|
DIRECTORS' COLUMN
By Seth Warren, PhD
Going Deep
Full fathom five thy father lies;
Of his bones are coral made;
Those are pearls that were his eyes:
Nothing of him that doth fade,
But doth suffer a sea-change
Into something rich and strange...
-W. Shakespeare, The Tempest ("Ariel's Song")
I would like to share a fascinating and surprising moment I experienced recently, in which psychoanalytic work made an entirely unexpected cameo appearance. First, however, I want to take a detour through a few psychoanalytic reflections on the meanings of water, both universal and personal.
Water has always had rich psychoanalytic connotations. In our work we refer to "surface" and "depth," our treatments are described as "depth-oriented," and the psychology of the unconscious has long been called "Depth Psychology." The contents of water are concealed from our conscious eyes, but we intuit the energy and forces below, sometimes in our thoughtful reflection and in our dreams, breaking the surface to encounter them.
All life comes from the sea, "she" is mother to us all, and each of us came into existence first as aquatic beings, in the silent sea of our own mother's wombs. Many world rituals of rebirth and regeneration involve water. We are baptized in water, born again; we cast our sins into the sea, water so vast - its infinite aspect mirroring God's - that they disappear there and we are clean once again. Water has always symbolized transformation, a substance remarkably available to us in three different states. Water is connected with change, there are dissolving processes, rusting, crystalizing processes, currents, waves and, always, the depths.
My earliest dream/memory is of fish, golden and beautiful, in a pond in no recognizable context. All throughout my life, even up to the present, I have had vivid dreams of an underwater world, seeing objects through water from above, and of oddly beautiful and alien creatures there, evocative, shimmering, and enigmatic, perhaps representing unconscious elements, simultaneously strange and familiar, sometimes inspiring fear or awe.
On a more conscious level, I have many happy memories involving the water. My father teaching me to swim, and his taking me as a small boy into the ocean at Rockaway Beach; many childhood summer vacations in Wellfleet, snorkeling in the ponds, and bodysurfing at the ocean beaches there; beachcombing with my children when they were small, finding magical watery creatures and treasures.
But when I learned to scuba dive about 12 years ago, I was finally able to break the surface and enter the dream-world beneath the sea, to experience the phantasmagorical landscapes and strange fauna of that underwater world, floating dreamily in very often quite warm and crystal clear blue water. Once again, sensations perhaps reminiscent of origins, the salty womb, the source of all living things, the Great Mother. Remember Freud's description of states of mystical union as the "oceanic feeling"?
It is because of my interest in scuba diving that I stumbled onto Bernie Chowdhury's book, "The Last Dive," a narrative that tells the story of a well-known father-son pair of adventurous technical divers who ultimately died in the course of collecting artifacts and trying to identify the wreck of a very deep sunken U-Boat off the eastern seaboard. Chowdhury, himself an accomplished technical diver, describes in his book the development and history of technical diving by sport divers using SCUBA gear. "Technical diving" is something entirely different from tropical scuba diving over shallow and colorful reefs, maybe a bit like Himalayan mountaineering in comparison to, say, a spring hike in New England. It involves a great deal of equipment and training, great depths, lengthy decompression schedules, complex gas mixtures, and the management of serious objective risks and hazards in conditions not suitable for recreational divers. All of which I could enjoy from the safety and comfort of my reading chair!
In his book, Chowdhury describes an incident in which he almost dies, surfacing from a deep shipwreck in an emergency without spending the requisite time at various depths "decompressing," and so suffered a serious life-threatening episode of the "bends." It is a terribly painful condition that can cause serious damage to multiple organ systems including the nervous system, and may leave a person permanently injured even if they survive. Chowdhury was evacuated by helicopter to a specialized "recompression" treatment medical where he received many days of intensive treatment that saved his life, though he was told he could never dive again. Chowdhury goes on to describe the lengthy and difficult process of rehabilitation from his injuries and his gradual return to scuba diving.
But it was at this point in his book that something quite remarkable happened. Thinking about his three year-old son, and wife, and how he nearly left them behind, Chowdhury makes a decision to re-evaluate his relationship to diving. He realizes that he needs to better understand his own motivations and his choices, some of which he recognizes contributed to the mistakes he made leading to his near-fatal incident.
