Spectrogram
Pristine Newsletter - 24 May 2013  
QUICK LINKS
STRAVINSKY The Rite of Spring, The Firebird
PADA Exclusives
HALF PRICE FLACs
 

All FLACs of this release 50% off for one week only 

 

MONTEUX

Early Recordings    


 Stravinsky
Ravel
Coppola
Chabrier

Paris, 1929-30 
 
CLASSIC REVIEW

This CD contains some very important audio documents. It was Pierre Monteux who conducted the notoriously disrupted first performance of Le Sacre du Printemps in Paris on 29 May 1913. A few months short of sixteen years later he made this recording of the work in the same city. I'm not sure if this was the first recording of the work for I believe that the composer himself made a recording in that same year and I don't know which one was set down first. However, what is important about this recording is that perhaps, with the work's first interpreter on the podium, it allows us to get as close as we're ever likely to get to experiencing what the première of Le Sacre may have sounded like - without the first night audience commotion. Indeed, it's perfectly possible that some of the players involved in this recording may have taken part in that infamous première.
 
Nowadays, when youth orchestras will give a performance of Le Sacre with panache and even insouciance and when the work has become a calling card for most professional orchestras it almost sounds too easy. Not here. In this imperfectly played and imperfectly recorded account we get more than a sense of the demands that this score, which must have seemed outlandish at the time, made on its early players. There's one other thing to throw into the equation. The Orchestre Symphonique de Paris had been formed as recently as 1928 and, in his biography of the conductor, Pierre Monteux, Maître (2003), John Canarina says that Monteux became the orchestra's principal conductor in the spring of 1929 - so possibly just after this recording was made. Incidentally, Canarina - himself a conductor who directed some Havergal Brian symphonies for the BBC in the 1970s - states that the Salle Pleyel, the intended venue for the orchestra's concerts, had been damaged by a fire and as a result the orchestra was unable to perform in it until December 1929. So I wonder if the recording of Le Sacre was indeed made there, as stated by Pristine. Until December 1929, Canarina says, the orchestra gave its concerts in the Théâtre des Champs-Élysées. It's possible, therefore, that this recording of the work was made in the very building where it had first been heard in public. If so, that would be a very neat symmetry.
 
Monteux leads a vital, energetic performance. There is no doubt that the orchestra, which had not then been honed into a fully proficient ensemble, is frequently taxed by the music. There are several instances where the players are audibly hanging on for dear life: 'Danse de la terre' (track 7) and 'Glorification de l'Élue' (track 10) are among the most obvious examples and the concluding 'Danse sacrale' is very scrappy at times. However there's a raw energy to the performance and the primitive feel that's imparted by hearing the music played by a fallible band, reproduced in early sound, lends its own fascination and excitement.
 
Unsurprisingly, given that the recording was made eighty-one years ago, the engineers were as challenged by the score as were the players. The strings are too forwardly balanced, as in 'Cercles mystérieux des adolescentes' (track 9). On the other hand, the horns sound as if they were in the room next door at the start of 'Jeux des cités rivals' (track 5) and, in general, both this section of the orchestra and the crucial percussion section are far too distantly balanced. There's also significant hiss at times, especially at the very start. But, those sonic imperfections notwithstanding, it's quite remarkable what the engineers of the day were able to pick up - one wonders if they'd ever had to contend with such a large orchestra - and it's just as remarkable how much detail Mark Obert-Thorn has been able to salvage, not least when one reads in his notes how variable were the source discs available to him.

A year later and Monteux had audibly improved the standards of the orchestra and the engineers were better able to record them. The recordings of the two Ravel pieces are particularly successful. The excerpt from Ma mère l'oye, which is certainly lightly and transparently scored by comparison with Le Sacre is much more accurately reported by the recording and Monteux obtains more cultivated playing. La valse offers the best performance of all on the disc. Monteux is vital and energetic in his direction and the orchestra plays very well for him - listen to the way the strings swoon in the passage beginning at 1:43. Again, it's important to remember that these Ravel pieces were pretty new music at the time these recordings were made. Indeed, I wonder if either or both were the very first recordings of these pieces.
 
The Chabrier piece is the sort of music that was meat and drink to Monteux and he doesn't disappoint here with a reading that's full of verve. The Interlude dramatique by Piero Coppola, best remembered as a conductor, was new to me. I doubt I'll be returning to what struck me as a pretty empty piece that's somewhat long on rhetoric but short on real musical substance.
 
Clearly this is a disc that's going to be of interest mainly to specialist collectors. Despite the sonic limitations all admirers of Le Maître and anyone interested in Le Sacre and its performing history will want to hear it. According to the discography in John Canarina's biography all these recordings have been available before. All five pieces were issued on Dante Lys-2374 and Pearl let us have the Stravinsky, Coppola and Chabrier items. However, the convenience of having all five of these recordings together will be attractive to many listeners and though I haven't heard the other transfers I doubt anyone will have surpassed Mark Obert-Thorn's skill in effecting these present transfers. 

