Header Image

Home

About 

Members 

Regulatory Matters 

Resources 

Join Us 

Contact 

California Biodiesel Alliance News

California's Biodiesel Industry Trade Association  

December 2012   

In This Issue
CBA USHERS IN 2013 WITH NEW OFFICERS
BIODIESEL EXPERTS CLARIFY IMPORTANT ISSUES AT LCFS CONFERENCE
CEC BIOFUELS WORKSHOP TO BE HELD JANUARY 11th
NOT YOUR GRANDFATHER'S FILLING STATION: CBA RETAILER MEMBERS ENGAGE CUSTOMERS IN SUSTAINABILITY AND ADVOCACY
REGULATORY AND POLICY ISSUE UPDATES
CBA WELCOMES NEW MEMBERS: Biofuel Recycling
WHO'S WHO IN CALIFORNIA BIODIESEL: Atul Deshmane, Whole Energy Fuels Corporation

Greetings!,

 

This month we are very pleased to welcome Biofuel Recycling as our newest business member and to offer a Who's Who article on Atul Deshmane, CEO/President of Whole Energy Fuels Corporation, who will be speaking on regional collaboration at our upcoming conference.  This issue is stuffed full of tasty morsels, so enjoy it along with the rest of your holiday cheer!  It was hoped that this issue could announce the name of the California company that produced Solazyme's algae-based Soladiesel sold in Propel's month-long pilot, but the information is still not available . . . . so stay tuned.

 

 

To view back issues of this newsletter and CBA Email Alerts 

click on the "View CBA Email Newsletter Archive" button on our Home page.  

CBA USHERS IN 2013 WITH NEW OFFICERS

  

This month the board of the California Biodiesel Alliance voted by unanimous consent to elect the following new officers:      

CBA logo  

 

 

The new officers will begin their terms January 1, 2013. The board also voted to elect new officers every other year.     

 

BIODIESEL EXPERTS  

CLARIFY IMPORTANT ISSUES AT LCFS CONFERENCE

 

Oil Dropping A two-day conference in San Francisco on December 13th and 14th put on by Oil Price Information Service (OPIS) featured a range of speakers addressing the details of California's Low Carbon Fuel Standard (LCFS), which requires a 10% reduction in the carbon intensity (CI) of the state's transportation fuels by 2020. The day began with Michael Waugh, Chief of Transportation for the Fuels Branch of the California Air Resources Board (ARB), who talked about ARB's commitment to the program and the success it is already enjoying. Several speakers, including Greg Staiti, Director of Energy Compliance Services at Weaver, detailed the program's requirements.

 

Dolores Santos, Director of Supply and Distribution at Flyers (a Nella Oil Company) expressed some of her concerns based on her daily work as a blender and marketer. Jay McKeeman, Vice President of Government Relations at the California Independent Oil Marketers Association (CIOMA) presented a range of feared outcomes for his organization's members under LCFS. In response to Mr. McKeeman's talk, conference attendee Ryan Lamberg, Executive Director of the California Biodiesel Initiative, pointed out that his recent extensive research has shown that the negative LCFS scenarios are based on studies commissioned by the petroleum industry, not the available, more objective academic studies.

 

Eric Bowen, Executive Director of Corporate Business Development & Legal Affairs at REG and CBA Chairman, ended the day with a presentation that discussed LCFS as a huge market driver and a program that is likely to proceed regardless of the outcome of the current lawsuit against it. He detailed several scenarios of how biodiesel and renewable diesel can meet the program's low carbon fuel demands of potentially hundreds of millions of gallons.

 

Bowen pointed out that, while today California lags in biodiesel/renewable diesel production and is still dealing with some regulatory uncertainty, the future is looking brighter. He acknowledged to Santos that distribution infrastructure is a problem in the state today, but said that it is improving, and cited two new terminals, which were put in at great expense in Fresno and Colton by Kinder Morgan as evidence that RFS2 is providing incentives to blend. Bowen corrected out-of-date information regarding California underground storage tank regulations presented by McKeeman and Santos by clarifying that new State Water Board regulations, which took effect this June, now allow for the legal storage of higher biodiesel blends. He also stated that new diesel technology and state fleet turnover rules provide a solution to short-term de minimis NOx increase.

 

Shelby Neal, Director of State Governmental Affairs at the National Biodiesel Board, provided corroborating facts during the group discussion that followed Eric Bowen's presentation, lending support and credibility to the California biodiesel industry's efforts to ensure the success of LCFS.  

   

 

CEC BIOFUELS WORKSHOP TO BE HELD JANUARY 11th 

 

Vials of Biodiesel

On Friday, January 11th, the California Energy Commission's (CEC) AB 118 funding program will hold a Biofuels Workshop in Sacramento. CBA encourages attendance at this event where our industry will again be making the case for biodiesel funding; calling for a metric-based approach to the agency's funding decisions; and discussing the importance of CEC funding for the success of low carbon biofuels under California's Low Carbon Fuels Standard program.