And, so he consults with... a psychoanalyst. I kid you not. An academic sociologist, to be precise, also a scuba diver, who had obtained psychoanalytic training. In New Jersey, no less! Chowdhury describes the process of coming to understand the idea of unconscious motivations, and he is determined to learn more about that inaccessible side of himself - the side below the surface - so that he might not again take an unnecessary chance, or make a decision lacking in self-awareness, and leave his family behind. "According to Dr. Hunt's training and beliefs, unconscious recollections, notions, and emotions affect what we think, what we say, and how we act. Unresolved conflicts from earlier life experiences may be hidden in the unconscious and influence behavior, which is especially important to people such as divers, who engage in high-risk activities" (p. 220).
As a psychoanalytic reader, I was stunned, completely unprepared for this turn. It was just so unexpected and delightful; to read about this man's search for self-understanding in the course of his growth as someone working on the adventurous edge of what is humanly possibly.
And I was pleased, needless to say, that someone out in the "real world" recognized the pragmatic value of what we have to offer as psychoanalytic practitioners and found his way to psychoanalytic consultation. It was the most unusual plug for our business I have seen in a while! This diver, used to penetrating otherworldly depths in the sea, recognized the "alien" otherness of his own psychic depths, and how they might affect his choices and his life.
We psychoanalytic workers are all divers in this sense, finding our way in sometimes difficult and murky water, sometimes water of startlingly beautiful clarity, looking for what is unseen and hidden in ourselves and our patients. We deal in the alien familiarity of the unconscious every day, the otherworldly parts of ourselves and others, crossing barriers, moving between states, marking transformations and discovering psychic landscapes "rich and strange."
1 Chowdhury, B. (2000), The last dive: A father and son's fatal descent into the ocean's depths. Harper Collins, NY.
|
|
Drawing Up a Practice Will
By Thomas W. Johnson, LCSW, EdD
 Recently, as I was talking about Practice Wills to a CPPNJ audience, one of the members of the audience stage-whispered "Oh YUCK!" when I was inviting people to attend the upcoming Practice Wills workshop on Sunday 4/7. I suspect she's not alone in these sentiments. Who wants to think about this issue? Yet, it is important. The motivation for the NYU Postdoc Practice Wills Group (the workshop presenters) was the sudden death of some of our beloved teachers and supervisors. These events highlighted the need for all of us to have a mechanism in place for the possibility (and I'm emphasizing possibility) of any of us becoming incapacitated or dying while still in practice. And most of us hope to continue to practice well into later life. It's critical for someone to have access to a list of our patients and their contact information,and for each of us to provide guidance about what our patients will be told and how their potential transfer should be handled. Some people imagine that their partners/spouses or family members will manage this, but the literature strongly discourages this. Our loved ones would have their own grief to manage and contact between them and our patients stirs up some very dicey relational complexity. Again, who wants to think about this? We hope in our workshop to try to use humor and empathy about our mutual resistance to think about our mortality, and to also offer concrete help in drafting a practice will. We'll be using a template that we devised to help you begin to draw up your practice will at the workshop. I encourage you to give this a try. As someone who has drawn up a Practice Will, I've found it ultimately comforting even though it seemed unsettling at first. |
May 19, 2013 Conference
Interrupting Repetitions and "Vicious Cycles" in Difficult Couples
Presented by Philip Ringstrom, PhD, PsyD
Lenfell Hall, The Mansion, Fairleigh Dickinson University, Madison, NJ 8:30am-4:00pm 6 CEUs will be offered for social workers
