Pristine Newsletter - 13 December 2013  

QUICK LINKS
Die Walküre
Newsletter Archive
CLASSIC REVIEW
MusicWeb International

A Very Pristine Christmas  
   
Save 50%
on all CDs & downloads of this album until
20 December
 

A Collection of Historic Seasonal Recordings remastered by Five Pristine Audio contributors


Recorded between 1926 and 1957
Restoration and remastering by John Duffy, Peter Harrison, Ward Marston, Mark Obert-Thorn and Andrew Rose     

Classic review:
MusicWeb, 2010
by Jonathan Woolf  

A phalanx of re-mastering's finest has been engaged to produce this festive feast from Pristine Audio. It contains an oddball selection of cuts interspersed by some serious minded ones, tracks that are hard to come by, or are just appropriate. That said it wears its programming quite lightly, leavening things throughout with the sound of Grace Castagnetta's Siena Pianoforte and its seasonal interludes.
 
It's appropriate to start there. Since the instrument is something of a rarity, let me briefly quote Pristine's on-line notes: 'The Siena Pianoforte has an intriguing history, though reading references one finds some are sceptical about the later segments! This highly ornate keyboard instrument was built in 1800 as a wedding present for a Siena farmer and his wife. After being sent to the Paris Exhibition of 1867, it was given to Crown Prince Umberto the following year again as a wedding present. It surfaced in the North African desert during the Second World War and was taken to Palestine, where it again vanished and resurfaced. Several LPs were issued in the mid-1950s, including one made by Charles Rosen, and the one used here made by Grace Castagnetta in which she plays a selection of Christmas carols and tunes, used here as interludes to the whole programme. The instrument produces an interesting sound, and may well steer some listeners to the other discs.' I should add that in addition to the Rosen LP others were made by Anatole Kitain, no less, as well as Marisa Regules and Kathryn Deguire.
 
Its sound is a cross between a fortepiano, Landowska's Pleyel harpsichord, Diana Poulton's thwacking lute - as thunderously recorded on those early electric John Goss recordings for HMV - and a soup�on of Sidonie Goossens's harp. The recordings are often rollickingly done, as befits the behemoth of an instrument; sonorous is the word I'm looking for, though subtle isn't.
 
There are some interesting things to acquire. Percy Pitt dishes out Coleridge-Taylor's Christmas Overture on an early electric. This festive tapestry may have influenced such things to come as Quilter's Children's Overture for example. One oddball offering, and not a very seasonal one really, is Milhaud's Quatre Visages, adroitly characterised by violist Michael Mann and pianist Dika Newlin on a 1957 DGG. Milhaud's charm is evident, and these national character sketches are whimsically done. The Californian lady is suitably laid back, the one from Wisconsin is a busy-bee; the lady from Brussels is phlegmatic, possibly even frumpish, whilst the Parisienne is something of a goer.
 
The Goldsbrough Orchestra's Gabrieli - recorded in 1950, with Deller in the ranks - has a hefty grandeur. Combustible Albert Coates is on hand with a less well known item from his discography - the overture to Hansel and Gretel, a recording made in 1926. The Weelkes Gloria in excelsis is sung by the Westminster Abbey Special Choir in another early electric and a valuable reclamation. There are also two performances by the august Flonzaley Quartet from 1928, beautifully done with their usual ineffable lightness.
 
Most of the numbers have been transferred using 'Ambient Stereo'. It imparts warmth at least. So, a very different offering indeed. You'll be amused by the Siena Pianoforte (I think), take succour from the vocal pieces, and enjoy the Flonzaley. For next year this writer suggests a backbone employing the Flonzaley methodology; the US Decca sides of Christmas tunes recorded by the London String Quartet in arrangements, some of which were by Anthony Collins. Gorgeous playing - and never reissued. 

NEW REVIEW
 
New reviews
December 2013,
by R.E.B.   
   


TCHAIKOVSKY: Symphony No. 4 in F minor, Op. 36. Symphony No. 5 in E mnor, Op. 64. Symphony No. 6 in B minor, Op. 74 "Path�tique"

Leningrad Philharmonic Orch/Yevgeny Mravinsky, cond.  