 

It is especially important to make our voices heard given the recently released Staff Draft of the 2013-2014 Investment Plan for the Alternative and Renewable Fuel and Vehicle Technology Program (ARFVTP), which does not reflect our industry's repeated, detailed requests for funding commensurate with biodiesel's benefits. The draft proposes $23 million for Alternative Fuel Production for all biofuels, including diesel substitutes, biomethane, and gasoline substitutes - consolidating them so that they have to compete with each other - and no funding at all for Upstream Biodiesel Infrastructure.    

 

At a CEC Advisory Committee meeting and public workshop on September 19th, Joe Gershen, CBA's representative on the AB 118 Advisory Committee, presented a white paper that included an analysis of data from the CEC's own 2011 Integrated Energy Policy Report (IEPR). The analysis, detailing how extremely underfunded biodiesel is relative to other fuel energy sources, shows that biodiesel provides 34.7% of benefits in terms of petroleum displacement, GHG reduction, and air quality improvements, yet has only received 4.8% of AB 118 funding through the ARFVT Program. Specifically, the presentation asked for grants and loan guarantees that would allow for the following: the expansion of biodiesel production at existing in-state facilities and the creation of additional capacity; support for the development of plentiful and inexpensive in-state feedstocks; and the building of new blending and storage infrastructure at petroleum distributors' and terminal racks.

 

At the most recent CEC Advisory Committee meeting and public workshop on December 4th, Joe's questioning why the CEC has not begun to employ metric-based decision making based on carbon-footprint comparisons of the different alternative fuels was picked up by an online newsletter publication of Inside Washington Publishers called The California Energy & Climate Report. The article reported that he was joined in this request by several other Advisory Committee members, including Stephen Kaffka of the California Biomass Collaborative and Will Coleman, a representative of several renewable fuel companies. It pointed out that the CEC's proposal to allocate $20 million of the total annual program budget of $100 million to hydrogen infrastructure was singled out as an area especially in need of review in terms of the costs and benefits of that fuel source.

 

The Staff Draft and related meeting details (Biofuels Workshop time and room TBD) are posted at: http://www.energy.ca.gov/2012-ALT-2/documents/.

 

NOT YOUR GRANDFATHER'S FILLING STATION:

CBA RETAILER MEMBERS ENGAGE CUSTOMERS  

IN SUSTAINABILITY AND ADVOCACY

 

BIodiesel Pump Far from operating your run-of-the-mill filling stations, California's biodiesel retailers have programs and communications that keep customers involved in sustainability strategies beyond filling up with biodiesel. Among them is Berkeley's Biofuel Oasis, whose website lists their other product lines including urban farming classes and goods, with actual chicks for sale. Propel Fuels offers the ability to buy carbon offsets or sign up for a CleanDrive membership, which gives customers a free online report of their alternative fuel use in terms of "reductions in CO2 emissions, barrels of oil displaced, decrease in foreign oil, and equivalent impact of trees."

 

Several retail companies keep in close touch with their customers via email communications that have become increasingly sophisticated. Dogpatch Biofuels, located in San Francisco, provides information, from the calculations involved in setting their fuel prices to anecdotal updates on the performance of higher blends in newer engines, and is among the CBA retailer members who engage their customers in policy work on behalf of biodiesel in the state and at the federal level as we fight alongside the national industry on behalf of RFS volumes and the federal tax incentive.  Keep up the good work!  

 REGULATORY AND POLICY ISSUE UPDATES

Grease containersGrease containersGrease containers  

   

CALIFORNIA ENERGY COMMISSION (CEC): AB 118 FUNDING    

The Energy Commission has posted the Staff Draft of the 2013-2014 Investment Plan Update for the Alternative and Renewable Fuel and Vehicle Technology Program.  The draft proposes $23 million for Alternative Fuel Production for all biofuels, including diesel substitutes, biomethane and gasoline substitutes - consolidating them so that they have to compete with each other - and no funding at all for Upstream Biodiesel Infrastructure.  The Staff Draft and related meeting details (Biofuels Workshop time and room TBD) are posted at: http://www.energy.ca.gov/2012-ALT-2/documents/.

  

DIVISION OF MEASUREMENT STANDARDS (DMS)

CBA continues its participation in the fuels working group of the California Department of Food and Agriculture's Division of Measurement Standards (DMS) consortium, which is designed to find solutions to fiscal challenges facing the program due to mandatory General Fund reductions. DMS is involved with biodiesel standards, testing, and labeling.   

