
Barry Lynn, Exec. Dir., Americans United, Washington, DC
Kevin Maxwell, CEO, Prince George's County Schools, Upper Marlboro, MD
Stan Olson, Director, Silverback Learning, Boise, ID
Steven Webb, Supt. of Schools, Vancouver School District, WA

 

Executive Director:
Jack McKay, Professor Emeritus, University of Nebraska at Omaha, 
560 Rainier Lane, Port Ludlow, WA 98365 (360) 821 9877
 
To become a member of the HML, click here to download an application.