We are indebted to Pristine Audio for these terrific reissues of legendary historic performances, all heard in the label's remarkable XR remastering. Yevgeny Mravinsky's famous recordings of Tchaikovsky's last three symphonies were made when the conductor and orchestra were in London, Symphony No. 4 September 13/14, 1960 in London's Wembley Hall , the other two November 7-10 the same year but in Vienna's Musikverein. DGG's engineering was not ideal, but thanks to Andrew Rose's XR remastering we now hear these magnificent performances in rich, well-balanced, wide-range sound. Forget the many previous reissues-these are the ones to have. These are among the best sounding recordings by the famed Russian orchestra and conductor.





VERDI: La traviata
 
Licia Albanese (Violetta). Jan Peerce (Alfredo). Robert Merrill (Germont). Maxine Stelman (Flora).

NBC Symphony Orchestra and Chorus/Arturo Toscanini, cond.
 

Verdi's La traviata is from two NBC broadcasts in December 1948. This performance also is remarkable, he first of the Maestro's live opera broadcasts. Toscanini does not dawdle-this is an impulsive, but sensitive, reading. Licia Albanese had a long respected career, and it must have been challenging to be featured under the Maestro's demands (it is rumored that Rosa Ponselle never appeared with him as she didn't want the pressure-how unfortunate she isn't in this broadcast!). Albanese is respectable, although the coloratura of the first act is a bit beyond her. Jan Peerce is a dependable Alfredo, and a very young Robert Merrill makes beautiful sounds as Germont. Chorus and orchestra are on their toes, and this is a fascinating performance essential for all Verdians. The XR remastering produces highly respectable results considering what Andrew Rose had to work with.





LEONCAVALLO: Pagliacci
 
Maria Callas (Nedda). Guiseppe de Stefano (Canio). Tito Gobbi (Tonio). Nicola Monti (Silvio). Rolando Panerai (Silvio).

Chorus and Orchestra of La Scala/Tullio Serafin, cond.
 

Another historic recording is this Pagliacci, recorded by EMI in June 1954 in La Scala. This was one of the earliest collaborations of Maria Callas and Tito Gobbi, and we also have the impassioned sound of a very young Giuseppe di Stefano. Pristine Audio's remastering provides a welcome warmth and ambience. No libretto, not a problem for collectors, and 24 tracks are provided.



PS EXCLUSIVES
Exclusives

New This Week:

Barber conducts Barber

Barber
Symphony No. 2  

New Symphony Orchestra

Recorded 63 years ago today:
13 December 1950

Transfer by Dr John Duffy




CONTENTS
This Week        Our 100th Vocal release
Free Bird          Download Charlie Parker's White Xmas
Furtw�ngler     The 1954 Walk�re - his last recording 
PSXclusive       Barber conducts Barber 63 years ago today

Wilhelm Furtw�ngler's Ring - started, never finished

Die Walk�re was his last studio recording - our 100th vocal issue 



This week's new release
Conducting Wagner at Bayreuth

This week we reach the second of this year's numerical milestones for Pristine with our 100th vocal music release. It's taken us literally a decade to get this far: our first vocal release was a recording made by Clemens Krauss with the same orchestra, the Vienna Philharmonic, in 1950 - this transfer was given to me on a couple of CDs by way of introduction on the day I met Peter Harrison for the first time at the end of 2003, a couple of months before I moved from England to France in early 2004. A year later it was to become our first vocal release at Pristine Classical - Die Fledermaus.

Today of course it's Wagner, not Strauss, but we're back in the Vienna Musikvereinssaal - and we're back with another conductor whose early and unexpected death robbed us of who knows what untold gems. (Krauss was also, of course, the other provider of a Ring cycle here on Pristine, with his 1953 Bayrueth recording).

When I realised we were heading towards this 100th issue I realised it would be worth pulling the stops out and putting together something both special and fitting, something that would be both popular (I hope!), would reflect our recent output (Furtwangler's 1950 Ring), and would also be of wider significance. At the end of this 200th birthday year, it had to be Wagner. I'd also received a request for this specific recording by e-mail - the writer making it perfectly clear that he was deeply dissatisfied with EMI's CD release.