 

EMISSIONS 

Our industry's working group on California emissions, which includes CBA members and national technical and policy experts, continues its active involvement with the California Air Resources Board (ARB) in the process of developing our state's first emissions-based specifications for biodiesel. A very important public workshop on this issue, to be held by ARB in Sacramento three weeks after the release of a white paper on this subject, is planned for early 2013.

      

LOW CARBON FUEL STANDARD (LCFS)

CBA has been engaged with the California Air Resources Board (ARB) on the issue of mixed feedstock for some time, and we are happy to announce that ARB has agreed with our input on how to allow allocation of feedstock CIs to finished fuel volumes.  ARB has issued a Revised LCFS Mixed-Feedstock Guidance document, which describes how mixed feedstock biodiesel/renewable diesel producers are to calculate the CI values of the fuels they report under LCFS's Method 1 provisions.   

  

In summary, it says that producers, in order to use the guidance, are required to use accounting systems that allow them to associate all volumes of the fuel produced with specific individual feedstocks. All volumes of fuel produced must be associated with a specific feedstock within a calendar month, and no gallons can be sold prospectively. Producers without that accounting capability must label all gallons produced with the CI value of the feedstock with the highest CI.

For distributors, essentially the same rules apply for all biofuel in the tank.
   

UST REGULATIONS

CBA urges compliance with the new 2012 permanent regulations governing UST storage of biodiesel. See our Regulatory Matters webpage for more information and links to the State Water Board website that posts the new compatibility forms from equipment manufacturers. The Water Board list is constantly being updated and revised forms may not be labeled as such. 

 

NOTE: Your CUPA may require engineering approvals for non-integral secondary containment (sumps and UDCs).   

 

FEDERAL ISSUES

Thanks to all who have been active in efforts on behalf of the tax incentive. The incentive, if passed in 2012, will be part of the fiscal cliff decision making process, which is at play at the time of writing of this newsletter.  

CBA WELCOMES NEW MEMBERS
 
Biofuel Recycling Logo


Biofuel Recycling is a San Francisco based non-profit providing ecological vision and technical expertise for energy and utility infrastructure projects with a focus on converting waste to energy.

 



______  JOIN CBA AS AN INDIVIDUAL, A NONPROFIT, OR A BUSINESS  _____  

 

If you are reading this and are not yet a member, please join us.  CBA offers membership levels with the following annual dues: $25 for students; $100 for individuals and nonprofit organizations; $500 for small businesses; and $2000 (Silver). Full voting memberships are available by application at $3000 (Gold) or $5000 (Platinum).  Our Join Us webpage has details and an easy online membership fee payment process. 

 

Membership benefits include:   

  • CBA's Email Newsletter with important industry updates and features about Who's Who in biodiesel in California and Action Alerts that let you know when your help can really make a difference.
  • Participation in policy discussions and legislative/regulatory visits. 
  • Discount on CBA's annual California Biodiesel and Renewable Diesel Conference.
  • Your company's logo and link on our Members webpage ($500 level and up).  
  • Special recognition at events and in publications (Platinum members).    

_______   SIGN UP FOR EMAIL ALERTS  _____

 

Anyone can sign up to get CBA's special Alert emails, which we send out when we need biodiesel stakeholders and enthusiasts to take action on important issues facing our industry. Visit our Home page and add your email address.  

 

_______   VIEW PAST NEWSLETTERS AND EMAIL ALERTS  _____

 

Just click on the "View CBA Email Newsletter Archive" button on ouHome page.

WHO'S WHO IN CALIFORNIA BIODIESEL

Atul Deshmane    

Atul Deshmane 

CEO/President, Whole Energy Fuels Corporation

 

Atul Deshmane first heard about biodiesel around 1997 while working at Ford Motor Company with a team that was building vehicles to run on electricity, natural gas, and hydrogen, but he wasn't at all sure that this young fuel would actually take off. Several years later, Atul was working for Clean Energy, a natural gas company, when he participated on a panel with Joe Jobe, CEO of the National Biodiesel Board, at a Clean Cities conference in Oklahoma City. Atul was impressed that Joe presented the benefits of biodiesel without claiming that it was a silver bullet or criticizing natural gas. This very sensible approach to biodiesel, plus the illuminating information that the fuel had in fact taken off, tapped the dormant entrepreneur in Atul. In 2005, he co-founded the Bellingham, Washington-based Whole Energy Fuels Corporation with Orion Polinsky.

 

The original dream was to become another New Leaf Biofuel or a SeQuential Biodiesel, but without the ability to raise the money needed to build a proper plant, the partners focused on leveraging what they knew and set out to create value with an Intelligent, informed approach to fuel distribution. Though initially it seemed like it wouldn't work because there wasn't a need for a middleman, the company began to create mutually beneficial relationships with regional biodiesel producers. They decided to tie their success to the success of those companies and to strive for the most sustainable approaches to biofuel production and distribution. Employing this unique regional strategy, Whole Energy now has operations in British Columbia, Washington,  

Oregon, and California; works in partnership with both local governments and businesses; and provides biodiesel to users including the Washington State Ferries, the largest public consumer of biodiesel in the country, and the Army Corp of Engineers.