This daylong conference will take up the topic of Dr. Philip Ringstrom's new book A Relational Psychoanalytic Approach to Couples Treatment. The conference will elaborate his six step model to describe the flow of couples therapy: Step One: Creating An Attuned Focus on Each Partner's Longings and Frustrations, which involves an empathically, introspectively attuned focus on both partners' wishes and longings as well as how their disappointment over their non-fulfillment often manifests in "vicious circle" engagements. Step Two: Highlighting Each Partner's Subjectivity, where couples sessions help to create an attitude of "perspectival realism" wherein each person's subjective version of reality becomes a primary target of exploration. Step Three: Identifying Critical Developmental Factors, such as each partner's attachment style, capacity for mentalization, affect tolerance, implicit and explicit patterns of communication, as well as trauma and its multigenerational complexities. Step Four: Making Enactments Conscious, which involves material that arises from beneath the radar of the therapist's attuned responsiveness in step one. This fourth step is sub-titled the "awakening of the slumbering giant" wherein particular focus is upon processes of dissociation. Step Five: Focusing on Dissociated Self-States, so that with increased awareness, each partner's unique conflicts can be uncovered. This enables the therapist to facilitate a partner's intersubjective engagement since, after all, that which has not been negotiated within, cannot be experienced between the two partners. A final question that hovers over all of the steps stems from Stephen Mitchell's volume Can Love Last? This question takes up the fate of sexual romance in long term relationships, where in the quest for attachment security often has a dulling effect on romantic mystery and sexuality. This conference will explore a resolution to this duality. Philip Ringstrom, PhD, PsyD is a Senior Training and Supervising Analyst and a Faculty Member at the Institute of Contemporary Psychoanalysis, in Los Angeles, California. He is a Member of the Editorial Boards of both the International Journal on Psychoanalytic Self Psychology and Psychoanalytic Dialogues, and Psychoanalytic Perspectives. He is also a member of the International Council of Self-Psychologists, and a founding member of the Board of Directors of the International Association of Relational Psychoanalysis and Psychotherapy. He has published over 50 journal articles and has presented at conferences all over the world. He is currently under contract with Routledge Publications for his upcoming book in 2013 entitled A Relational Psychoanalytic Approach to Conjoint Therapy.
Click HERE to register for this program |
|
April 7, 2013 Faculty Forum
Everyone is invited: faculty, candidates, students and members of professional and local communities
Secure Your Practice with a Professional Will Technical and Affective Challenges in the Preparation of a Professional Will Presented by Caryn Gorden (Chair), Barry Cohen, Christine Girard, Tom Johnson, Alan Kintzer and Lisa Lyons
Hartman Lounge, The Mansion, Fairleigh Dickinson University, Madison, NJ 9:30am-1:00pm 3 CEUs will be offered for social workers
Few topics strike more fear into the hearts of clinicians than stories about the sudden or untimely illness or death of a colleague who is fully engaged in practice. Despite our wishes to avoid this topic we all need to have plans in place. This workshop / panel, modeled after an event we presented for the NYU Postdoc community, focuses on the importance and difficulties of creating a professional will. We begin with a funny video about the denial of death, created by the panel. We continue with short presentations concerning ethical and personal issues related to the creation of a Professional Will and presentation of our newly developed will model and template. We take the participants through the task of filling it out, and most importantly, engage the group in discussion and reflection on the complex emotional and professional issues raised when confronting our own incapacitation or death.
EDUCATIONAL OBJECTIVES:
1. At the completion of this panel participants will be able to describe the ethical requirements and issues related to preparing a Professional Will.
2. At the completion of this panel participants will have a Professional Will template for their own use and will better understand the emotional difficulty in filling it out.
|
Candidates' Organization Sponsored
Mini Retreat and Breakfast
The Executive Committee of the CO is very excited about an upcoming professional development opportunity open to faculty and candidates. Ronnie Bearison and Nina Williams will present "Come Play with Us: The Use of Creativity and Writing to Enhance Analytic Thinking".
The event is being held at the Hyatt Regency in New Brunswick, NJ on April 28, 2013 from 9:30am-12:15pm.
**There is no charge for participation but space is limited - RSVP now to reserve your place.
To RSVP, and for additional information and directions, email: wendynewman22@gmail.com
|
Graduation and End of Year Celebration
Join us on June 2, 2013 for CPPNJ's Annual Graduation and End of Year Celebration to be held at the Hamilton Hotel in Madison, NJ from 12:00noon-4:00pm. Come congratulate our many graduates and honor Stan Moldawsky. Invitations will be sent out next month. We hope to see you there.