    

John Quinn
MusicWeb International August 2010


ALL FLAC DOWNLOADS OF THIS RELEASE ARE HALF PRICE FOR ONE WEEK: 

 

PASC 219

 


NB. Offer does not apply to CDs or MP3 downloads  
LATEST REVIEW
 Fanfare

May/June 2013
 

Sargent Classics 

by Dave Saemann
 

  

"Hearing the standard repertoire played this well is something no one should take for granted. "

 

 Malcolm Sargent rarely recorded the core German symphonic repertoire. That he did so beautifully should not be surprising, given his excellent accompaniments to Artur Schnabel in Beethoven's piano concertos. I would not say that the renditions on this CD are great interpretations, but they are great performances nevertheless. Their greatness resides in the gorgeousness of the orchestral playing, as accomplished an account of these two symphonies as I've ever heard. I don't mean gorgeous in the Karajan/Berlin Philharmonic sense of the word, with a dark hued wash of enveloping sound. Rather, I mean beauty in the nuts and bolts of orchestral playing. Sargent's attention to detail in note values, attacks, intonation, balance, and dynamics is just breathtaking. Raymond Leppard, whom Sargent befriended early in Leppard's career, wrote that he didn't think Sargent looked too deeply into his scores, but "you couldn't miss with that stick." Indeed, Sargent was one of the most gifted conductors of his generation. He also was a rigorous rehearser, an aspect of his art that is brought out by the superbly prepared performances on this CD. George Martin of Beatles fame produced a number of Sargent's recordings, and it would be interesting to know if he was the producer for these sessions. Regardless, this CD shows that there was much more to Sargent than his nickname of "Flash Harry" would suggest.

The first movement of the "Eroica" goes at a moderate clip, without the exposition repeat. The blend of the strings can give you goose bumps. The brass never overwhelm them, while the wind choirs play with subtlety. Sargent's funeral march is slow but not heavy handed. He always provides the sense of forward motion, never allowing the phrasing to drag. His scherzo is quick and angular, with particular care for accents. The horn playing in the trio is especially elegant. Sargent takes the last movement at a moderate tempo, always phrasing with a delicate touch. His coda is exuberant, the timpanist adding just the right amount of propulsion. This is an "Eroica" whose details you never will tire of.

Sargent paces the first movement of the "Unfinished" at a relatively quick tempo, and includes the exposition repeat. He gets a dark sound from the strings, and a wide dynamic range from the entire orchestra. The intonation of the lower strings is breathtaking, while the sound of the brass choir has plenty of depth. The second movement features a measured tempo, yet it moves. A sense of tragedy is paramount, with the quiet moments at times possessing a feeling of desolation. This is a highly distinctive "Unfinished." Andrew Rose's remasterings from LPs in both symphonies are warm and agreeable. The tuttis, however, have a slight fuzziness, and the dynamic range is a little restricted. The "Eroica" was available on a Royal Classics CD I have not heard. If forced to recommend just one recording of each of these symphonies, I would choose Hiroshi Wakasugi and the Saarbrücken Radio Symphony for the "Eroica," and Leonard Bernstein and the New York Philharmonic in the 'Unfinished." Sargent's recordings allow us to revel in the craft of a master conductor. Mstislav Rostropovich compared him to "a lion." Hearing the standard repertoire played this well is something no one should take for granted.  

    

PASC 374 (76:58)  
Join Our Mailing List
CONTENTS
This Week   Guest Editorial by Mark Obert-Thorn
Help!            Jascha Spivakovsky: recordings wanted
Stravinsky   conducts his Rite of Spring, Firebird Suite
PADA            Szigeti and Schnabel play Beethoven

Stravinsky's early orchestral recordings

by Mark Obert-Thorn    



The Rite at 100

Who wrote this fiendish Rite of Spring?

What right had he to write the thing,

Against our helpless ears to fling

Its crash, clash, cling, clang, bing, bang, bing?


(Written by a Boston Symphony Orchestra concert subscriber in 1924 upon hearing Stravinsky's The Rite of Spring)  
 
Igor Stravinsky

There are few dates about which one can say that the course of Western music was irrevocably changed - April 7th, 1805, the première of Beethoven's Eroica Symphony, perhaps, or March 12th, 1859 when the Prelude to Wagner's Tristan was first performed; but certainly May 29th, 1913 has to be among them. For it was on that day, in the Théâtre des Champs-Elysées in Paris, that Stravinsky's Rite of Spring was first presented. In its emphasis on rhythm over harmony and even melody, it set the stage for much of what was to follow for the rest of the 20th Century.

