The Love of 12 Oranges 
Harry T. Cook


By Harry T. Cook
1/8/16
 
 
On this date -- January 8 -- in 1947, my mother would celebrate her 30th birthday in a dwelling only a month or two since it had been equipped with indoor plumbing. A budding thought stirred in my almost 8-year-old mind that, given the privations attendant upon raising three kids -- one less than a year old -- in an old, drafty rented house, she might like to be surprised with something nice.
 
Sixteen months earlier, our family had moved from a near-in Detroit suburb to a northwestern lower Michigan village to which Dad had come as a single man in the early 1920s to fish for trout on a brief vacation. As I learned the story much later, my mother early on in their courtship agreed, if somewhat reluctantly, to leave Detroit and environs in due course for this mecca of outdoor sport. She loved Dad that much.
 
So there she was -- bereft of her brothers and sisters and their families still sorting out life in post-war Detroit -- in a hamlet of fewer than 150 souls. I guess I was on some level aware of her loneliness and, remembering that she was partial to fresh oranges, wanted her to have a birthday gift that would bring a smile to her face.
 
Thus I took the longer way home from school that day under a leaden sky and into the teeth of a frigid snow squall off the nearby lake down to the block-long village and its sole grocery store, hoping to find there an orange or two.
 
People who have since "discovered" Alden, Michigan, and erected lakeshore manses that rival those in upper-class neighborhoods in leafy American exurbs would have thought that Leo Angell's grocery store in the winter of 1946-47 was a movie set in which 19th-century life on the prairie was being depicted.
 
Nevertheless, there my eyes fell upon a pile -- a whole pile -- of fresh oranges, a delicacy not ordinarily available in such volume at that time of the year, as I was told. I'm sure now that they would have retailed for something near solid gold. Mr. Angell told me that two crates of the fruit had been put off the express car of the northbound train that very afternoon with the name of his grocery on the shipping label marked "PAID." He said he had neither ordered nor paid for them but was glad to sell them for pure profit.
 
I told him of my mother's birthday and of my desire to buy oranges for her. Whereupon he took out a large paper bag and threw in a dozen oranges, asking 50 cents for the lot. What made him think that a lad of my age would have such riches in his pocket, I cannot tell you. I think I had may have had all of a nickel and perhaps should've asked if I could buy just one orange with it.
 
But suddenly it had become too complicated for me. Just as I shrugged my shoulders and turned away he said, "Wait. I'll charge them to your father, and you can take them home to Mom." I did not then know what charging them meant. Some while later, I found out that the price put on those dozen oranges was a damn sight more than 50 cents.
 
Be that as it may, I lugged home that bag of oranges, nearly falling in the front door whilst handing them over to my mother. "What's this?" she asked. I said they were oranges and that I had bought them for her birthday present.
 
One of the few times I can remember her weeping was that day. She took me in her arms and murmured something about what a good boy I was. Then doubt clearly set in: "But how ever did you get the money to pay for them?" It would be another six months before I began to be useful to the village railroad agent by hustling baggage and delivering Western Union telegrams for tips, allowances being unheard of in those days.
 
So smiling victoriously, I said, "I charged them to Daddy." Her face fell, but for just an instant. I was unaware then that Dad did not have much of a job. He had only recently been admitted to the practice of law and had been picking up such work as there was until he could get established. I think life during that winter must have reminded my parents of the rigors of the Depression in the midst of which they had been wed.
 
The episode of the charged fruit occasioned my first tutorial in economics. Dad was kind but stern in his lecture on the subject. It was to the effect that one spends what he does not have or cannot replace to his own eventual peril. Thus, over the years I have tried my best not to live on credit, for the simple reason that I like a sound sleep unbothered by nightmares featuring bill collectors and bailiffs at the door. I cannot now remember the exact amount billed to my father in l'affaire des oranges. It wasn't all that much, but I was required to pay it back to him in the performance of a couple of weeks' worth of extra household chores. It was a useful lesson.
 
All this comes to mind as of late I have been testing my post-Proustian hypothesis that memory and history are sometimes one and the same, though often not. I learned that the hard way during my days as a newspaper reporter.
 
Leo Angell is long since dead, as are my mother and father. No one living would have cause to remember the story of the oranges, save me. Accordingly, you will have to take my word for it: The incident as described is a brief flash in an otherwise inconsequential sliver of history. Yet each January 8, it emerges intact from memory as I feel the cold of the long walk home toting the bag of oranges and, at its end, the warmth of my mother's embrace. Today I will eat an orange in her memory.

Copyright 2016 Harry T. Cook. All rights reserved. This article may not be used or reproduced without proper credit.
 


Readers Write
Re essay of 1/1/16 2016: Annus Fatalis 
 

Bradley Schmidt, Kent, Ohio:
You say we may somewhere down the road "subvert." I think now is the time to subvert. I think things are away out of hand. If we take to the streets, will the National Guard come again and shoot us?
 
Eileen Ray, Melbourne, Australia:
I note with great interest your concern for the future of the livability of our planet depending so much upon the election results to be decided later this year. The concern is widely shared here in Australia, with many going so far as to say that we should all be entitled to vote: we will all be affected by the outcome, even non-American citizens.

David B. Stewart, Huntington Woods, Michigan:  
It's risible to think that anything will come of the Paris conference or that there will be any cooperating nations. President Obama has already set the precedent for arrogating power to himself beyond that set by the Constitution and governing as if he were a Caesar. The usurpation has already been done. By a Democrat.

