At Twilight's Last Gleaming
Harry T. Cook

By Harry T. Cook
7/10/15
 

 

 

Its effective beginning came on January 9, 1861, in Charleston, South Carolina, when a rebel artillery battery fired on the federal garrison at Ft. Sumter. The beginning of its end may have come in a volley of bullets fired by a 21-year-old white supremacist in a Charleston church on June 17, 2015, killing nine African-Americans engaged with their pastor in that subversive activity known as bible study.

 

The War Between the States had its roots in 150 years of indentured servitude of African people brought against their will to this country as chattel. The bombardment of Ft. Sumter was the first overt act against a federal government's intent to end slavery in America.

 

That war, though ended officially at Appomattox on April 9, 1865, with Lee's surrender to Grant, went on in other guises for another century and goes on still. It was going on that June night when a white guy was warmly welcomed into a circle of devout African-Americans only to shoot them dead because they represented to him all that was wrong with America.

 

The alleged shooter had wrapped his ambitions in the Confederate flag -- that prized symbol of ignominious failure so cherished by many as a sign, not of defeat, but of rebellion against a future in which persons would be judged, as blessed Martin said, not by the color of their skin but by the content of their character.

 

Now the governor and majorities in both houses of South Carolina's legislature -- a state that once indulged in nullification and secession while leading the charge against Lincoln's resolve to preserve the Union -- have bowed to the onrush of history.

 

Down from the state capitol grounds will come the Confederate flag -- the symbol of an entity that has not existed outside prejudiced minds for 150 years -- and sent on its way to a museum where it belongs.

 

Of course, we will continue to see the Stars and Bars pasted on bumpers and otherwise displayed on private property, where it will represent the alienation, resentment and a certain kind of nihilism uniquely American in nature. To such people, it seems that freedom means being as loutish and contrary as they want, almost daring others to challenge their behavior.

 

Often their preference is for the the kind of climate in which the plain English of the Second Amendment that calls for a well-regulated militia to be prepared to bear arms is dismissed in favor of the constitutional fiction that no one should be denied ownership and the open carrying of a firearm.

 

The congregation of Charleston's Emanuel A.M.E. Church is tragically familiar with that point of view.

 

Meanwhile, the accused killer of the Emanuel Church nine made himself an enforcer of what he believed to be the message conveyed by the Confederate flag:

 

+ Black people and their lives mean less than white people and their lives.

+ Persons with black skins are not deserving of ordinary American rights, such as voting.

+ America is a white man's nation.

+ And borrowing from the Gadsden flag recently adopted as the standard of the Tea Party,  "Don't tread on us."

 

Most snakes don't issue such a warning, and those that do are still reptilian.

 

Flags and standards of all sorts at one time or another become something more or less than they were meant to be in their inception. The cross, for instance. A crucifix is the more appropriate presentation of the cross because it is a symbol of a martyr's death. It is not a symbol of victory, but no one in the Christian realm has yet to figure out how to make a wearable emblem of an empty grave.

 

The Rev. Sabine Baring-Gould wrote of "the cross of Jesus going on before," but he wrote that hymn for a simple Sunday school procession. Perhaps, though, he had in mind the crosses that processed before the crusaders a millennium earlier.

 

The dread banner of Nazi Germany -- blood-red embossed with a huge black swastika -- gathered a whole people to it for the sake of ridding the world of Jews and other allegedly lesser beings.

 

The Confederate flag is a relic of a terrible time in the history of the human race and of this country. Its consignment to the back room of history should help us remember that time, and just as Yom HaShoah (the Holocaust and Heroism Remembrance Day) helps us vow "never again," a similar vow should be given with similar determination to honor the memory of our African-American sisters and brothers who were dehumanized under the Stars and Bars with multitudes driven to their deaths.

 

Many of their descendants are trying still to recover from the inaptly named "Reconstruction" and the era of Jim Crow that did not see the beginning of its end until Mrs. Parks sat down.

 

May the twilight's last gleaming of this day be the last light ever to shine upon the Confederate flag other than that in an illuminated museum case. May he who dares fly the Nazi flag, or any other symbol of human degradation, dwell in his own darkness. May his dreams be nightmares in which he sees himself put upon by the same forces he in waking hours longed to join, and thereby learn a lesson about the crucial need to respect the dignity of every human being.

 


Copyright 2015 Harry T. Cook. All rights reserved. This article may not be used or reproduced without proper credit.
 


Readers Write
Re essay of 7/3/15 American Exceptionalism: An Inquiry
 

 

Ronald Payne, Milford Center, Ohio:

Again, a very fine piece! Your list of things we "know" had the cadence of the indictment against the King in the 1776 Declaration being read on NPR in the background as I read your column. Thanks once more for your prophetic insistence that church and country live up to their self-declared purposes. By the way, four and a half years ago, I ventured to North Carolina to preside at a Holy Union ceremony (my own liturgical creation) for my niece and her partner. I did so with the sanction of neither Church nor State, in fact, contrary to the laws of both; I did so with pride and tears. The couple went to the State of Delaware a year ago to be legally married and the SCOTUS decision nearly coincided with their first married anniversary; the grist of God does grind slow but fine.

 

Prof. Daniel McGuire, Marquette University, Milwaukee, Wisconsin:

Great things you write. You are not a truth-fearing man. So many are . . . Keep pushing.

