|
|
THE TTALK QUOTES
On Global Trade & Investment
Published Three (Sometimes Four) Times a Week By
The Global Business Dialogue, Inc.
Washington, DC Tel: 202-463-5074
Email: Comments@gbdinc.org
No. 30 of 2014
|
WEDNESDAY, APRIL 23, 2014
Filed from Portland, Oregon
Click here for Monday's quote from Ronald Reagan
|
|
TPP: THE DEVIL IS IN THE DELTAS
"The U.S. may lose some pork sales unless they reach agreement with Japan on tariffs, given Australia gets an advantage under the bilateral accord."
Tetsushide Mikamo
April 17, 2014 (publication date)
|
CONTEXT
|
Mr. Mikamo is a director at the Marubeni Research Institute in Tokyo. Today's quote is from a Bloomberg story we found today on Agweb.com. The headline is "Japan Adds Pork Tariff Cut to Beef in Trade Pact with Australia."
The story opens with some key facts: Japan is the world's largest buyer of pork and at present the U.S. is the top supplier, capturing about 38 percent of Japan's purchases of imported pork in 2013. We are not sure whether that percentage is by volume - that would be 280.6 tons out of the 738.5 imported - or by value. That would have been $1.4 billion out of $3.8. For our purposes, it really doesn't matter. If the Japan-Australia deal is implemented and there is no TPP, Australian producers will see beneficial changes in the relevant tariff-rate quota that their U.S. competitors will not enjoy, namely a drop in the tariff and an expansion of the quota.
|
COMMENT
|
It is already tomorrow, April 24, in Tokyo, though it is still very early there (4 p.m. in Washington is still just 5 a.m. in Tokyo.) Anything could happen. We confess we are not sure just what is being negotiated - how much is TPP per se and how much is a related U.S.-Japan side agreement. All of that will be clear enough later. For now, we will stick to a couple of obvious points and equally obvious observations.
Point one: Japan clearly had TPP in mind when it decided earlier this month to close the deal with Australia. And since then, Japanese spokesmen, both official and non-official, have been using the potential downsides for the U.S. of the Australian agreement as leverage in the TPP talks.
All of this is a clear and stern reminder that, in a commercial context, it is the differential, the delta, that matters. It is not hard to imagine the exporter who, given a choice between a) no tariff for anyone or b) a tariff that is lower than the one his competitors face, will go for "b" every time. Who wants a level playing field when you can have an advantage?
All of this is fine if it works, if TPP gets done and the playing field of the Japanese market, if not level, is at least no more un-level than it was before all of these deals. But what if the bilateral goes through and TPP doesn't? Might not that add new bitterness to already difficult relationships? It might indeed.
I'll switch to the first person here and confess that I went for a walk not long after reading the story with today's featured quote. Surely, I thought, as I walked down Miller Hill, this will affect more than TPP. It is bound to re-energize Canada's FTA negotiations with Japan. When I got back to my desk I found another Bloomberg story, this one with the headline, "Japan may offer Canada Head Start on Pork Tariffs."
There will be results from this week's TPP negotiations in Tokyo. The question is: Will they be positive for American producers?
|
RELATED EVENT
| At 3 p.m. next Tuesday, April 29, 2014, the Global Business Dialogue will host a debate on TPP generally. The topic is TPP: TOO RISKY TO PASS OR TOO RISKY TO PASS UP? The two sides will presented by Lori Wallach of Public Citizen's Global Trade Watch and Derek Scissors from the American Enterprise Institute. The link will take you to the flyer for this session, which includes registration information and other details.
|
SOURCES & LINKS
| FTA Benefits for Australian Pork Producers takes you to the Bloomberg/Agweb.com story that was the source for today's quote.
Japan's Busy Negotiators is a link to a page on the website of the Japan's Ministry of Foreign Affairs with a list of Japan's free trade agreements. Factually, we assume this list is accurate. In this listing, Japan's FTA with Australia is among those that are still being negotiated. Factually, that is correct. Rhetorically, however, that agreement it is being treated by all concerned as a done deal.
Australia-Japan FTA Announced. This is the TTALK Quote for April 8, which highlighted remarks of Australian Prime Minister Tony Abbott, when he announced this agreement during his recent visit to Tokyo. The same entry includes a comment by Japanese negotiator Hiroshi Oe on the likely effect of the agreement on U.S. beef producers.
A Head Start for Canada is a link to the story on Canada's FTA negotiations with Japan mentioned above.
|
SUBSCRIBE
|
If you want to receive these TTALK Quotes, we're happy to send them to you. That's the deal. If you want to help and ensure that they keep coming, please
SUBSCRIBE NOW
It's just $50 a year. Click here and you' re done.
Thank you.
Note: GBD Members are already subscribers and we thank them for their membership and support.
|
|
|
TO GET THE TTALK DAILY QUOTE IN YOUR INBOX
Or Other GBD Notices, Click below.
|

© 2014 The Global Business Dialogue, Inc.
1140 Connecticut Ave., NW, Suite 950
Washington, DC 20036
Tel: (202) 463-5074
R. K. Morris, Editor
www.gbdinc.org
|
|
|
|
|