Rabbi Jonathan Slater  
 Torah Study for the Soul:
Selections from Birkat Avraham:  5 BA Chayye Sarah

 

Peshat | Drash | Remez | Sod  

 
 
To continue receiving texts after this week, please register at http://www.regonline.com/5773textstudy

Find us on Facebook 
Register for 5773 Text Study
Birkat Avraham
5 BA chayye
5 BA chayye
Join rabbis, cantors and leaders across the country and across denominations in -
 
TORAH STUDY FOR THE SOUL: A CONTEMPLATIVE PERSPECTIVE FROM HASIDIC TEXTS
5773: Birkat Avraham
Cost for the year:  $240

Welcome to the Torah Study for Your Soul, contemplative study of Hasidic texts. This week we begin our study of the late-classical Hasidic text Birkat Avraham, by Rabbi Avraham Weinberg (the third) of Slonim. We are happy to provide this to you as an introduction to the Institute for Jewish Spirituality Ongoing Text Study Program. You will receive it free through the first five weeks of the Torah reading cycle, after which it will be sent only to those who have subscribed to the program.

 

Each week, the text can be read in this email, or it can also be accessed as a clean Word document by clicking the link at the top of the page. I will present the lessons using the classical PaRDe"S structure in this manner: Peshat will be the translation of the text; Drash will be a commentary, unpacking the core elements of the lesson; Remez will be a series of reflection questions for discussion or personal inquiry; Sod will be additional commentary, interpreting the prayer offered by R. Avraham, and offering a new one in the mode of mindfulness practice.

 

You may wish to purchase a copy of Birkat Avraham (two volumes) to accompany your study. The book is still under copyright, and it is right and proper for you to purchase it. You can find it here:

I have also had positive experiences purchasing books from Biegeleisen Books in Brooklyn. Their phone number is (718) 436-1165, and you can purchase the books with a credit card.

 

I have heard the this book may be out of print at this time, and if we find that it is impossible to acquire a copy for study, we may provide other means to access the original Hebrew text.

 

I look forward to studying with you this year, engaging with R. Avraham as teacher and companion in deepening our spiritual lives. Be well.

 

Jonathan. 

 

If you questions about this study program, please contact me at jonathan@jewishspirituality.org  or 914-478-7326. 

 

 

 
peshat
Peshat

s.v. va'ani tephilati lekha H' eit ratzon E' berov chasdekha aneini be'emet yish'ekha (#3, pg. 61)

 

"As for me, may my prayer come to You, O YHVH, at a favorable moment; O God, in Your abundant love, answer me with Your sure deliverance" (Ps. 69:14).

 

"And he said, 'YHVH, God of my master Abraham, grant me good fortune this day, and deal graciously with my master Abraham....He had scarcely finished speaking, when Rebecca came out, [she who was born to Bethuel, the son of Milcah the wife of Abraham's brother Nahor, with her jar on her shoulder]" (Gen. 24:12, 15). The commentator Or Hachayyim (R. Chayyim ibn Atar, 17-18th c., Morocco and Jerusalem) explains this passage: Eliezer (Abraham's servant) believed that since Abraham had already requested help of God that surely there would be a propitious moment (eit ratzon) to fulfill his request. Rather, his prayer - "make it happen for me (hakreh na lephanai)" - was that he merit that the matter come about through him, and that his being unworthy not spoil this time of favor.

 

In this manner we can interpret our verse: "As for me, may my prayer come to You, O YHVH, at a favorable moment". When we set out to pray, we become aware of where our thoughts have sunk, and how our prayers are self-serving. But, the time of prayer is surely a "favorable moment", and it is then that we must set it in our heart that our sole intent is to fulfill God's will, and not where our desire has sunk. So, we examine our selves: "as for me" - whatever deficiency exists now is mine, as I have messed myself up. Let me pray and request of God, as did Eliezer, that I merit to be included in this "favorable moment"; that at least a "favorable moment" influence me so that I can turn again toward God. "Yours, O YHVH, is the favorable momentY": I realize that I have nothing, and all that I have is not by my merit, but a gift from God. Scripture teaches "Abraham was now old, advanced in years, and YHVH blessed Abraham [in all things]" (ibid. vs. 1): everyone knew that Abraham directed blessings to others, but Abraham knew that "YHVH blessed Abraham", all was just a gift from God....

 

(ukm"k y"l): In a similar manner we can interpret "As for me, may my prayer" relative to Shabbat. There is a Shabbat hymn (Barukh El Elyon...Hashomer Shabbat) that says:

All who keep Shabbat, and do not desecrate it,

Will merit love, the Holy One is their lot,

And, if they fulfill their obligations on that day, how blessed are they,

For it is a gift sent to God, the Creator.

