LOGO unsizedProtonPals Newsletter

Am I Cured?

  Don't Forget

 ProtonPals on FB
Like us on Facebook
Join your Pals at the
The locations rotate among various restaurants in the Houston Medical Center area. 

Tell your ProtonPal friends about Joe's House to find housing in the Medical Center area. This link is also on the Pals website and on the MD Anderson website. 
In This Issue
We're On Facebook
More Inaccurate Press
A "My Story" is Added
Highlights of First Half of My Story
Article Headline
Mark Cheers Em Up Again
Quick Links
Meet Our Survivors (PTC)
(Updated August 2013)

More On Us-ProtonPals Leaders
For Email Marketing you can trust
Join Our List

Join Our Mailing List
Issue: #65August/2013
Machining Parts for Transport Planes. 
Lathe Operator at Consolidated Aircraft - Dallas, Texas October 1942
Saturday August 31, 2013, HOUSTON, TX 
    
Greetings!

Labor Day is set to be celebrated on Monday and will probably mean something different to each of us. For some it will mean the end of summer with the kids back in school. For a large number of the ProtonPals with grown and middle aged children, those days are long gone although we still serve a role as grandparents and car poolers. But in our group we do have some relatively young readers who I bet were happy to pack the kids up for school for another hopefully safe term. I also hope the passing of Labor Day means cooler weather for Houston, the West and the plains. For others it may mean the beginning of a political campaign and certainly college football. 
   
For some it will be celebrated in it's original intent; a federal holiday established in 1894 to highlight various labor organizations' strengths and contributions to the United States economy.
 
World War II was very important in changing the labor force and I love to write about Rosie the Riveter shown in the image below and I hope you find this of some interest. It could be because one of my daughters got a toolkit for a gift (sort of a gag gift by her friend but close to home).

I can't say what draws me 
about this painted illustration -  maybe it's the pose used by Rockwell. Some critics say he used Michelangelo's painting of the "Prophet-Isaiah" in the Sistine chapel ceiling. But then maybe it comes from my growing up around strong farm and ranch women and the workers around Houston.  For example my house cleaning lady who grew up in Central America does not hesitate to roll up her sleeves to repair the vacuum cleaner, lamp cords, or last week helped me in a joint project to unplug the lavatory. This involved disassembling some piping.You do what you have to in those countries and in those economic situations to keep things running.     
 
 
"But Rockwell used some irreverent humor to support necessary and serious message.  In more recent years, reviewers of Rockwell's Rosie have added their interpretations and observations. "Just as Isaiah was called by God to convert the wicked from their sinful ways and trample evildoers under foot," wrote one Sothebys curator in a May 2002 review, "so Rockwell's Rosie tramples Hitler's "Mein Kampf" under her all-American penny loafer." 
  

In times of national crisis like in the early 1940s for World War II, the"We Can Do It" poster was the slogan. With everyone's help we ended up with a huge economic engine that the 1930s Japanese administration grossly underestimated. The growth of this engine was due in no small part to women moving in to fill in for the men who were shipping out as well as moving into jobs that were more directly tied to the war effort. This inspired social movement increased the number of working women from 12 million to 20 million by 1944, a 57% increase. The women had altruistic and patriotic motives but the difficult and dangerous jobs were better paid then clerical and secretarial jobs.    

Why do I write this? I think it's about a belief I have that work is good in it's own right. To support my point I'd like to refer you to Governor Mike Huckabee's observation last week which connects Labor Day and the meaning of work. He said that we see joblessness as an economic fact, we talk about the financial implications of widespread high unemployment, and that isn't wrong but it misses the central point. Joblessness is a personal crisis because work is a spiritual event.  Followers of St. Benedict's rule of which I've had some training have in their crest, "Ora et Labora", prayer and work.