Harvey H. Guthrie, Fillmore, California:
I've got to take issue with your third paragraph: "Among other things the planet needs so critically right now is an American voice more sure and certain than that of Barack Obama. The conflagration that is sweeping over and beyond the territories now controlled by radical Muslims bent on martyrdom must be contained and extinguished. ISIS followers need to be put in a situation that will require them to re-think their fundamentalist take on Qu'ran and adopt a theology that does not call for destroying the world in order to save it." Standing on its own, it could have been written by Trump or Cruz. The Obama voice I hear is sure and certain: It is clear and firm in asserting and taking action in light of the fact that American military exceptionalism as the basis of dealing with present international reality is not only pass�, but has been through Viet Nam, Iraq, Afghanistan, Syria, etc. "Sure and certain" is what the demagogues are offering. The only way forward is via chancy and non-macho things like the Iran deal and what Kerry is now trying to do with Syria.

Edie Broida, Palm Beach Gardens, Florida:  
As always, you are spot-on with the predicament we face with the coming election which is why I am wholeheartedly supporting Hillary Clinton based on her experience. It is frightening to think of anyone else in the White House at this time. Bernie Sanders is worthy of respect. The other candidates are all self-serving. I have to hope the electorate realizes this before it is too late. Hillary may have baggage but it's past tense. Obama has moved the country forward and HiIlary can continue its advancement. I am not ashamed of being this political.
 
Betsy Paull, Washington, D.C.:
I just read today's essay and fully appreciate your stance. I never have anything interesting to write in response because I am always in such close agreement with you. A debate between us would go like this: "YES!" "Indeed." "Absolutely." "Spot on!" "I know."
 
Tom Richie, Anderson, South Carolina:
Thanks for your insightful summary of what is up for 2016.  May many hear your warning as to the critical times in which we live and that we can't make it someone else's problem/problems .
 
Cynthia Chase, Laurel, Maryland:
Happy New Year ... maybe.
 
Eunice M. Rose, Southfield, Michigan:
I loved your New Year message. I wish, wish, wish, we could divest ourselves of the coal and oil industry, I fear it will go kicking and screaming to its demise. Case in point: are you ready? Here in Southfield, Word of Faith, a huge congregation, has already been promised millions of dollars so that the Jordan Company could frack on their land for oil. As I said at our last City Council meeting, the earth does not belong to us; we belong to the earth. We can't afford to destroy this planet, which is our only home. Many of us spoke at that meeting, all saying that fracking for oil within our city could bring horrific damage to those who use wells for water, could bring down property values, could seriously impact our environment. We will continue to fight this congregation. As I said in my speech, those church folks who look forward to living in luxury, could possibly not be alive to enjoy the fruits of their greed. 
 
Blanche Erickson, Warwick, Rhode Island:
You paint a frightening picture of what 2016 may become. I hope that you are wrong and fear that you are not. I don't see how this political furor can go on much longer. You have written many times of your admiration of President Obama. I voted for him twice. I do wish he would come forward with a policy or plan to, as you say, "extinguish" the fire of ISIS and guide its followers to a less apocalyptic approach.
 
Marina B. Brown, Ann Arbor, Michigan:
You mentioned the xenophobia and ignorance being promoted by our "leaders" like Trump and many others, mostly Republicans, against all Muslims (the enemy of the day). I have just read the book "Infamy" by Richard Reeves on the incarceration of Japanese-Americans during WWII.  I am also reading other materials for a presentation to my book club. It is absolutely scary to see how people's perceptions were swayed thanks to misinformation, innuendos, fear, etc.  Important influential names like journalist Walter Lippmann and Earl Warren, who later became a member of the U.S. Supreme Court were strong attackers of the loyalty of the Japanese-Americans. Over 110,000 were kept in concentration camps, 75% of them born in this country. All their possessions were taken away. After the end of the war many people recognized that they were driven by unfounded fear, confessed their enormous mistakes and apologized for their actions. I just wonder if we have learned anything about this experience? I guess not. Including the fact that most Americans either have no or very vague knowledge of this disgraceful chapter in American history. As Congresswoman Barbara Lee said during the fever to go to war against Iraq: "Let us not become the evil that we deplore."
 
Mark Bendure, Grosse Pointe Park, Michigan:
So very true. I remain hopeful that the extremism of the other side will push the political middle of America -- fundamentally good people with the values we treasure as Americans, albeit misinformed and manipulated -- to a more progressive president, who can bring with him or her a more progressive Congress. In my view the much-maligned current occupant of the office has done a wonderful job, but the circumstances crippled his ability to advance an agenda that includes such important issues as climate change and international diplomacy. It is time for a president who can lead in the fashion of Lincoln or Roosevelt. I just hope it doesn't take another world war to bring such a president to act.
 
Fred Fenton, Concord, California:
You are right about Trump supporters being "mostly white and mostly angry." Bill Clinton said recently that white Americans without high school diplomas are "dying of a broken heart" because they have seen their income and chances for success decline while rich folks game the system and reap every advantage. Bernie Sanders thunders that we need a revolution in America. However, the chance for real reform seems ever more remote. Those of us who are not Trump supporters but find ourselves angry over lost opportunities to make genuine progress in this country had better work to elect an experienced, responsible leader who supports policies that benefit all Americans and not just some.
 
Don Worrell, Troy, Michigan:
You've succeeded in confirming my worst fears and foreboding about 2016 and the forthcoming presidential election season not even seven hours into the new year. I had thought all along that Trump's support was a mile wide but only an inch deep. Unfortunately this doesn't seem to be the case. This demagogic neo-fascist has the ear of a shocking number of people. What's equally scary is that if Trump finally does stumble, Ted Cruz, truly a dangerous and unscrupulous man, will be there to pick up the pieces. Yes, 2016 may turn out to be a watershed year like 1860 and 1932, but there's no Lincoln or FDR in either party. Happy New Year?
 

What do you think?
I'd like to hear from you. E-mail your comments to me at revharrytcook@aol.com.