|
Save These Dates for Next Year
September 29, 2013 - CPPNJ Welcome Back Brunch - Maplewood Community Center - 9;30am-1:30pm
October 6, 2013 - Supervision Workshop Series - Martin Silverman, MD presents A Field Theory Approach to Psychoanalytic Supervision - Rutgers Conference Center, New Brunswick - 9:30am-12:30pm
November 24, 2013 - Christopher Clulow, PhD presents Surviving the Gridlocked Moments with Couples: A Tovistock Approach to Couples Therapy - Lenfell Hall, FDU Florham Park - 8:30am-4:00pm
March 8, 2014 - Richard Chefez, MD presents Dissociative Processes and the Toxicity of the Shame Spectrum of Emotion - Lenfell Hall, FDU Florham Park - 8:30am-4:00pm
May 3, 2014 - IDfest: An Evening of Comedy and Dessert - Lenfell Hall, FDU Florham Park -TBA
|
|
|
Ethical Concerns When the Psychologist Becomes Ill By Thomas W. Johnson, LCSW, EdD This article was reprinted with permission from the New Jersey Psychological Association. The original article appears in their publication, The New Jersey Psychologist, Volume 59, Number 1, Spring 2009. Special thanks to Thomas Johnson, LCSW, EdD. There are few topics that strike more fear in the heart of a psychologist, particularly a psychologist in private practice, than stories about colleagues who've become ill and are forced to take a leave from their practice, even for a time-limited recuperation. Anxieties abound about financial catastrophe, about loss of opportunities, and about compromise of professional identity and reputation. Despite the natural wish to avoid this topic, much needs to be said about the impact of this experience on our work. In particular, the potential for ethical complexity in this situation needs to be addressed, not only from the perspective of the people we serve, but also from the psychologist facing the crisis. Until the past twenty years or so, there were few accounts of the impact of illness in a therapist on the process of treatment (Dattner, 1989; Halpert, 1982). For example, Freud suffered intensely from jaw and oral cancer for the last 16 years of life and underwent 33 painful surgeries (Edmundson, 2007; Halpert, 1982; Schwartz, 1990). Yet there is no mention of the effect of this experience on his clinical work in any of his writing. We are left with the image of a heroic caregiver who stoically continues to analyze in the face of pain and death. We still hear many stories of clinicians who "bite the bullet" and work in the face of pain, discomfort, and even death. In truth, many of us are devoted to the people we serve and worry about leaving them in the lurch when we become ill. But there are also other important emotional processes at play here that drive an ill psychologist to keep working: the fear of lost income; the fear that no one will ever again refer to an ill psychologist once the word gets out; the loss of privacy in dealing with illness in one's own idiosyncratic way if illness is acknowledged and disclosed; and the belief that recovery will go better if a sense of usefulness and power is ensured. But there are other stories that have to be recognized too: of patients who only discover that their therapist has been suffering from serious heart disease upon notification of the therapist's death (and, at times, with terrible irony, these are patients with histories of traumatic loss); of patients becoming terribly destabilized when they arrive for an appointment and discover at one fell swoop that their psychologist is wearing a wig and that she is undergoing chemotherapy; of patients whose inquiries about the apparent poor health of their psychologist are met with denial or mystification. There is much clinical complexity with regard to these scenarios, and no unilateral clinical truth to endorse, but a discussion of the ethical complexities that emerge when a psychologist becomes ill is an important dimension of this situation to examine. Three ethical issues seem to be the most salient in this situation: Informed Consent; Competence; and Provision for Continuity of Services. Informed Consent According to the Ethical Principles of Psychologists and Code of Conduct 2002 (APA, 2002), psychologists are obliged to provide information to therapy patients about "the nature and anticipated course" of the treatment "as early as is feasible in the therapeutic relationship" (Standard 10.01). We can extrapolate from this principle to consider the ethical aspects of the issue of whether or not an ill psychologist should disclose information about their illness to a patient. There is a diversity of opinion about this from a clinical perspective. Some address the psychologist-centered perspective of whether or not an ill psychologist is owed privacy and self-protection in meeting the demands of their situation (Barbanel, 1989). Others contend that disclosure of this kind of information burdens the patient and interferes with their treatment, particularly if one aspires to create an atmosphere of neutrality, and that ill therapists are too much in the grip of countertransferential strain to sort out effectively which patients would be helped versus harmed by this kind of disclosure (Abend, 1990). Some psychoanalytic writers advocate taking a case-by-case approach in deciding whom to tell (Dewald, 1990). There are others who feel that this kind of disclosure is inevitable given that the therapist's illness will invariably