September promises to be a busy month. Bob Marckini points out that September is Prostate Cancer Awareness Month as recognized by the American Cancer Society and many other organizations. It's also the month for The University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center's Prostate Health Conference led by Dr. John Davis on September 7, 2013 on the South Campus, 8am to 11:30pm. Registration is at no cost. register here.

Dave Stevens is planning to repeat one of his well received talks on proton therapy treatment for prostate cancer at the Beam News Meetings on a Wednesday in late September at the Proton Center on Old Spanish Trail, Houston.

He and I have been working on the planning committee of the Anderson Survivorship Conference to be held on September 27 and 28 at the Omni Westside. The headliner will be cancer researcher and Pulitzer Prize author Siddhartha Mukherjee, M.D., Ph.D., of the book "The Emperor of All Maladies". The conference which continually draws more attendees every year could draw over 700 this year. You can have special rates at the Omni for attendees and the conference is heavily subsidized. (conference information and registration)

One of our long time entertainers is featured in a YouTube audio this month.  Mark and Red Anderson entertained a whole group of folks at every Wednesday night dinner while they were in Houston with a skit and a ditty. 

In Gratitude, 
Joe Landry

 
Like us on FacebookFollow us on Twitter
Another Factually Inaccurate Article about Proton Therapy
From the Wall Street Journal
Some of the greatest advances in medicine have been fought by doctors who should know better. Thus, for centuries, doctors did not believe hand washing was needed when delivering babies in the maternity ward. Dr. Ignaz Semmelweis proved in the 1840's that washing hands with an antiseptic solution before delivery reduced mothers' deaths from childhood fever by 90%. However, the medical community rejected his findings for over 20 years, because they conflicted with entrenched beliefs of doctors of the time. Eventually, antisepsis became an accepted practice in operating rooms by about 1870, and remains so today.

In our own time, proton therapy has been rejected by some influential medical professionals and institutions. A recent Yale University study by James B. Yu, a radiation oncologist is cited in a newspaper article published earlier this week for the proposition that
"assertions about proton beam's superiority in treating prostate cancer haven't been backed up by medical evidence."   Prostate-Cancer Therapy Comes Under Attack"
(Wall Street Journal 8/28/13).

The article suggests that the Yu study, among others played a role in the decisions to stop covering proton therapy for prostate cancer by Aetna, Inc. as of August 1, and by Blue Shield of California as of October 31 for "early-stage prostate cancer."
 
The article omits any reference to studies showing proton therapy's fewer side effects compared to other studies of the side effects of X-Ray radiation therapies including Intensity Modulated Radiation Therapy (IMRT).  Two randomized trials of Protons are Coen (2011 - randomized dose escalated trial) and Nihei (2011 - prospective trial), while two for X-Rays are Zietman (2010 - CRT - randomized dose escalated trial) and a 2009 IMRT subset of a Dutch randomized dose escalated trial by Al-Mamgani and colleagues.  Although virtually all of the acute and late side effects for GI (rectum) are Grade 1 and 2, there are far more of these in the IMRT and CRT studies than in the proton studies. As for the Acute GU (bladder), the proton side effects are grouped mostly in Grade 1, while the IMRT side effects are grouped more in Grade 2 and a significant number in Grade 3.  
 
These are separate studies, however they are mostly both prospective and randomized. To date, there have been no prospective randomized clinical trials where the same study compares protons vs. IMRT. The study at Yale University (which does not offer proton therapy) purports to do that in a single retrospective observational study, however, there are some serious flaws which render it a poor basis to compare IMRT vs. protons.
 
For one thing, the Yale study's authors virtually admit that the 12 month length of the study is not enough time to look at the full scope of side effects from protons and IMRT.  Second, the Medicare claims data on which the Yale study is based omits crucial information needed to make a meaningful comparison. Thus, the Medicare data does not reveal any patient's radiation dose and field size --- such information could be valuable if protons radiated a higher dose and field size than IMRT, but produced fewer side effects, or vice versa.
 