So the 1954 Die Walk�re it was. I assembled my materials and got to work. I'm never quite sure in advance what XR remastering (which has a new logo today, too!) is about to achieve when I start working on a recording. Sometimes it seems to lift a veil from the sound, sometimes it opens a rather nasty can of worms.

Here it was more like lifting a heavy blanket from the recording to reveal something rather wonderful hidden underneath - with all the clarity, warmth and depth you'd hope to find in a later recording, and remarkably few flaws beyond tape hiss to contend with. (By comparison, I'm working on a 1948 Soviet opera recording right now for next month which is perhaps a perfect example of how not to do it!)

Earlier in the week I posted a couple of excerpts from this recording on our Facebook page, via rather static videos on our new YouTube channel, to enthusiastic responses. It really is a great-sounding recording now, and one can only wonder "what if"? Recording was completed on 8th October 1954. Furtw�ngler died on 30th November that same year (coincidentally, 14 years to the day before I was born). Furtw�ngler had elected to begin his studio Ring with the second of the four operas - we can only guess how the whole might have turned out. It would have been the first full Ring on record; instead that accolade went to Solti.

Writing in 1989, the great critic Alan Blyth had no doubt that Furtw�ngler would have been the ideal man for the task, as evidenced by his studio Walk�re:

"It is one of the sadnesses of recorded history that Furtw�ngler died before he was able to complete his studio recording of the Ring begun so auspiciously with this set of Die Walk�re in 1954. At that time Furtw�ngler's interpretation of the cycle, matured over more than a quarter of a century's experience of the work, was acknowledged to be the most profound of its day. We are lucky enough to have his 1953 recording of the whole cycle emanating from Rome Radio but, valuable as those performances are, the orchestral playing and sound quality leave something to be desired. As we can hear in this performance, the conductor's gifts as a Wagnerian were very special. He managed to combine a natural spontaneity of expression with a profound, metaphysical knowledge of the music's and text's inner meaning. Within a broad freedom over tempi and dynamics, Furtw�ngler held a secure grip on the long paragraphs of Wagner's writing. That command was based above all on the firm, rich, intense sound he encouraged from his cellos and double basses. No detail was overlooked in his readings yet it was his skill to correlate these details with his total view of the work in hand. A master of transition, he was able to encompass the sweep of a whole act. Nobody before or since has quite managed to convey the tragic force of Wagner's writing - listen to the close of Wotan's Narration - with such unerring conviction and inevitability. The sheer incandescence allied to truthfulness of his approach brooks no denial."

Take a listen to it now - it really is quite remarkable, in every respect.



A fortuitous anniversary for Pristine Streaming Exclusives

I was preparing Dr. John Duffy's transfer of Samuel Barber conducting his Second Symphony for Decca yesterday when I stumbled across the recording date in my Decca discography and realised it was exactly 63 years ago to the day - 13 December 1950 - that Barber made the recording. I hope subscribers to Pristine Streaming will seek it out and enjoy it to the full!

We've added a new annual-subscription model to Pristine Streaming, which essentially means you get two months free when you sign up for a year. See here for more details.


A Christmas Gift For You!

Charlie Parker



Last Sunday morning I was listening to the radio whilst shaving when a jazz-tinged Christmas song came on. To be honest it sounded pretty awful - the sound quality, not the performance - but as I wiped my face clean a tiny niggling idea was worming its way into my mind.

I remembered a rather poor Miles Davis compilation LP this was very loosely sold as a Christmas issue and wondered what was on it and when it was recorded. Admittedly I hadn't seen it in my collection for a good few years, and after a search, gave up on finding it. So I turned instead to my Charlie Parker collection, figuring that the sound quality I'd heard on the radio indicated something more of his vintage than Davis's.

After much digging - in which nothing even vaguely seasonal was found - I came across three tunes released by Savoy from a live broadcast on Christmas Day 1948 from The Royal Roost. Now I'm guessing when the announcer, "Symphony Sid" Torin, refers to it being Christmas morning, that this is actually the small hours following on from the evening of Christmas Eve, and we're playing deep into the night.

