Top
 In This Issue:  
 

Featured Article

 

Newsletter Archive

 

In The Spotlight 

 

Seminars & Events 

 

What our Clients say... 

Quick Links:   

 

 
 
 
 

PCFS Solutions

 
 
 

Contact Us 

 Spotlight

IN THE SPOTLIGHT

  

Ethan W. Smith
Ethan W. Smith, Esq.

Ethan W. Smith is a partner in the law firm of Starfield & Smith, P.C., where his areas of practice focus on government guaranteed lending, commercial lending, banking, real estate and commercial law.  Mr. Smith has closed thousands of government guaranteed loans on behalf of his lender clients, assists lenders nationwide with SBA guaranty purchase issues and has been retained as an expert witness on SBA related litigation matters.  Mr. Smith is a licensed title insurance agent for Chicago Title and Fidelity National Title in both Pennsylvania and New Jersey.  He is a member of the National Association of Government Guaranteed Lenders (NAGGL) and is a frequent speaker and serves as a member of its Associate Member Committee.  Mr. Smith is also an affiliate member of the National Association of Development Companies (NADCO) and is qualified as a designated closing attorney under the SBA 504 Program.  During the years 2005-2011, Mr. Smith was honored by being named a Pennsylvania "Rising Star" by Philadelphia Magazine and is rated by  Martindale Hubbell as an "AV Preeminent" attorney.  He earned his B.A. degree from Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, Maryland and J.D. degree from the College of William and Mary School of Law.   

  

ADMISSIONS:

  

  • Pennsylvania
  • New York
  • Federal District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania

 

To read more about Ethan, click here

  




CONNECT WITH US:

Find us on Facebook!

 

Like us on Facebook

 

Become our fan on Facebook to receive updates, articles and news pertaining to SBA and lending related topics.  

Starfield & Smith, PC is on LinkedIn!

 

View my profile on LinkedIn 

 

Link yourself to Starfield & Smith to receive updates, articles and news pertaining to SBA and lending related topics.  

FeatureArticle 
FEATURED ARTICLE 

Best Practices:  Don't Do That; Do This Instead  

 

By: Amy R. Brownstein, Esquire  

  

Amy R. Brownstein
Amy R. Brownstein, Esquire

The SBA's Regular 7(a) Guaranty Purchase Package Tabs (commonly known as the "10 Tab") identify the documentation that the SBA requires for its review and determination that it will honor its guaranty of a loan. By the time a lender is preparing its 10 Tab, however, it may find that it has taken an action - or failed to take an action - that could jeopardize all or a portion of its guaranty. There are some simple actions that can be taken, or should not be taken, to increase the likelihood that the guaranty will be honored without repair.

 

Don't do that:  Liquidate collateral without properly inventorying and appraising.

Do this instead:  Obtain a listing of all remaining business personal property collateral. Reconcile the list against the list of equipment and fixtures obtained at closing (the SBA 7(a) Loan Authorization Boilerplate requires the lender to obtain such a list at loan origination, with description and serial numbers for items valued at $5000 or more).  Obtain a valuation of the business personal property; this value is needed to support the value obtained from liquidation or the decision to abandon the collateral, in accordance with the provisions of SOP 50 57.  The equipment list, reconciliation and appraisal are required by Tabs 8 and 9 of the Guaranty Purchase Package.

 

Don't do that: Conduct lengthy work-out or modification discussions with the borrower without performing a site visit.

Do this instead:  As the lender works with the borrower to try to keep a loan in (or return a loan to) performing status, the lender should be mindful that a payment default occurs on the date when the next payment is due and is not made, and should also consider whether a non-payment default has occurred.  SOP 50 57 requires the lender to perform a site visit within 60 days of an uncured payment default, within 15 days of an adverse event that caused the loan to be classified in liquidation status, or sooner, in either case, if the collateral could be removed, lost or dissipated.  Failure to perform a timely site visit, even if the failure occurred because the lender was working with the borrower, shifts to the lender the burden of proving to the SBA that its failure to perform the site visit on a timely basis did not contribute to any loss. If collateral is unavailable for liquidation and the lender cannot provide evidence of a timely site visit, a repair to the guaranty is likely.  Therefore, a lender can best protect itself by performing a site visit while it continues to work with the borrower.