Even the authors of the Yale study concede that the Medicare data's grading of the side effects from minor to severe is unreliable; the data does not say how long the treatment for side effects lasted; and the data does not include side effects where a hospital visit was not required.  Indeed, the Yale study's conclusion itself is an outlier, due in part to the relatively incomplete data upon which it is based.
 
Bottom line, the best evidence-based studies support the view that protons results in fewer side effects than X-Rays and IMRT. By omitting that fact, the Wall Street Journal article presents a biased and highly misleading picture of proton therapy for prostate cancer. In so doing, they reject protons much as the medical establishment of 150 years ago rejected the idea of doctors washing their hands in the operation room.  
 
Oddly enough, the closest the article comes to the truth is in the final paragraph, where the authors of the article suggest that the debate is really all about cost, not about the efficacy of protons. They quote the executive director of the National Association for Proton Therapy who states "there would be no debate [between IMRT and protons] if costs were the same as conventional X-ray radiation."
Dave Stevens 

Key Features this Month 
A New "My Story" 
Large part of this newsletter is about Phil Meaders, the Proton Cowboy, a tall Texan we wrote about in ProtonPals April eNewsletter, (read more)  Phil Meaders. Phil dressed for work in his cowboy boots, white shirt, slacks and a hat
Phil Gonging Out
and wasn't about to take his boots off to walk to the Fixed Beam Treatment Room 4.  

This month Phil sent me his "My Story" which describes the current processes at the center for some diagnosed with prostate cancer. We have published a few my stories in the past including the one we started with and recently updated by Ban Capron. Ban's work made the content of the web site what it is today and so valuable to newcomers.

As you read Phil's story you can pick out the key points of what a model patient should do, from getting examined, setting an early baseline, to following a nutritional, physical and spiritual wellness discipline to acting on signs of cancer. In addition, if you don't catch this point when you read his story, with 20 years of physical conditioning this Texan can still press 300 lbs at age 52.

My Story by Proton Cowboy
 Following on Phil's Intro Above
The "My Story" is stored on the website complete and runs for several pages. It chronicles the beginning of his journey to the completion of proton treatment for Phil.

Specifically we wanted you to read his inspiring story but also to show what the processes in the proton treatment area are today; and to indicate that they have changed to a significant extent since I went through there 6 1/2 years ago. Most of it has to do with repeatability in positioning; repeatability from the time of simulation as to the daily positioning of your hips, the balloon, the fiducials for location of the gland, the bladder, the fiducial in the tip of the balloon, the gas relief tube - all implemented to optimize the treatment while reducing any unnecessary exposure of the sensitive organs and nerves in the pelvic area. 
 
Proton Cowboy Phil Meaders 
Family History

Phil was 42 when his brother was diagnosed with prostate cancer. Like many of the ProtonPals,for example Bob Marckini, yours truly, a close friend and several others have a family history of prostate cancer whereProton Cowboy Phil Meadors a direct relative has been diagnosed. Although a very complex relationship there are many studies that strongly suggest that prostate cancer susceptibility genes exist in the population. This percentage maybe as high as 42% of prostate cancer risk may be accounted for by heritable factors. That alone should raise a cautionary flag. These heritable factors can also come from the maternal side of the family. Here Phil was 46 when following a wellness approach decided to get screened for prostate cancer. If you'll recall the USPSTF guidelines would lead you astray and you wouldn't be tested. The lesson-learned is start young, record what your baseline is and keep the records.

 

"My journey through prostate cancer began when my older brother had his diagnosis in 2006. He is nine years older. We each have a son and they are the same age. Both son's, my brother, and myself and were both active in Boy Scouts as youth and adult leaders. The Boy Scouts require an annual physical exam for adult Scout Leaders who participate as adult volunteers and attend summer camp with the Boy Scout Troop. My brother discovered his prostate cancer as part of the annual physical exam required by the Boy Scouts for adult leaders. His diagnosis and my participation in Boy Scouts as a Scoutmaster led me to beginning an annual regimen of having a regular physical exam"

 

Wellness Exams

The key to screening examinations is that the tests will detect prostate cancer early when it is easiest to treat and the doctor will have more success in curing the cancer. What determines whether someone should be screened? - age, gender and ethnicity or family history and here I'd say we had age as over 40 , male and a family history.