come to color the work (Pizer, 1997), and others who feel that intentional disclosure offers many benefits to patients including appreciation of their abilities to reciprocate empathic and reparative intentions (Hoffman, 2000). I believe that a psychologist's work is always affected in known and unknown ways when they are ill. Disclosure allows for direct interpersonal negotiation and intrapsychic exploration of the effects of that variable; however, there are some patients who prefer that this kind of material is not overtly discussed, and we have to be flexible about how we work. Competence In the Competence section of the Ethical Principles, Standard 2.06 (Personal Problems and Conflicts), indicates that psychologists should restrict their activities in areas in which personal problems will compromise their competence; and that they obtain consultation when they become aware of problems that may interfere with their work performance. Similarly, in the General Principles, under the Principle of Beneficence and Nonmaleficence, there is specific call for psychologists to remain aware of the impact of their own mental and physical health on their capacity to help. The ability of psychologists who are physically ill to be competent professionals, in general, is obviously not in question. Amy Lichtblau Morrison (1990, 1997), a clinician who maintained a practice while living with metastatic breast cancer for 10 years, wrote compellingly of the many ways in which her experience enriched her attunement to her patients and sharpened her acumen in helping patients struggle with unresolved separations and loss. Ann-Louise Schlessinger Silver (1990), a psychiatrist at Chestnut Lodge who struggled with cancer, and Irwin Hoffman (2000), a Relational analyst who underwent coronary bypass surgery, also write about the possibilities for interpersonal and intrapsychic transformation in patients who deal directly with the implications of the serious illness of their therapists. However, all of these clinicians had regular consultation available to them. There are so many opportunities for bias and blind spots when a working psychologist is contending with illness because the experience is so potentially overwhelming. Psychoanalytic writers suggest that we all have the inclination to regress under the strain of illness, and defenses such as denial and omnipotence, and problematic affects like shame, guilt, and envy can shape our work (Halpert, 1982). When patients know of the psychologist's illness, their potential responses -anger, terror, indifference, flight-can also tax an already overwhelmed clinician. Supervision and consultation are invaluable in trying to respond in ways that take both the clinical needs of the patient and the personal needs of the psychologist into consideration. Provision for Continuity of Services The ethics code requires us to make plans for patient care and transfer of services in the event of possibilities we all dread: withdrawal from practice due to illness, sudden disability, or death (Standard 3.12, Interruption of Psychological Services; Standard 6.02, Maintenance, Dissemination, and Disposal of Confidential Records of Professional and Scientific Work; Standard 10.09, Interruption of Therapy). Professional wills offer a means for addressing these possibilities. They offer plans and instructions for taking care of patients; provide information on the location of important files and professional resources; and designate colleagues to take over in the event of one's disability or death. There are a number of resources for creating professional wills (De Angelis, 2008; Pope & Vasquez, 2005). The reports of therapists who have worked with patients whose previous therapists died over the course of treatment offer some useful perspectives on patient care (Ziman-Tobin, 1989). These writers recommend that a "Bridge Therapist" be designated who makes contact with the therapist's patients when the therapist dies, offers them crisis sessions, and helps them find another therapist should they choose this. All of these issues are complicated and delicate for everyone concerned. The availability of a Colleague Assistance Program and of professional consultation can help to make a painful and sometimes lonely professional situation less isolating and overwhelming. References Abend, S.M. (1990). Serious illness in the analyst: Countertransference considerations. In H.J Schwartz & A.S. Silver (Eds.), Illness in the analyst: Implications for the treatment relationship (pp.99-113). New York: International Universities Press. American Psychological Association (2002). Ethical Principles for Psychologists. Washington, D.C. Available on line www.apa.org/ethics. Barbanel, L. (1989). Introduction to The Death of the Psychoanalyst (Panel Presentation). Contemporary Psych., 25(3), 412-419. Dattner, R. (1989). On the death of the analyst: A review. Contemporary Psychoanalysis, 25(3), 419-427. DeAngelis, T. (2008). How to prepare for the unexpected. Monitor on Psychology, 39(6), 50-52. Dewald, P.A. (1990). Serious illness in the analyst: Transference, countertransference, and reality responses-and further reflections. In H.J. Schwartz & A.S. Silver (Eds.), llness in the analyst: Implications for the treatment relationship (pp.75-98), New York: International Universities Press. Edmundson, M. (2007). The