After more than a year of travelling the United States and educating thousands on the Transfer of Public Lands legislation, we never cease to be amazed at how many people just assume that the states have no right to their lands. Likely, you have run across the same arguments. Today, we'd like to share with you how you can open people's minds to the facts in under 2 minutes.
All you need to do is show them a copy of the Federal Fault Line map, and ask the question, "Why?" Ask them, "Why the difference?" The answers don't vary much. The most common answer people generally give with embarrassment is, "I don't know. I've never really thought about it." Well, people...it's time get everyone to THINK about it.
If they have thought about it, the answers they give usually fit into one of two categories. Either:
1) Your lands are so arid/rugged...OR
2) You gave up your lands.
Let's take a look at these arguments one at a time.
- "You gave up your lands."
This myth is refuted by the fact that states east of Colorado have the same unique "forever disclaim all right and title to the unappropriated public lands" language in their enabling acts and yet they banded together and compelled Congress to transfer their public lands that it had delayed in disposing of for many decades. This myth is also dispelled by the fact that in 1932 Congress relented to the persistent demand of the public land States and convened hearings for the purpose of "Granting Remaining Unreserved Public Lands to States." However, the bills most in consideration only proposed to transfer the surface rights to the States and not the minerals. The States flatly rejected this inequitable proposal that would violate the duty of Congress to dispose of all rights within the boundaries of each state not expressly reserved at statehood. As a result of the stalemate, Congress passed the Taylor Grazing Act in 1934 merely as a stopgap measure. As expressed in the very first line of the Act, it was passed "In order to promote the highest use of the public lands pending its final disposal." In 2009, the U.S. Supreme Court unanimously declared that Congress does not have the authority by a subsequent, unilateral policy to alter or diminish "the uniquely sovereign character of [a state's] admission" particularly where "virtually all of a State's public lands are at stake." (For a summary of the constitutionality of the TPLA, read here.)
There you have it: In two minutes, you can help people question the false assertions they've heard over and over again, and help them be open to the truth. And the truth is that these public lands were supposed to be disposed of a long time ago. The Transfer of Public Lands is The Only Solution Big Enough to deal with the overwhelming challenges faced by our states today.
I urge you to take every opportunity this week to educate the people around you by simply showing them the Federal Fault Line map and asking the question, "Why?" God bless you in your efforts.
(For more detailed information on this topic, and a copy of the information we prepared for Western Governor's Association last week, click here.)
Sincerely,
Ken Ivory
ALC President
P.S. Click here to discover how you can stand with the American Lands Council, and help this work move forward.
|