 

"My initial PSA results were unremarkable and just over zero when I had my first test in 2007 when I was 46. I continued annual testing over next few years. Over those subsequent exams my PSA gently climbed from near zero to just over 1.0."

 

After moving from Houston to Dallas in 2010 based on a promotion this is what Phil wrote

 

"The blood test results came back with a PSA result at 3.96. I scheduled a follow-up with the internist. My Internist discussed the remarkable jump in my PSA level, and recommended an appointment with an urologist.My internist provided a referral to a local urologist who he was familiar with."

 

Follow Ups and Monitoring

Like all business processes, medical processes are subject to the same "rule of thumb" or business adage - "You can't manage what you don't measure."  PSA is challenged in a lot of areas but one key area no one will argue against is - it works in monitoring the significant change in the number of malignant cells.

 

"My initial PSA test conducted by the urologist came back at about 2.5. I had a follow-up with the urologist and he recommended I wait a few months and return for another PSA test. I went away with some relief and I was feeling comfortable with the way my urologist was handling my case. I returned for my follow-up test in October 2011. Again the result was around 2.5 and I was feeling as I had dodged a bullet again. The urologist asked me to come back and continue to monitor every six months. I returned again for tests again in February 2012 again there was no remarkable change."

 

Prostate Biopsy

Like many of our ProtonPals, Phil had a strong faith and a very active spiritual life that supported his decisions and his questions at all turns.

 

"Looking back, it is remarkable when I finally let go and followed God's lead, I gained new sense of peace to deal with the approaching biopsy.

My urologist performed the biopsy procedure in an exam room in his office. The procedure went as he described. However, it was my first experience with the sonogram and the sticks in the backside. Many adult males have the annual prostate exam which is a target of many locker room jokes when you talk among your buddies."

 

"The urologist reported the prognosis for a cancer like this has a very high cure rate and he presented some options to consider ranging from watchful waiting; prostatectomy using robotic surgery; radiation by external beam; and radioactive seed implants. He told me since I was relatively young at age 52, I most likely would have to have one of the treatments to remove or treat the cancer cells eventually."

 

Research and Referral

Here's what Andrew Schorr, one of my favorite authors and blogger, has to say about being savvy and proactive in your illness. He gives 3 tips and they are:

 

  • Find doctors who are at the cutting edge of the treatment for your specific condition.
  • Seek and use the medical facility where patients with your condition are having the best outcomes.
  • Find and connect with patient mentors who have journeyed down this road and are poised to share their knowledge with you.

 

MD Anderson contracts with Andrew Schorr for a program called Patient Power. He's a pioneer in health communications and patient education and along the way he became a patient with a successful treatment and survivor. (read more)  

 

We're given feedback that the One-on-one conversations are so valuable to a newly diagnosed patient and that is the reason we've implemented this program on our ProtonPals web site and continue to maintain a list of Pal to Pal contacts. It's also why MD Anderson has the telephone call list as well as Bob Marckini's Brotherhood of the Balloons.  Here you can see Phil follow through on one of the key tips and found his one-on-one mentor who was treated at MD Anderson on his own and somewhat by chance.  

 

"After doing some research, I called the former MD Anderson Proton Therapy Center prostate cancer patient as recommended by my assistant. He took my call even though he had no idea who I was. When we spoke it was if we were long lost friends. This man could not say enough good things about his experience with the MD Anderson Proton Therapy Center and his prostate cancer treatment. He told me felt great during treatment, exercised every day, and most importantly he had no side effects. His story was very welcome news and caused me to seek more information about proton treatment for prostate cancer."