Anyway, what's special here is a unique (as far as I can tell) rendition of White Christmas by Parker, with Kenny Dorham (who'd just replaced Miles Davis) on trumpet, and Parker regulars Al Haig (piano), Tommy Potter (bass) and Max Roach (drums).

The sound quality on the Savoy issue is pretty abysmal, but again XR remastering has made a massive difference. It's not going to find the unrecorded frequencies above 8kHz, and just trying to bring up those upper buried harmonics that are there was very tricky indeed, but it was worth the effort.

I worked on the three recordings Savoy released from this broadcast - Half Nelson, White Christmas, and a Davis number, Little Willie Leaps. I've put them together for you as a 16-bit Ambient Stereo FLAC download, available only from this newsletter:

If you're still not sure what to do with a FLAC here's the perfect time to learn. First unzip the download into three FLAC files. Then either play directly (forget iTunes for this - Apple still won't support the Internet's most popular lossless format) using something free like Songbird or XBMC, or burn to CD using one of the excellent commercial packages from the likes of Nero or Roxio.

Either way, enjoy the music - and seasons greetings to you from all at Pristine.

We'll have one more release for you this year - next Friday, 20th December - thereafter I'll leave you to enjoy Christmas (if you're celebrating it) and we'll be back in 2014.


Andrew Rose
13 December 2013    
 

Furtw�ngler's final studio recording in a brilliant XR remastering transformation
 
From the Ring that never was - Furtw�ngler shows his could have been the best: this Walk�re is one breath-taking ride     

  

Furtw�ngler
WAGNER Die Walk�re   
          
Siegmund - Ludwig Suthaus
Sieglinde - Leonie Rysanek
Wotan - Ferdinand Frantz
Br�nnhilde - Martha M�dl
Hunding - Gottlob Frick
Fricka - Margarete Klose
Gerhilde - Gerda Scheyrer
Ortlinde - Judith Hellwig
Waltraute - Dagmar Schmedes
Schwertleite - Ruth Siewert
Helmwige - Erika K�th
Siegrune - Hertha T�pper
Grimgerde - Johanna Blatter
Ro�wei�e - Dagmar Hermann


Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra 
conductor Wilhelm Furtw�ngler

Studio Recording � 1954       

                                                         

Producer and Audio Restoration Engineer:

Andrew Rose   

  

Website page: paco100     

  

  

Producer's note


It should have been the world's first full Ring on LP - Furtw�ngler's Die Walk�re the first of the four operas to be recorded by EMI, in mono (would they have remade it for stereo?) in the autumn of 1954. Two months later the conductor was dead, his most ambitious recording plan barely begun. EMI duly released the LPs, to the response reprinted here, and music-lovers were left to guess what might have been, their what-ifs only further amplified by the two live Furtw�ngler Rings that have trickled out since.

This XR remastering shines a whole new light onto the Furtw�ngler Walk�re, stripping away the years and embuing it with a sense of life and depth that makes the original 1954 sound seem flat and dull - it really is one of the most remarkable transformations I've heard using these remastering techniques.

This Walk�re offers moments as dark and as thrilling as you're ever likely to hear in a recording: from the moment the rosin starts flying off the double-basses in the opening Prelude to the blaring, then glowing brass in the music's dying moments, this Walk�re is one breath-taking ride.

Andrew Rose  


MP3 Sample
Act 3, 15-minute excerpt: Download and listen  


YouTube Sample
Ride of the Valkyries:

The Ride of the Valkyries - from Furtw�ngler's last studio recording, 1954
The Ride of the Valkyries - from Furtw�ngler's last studio recording, 1954

  

Historic Review 

The playing and recording of the storm music before the curtain rises on Act 1 of Die Walk�re convinces us that whatever else may happen we are assured of a vital and splendid rendering of the orchestral part of the score, and so it turns out. Furtw�ngler, the Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra (and the engineers) are the bright particular stars of this performance.