 

In anticipation of the centennial of that first performance next Wednesday, the major record labels have rolled out large box sets. Sony has produced a ten-disc "original jackets" collection with ten historic recordings from the RCA Victor and American Columbia labels. Decca has gone them one better, releasing a twenty-CD set featuring no fewer than 38 performances drawn from the various Universal labels, with a smaller selection available in a four-disc box.

 

Silent in all this, however, has been the recently-sold EMI Classics. The reason is not hard to ascertain. After an impressive early showing, releasing the first two recordings of the work in 1929 for French HMV (conducted by Monteux) and French Columbia (led by Stravinsky), the label let their American affiliates do the heavy lifting for the next two decades, importing recordings by Stokowski, Stravinsky (his New York Philharmonic remake), and Monteux (twice more, in San Francisco and Boston) before commissioning their first new European inscription (Markevitch and the Philhamonia) in 1951. And that was all there was to be from them until the stereo era.

 

As part of the spate of reissues, Sony is separately bringing out a two-disc set with Stravinsky's second and third recordings of The Rite. But what of his first? As far as I have been able to determine, it has not been available on compact disc since a 1988 reissue on the Pearl label. It was not included in Andante's three multi-disc sets of the composer's 78-era recordings a decade ago, nor did EMI feature it in their "Composers in Person" set devoted to Stravinsky's pre-war recordings.

 

 

This week, Pristine returns this historic recording to availability, coupling it with the composer's contemporaneous version of an augmented Firebird Suite, also left out of the earlier EMI and Andante collections. And, as an added bonus, the very first complete recording of the work under Monteux, reissued by Pristine in 2009, is being made available as a half-price FLAC download.

 

The composer's early recording of The Rite may lack the polish of his later ones with better ensembles, and his conducting may be less assured at this point in his career; but the raw energy of his performance, set down in the same hall in which it had premièred 16 years earlier, serves as a potent time machine, transporting us back a century to when this music still had the power to shock, discomfort, and change the world.

 

Mark Obert-Thorn        

 




Virtual Box Sets - Save 10% on the full Ring

As before we're offering "virtual" box sets of the Furtwängler La Scala Ring cycle at a discount of 10% over the individual opera prices. I say virtual as we don't actually have a box to put them in, and the majority we expect to sell will be downloads rather than CDs!

You can find full details of these and order them from any of the four pages dedicated to the Ring operas on our website - and I suggest you start here, on the new Götterdämmerung page.

Getting the 24-bit version online has proved to be much tougher than I expected, thanks to our connection repeatedly dropping off just as we neared the end of the upload. Unfortunately our small village upload speed is around a twentieth of our download speed, and with each attempt taking nearly 24 hours each failure was a major waste of time. Eventually I resolved this by stripping the 24-bit download of the full orchestral scores, which themselves were quite hefty files, and between Wednesday and Thursday afternoon we finally succeeded in transferring the full download to our server and making it available online.

So if you've been waiting for the full-quality 24-bit FLAC download of the entire Ring, at a saving of €18 over the regular price, click here to order it now!



Next Week: Bruno Walter

Eagle-eyed readers will have noticed the lack of Bruno Walter's Bruckner 7 this week! This has been held over and will now be released next Friday.




Jascha Spivakovsky (1896 - 1970)
 - call-out for recordings

Russian-born pianist Jascha Spivakovsky was the older brother of renowned violinist Tossy Spivakovsky. Hailed as a child prodigy at the age of four, he began giving concerts at seven and rapidly rose to world fame for his golden tone, crystal technique and interpretive mastery over a massive repertoire.
[L-R] Tossy Spivakovsky, Jascha Spivakovsky, Edmund Kurtz
Unlike Tossy, Jascha's brilliance at the keyboard wasn't captured in studio recordings; what survives are private recordings held by the family and recordings of the many broadcasts he made around the world. Jascha's son and grandson are busy trying to locate as many recordings as possible that have survived, be they tapes, acetate discs, or other formats, with the intention of making the best of them available to the public. Of particular interest is a wartime broadcast of Beethoven's Emperor Concerto with the BBC Scottish Orchestra which exists in a poor-quality short-wave radio recording, but may well be preserved in better quality in someone's attic.

But there may be much more than this - they simply don't know. If you know of any recordings (or other interesting material), either in your own collection or which may be available to you of Jascha Spivakovsky, please get in touch and I'll pass the details on to his family so they can compare notes, or you can contact Mark Spivakovsky directly (Jascha's grandson) at this e-mail address: edenspivak@hotmail.com

You can read more about Jascha here. I hope in due course we'll be able to offer examples of his fabulous playing at the Pristine Classical website, and there's a book about him due to be published soon. I've heard a small amount of his playing, and it's very special indeed. Who knows, perhaps he might become a household name once again?