 

Here his urologist doesn't favor proton therapy, equates it with regular XRay (IMRT) and doesn't offer proton therapy as a treatment option. This fact is supported by my personal experience as well as numerous men I've spoken with and have written their "My Story". Dr. Richard Dawley conducted research while he was in treatment and reports a same out look in his book, "The Proton Warrior." 

 

" I had questions for him regarding the different procedures available, side effects, and risks. We talked about robotic surgery and radiation methods. My urologist made no mention of Proton Therapy at no time during our discussion. After we talked a bit, I asked him what he knew about Proton Therapy at MD Anderson. I recall him saying he knew of the treatment and he presented it as the same as regular x-rays known as Intensity Modulated Radiation Therapy (IMRT) with similar risks. Then I told the urologist, I wanted to seek a second opinion, and learn more about the MD Anderson Proton Therapy Center. Then I would decide on surgery or proton therapy. He did not encourage my further investigation nor did he say anything discouraging. He simply left it as my personal choice. At the time, I was disappointed in my medical professional for not being forthcoming in presenting proton therapy as a treatment option."

 

Initial Appointment at MD Anderson Proton Therapy Center

Research and preparation led Phil to feel more comfortable when he heard what the doctor had to say at his initial visit. He felt the oncologist was shooting straight with him as the information was not completely new and now easier to understand. He credits the book written by one of our Pals, Harold Dawley.   

 "My wife and I left the Proton Center and drove back to Dallas. On the road back to Dallas, we talked about the treatment options among ourselves. I told her, I felt the Lord leading me to continue to pursue treatment at Proton Center since I felt very comfortable with the Proton Center doctor; and my information discoveries about proton therapy from the book "Proton Warriors"; information on the internet about proton therapy for prostate cancer; information on the Proton Pals website; and my discussion with a former Proton Center patient."

MRI Appointment
New technology in imaging like the MRI has advanced the treatment of prostate by leaps and bounds. This imaging gives the oncologist the ability to decide how to treat a Gleason 7 precisely and without androgen deprivation hormones.  

"MD Anderson is an amazing facility. It is a city of its own in size, but it is very personal in handling patients and very efficient in operation. I rode the MD Anderson shuttle bus from the May's Clinic back to the Proton Center. This took about 15 minutes. I immediately went in to see the Proton Center doctor to discuss my diagnosis. The staff knew I was running tight on my flight schedule. By the time I met with the doctor, he had already reviewed my MRI images and he showed them to me on a computer screen. He pointed out the tumor in my prostate and the structure of the organs involved in the anatomy of the prostate area in my body. The doctor gave me some positive news. He told me my prostate was of normal size and the tumor was contained in the prostate although it was close to the wall. He also pointed out the shape of my prostate was very favorable to the proton therapy in avoiding some side effects of proton treatment. This good news meant he would not recommend hormone treatments as a part of my treatment plan. I addition, he told me I would be a good candidate for proton therapy to treat the cancer. Upon hearing the results, I told the doctor I wanted to move forward with scheduling treatment at the Proton Center towards the end of January 2013."

These set of clips brings us to the start of Treatment Preparation and the steps one goes through for this like Fiducial Placement, Simulation and the first day of proton treatments along with his experience with Ringing the Gong.  

 

You can read or down load a PDF copy of Phil Meadors, "My Story" from the ProtonPals webserver at this location.  (Read more).  

 

If you reading this newsletter on smart phone or pad, this version is formatted a little differently and maybe easier to read in landscape mode.  (Read mobile in device format).  

 

Ban Capron Updates His "My Journey"
Ban "Gongs Out" February 22, 2008
Co-Founder of ProtonPals
Ban was treated for prostate cancer at the MD Anderson Proton Center in 2008. While in Houston he documented his treatment with a series of photographs (view a great slide show) and a narrative about his journey (my journey). This work plus his willingness to join me in the early web site and organization efforts gave much more value and meaning to the ProtonPals vision.

