nhsManagers.net

9th September 2015 3

Live Health News | Weather | Archive
For Local Authority, Council news and comment subscribe FREE for councilManagers.net HERE

Health Chat

29th October King's Fund 5.30pm

Samantha Jones NHSE Director of New Models of Care and Vanguards.

Last few tickets... here.

Cancer drugs fund

News and Comment from Roy Lilley

It looks to me like the wheels are coming off. I'm talking about the cancer drugs fund. Effectively it has halved the number of treatments it covers because it is overspent.

The present fund was started by the Prime Minister and has been in trouble since the off. There have been rows about what drugs should and should not be included. Big Pharma getting airyated, patients getting upset... horrible.

Then; there's the application process. Groan. As if having a rare cancer isn't worry enough, patients are put through the palaver of getting their consultant to make application to the fund.

The forms are on the NHSE web-site along with a summary of the decisions month by month. A number of cancer charities publish guides on how to apply and present the best case. Clink or what? Patient focussed it is not!

It is an atrociously stressful process. Asking for permission to live another six months. The decision handed down by someone who will never look you in the eye and tell you why they said no.

Set up in 2011 because none of the really expensive drugs could satisfy NICE's value for money requirements and the Government found the criticism from the tabloids unsustainable; originally it was the interim cancer drugs fund.

In 2010, each SHA was funded, from a total of Ł200m pa, to kick it off. By 2014 it was overspent by Ł30m. In 2014 another Ł80m was added; the fund just kept running out of money.

In 2014 the FT attacked the fund as 'populist'. In 2015 York Uni research concluded it was poor value for money. The drugs are often new, eye wateringly expensive and little more than experimental.

Last July the NHSE's independent cancer task force said the fund was no longer sustainable or desirable.

That's all well and good until it's your Mum, your daughter, your husband or you. How can you put a price on an extra six months to see your daughter married, your son graduate, put your affairs in order and say goodbye.

What's to do?

Think what you like about big-pharma; greedy, fat-cats and all the rest. The fact is unless Prime Minister Jeremy Corbyn nationalises them, we are where we are. Most of us have a pension fund, that is probably, in some way, dependent on pharma shares. We have to grow up a bit.

We have to figure out smarter ways to sort this mess out.

We need R&D and new, effective medicines. In the last ten years average bed-stays have halved. Partly because of medical technology and in large measure, better drugs.

There might be a solution. We have to start with the fact that modern drugs take years and years to develop, clinical trials get more difficult as the cohort of patients they can recruit gets smaller and harder to find.

As soon as they discover a new molecule Pharma has to register a patent, in case it shows promise. The clock is then ticking and they have 20 years to bring a safe drug that works, to market.

It can take 14 or 15 years of that patent period to finesse a new drug, meaning the company has 5 years to amortise its R&D and marketing investment that could run to $2.5bn. And don't forget; no profits... no more investment in R&D and no next generations of drugs.

In the meantime, if you happen to be strumming your guitar one day, or tinkling a piano key board and come up with a great song, you can copyright it for 50 years.

Popular song protected for 50 years, lifesaving drug, 20 years. Errr?

If we gave pharma the same protected period as a song, giving them longer to recover their investment, it might mean drugs would come to market at more manageable prices.

I can hear the howls of abuse and argument: yup companies might cheat; they make enough money out of us already and blah, blah. It's not a perfect solution.

However, if the Prime Minister was looking for something to renegotiate in his EU package, a reworking of European patent law, for drugs, might benefit all countries... not just us.

What's the alternative? Tax breaks for competing pharma companies who share R&D> An anonymised repository of undevelopable molecules that someone might, later, be able to take on and make useful?

Or we could set up a cancer drugs fund....

-----------------------------------

Academy of Fabulous Stuff;

Have you looked at the fabulous stuff?

New 'shares' every day.

Make a note; be a sharer this week.

------------------------

Contact Roy - please use this e-address

roy.lilley@nhsmanagers.net

Know something I don't - email me in confidence.

Leaving the NHS, changing jobs - you don't have to say goodbye to us! You can update your Email Address from the link you'll find right at the bottom of the page, and we'll keep mailing.

----------
Disclaimer

Medicine for Managers

Dr Paul Lambden

Headache

There is more to it than you'd thnk...

--------------------

The Vanguards

Have a look at what they are up to on our new

Fabulous Vanguards Page

You can keep up to date with all the Vanguard Developments

and News

Here.

------

Events

Link to our

Fabulous HealthChats

and other up-coming stuff on our

new

Fabulous Events

page

Here

---------

Share your good stuff

here!

Latest 'shares'.

Safe Staffing App, this is a real humdinger... be sure and have a look

Here

Share your fabulous stuff.

---------------

Follow us on Twitter

Web-site here.

Please share your good stuff!

---------------

News and Stuff

-------------------

>> Weekend Deaths - the issue rumbles on; this is a very interesting study concerning the imminence of death among hospital inpatients. This is a very important factor in getting to grips with the weekend factor.

>> Mortality tracking system - this looks to me to be a much better way of trying to get to grips with the weekend palavering about.

>> A Short Guide to the DH - this is very good, great data and graphics. This is one to download and keep.

>> Patients to be sent of France - this is what you get when you get open markets...

>> MPs to debate petition demanding Jeremy Hunt is sacked after over 200k signatures - 14th September Westminster Hall; just keeping the kids occupied. Nothing will come of it.

>> NICE approves immunotherapy drug - for advanced melanoma.

>> Seven day working Nottingham - cost them Ł500k.

-----------------

HealthChat

Sam Jones

In conversation with

Roy Lilley

Chief Vanguardista

Last few tickets today.

King's Fund

29th October.

Couple of tickets remain

Here

---------

PLUS

1st December

King's Fund 5.30pm

Janet Davies

New boss at the RCN

King's Fund 1st December 5.30 pm.

Details here.

----------------------

Sir Robert Naylor

HealthChatting with me on 16th September at the King's Fund 5.30pm.

Extra ticket sales Click Here

----------------------

JOBS

-------------

Looking for something different

Have a look here

-------------

Tell us about your jobs or post them for free.

Give it a try.

-------------

Gossip

This is what I'm hearing;

if you know different,

tell me here

-------------

>> I'm hearing - a lot of complaints from you that the vast Health Innovations Expo conference in Manchester was free to visit and no tax payer money involved and the NICE conference costs the best part of Ł500 a ticket. I don't have an answer but if they'd like to provide me with one I'll publish it!

>> I'm hearing - Norman Lamb is to chair a MH commission.

-------------

Need inspiration, a good idea or solve a problem

Look here.

-------------------

Thank You Wall

Our wall of

Fabulous Thank You's cheer yourself up and have a look; post yours and join in!

--------

>> Transforming urgent care - guide for local health and social care communities; this looks like good stuff to me.

>> Encouraging staff wellbeing - good stuff from the King's Fund.

>> Vaccines centrally procured for a practice - information.