death of Sigmund Freud: The legacy of his last days. New York: Bloomsbury USA. Halpert, E. (1982). When the analyst is chronically ill or dying. Psychoanalytic Quarterly, 51, 372-389. Hoffman. I. Z. (2000). At death's door: Therapists and patients as agents. Psychoanalytic Dialogues, 10(6), 823-846. Morrison, A. L. (1997). Ten years of doing psychotherapy while living with a life-threatening illness: Self -disclosure and other ramifications. Psychoanalytic Dialogues, 7, 225-241, Pizer, B. (1997). When the analyst is ill: Dimensions of self-disclosure. Psychoanalytic Quarterly, 66, 450-469. Pope, K.S. & Vasquez, M. J. T. (2005). How to survive and thrive as a therapist. Washington D.C.: American Psych. Association. Schwartz, H.J. (1990). Illness in the doctor: Implications for the psychoanalytic process. In H.J. Schwartz & A. S. Silver (Eds.), Illness in the analyst: Implications for the treatment relationship (pp. 115-149), New York: International Universities Press. Silver, A. S. (1990). Resuming the work with a life-threatening illness - and further reflections. In H.J. Schwartz & A. S. Silver (Eds.), Illness in the analyst: Implications for the treatment relationship (pp.151-176), New York: International Universities Press. Ziman-Tobin, P. (1989). Consultation as a bridging function. Contemporary Psychoanalysis, 25(3), 432-438. |
Meet Our Faculty: Richard Reichbart, PhD
I have been asked to write something personal about myself as a faculty member of CPPNJ, and so I will try to tell the somewhat wandering story of how I came to be a psychoanalyst. I do so with trepidation, for although our very profession began with an act of self-revelation in the Interpretation of Dreams, we have since been taught a "blank screen" way of speaking about ourselves (supposedly so our patients do not know too much of us) which I sometimes think borders on self-abnegation, but which is generally the approved way of doing things. I have practiced in Ridgewood for 25 years. Whenever a psychoanalytic patient graces me with her narrative, I marvel at the adventures that brought me here. I was raised when quite young in a small town (less than 800 people in the winter) in the high Adirondacks, where my grandfather, a country doctor, and my grandmother, a country dentist - both originally from Riga, Latvia -- lived and practiced and to which I frequently returned in the summers. For my elementary and high school years, I lived in Manhattan. Perhaps it was this dichotomy between city and country, perhaps it was my experience of a black maid when I was a child, or perhaps it was the decidedly liberal leanings of my parents -- but regardless, I always have been fascinated by different cultures and their formative effect upon people and always moved by a sense of justice for people in general. But I did not begin with any particular interest in psychology much less psychoanalysis. In fact, although intellectual and knowledgeable, my parents thought psychoanalysis was not a profession to pursue. As a young adult, my interests were varied - at one point medicine, then art and creative writing and anthropology. After graduation from Yale College, I ended up at the University of California at Berkeley in playwriting, and became involved in and arrested in the Free Speech Movement in late 1964. From there, with some detours, I went down south where for one long summer I was on the staff of the Southern Christian Leadership Council, Martin Luther King's organization, and in charge of civil rights workers in Peach County, Georgia. I lived and worked in a small southern town, Fort Valley, for part of that time: an experience which to this day has influenced me greatly. Click HERE to read the rest of this article |
Neuro-Psychoanalysis Reading Group Critiques Neurologist's New Book Centering on the Role of Emotions in Psychological Development
By Harlene Goldschmidt, PhD Antonio Damasio's recent book, Self Comes to Mind: Constructing the Conscious Brain (2010), inspired three members of the Neuro-Psychoanalysis reading group to prepare a review essay of it for The Psychoanalytic Quarterly. With the guidance and experience of Martin Silverman and Debi Roelke, we set out to summarize and critique a cutting edge book that addresses the role of emotions in generating the evolution of the human consciousness. Most of the books selected for our reading group have been written by psychotherapists who have acquired advanced knowledge of neuroscience. Damasio's book, however, was written by a neurologist rather than by a therapist. That he comes to some of the same time-honored views that are held by psychodynamic psychotherapists is validating and gratifying. His main point is that feelings are integral to human consciousness and shape our human psychological experience. Without feelings there would be no consciousness. After some back and forth discussion, we decided to title our review essay "Sentio Ergo Cogito"- "I feel, therefore I think." This is a reference, in part, to an earlier book by Damasio, Decartes' Error: Emotion, Reason, and the Human Brain (1994). As his titles suggest, Damasio sees continuity in self, mind, emotion, and body rather than subscribing to a false mind/body dichotomy. He takes issue in both books with the historical neglect of emotion as an essential focus of neurological research. For the inquiring psychoanalyst, Self