 

When we enter Shabbat, so long as we do not sense "the love of the Holy One as our lot", and do not feel love and delight, then we are not among those who truly "keep Shabbat, and do not desecrate it". If we notice that we are not feeling love and delight, and examine how we have passed through the days of the week, and that even on Shabbat weekday affairs draw our attention, then  let us at least "fulfill our obligations of the day, and find delight in that". At least now we can set out anew to take on the "obligations of the day". That will be a "a gift sent to God, the One who bore him" (mecholelo can be read as related to giving birth): God helps us to renew ourselves as a new being, as a new born babe.

 

This is what we request during the "favorable moment" of Shabbat afternoon, during the third meal: "As for me, may my prayer come to You, O YHVH, at a favorable moment". We examine our selves and realize where our desire has sunk, preventing us from feeling the desire and yearning for God, and know directly that this deficiency is "for me", it is due to me. Then "my prayer to You, YHVH, is for a time of desire", that You give me, now, the will to do only Your will. This is only "to You" - what I ask for is only for Your sake, to arouse a "favorable moment". Just as "He had scarcely finished speaking, when Rebecca came out" - the power of prayer is so great when I pray only for God's sake, even before I finish speaking God fulfills my request. "O God, in Your abundant love" - limitation and constriction (middat hadin, the aspect of Elohim) are transformed to love when my request is only for God's sake. Even if I am in need of material blessings, I receive this abundant love through the power of the desire that is aroused through my prayer for God's sake. The key to this prayer is the plea: "answer me with Your true deliverance", let me walk in the paths of truth.
Drash Drash

In this lesson we see, again, the various ways meanings of ratzon (favorable, favor, desire, desirable, will, willingness). Here we are presented with the contrast between God's will and our personal desires; between the experience of God's favor and its obscuration by our mindless deeds. R. Avraham sets us up with the teaching from the Or Hachayyim, and as might be expected, emphasizes what interests him. Here is the original comment:

"He said, 'YHVH etc. grant me good fortune (hakreh na lephanai) etc.". Eliezer had complete trust in his master, that his prayer would be accepted. He had prayed "[YHVH, the God of heaven, who took me from my father's house and from my native land, who promised me on oath, saying, 'I will assign this land to your offspring'-] He will send His angel before you, [and you will get a wife for my son from there]" (Gen. 24:7). But, Eliezer prayed in addition that he be worthy that the matter come about through him. It does occur that sometimes the mechanism by which a prayer is fulfilled presents an obstacle to its being accomplished. That is why he prayed to the God of his master that God make it unfold through him (sheyikreh lephanav).


The driving issue here seems to be the verb hakreh. It seems to mean here "to make come about": cause this to happen. But, it is also related to the word that means "chance" or "happenstance" (as in Balaam's form of prophecy; cf. Num. 23:3), or event or outcome (cf. Eccl. 2:14, 9:11). So, it is ambiguous what precisely the servant meant in his prayer. The Or Hachayyim brings these two dimensions together. He distinguishes between the certitude of Abraham's prophetic prayer and the unreliable request of the servant. The servant recognizes that his imperfections might, in some manner, impeded the true unfolding of the divine plan, and he prays that he not cause such an untoward occurrence (another sense of mikreh).


The Or Hachayyim goes on:

The reason he had to do so was caution that Abraham's family not deceive him when they learned that he was deputized to take one of their daughters -- they might give him a family handmaid and claim that she was their kin. So he strategized and acted in this manner, with a critical test to determine that she would offer more than she was asked in an exemplary way. He would also know that she was of Abraham's family because she would speak in innocence, without suspecting anything more than what was asked of her. He would know to ask for this woman. And, indeed, Rebecca's first words fit this test, in that she identified herself as "Bethuel's daughter" (vs. 24).

  

Here we see a more naturalistic reasoning for the servant's caution. It was not only due to his inferiority to his master but because he mistrusted the people he would be dealing with. R. Avraham seems to ignore this line of explication to emphasize, instead, the servant's lowly estate, applying it to our experience.

  

The argument of the lesson is that we have the capacity to be like Abraham: to align our will with God's, to experience God's favor always. Yet, the distractions of daily life, our propensity to run after fleeting pleasures and material desires, alienate us from sensing God's favor. We can, like Eliezer, acknowledge our mistake, and pray for God's favor. If we do so with a pure heart, we can be assured of receiving blessing, as if through Abraham.

