5th October 2015

Live Health News  |  Weather  |  Archive
  For Local Authority, Council news and comment subscribe FREE for councilManagers.net HERE

New Health Chat

21st October King's Fund 5.30pm

Former boss of Addenbrooke's Keith McNeil

In conversation with Roy Lilley; gives his side of the story and tells us

what it is like to be a CEO in the NHS, the impossible demands and is the job worth doing.

This will be another sell-out   Tickets... here.

Roll up his sleeves
News and Comment from Roy Lilley
At weekends the Guardian newspaper cross-dresses as the Observer. Saturday evening this article appeared, via Twitter. It accuses Ministers of 'leaning on' the TDA and Monitor to delay publication of the regular financial up-sum of Trust performance. The Gobserver tells us:
"One senior figure at the health service regulator Monitor said his organisation had been "leaned on" by Whitehall to delay its report, which shows that NHS finances are worsening."
Publication of the full situation, whilst the Tories are conferencing in Fortress Manchester, would be tooooo embarrassing:
  • 15 Trusts in special measures
  • 71% of inspected Trusts rated requiring improvement or inadequate
  • 75% of Trusts receiving bungs from the TDA to pay the wages
  • Monitor rating 6% more Trusts in danger of discontinuity of service
  • 33 Trust' COE posts vacant or interim.
  • 2/3rds in debt of some sort.
It is true; biz-plans and returns were submitted a couple of months ago and should have appeared in public by now. Why not?  The chair of the Health Select Committee agrees, they should be published.
My guess; if you add up all the plans and consolidate them into one set of numbers, they won't balance. The bottom line will be bigger than the top line. FTs have had two goes at this year's biz-plans and attempts to set a tariff appear run into the sand. We know the NHS is already 2bn behind the eight-ball.
The merciful departure of David Bennett, former Monitor boss, has made way for professional, portfolio, non-exec, accountant, lawyer and former NED at the Carbuncle, Ed Smith, to emerge as chair. He's been looking for a chief executive.
His choice was leaked by the Gobserver; Northumbria FT Trust boss Jim Mackey; another accountant, appointed to;
"... get (NHS) finances back in order".
I've been to Mackey's Trust. It is spectacularly good but if all Trusts were run as well as Mackey's fiefdom there still wouldn't be enough money in the kitty to run the health service.  We are beyond rearranging the management deck chairs. 
Geography and history have combined to put a patient and popular Mackey into an insulated position that is simply not replicated elsewhere; places where spirit, leadership and finances have been eroded by impatience, demand, time and neglect.
Mackey's well-worked, close relationship with local government (they lent him the money to buy out his PFI and fund other projects) is reflective of a collective desire for the council and health to want to do good things; rather like I reported on at Widnes.
It is rarely replicated and certainly not in the Tory Shires whose aim seems to be cut, trim, slash and close. With no one in the system with the power to make LAs do otherwise and the Better Care Fund evaporating, Mackey faces a challenge. He needs to scour the world for best practice, new ideas and different approaches. He has to show the NHS what doable-good looks like and help them do it.
Has Monitor been 'leaned-on' and is there a highly placed leak?  You could be forgiven for thinking, probably and yes. 
If Monitor is truly independent Smith has to rebut this, fast. At the time of writing he is still silent. If I were Smith, this Monday morning, I would start at one end of the corridor; purge, what looks like a Board, gone feral and keep going until I found the head of communications and show them the door.  Then I'd talk to the press. 
Smith needs a fresh start, a clean slate and to show us who's the boss.
Unless, of course, he has been leaned on? I would rather believe, for now at least, that the delay in publishing the numbers is down to the fact they don't add up. It's now Mackey's job to cajole, brow beat and bung until they do. He needs time.
Mackey must know there is no role for Monitor; packaging it with the TDA, in a 'transformation-gift-wrap' has no legal standing.
Vanguards are the future but they narrow choice and have made innovative, structural changes without market testing. Monitor will have to develop a serious case of competition-cataracts and turn a blind eye. Fine until a disgruntled private provider presses the 'it's not fair' button. Then the whole lot unravels.
In another world Smith & Mackey are authors of very good Social Psychology text books. They don't treat social psychology as intellectual candy; they give us meaty, comprehensive, and nuanced ideas.
It'll be interesting to see if S&K can rewrite the text book for health and social care (over which they have no purview) transformation.
Right now Monitor is about as useful as a sheepdog in a fish farm. Smith has a full-time job on hands and must roll up his sleeves.

Have you looked at the fabulous stuff?
New 'shares' every day.
Make a note; be a sharer this week
  Contact Roy - please use this e-address
Know something I don't - email me in confidence.
Leaving the NHS, changing jobs - you don't have to say goodbye to us! You can update your Email Address from the link you'll find right at the bottom of the page, and we'll keep mailing.
MaM Logo  
Medicine for Managers
Dr Paul Lambden
Bill Gate's quote at the end of this article is very thought provoking...

 The Academy of Fabulous NHS Stuff
  New ideas dawning on you? See some more
Share your good stuff
Latest 'shares'.
School nurses international song; 'up lifting' heart project.
Share your fabulous stuff.
Monthly Winners
Please vote here for the October Awards.
Six clicks to send your favourites into the final.
Keep up to date with all the Vanguardistas
Follow us on Twitter
Please share your good stuff!
News and Stuff
News boy
1st December
King's Fund 5.30pm 
Janet Davies
New boss at the RCN
King's Fund 1st December 5.30 pm.
NEW Health Chat
21st October
King's Fund - 5.30pm
Keith McNeil
Keith McNeil was, until very recently, the Chief Executive of Addenbrooke's hospital in Cambridge, one of the nation's highest profile hospitals and leadership positions.
He resigned in late September in the wake of what was described as a 'critical' CQC report that resulted in the trust being put into special measures.
What is the full story behind what has taken place?
Why is NHS leadership now such an apparently precarious occupation? What role is the money playing in inspection (or is it the other way around)? What lessons can be learnt from what appears to be a terrible mess that affects not just the hospital personnel but the reputation that they have and the impact on the research facilities that they partner with?
This is Keith McNeil's first live conference interview and will be a sell out.
Tickets are selling fast
19th November
King's Fund 5.30pm
Lord Hunt
Labour's Health Leader in the Lords.
Dr Rodney Jones
New analysis
'Is Cytomegalovirus involved in recurring periods of higher than expected death and admissions?
Tell us about your jobs and post them for free.
Why pay to advertise when we will do it for nothing - and it works!
This is what I'm hearing;
if you know different,
tell me here
>>  I'm hearing - there is some real serious anxiety about the state of NHS finances.  'Days away from not being able to pay the bills'.  Really?
Need inspiration, a good idea or solve a problem