Comes to Mind offers certain neurological parallels to Freud's division of the mind into Id, Ego, and Super-Ego. Damasio describes an Id-like, drive-based, somatic Protoself, operating in the brain stem and primitive cortex, that generates emotions which are expressed outside of psychological representation, and an Ego-like, somato-psychic Core Self, that observes and appraises the world around and within us, and even more importantly, studies our interaction with that world in order to decide what succeeds more or less successfully and what does not. As the complexity of memory and experience builds, a truly psychological Autobiographical Self emerges that examines past and current functioning and mediates anticipation and planning for the future. The activity of this over-arching agency is reminiscent of Freud's concept of a Super-Ego. Damasio also provides a neurological basis for Freud's emphasis on defense and on the importance of conflict among different components of the psyche. He states, for example, that: "Increased cognitive demands have made the interplay between the cortex and the brain stem a bit rough and brutal, or to put it in kinder words, they have made the access to the wellspring of feeling more difficult (p.251)." Authors like Antonio Damasio are helping to build bridges between psychoanalytic therapists and the researchers who yearn for a fuller understanding of the neurological basis of our conscious and unconscious, mental and emotional functioning. Damasio deserves credit for being quite accessible, clear, and comprehensive as he presents the extremely complex information that is contained in his books. The reader of his books is rewarded by obtaining a deeper understanding of feeling, thinking, and the emergence of self within the context of our multi-factorial neurological, emotional, and bodily dimensions. |
A LOOK AT RECENT CPPNJ PROGRAMS
|
A Modern Attachment Theory Perspective on Treatment
By Marion Houghton, EdS, LMFT
| Daniel Hill, PhD |
CPPNJ hosted Daniel Hill, PhD from PsyBC for Part 2 of his presentation on "Attachment Theory and Affect Regulation-Treatment Applications" on Saturday, March 16, 2013 at Fairleigh Dickinson University. Dr. Hill focused on the period of human development between 10 and 18 months. He described the evolution of primary affect during this time-emphasizing the right brain with its limbic system as coming on line through the caregiver's nonverbal communication of affect. He gave a treatment parallel describing attunement as the way a therapist is with a patient. He stated that the therapist's ability to be attuned to affect is especially useful when the patient's affect is dissociated and needs the therapist to pick it up and amplify it.
According to Professor Hill, the primary function of the early attachment figure is to regulate the infant. Since the survival of the infant requires that he/she adapt to the emotional style of the caregiver, the attachment relationship shapes the regulation of primary affect in the developing child. Managing the affect of shame can be seen as the central regulatory problem faced by the infant. Dr. Hill described shame as the wish to hide and indicated that it results in a state of metabolic collapse in which the heart rate drops precipitously-the freeze response.
Dr. Hill described right brain processes as forming a "gestalt". In contrast, he noted that the left brain, which comes on board at around age 2, processes information in a linear fashion and leaves out context. He concludes that treatment needs to encompass both right and left brain activity. This is especially the case with a relational approach. As we engage our patients, we help them explore their own minds and the minds of others. This requires that we help to regulate the patient nonverbally by keeping ourselves regulated.
As a metaphor for the relationship between right and left brain activity which is well integrated, or not-- Professor Hill recommended a book by Iain McGilchrist entitled The Master and his Emissary. It tells the story of the "divided brain and the making of the Western world."
Dr. Hill credited Allen Schore with the formulation of Modern Attachment Theory. Schore speaks of the "relational unconscious" and states of "bodymind" (comparable to "self states"), which are more or less integrated depending on the basic attachment patterns that have emerged. Insecure attachment patterns are correlated with disorders of affect regulation and lead to negative expectations in life.
Specifically, the narcissistic character disorders are linked with both preoccupied and avoidant attachment patterns. "Uninhibited" narcissism shows itself in hyperaroused dissociation and the search for mirroring, while "inhibited" narcissism presents with hypoaroused dissociation and the withholding of attention. Both are considered to be the "structured insecure"- because they have a strategy for maintaining safety with a caregiver, whereas the individuals who display "disorganized attachment" have coping mechanisms are that are unstructured and chaotic. Borderline personality disorder has been linked to disorganized attachment.
As time ran out, Dr. Hill invited further questions and was quickly surrounded by a group of enthusiastic participants. Perhaps there will be more to come...
|
Play Fighting: Who's on top in Fifty Shades of Grey?