 

Whole Energy helped get two British Columbia biodiesel plants up and running by assisting with plant and lab design, securing feedstock, and getting the bugs out of the production process. This allowed the plant to speed up production and provided a supply of fuel for Whole Energy. In 2010, Whole Energy began working with Oregon-based Biomass Renewable Technologies (BRT) to manage everything from production to sales and marketing of BRT's proprietary biodiesel production processes and equipment, including their add-on modules for free fatty acid reduction. This year Whole Energy is working on a project with oil recycler Oregon Oils and fuel producer Beaver Biodiesel to get co-located operations online toward the goal of lowering costs and efficiently supplying Portland's discretionary blending market.

 

With a desire to be involved in production without competing with its suppliers, Whole Energy is excited about expanding into glycerin production in Washington, which will allow them to help increase the value of glycerin co-products for their suppliers and create new markets for technical grade glycerin. In terms of California production, right now Whole Energy is looking mainly to add value to suppliers by promoting best practices for glycerin, not necessarily creating their own profit centers.

 

Whole Energy's biodiesel distribution system includes terminals in Anacortes and Tahoma, Washington; Portland, Oregon; and a terminal in Richmond, California, which has been providing fuel since 2008. Recently the company received $125,274 in grant funding from the California Energy Commission to enhance their blending at this facility by adding microfiltration and in-line additization capability. Whole Energy also has distribution infrastructure in the Los Angeles area as well.

 

With a track record of creating successful regional business-to-business partnerships, Whole Energy is still learning how to do public private partnerships right, according to Atul. "It's a challenge because you have to compromise from a business perspective, and it boils down to learning what's realistic," Atul said. Their joint venture with the City of Pacfica, California, a project designed to collect used cooking oil from the waste water stream and process it into biodiesel for both power generation and vehicles use, failed after the original advocates left their city jobs. Atul was happy that state funding for this project was reallocated to another California producer, but Whole Energy was dealt a near fatal blow and has yet to staff back up to the levels it had at that time.

 

Wolfkill Whole Energy, a joint venture between Wolfkill Feed and Fertilizer and Snohomish County, Washington, is another public private partnership with an innovative vision for the county's drying and crushing facility, which is located at a landfill site. The idea is that methane gas recovered from the landfill will be used to dry the seeds, and the crusher will produce oil to be made into biodiesel for the county's vehicles. The process would also provide the local dairy industry with high quality feed and high-value meal. To meet some infrastructure challenges there, Whole Energy went back to the drawing board and is now installing a degumming system. Atul is hopeful that this unique operation will achieve commercial levels of production in the next few years.

 

Committed to a long view of alternative fuels, Atul believes that the time and large sums of money needed to turn garbage into diesel fuels at commercial levels of production will be well worth the wait. Toward that end, he works part-time supporting the cellulosic diesel project of Mercurius Biofuels, which Whole Energy helped form, sometimes returning to the country of his birth, India, for related business meetings. This pilot, based on the patented Renewable Acid-hydrolysis Condensation Hydrotreating (REACH) technology has partnered to apply for DOE funding with Purdue University, and Mercurius has been awarded matching funds from the Australian national lab, CSIRO. The technology is expected to be commercially available in 4 or 5 years.

 

When asked about how Whole Energy has survived tough economic times, Atul says that by raising more money from investors and using his personal retirement savings, the company has stayed in the black for the last few years, including this year, which has been difficult. He believes that being small is a significant benefit in that it is easy to adapt, but that being multi-regional is a godsend, because the risks can be spread out over several states. He points out that, happily, economic conditions have never been "horrible in all locations at the same time."

 

Atul attended CBA's first conference in San Francisco in January of 2012 and appreciated that there were many attendees from neighboring states. In February of 2013, Atul will return to CBA's annual conference as a speaker. At the helm of a company that has successfully banked on a regional strategy and built a network from Canada to Southern California (including two states with biodiesel mandates), Atul is uniquely qualified to speak about creating synergy for biodiesel through regional collaboration. We look forward to the opportunity to learn from the considerable knowledge that he has gained over many years of working on the cutting edge of alternative fuels.

 


Seasons Greetings Thank you for your time and efforts on behalf of biodiesel. I look forward to working with you in 2013.  Also, I want to personally thank Eric Bowen for his leadership and for the considerable depth and breadth of very important work he has done as CBA's Chairman since its inception.  

 

 



Sincerely,

Celia DuBose
Executive Director
California Biodiesel Alliance