26th November 2012

                                                                                                         

Issue 46/2012

PMA Australia logo

      Newsline

Click (refresh) Frenzy Special Edition

Well what a frenzy that was!

I think many people got blisters, not from the red hot deals but from the constant rubbing on their fingers as they hit the refresh button.

 

It is always hard to manage customers expectations.

Advertising yourself as the sale that stops a nation sets some pretty high, and obviously unrealistic, expectations from consumers.

 

The end result was a lot of aggrieved customers in the first 12 hours of the sale. 

 

The Click Frenzy folk are claiming the event a success with some retailers seeing a 2 1/2 fold increase in sales over their best ever day. 

My take is imagine how big the day could have been if half your customer base hadn't given up in despair?

 

Another issue for the Click Frenzy folk quickly arose - why did they need everyones name, email address and postcode for a site that was a mere portal into other retailers sites.

 

With no opt in or opt out option for spam it will be interesting to see how that data gets used.

 

The PMA Xmas parties are coming up soon. If you attend please send us a couple of your favourite pics from the event so we can all join in the fun.

 

Email your pics to glynn@creativephotoworkshops.com.au

 

Cheers

Glynn Lavender

Editor

In This Issue
Click Frenzy or Click Fizzle? - the aftermath - by Glynn Lavender
Facebook Frenzy
Twitter Frenzy
Will Street retirement drinks
PMA Xmas Parties
Click Funnies
PMA Calendar 2012 - 2013

Your PMA Australia Executive

 National Chairperson

Phil Gresham
philip@fotofast.com.au

 

Eastern Region TVP

and NSW Chairperson

John Ralph

jrcamerahouse@bigpond.com

 

WA, SA, NT, QLD TVP

and QLD Chairperson

Andrew Mason 

print@photocontinental.com.au

 

 TAS Chairperson

Tim Jones

 tim@perfectprints.com.au

 

VIC Chairperson

Jeff Crowley

jeff.crowley@fujifilm.com.au

 

SA Chairperson

Paul Atkins

paul@atkins.com.au

 

WA Chairperson

Murray Gibbs

murray@ggch.com.au

 

Director of Australian Activities

Peter Rose

prose@pmai.org

  

Australian Directors for PMA

John Paxton

jpaxton@paxtons.com.au 

Len Sandler

len.sandler@starshots.com.au

 

PPFA Chairperson

Bob Smith

bob@classicframing.com.au

 

APCI Chairperson

Paul Atkins

paul@atkins.com.au
 

PSPA Chairperson

Paul Dawson

pd@hydrophotographics.com.au

 

PIEA Chairperson

Earle Bridger

e.bridger@griffith.edu.au

 

PMA Australia Office

02 9454 2444

pmaaustralia@pmai.org


Editor

Glynn Lavender

pmaaustralia@pmai.org

 

 

Click Frenzy or Click Fizzle? - the aftermath - by Glynn Lavender

It was supposed to be "the sale that stopped the internet". 

Instead, it was the sale that crashed the internet.

- Herald Sun headline - Melbourne

 

Last week I wrote the following about the upcoming 'Click Frenzy' event

 

"Taking it's lead from the American 'Cyber Monday' it will be interesting to see how the Australian equivalent fares."

 

"One of the interesting things to watch out for is how will the various sites handle the web traffic if it really takes off? This years Cyber Monday in the US saw a peak of 1.6 Million pages views per minute - there is nothing more frustrating to customers than not being able to get the deal they were after due to technical issues."

 

Well the technical issues certainly became the talking point VERY quickly with the majority of customers unable to log on to nearly every participating website.

 

 "there is nothing more frustrating to customers than not being able to get the deal they were after due to technical issues"

 

As with anything online, there is no hiding if things don't go right.

In no time the event was trending on Twitter for all the wrong reasons.

Facebook pages, such as Click Fail, were popping up everywhere with people venting their frustrations.

 

One of the first things I learned in retail while dealing with angry customers was to NEVER, EVER say to them "Don't get angry" - it's like a red rag to a bull.

 

So when Grant Arnott, the main public face and co-founder of Click Frenzy told consumers not to get angry it was always going to cause a backlash. (more of that later)

 

Part of the problem I feel was that consumers thought that the deals were 'door buster' offers. First in, best dressed and if you are late you miss out.

They were also looking for the advertised 'up to 90% off' deals.

The reality was the event was a more general sale that had offers that would last the full 24 hours with modest discounts akin to 'normal' sales offered by retailers.

 

Sure there were some products that sold out but there were plenty of offers available up until the close of the sale.

 

The rush to market of this event clearly left flaws in how the organisers conveyed the event to the public.

 

As traffic 'normalised' on the sites, consumers started being able to buy with the majority of purchases being made from 9am - 6pm on the following day.

 

The wash up of all the 'frenzy' seems to be that some sites saw a 2 1/2 fold increase in turnover over their best previous online sales days. A more interesting by product though would have to be that some NON participating sites saw a 30% increase in their sales. A clear sign that people were checking the sales prices on products across multiple sites and buying where it was cheapest.

 

Australian consumers have now been primed for more online shopping.

There is an obvious thirst and it will be interesting to see how retailers tap into that demand over the coming months.

 

The Click Frenzy people have grand plans to expand into Europe and the USA but will Australian's follow them again next year?