By Ruth Lijtmaer, PhD  | Nina Williams, PsyD |
On March 10, Nina Williams, PsyD, faculty member at CPPNJ and an innovator in sex education for nearly twenty years, presented a thought provoking workshop based on the trilogy of books and their focus on the erotic and emotional experiences of dominance and submission. Unlike the secrecy surrounding the popularity of previous books on the subject, these books have become part of the cultural mainstream.
Dr. Williams started the talk indicating how these series are being described as "mommy porn." However, in her research she found that 90% of the readers are females of all ages. This series became a "best seller" before it was published as it started on-line. It also stayed on the "best sellers" list for a year. In terms of technology, the search "50 Shades of Grey" got 81 million hits. These books also increased sales for sex shops. At that point in the presentation, Dr. Williams showed an amusing Amazon commercial for Mother's Day in which mothers were reading the book and "got caught" doing it. Dr. Williams indicated that BDSM (bondage, dominance, submission and masochism) and sadomasochism) are topics implicit in the books.
Dr. Williams raised some questions throughout her presentation that were discussed with audience participation. The first question concerned why the books were so popular. She explained that Fifty Shades of Grey (FSOG) was originally on-line fan fiction of the popular series Twilight. She compared the books with romance novels, noting that readership of romance novels was almost as large as consumption of on-line pornography. The second question was: What do women in particular like about the book? The audience described a range of responses from enjoying the book's depiction of an evolving relationship, to appreciating the sexual exploration for its erotic potential to the popularity indicating a growing comfort with the public acknowledgement of private matters. Some in the audience indicated how difficult it to admit that they liked the books for fear of exposure and embarrassment while younger commenters didn't regard the content as particularly lewd because they had longer access to a wider range of sexual content via the internet, Dr. Williams also mentioned two contrasting viewpoints: (1) As women have more power in the outside world, they have tired of their independence and long to surrender and (2) As woman have more power, it becomes safer for women to explore sexual submission because they no longer need to fear gender inequality.
The third question followed on this reasoning: As gender equality increases and more trust between man and woman develops, are we destined to become more kinkier? One unknown is the reason many men resist reading this book, despite its potential for describing "what women want."
Dr. Williams summarized the on-line BDSM community's concern that the relationship depicted in FSOG, which practitioners describe as unhealthy, will mislead the public about these practices. BDSM conventions of clear verbal negotiations of limits are not followed in the books. One member of the audience brought up the topic of domestic violence and how she had mixed feelings about recommending the books to her abused female patients because the hero of the novel behaves dangerously. The last point was directed to us as psychoanalysts and clinicians. Referring to Dimen's argument that psychoanalysis either domesticates or demonizes perversion, Dr. Williams pointed out while the topic matter of the books may shock some readers, the outcome of the story is that the sadomasochistic desires of Christian Grey are ultimately dominated by Anastasia Steele, who wins him over to a traditional version of committed love. |
Member Presentations and PublicationsRuth Lijtmaer, PhDPaper: Social class, social reality and power: Emphasis on the Latino poor. Winter Roundtable Columbia University, 2-15-13 to 2-16-13. Please note: If you have an announcement of either a paper you've recently published or a presentation you've given, let us know. Send Cathy Van Voorhees an email at cppnj@aol.com and we will be happy to get the word out. |
Book Reviews
What are you currently reading? We would like to include book recommendations and reviews. Send Cathy Van Voorhees an email at cppnj@aol.com - tell her what you are reading and we will spread the word.
|
All Programs are Co-Sponsored with the New Jersey Society for Clinical Social Workers
The New Jersey Society for Clinical Social Workers (NJSCSW) provides leadership and support to clinical social workers in all practice settings. NJSCSW has given voice to clinical social workers dealing with the health care industry. The organization provides outstanding education programs and opportunities for collegial contact. www.njscsw.org
|
Our E-Newsletter Editorial Staff
Mary Lantz, LCSW, Editor-in-Chief
Rose Oosting, PhD, Consulting Editor
Martha Liebmann, PhD
Marion Houghton, EdS, LMFT
|
Unsolicited articles are welcome. Something you'd like to write? Send it to us at cppnj@aol.com. We're happy to hear from you.
Thank you for joining us. Look for our next newsletter in May 2013 when we will profile our 2013 graduates.
|
|
No need to print this email - for future reference, all issues are archived. |
|
|
|