 

Andrew Rose
24 May 2013   
Go Digital

Stravinsky's first recordings of his Rite of Spring and Firebird Suite   

Historic 1928/29 recordings finally returned to the catalogue in brilliant new transfers by Mark Obert-Thorn     

 

  

STRAVINSKY
The Rite of Spring
The Firebird Suite 
 
Walther Straram Concerts Orchestra 
Igor Stravinsky     

  

Recorded 1928 & 1929                                       

Producer and Audio Restoration Engineer: 

Mark Obert-Thorn             

    

   

 

Web page: PASC 387   

    

  

Short Notes  

  

"Who wrote this fiendish Rite of Spring?
What right had he to write the thing,
Against our helpless ears to fling
Its crash, clash, cling, clang, bing, bang, bing?"
- Boston Symphony Orchestra concert subscriber, 1924


Exactly 100 years to the week since its notorious, literally riotous première in Paris on 29th May, 1913, Mark Obert-Thorn has returned to the composer's first recording of The Rite of Spring, made in Paris in 1929 and curiously neglected since - quite possibly due to some previously incurable pitch problems which we have now, finally, been able to solve.

It's coupled with his recording a year earlier of the Firebird Suite, in its 1911 incarnation. Both bring to life the composer's true intentions in a whirl of passion, and restore these neglected masterpieces to the catalogue for the first time in a quarter of a century.   

          

  

   

  

Notes On this recording   

  
Igor Stravinsky's career as a recording artist began in 1925 with a series of acoustic piano solo sides for American Brunswick which were never released. His first issued records were made by Columbia in London, a Petrushka Suite recorded in June of 1928. Five months later, Columbia's French affiliate recorded the Firebird Suite presented here, with an uncredited ensemble believed to be the Walther Straram Concerts Orchestra. Stravinsky chose to record the 1911 version with the addition of the Berceuse and Finale from 1919 (although the bridge linking them is missing), as well as interpolating the trombone glissandi from the 1919 version in the Infernal Dance. The present composite version gives a more fully rounded picture of the action of the ballet and the fairy-tale aspects of the plot.

While the Firebird Suite and even the complete Petrushka had already been recorded more than once before Stravinsky made his own versions, The Rite of Spring had a longer gramophonic gestation. The first attempt was in April, 1927, when Leopold Stokowski set down the first three sides of an aborted complete recording with the Philadelphia Orchestra. Extant test pressings suggest the ensemble had not played the piece for awhile, as the execution is uncharacteristically scrappy. Sixteen months later, portions of the work were set down during an August, 1928 rehearsal with Eugene Goossens leading the Hollywood Bowl Orchestra as part of a balance test that eventually saw publication on CD.

Finally, the first two complete recordings of the work were made in Paris in 1929. Pierre Monteux, the conductor of the 1913 première, recorded it for French HMV in January (on Pristine PASC 219), while the composer set down his version for French Columbia that November. In the meantime, Stokowski had begun his issued recording in September, 1929, although it would not be completed until the following March. These three would become the only recordings of the work through the end of the 1930s.

While Stravinsky's ensemble is less precise, and his direction is less assured, than in his 1940 remake with the New York Philharmonic, the recording affords a valuable glimpse of how the composer approached this epoch-making work a mere sixteen years after its première, before familiarity and rising orchestral standards smoothed out the rawness experienced by the outraged opening night audience in Paris a century ago.

The sources for the transfers were first edition American Columbia "Viva-Tonal" pressings. Pitch fluctuations inherent in the original recordings have been corrected in this edition.

Mark Obert-Thorn  

    

    

  

   

  

MP3 Sample  Excerpts from both works    

Listen  

   

  

Download purchase links:

Mono MP3     

Mono 16-bit FLAC   

     

  

CD purchase links and all other information:

PASC 387 - webpage at Pristine Classical  


Szigeti and Schnabel play Beethoven

Artur Schnabel
PADA Exclusives
Streamed MP3s you can also download
     

 

BEETHOVEN
Violin Sonata No. 5 in F, Op. 24 'Spring'      

Joseph Szigeti  violin
Artur Schnabel  piano


Recorded 4 April 1948 in concert at the Frick Museum, New York City


This transfer by Dr. John Duffy
Additional remastering by Andrew Rose

 

 

Joseph Szigeti

 

Over 500 PADA Exclusives recordings are available for high-quality streamed listening and free 224kbps MP3 download to all subscribers. PADA Exclusives are not available on CD and are additional to our main catalogue. 

 

 

Subscribe to PADA Subscriptions start from €1 per week for PADA Exclusives only listening and download access. A full subscription to PADA Premium gets you all this plus unlimited streamed listening access to all Pristine Classical recordings for just €10 per month, with a free 1 week introductory trial.