Facebook reaction to Click Frenzy

Click Fail, Click Frenzy Stuff Up, Click Fizzer were just some of the Facebook pages that sprung up for people to vent their frustration.

Their own Facebook page was inundated with both complaints AND non participating retailers saying 'buy from us, our website works'.

 

"believed my browser was trying to hypnotize me with the hours and hours of circles spinning in front of my eyes. Have bought nothing but wanted to do all my shopping tonight. Thanks for nothing Crap Frenzy."

 

"I wonder if MYKI (Victorian Public Transport ticketing system) are the IT people behind this stuff up ?

 

"If they ever try this again no-one will be interested. We learnt our lesson this time."

 

"Just love the power of social media... well done to whoever it was that put this site together so quickly. What a disgrace Click Frenzy. Absolute amateurs!"

 

The response to their 'apologies' the next day was damning, here is a sample.

 

No excuse. Not good enough.

 

The "sorry" is too little, too late CF. Good luck with anyone listening to your spin/hype next year.

 

If it was based on the system used successfully in the US, which has a much larger population than ours, I fail to understand how/why this happened.

 

I think the majority of your customers who shopped elsewhere found better bargains anyway. Maybe the participating retailers could learn from this as well? FAIL all around

 

Maybe your first priority should be to get adsl and not dial up? Just a thought...

 

The sales and offers were simply ordinary.

 

it was more about marketing than a sale in my view. shipping turned me off costing more than items at full price in some case's

 

whole problem was not good enough they rediculed most of us by saying the few who could not get access pffffft few i would say 90%

 

The thing is when you advertise something like this. That there will be amazing bargains at 'the sale that stops the nation'. You expect more than 10%-20% off that you can get in the shop at a regular sale. I would expect closer to 40% the way it was hyped up

Twitter reaction to Click Frenzy

Here are a FEW of the thousands of Twitter comments #clickfrenzy 

 


"You have only gone to reinforce the notion that we should shop online overseas. Better prices. Better service".

 

"The repeated failure of the #clickfrenzy site is a perfect metaphor for Australian retailers online efforts".

 

"Long downtime and no real bargains. Another sales hoax by Australian retailers. Xmas shopping on USA & Japanese sites now"

 

"Ah damn it maybe that's their whole evil plan for #clickfrenzy show consumers ecom is unreliable to bring them back 2 stores"

 

"Wonder when people who joined the #clickfrenzy hype realise they could've got the crap they bought cheaper if they'd searched online a bit".

 

"The #clickfrenzy experience highlights how shoppers can't be fooled by a deal that can be found better somewhere else".

 

"Have they tried turning it off and on again?"

 

"Clickfrenzy shows how unprepared Australian retailers are for online shopping, and how ready the customers are. No wonder we import"

 

"Good luck all on #clickfrenzy tonight but remember the shops are full of awesome workers who are happy to assist you"

 

"I just bought an error 404. Don't know what it is but it must be good"

 

Somewhere Gerry Harvey is laughing at us all

 

Will Street retirement drinks - by Paul Atkins
Will Street Retirement Dinner

  

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

What a great way to celebrate an illustrious career. Will Street was joined by friends at the Pig and Whistle Brisbane for a retirement dinner in combination with a Queensland PMA Christmas drinks. The evening was filled with a lot of laughs, some in-depth explanations and more food and wine than anyone could remember. It is clear to all that Will will have trouble sitting still in his retirement, but it is well deserved and we wish he and his "much better half" Karen, all the best.

 

 

 

PMA Industry Christmas & End of Year Functions 

    

  

PMA NSW Xmas Party Tuesday 4th December - The Red Room, Bowlers at 99 On York, Sydney.

Click here to download the ticket order form.

A big thanks to our generous sponsors:  Canon, C.R Kennedy, Independent Photographic Supplies, Nikon, Olympus  and Maxwell International Australia for making this event possible.

 

PMA TAS- Industry Xmas Drinks & Finger Food - Thursday 6th December, Lark Distillery, Hobart 6pm - 8pm. 

PMA Members $15 per head, Non-Members $25 per head. Sponsors & Sponsorships welcome. RSVP by 3rd December to John Mullavey jandaagencies@netspace.net.au

 

PMA VIC- Industry Xmas Drinks & Dinner - Wednesday 12th December @6:30pm  Pumphouse Hotel, Fitzroy. If you are thinking of attending, please  rsvp to kwarlum@pmai.org

 
Click Funnies
Click UnPopular Greg Arnott
Click Down Bargains
PMA Calendar 2012 - 2013

 

Tues Dec 4                              PMA NSW Xmas Party

                                                99 On York, Sydney

 

Thurs Dec 6                             PMA TAS Xmas Party

                                                Lark Distillery, Hobart

 

Wed Dec 12                            PMA VIC Xmas Party

                                                Pumphouse Hotel, Fitzroy

 

Jan 6 - 7 2013                          DIMA, PSPA & SPAA Conference

                                                Bally's, Las Vegas, Nevada

 

Jan 8-11 2013                          PMA @ CES

                                                LVH (Las Vegas Hilton), Las Vegas, Nevada

 

Jan 26-27 2013                        PPFA Convention

                                                Mirage Hotel & Casino, Las Vegas,. Nevada 

 

May 4-5 2013                          The Big Photo Show

                                                 Los Angeles Convention Centre, Los Angeles, California