 

Charles White, Beverly Hills, Michigan:

Your unhappiness is because of your opinion of America as having many flaws, and you are excellent at pointing out the biggest. I didn't notice any portion dedicated to America's high moral principals. One can only assume that you believe America has no high moral principals. One could sum up your essay as directed toward an arrogant and critical America self-absorbed in its own accomplishments while touting them to many. The very same could be said of you. There are undoubtedly other countries that could better meet your high socialist standards.

 

Josephine Kelsey, Ann Arbor, Michigan:

You're on a roll. Keep going.

 

Harry Dyck, Elkhart, Indiana:

Another bull's-eye essay as pertains to the would-be "land of the free and the home of the brave." I find it so ironic that in a land of unequaled resources via economic prowess, education and facilities, medical expertise, and information technology, it is only in rarest occasions that the leaders of these united states opt not to employ same where tensions prevail, but rather and habitually opt for militarism, deception, and make-believe Hollywood style solutions to engage with perceived enemies. And after 239 years, there is little evidence that such solutions will not continue to be employed. I am reminded of the song as sung by Peter Paul and Mary: "When Will We Ever Learn?" Your essays "are a light unto my path."

 

Albert Foster, Dearborn, Michigan:

I don't think of AmericanExceptionalism in the political or moral sense, and if I did I would not cite American attitude towards native people, slaves, or women from past centuries without any context. Early America may have been exceptional in its time period, especially by declaring all men equal, and by no means is worse than Islam today in countries controlled by Islam. I think of American Exceptionalism as in the area of invention and production of world leading technology. Less than two miles from where I live is the very Laboratory in which Thomas Edison invented the electric light bulb in 1879 and countless other inventions. The light bulb led to power companies and power distribution networks. Electric distribution led to electric motors that replaced human labor in countless backbreaking tasks. The mass production of the gasoline powered automobile soon followed. The Model T spread all over the world and allowed ordinary men to travel more than 20 miles from their place of birth in one day. The birthplace of the model T still stands in Detroit, Michigan on Piquette Avenue.Vast railroads were built to tie our country together. Telegraph and telephone followed. Television was invented here in the 1930s. The first transistor was invented in the Bell Labs, in 1947. This eventually led to the integrated circuit and then the personal computer that you use. Portable telephones started to show up in the 1980 and led to cell phones and to today's I-phones. We were the world leaders in these inventions and we changed to entire world. We live in an exceptional country. And, boy, are we lucky to have been born here or just to live here. I hope some political idiot doesn't destroy it.

 

Eunice Rose, Southfield, Michigan:

It is sad indeed that our July 4 celebration is marred by what our country has done for these 239 years since we began as a nation.

 

Clarke Levan, Brooklyn, New York:

I've recently read your book Long Live Salvation By Works: A Humanist Manifesto and now read your essays. This country needs minds like yours at work. Thank you for your thoughtfulness.

 

Robert Causley, Roseville, Michigan:

Re: the massive amounts of money to be made by the famous military industrial complex. It is just that, a very complex arrangement of civil servants, military, elected officials and public entities. The whole operation is hidden from open view by laws protecting operations of the military for security reasons. Like you, Jon Stewart has been trying to wake up the populace to the errors of our elected official and unfortunately he is now planning to leave. I truly hope for your continued good health as the "ringing of the bell" is needed with your lectures and essays.

 

Tracey Martin, Southfield, Michigan:

If exceptionalism means extraordinary, we were indeed unique among the nations when we declared in 1776 that "the common sense of the matter" meant that humans had no inherent need for kings or other rulers claiming divine authority. And that a people abused by that power had a right, if not an obligation, to sever those ties and pursue their independent interests. We became even more singular when we created in 1787 a governing document accorded legitimacy by "we the people" and initiating political authority founded on constitutional concepts independent of divinity. In that latter half of the 18th century, the United States were (to later become was) truly "one of a kind." By the time of Tocqueville and "manifest destiny," we had become not exceptional but merely another nation aggressively pursuing its self-perceived national interests (independent of compassion, or of concern for the rights of anyone daring to impede our self-directed progress). Spain, Vietnam, Iraq were wars of aggression. And today we proclaim our trust to be more with god than in ourselves. That's uniquely unexceptional. And our present nationalistic "exceptionalism" is more an expression of conceit than of merit. (Yes! The past two weeks have been cause for celebration. If exceptionalism is "alive and well in U S of A," it can be found in our ability to repudiate serial bigotry in favor of liberty, and a century and a half after Negro slavery to elect a black president to be "the most powerful man in the world." Amazing, with or not accompanied by grace. Thanks for another insightful analysis.

 

Fred Fenton, Concord, California:

American Exceptionalism has always seemed to me the boast of unthinking, uncaring people who ignore the many "trails of tears" in our nation's history. How many Americans gave thought to the misery we impose on women and children by our immigrant detention programs, rightly called "immoral" by the editors of The New York Times, as we waved the flag and celebrated the 4th of July? The Unitarian Universalist slogan "Love Finds A Way" applies to your celebration of the union of two gay men all those years ago. In the Santa Monica parish, long before gay marriage was legal in California or the Episcopal Church, I married two young men, wearing tuxedos and cowboy boots, with full ceremony and celebration. They were "given away" by a woman priest who was Episcopal chaplain at USC. 

What do you think?
I'd like to hear from you. E-mail your comments to me at revharrytcook@aol.com.