 

To take the singers in the order of appearance, Ludwig Suthaus begins unimaginatively and conveys little sense of exhaustion (the stage direction supposes him to be "utterly exhausted ") in his opening words, but it is not long before he grows into his part and becomes as inspired by Furtw�ngler's direction as he was in the recording of Tristan. His enunciation is crisp, he phrases well and sings expressively, and he is in every way to be preferred to Set Svanholm in this part.

 

Leonie Rysanek had a great success at Covent Garden as Sieglinde and, on the whole, repeats it in this recording, except for a tendency to let the tone spread at the top of her voice when she puts pressure on it and to waver in soft passages. Gottlob Frick is a very good Hunding.

 

The great duet in Act 1, preceded by Suthaus's eloquent delivery of the Spring Song, is full of rapture, the singers being borne along on the full tide of the glorious orchestral playing. After the prelude to Act a we hear at once that Ferdinand Frantz is a commanding and authoritative Wotan, with a fine ring to the top of his voice, and so he remains throughout. Then Martha M�dl utters her war cry and confronts the critic, anxious to do her justice, with a difficulty. There is a sense of strain in this war cry that a Br�nnhilde, a goddess, should not show, and she leaves us in doubt as to what kind of tone she may produce at any moment above the stave: throaty, constricted, with breathless phrasing, or ringing out freely. Her vocal acting is excellent, but her vocal uncertainty is a handicap. She does not command the rocklike steady tones of Flagstad or even the well-placed ones of Marta Fuchs in the old 78 r.p.m. recording of Act 3.

 

Margarete Klose sang Fricka in that set and though time may have robbed her voice of some of its bloom, she is still magnificent in the part and able to rise to the full height of the great outburst at the end of her scene with Wotan.

 

The scene between Wotan and Br�nnhilde which follows enables Furtw�ngler to show us Wagner's wonderful power of steadily building up, over a long stretch of music, to a great climax, and the conductor handles the scene superbly. (The bass clarinet, at the start of it, is not perfectly in tune.) Suthaus and Rysanek do well in the next scene, the latter acting her hysterical fit convincingly: and then, preceded by some lovely orchestral playing, we come to the solemn moment of Br�nnhilde's warning to Siegmund. M�dl just does not have sufficient weight of voice here and her tone becomes painfully constricted at the great cry of "Sieglinde shall live then, and Siegmund ", which is the climax of the scene. The dramatic end of the act is finely done.

 

The whole of Act 3, up to Br�nnhilde's fateful interview with her father, is most exciting and I shall not complain that the voices of the Valkyries (a well-rehearsed ensemble) are sometimes overwhelmed by the "surge and thunder" of the orchestra, for it is a relief to have their coy laughter at the goings-on of their horses reduced to a fairly faint obbligato.

 

Furtw�ngler's direction of this scene conjures up a vivid picture of the wild, rocky place with the storm clouds drifting over it and the wrathful Wotan ever drawing nearer to his disobedient child. M�dl is not able to thrill us in Br�nnhilde's prophecy of the birth of Siegfried and Rysanek spoils the exultation of Sieglinde's reply by forcing her tone. There is a wonderful moment when the brass blazes out through the confused cries of the dismayed Valkyries and the whole section is extremely wel! recorded in point of tone and balance. M�dl is moving throughout her defence, but when sentence is passed and she begs that she may be surrounded with fire her tone again becomes thin and constricted.

 

Frantz rises to his full stature in Wotan's farewell, which he sings as superbly as the orchestra plays it, so that the final impression is of a nobly and grandly conceived performance of the great work, with a splendid Wotan, an excellent Siegmund and Hunding, a very good group of Valkyries, and a Sieglinde and Br�nnhilde whose intentions are always admirable and often realised, but sometimes are flawed in execution.

 

I should like to have had time and space to point out the many felicities in the orchestral playing, but must content myself with saying that it is in every department of the finest quality and as finely (and spaciously) recorded, so that the loveliest of The Ring operas shines and glows with light and warmth under Furtwangler's inspired direction.

 
Review by A.R., The Gramophone, September 1955 
 

Go Digital
Join Our Mailing List