  

I have included the last section that connects this dynamic to Shabbat as it will be an ongoing theme in our study of Birkat Avraham. It is quite likely that most of the teachings we will study were delivered at the third meal, shalosh se'udot, on Shabbat afternoon. The Zohar identifies this time as ra'ava deravin, the time of deepest desire, of the greatest favor (ra'ava is the Aramaic cognate of ratzon). At this time on Shabbat afternoon, after a day of prayer, rest, study and nourishment both physical and spiritual, one might be most likely to be able to let go of a personal agenda and lean into God's will; to experience the fullness of the moment as an expression of God's favor, and not seek anything more. Rather than hear criticism in how deeply our thoughts have sunk or our prayers are self-serving, R. Avraham is inviting us to see our lives clearly, offering the promise that if we wake up, we can taste of the divine will, share in God's favor.

Remez Remez
  1. R. Avraham states: "When we set out to pray, we come to see where our thoughts have sunk, and how our prayers are self-serving." Is this your experience? Do you see yourself clearly only once you start to pray, or do you pray because you see yourself clearly, know deeply that you need help? When, how, why?  
  2. R. Avraham sees Abraham and Eliezer in a particular way, one quite different from the other. When do you sense yourself to be like Abraham? When like Eliezer?  Do you aspire to be like Abraham, or are you satisfied to be like Eliezer? When, how, why? 
     
  3. How and when, if at all, have you found Shabbat to be transformative in your life? Has the experience of Shabbat ever left you feeling like a newborn, a completely new being? When, how? What do you sense might contribute to that experience and what might impede it?
Sod Sod

R. Avraham's prayer:

The week comes crashing to its end in a headlong rush into Shabbat. I arrive hoping to feel Your favor (ratzon), God, to sense the rest, to taste the sweetness of Shabbat. But, my mind is filled with all that I want (ratzon), worried about the week that has passed, anxious about what is yet to come. I get in my own way. God, grant me good fortune, make Your will my will so that I can open to the great love constantly coming to me, to know Your blessings in body and soul. Save me - from me, for You.

 

R. Avraham points to a central concern of spiritual practice: the connection between the outer form and awareness. It is possible to say the words of prayer, and for our thoughts to be elsewhere; it is possible to enact Shabbat without feeling its love and delight. The habitual response is to blame our conditions, to find fault in the practice, to look elsewhere for the emptiness we feel. In our lesson we are pointed back to our selves. It is possible, if we pay attention, to notice where our thoughts are, and to reclaim them, bring them back to our point of focus, to our intention. It is possible to pause in the performance of a practice and feel precisely where we are, to allow all that is to be present in the moment without discrimination. We resist this, often, because it might mean letting go of our preferences, or accepting our failures. But, until we open to this moment and let our selves get out of the way, we will not fully inhabit our practice. We will feel distant.

 

In the Torah the servant asks that God bring something about, make something happen: hakreh na. It is as if he has no responsibility, he is asking for some chance event to come about. This may be what R. Avraham senses, leading him to teach that Eliezer admits that he is at fault, he stands in the way of God's favor being fully expressed. Much that happens to us in our lives is not of our making, but too often we allow that to obscure how much more is our responsibility. We blame our unhappiness on our circumstance, on the chance events that have affected us. We want someone, something else to be responsible: it is all chance. When we sit in that place, we cut our selves off from the fullness of life. In our passivity, we relinquish our power and our responsibility. Standing up to say "this is my life, as it is right now, and I am fully in it, it is mine" is both to acknowledge personal failure and flaw, and to open to all that is already there, the blessing in the midst of the suffering.

 

Taking responsibility for our lives is not to claim that we are all-powerful, that we control our lives. Rather, it is to meet our lives fully, to accept that which we do not control as welcome, as what is, just as we do all in our power and awareness to do to be happy, to make life whole. Accepting what is, we meet God's ratzon: God's will, and the blessing of God's favor in all that is. Actively engaging in our lives -- rather than blaming it on others, sleeping through each day - we find that we have more opportunities to know God's ratzon, and to experience the love, solace and joy that it brings.

 

My prayer:

I want to blame You, God, but You put it back on me. And rightly so. I am responsible for the content of my thoughts, the climate of my heart. In prayer, I meet my life. I take a deep breath, I settle, I know the truth. I am in the way. With each breath I open to You, welcome You, rest in You - all that is, happenstance interconnected and ineluctable, lawful and always open to change. This is Your will; I bask in Your favor. Knowing this truth, I am saved.

 
Thank you

Thank you for taking time out of your day to be with us again this week.  I look forward to studying with you this year as we engage with Birkat Avraham, the teachings of R. Avraham Weinberg of Slonim, as teacher and companion in deepening our spiritual lives. 

Be well.
Jonathan.