 

Don't do that:  Ignore requirements of the 10 Tab because items are missing from the loan file.

Do this instead:  Address deficiencies or other issues in the guaranty purchase package. The SBA wants lenders to explain missing documentation; if a 10 Tab requirement is unmet, the lender should explain why - or, better still, find a way to meet the requirement. For example, if an appraisal from origination is missing, a forensic appraisal might be obtained; if a timely site visit was not performed, consider whether a personal property appraisal obtained within the required timeframe might serve as a site visit.  It is also important to resist the temptation to overinclude. The Guaranty Purchase Package Tabs set out the SBA's requirements for the guaranty purchase request; this is the information that the SBA must see.  While certain events and decisions may require explanation, providing the SBA with additional documentation from the loan file may create issues by providing the SBA with additional opportunity to second guess the lender's decisions and actions with respect to issues that the SBA would not otherwise consider.  Addressing only the SBA's guaranty purchase requirements eliminates review of issues outside of those requirements.

 

For more information regarding guaranty purchase issues, contact Amy at abrownstein@starfieldsmith.com or at 267-470-1187.

   

Back to Top 

EVENTS & SEMINARS Events

 

7(a) Loan Closing Fundamentals Webinar

 

Presented By:  SBA
Date:  Tuesday, July 15, 2014
Time:  10:00 am EST
Instructor:  Ethan W. Smith

 

Presented By:  CTAGGL
Date:  August 18 - 20, 2014
Location:  Westin Riverwalk, San Antonio, Texas

For more information about this event and/or to register, click here. 

Presented By:  FLAGGL
Date:  September 17 - 19, 2014
Location:  Rosen Shingle Creek Resort, Orlando, FL
 
For more information about this event and/or to register, click here.

NAGGL 2014 Annual Conference

Presented By:  NAGGL
Date:  October 28 - 30, 2014

For more information about this event and/or to register, click here.


Stuart Forsyth / Market President & Chief Lending Officer / HomeBanc, N.A.

 

We rely upon Starfield & Smith as our compliance counsel for our SBA lending business, and we  have been very pleased with the level of service that the firm provides to us. Starfield & Smith's attorneys are very knowledgeable regarding all aspects of the life span of an SBA loan, from origination to servicing to liquidation and guarantee proceedings, and they consistently provide us with prompt, responsive, and practical advice. We have found Starfield & Smith to be a particularly valuable advisor and counselor in instances where it has become necessary for our bank to request that the SBA honor its guaranty. We would strongly recommend the attorneys at Starfield & Smith to other SBA lenders that are seeking guidance on SBA compliance issues.  

 

                                          
OUR PRACTICE AREAS

 

SBA Compliance Audits  |  SBA Guaranty Purchase Reviews & Recovery

SBA Franchise Reviews |  SBA Lender Training

Regulatory Compliance & Lender Oversight |  Loan Documentation & Closing

Commercial Litigation |  SBA Portfolio Management

SBA & Conventional Creditors' Rights 

 

Contact
Starfield & Smith, PC
  
 
Pennsylvania Office:
1300 Virginia Drive | Suite 325 | Ft. Washington, PA 19034
phone: 215.542.7070 | fax: 215.542.0723
  
Philadelphia Office:
2000 Market Street | Suite 500 | Philadelphia, PA 19103
phone: 215.542.7070 | fax: 215.542.0723
  
Florida Office:
2600 Maitland Center Parkway | Suite 330 | Maitland, FL 32751
phone: 407.667.8811 | fax: 407.667.0020
 
 
This email is an advertisement from Starfield & Smith, P.C. and is subject to this disclaimer.
 © 2009-2014 Starfield & Smith, P.C. All Rights Reserved