He recently updated his PSA values from a check up this spring.

  Plot of PSA track - Ban's

Like shoes, where a great fit on one person will wear blisters on another's feet, no two patients are alike; and everyone's response to medical treatment is somewhat different. However I think I can generalize and say that for low to intermediate risk patients who have not had hormone therapy (androgen deprivation), a "typical" PSA response after proton therapy treatment will look like this. (Read more).  With hormone therapy one can measure an almost immediate drop in PSA as testosterone is suppressed and a completely different response in the following months as we've seen in Dave Steven's talks and papers.

 

Footnote: The gong acquired when the Proton Center opened in 2006, that Ban is striking in 2008, eventually wore out from being struck by so many patients and was replaced by another last year.

Well I Don't Like Dem DREs 
Mark Anderson Proton Ditty 2
Mark Anderson at his first Annual Reunion.
Proton Ditty 2
Mark Anderson, now living in the Texas Hill Country, Kerrville, Texas kept his "class" entertained both in the Proton Center dressing room and at restaurants for the Wednesday dinners. He usually brought his guitar and his bag of gags for us, and he and his wife Red had a skit for us on every Wednesday. Here's Mark rendition of Proton Ditty 2.
 

Mark and Red wish low PSAs to all their friends and wants them to know they are planning a two year reunion around Halloween in Houston. The current plan is to hold a dinner at Canopy's on Wednesday Oct 30, and a costume get together at the Proton Center on Thursday the 31st. Contact Drew Cox for more current information.
About the ProtonPals Organization
Thanks for subscribing to the newsletter and using the ProtonPals website. We won't sell or give your addresses to anyone. You'll receive one or at most two mailings a month from us. If you're a new subscriber you may want to note that the past newsletters are archived back to May 2009. Newsletter Archives

We're a group who chose proton beam therapy to cure our cancer and were treated at University of Texas M.D. Anderson Proton Therapy Center in Houston, Texas. The "Pals" formed a network in order to:

  • Stay up to date with treatment cure results
  • Provide support to others and Center activities
  • Be informed on any side- effects
  • Promote proton radiation since it's widely regarded to have a significant advantage over conventional x-rays.
  • Attract and nurture more Pals who support our cause, patient-to-patient and friend-to-friend

  • Support ProtonPals by letting us know how you're doing. That is so important to newly diagnosed men and their wives and partners.  As a former patient we'd all welcome your help in getting the word out about proton radiation and how you're doing. Please donate using the Donate Icon below or mail a check made out to ProtonPals, Ltd.(we're a tax deductible non-profit) at my home address.  Read more about it on the website How to Help - Giving

     

     

    Sincerely,

     


    Joe Landry, Founder
    ProtonPals, Ltd.
    ProtonPals, Ltd. is a 501 (c) (3) public charity incorporated in Texas.
    DISCLAIMERS ProtonPals is an exclusively patient-sponsored organization with no official relationship with or support by The University of Texas M. D. Anderson Cancer Center or the M.D. Anderson Proton Therapy Center. ProtonPals is simply an information sharing network of patients. ProtonPals hopes to inform, encourage and help patients through shared knowledge. Members are not doctors so more serious concerns should be directed directly to your doctor. ProtonPals also desires to promote the M. D. Anderson Proton Therapy Center as for virtually everyone it has been a very positive if not life saving experience. The ProtonPals web-site, commonly known as the ProtonPals.net weblog, will contain hypertext links to information created and maintained by other public and private organizations.  These links are provided for your convenience.  ProtonPals does not control or guarantee the accuracy, relevance, timeliness or completeness of this outside information.  Further the inclusion of these links to particular items in hypertext are not intended to reflect their importance, nor is it intended to endorse any of these views expressed or products or services offered on these outside sites, or the organization sponsoring the sites.