Terry Hershey
The Right Question
October 14, 2013
  

What is honored will be cultivated. Plato

 

We teach children how to measure and how to weigh. We fail to teach them how to revere, how to sense wonder and awe. Rabbi Harold Kushner

 

The right question

I would love to live

Like a river flows,

Carried by the surprise

Of its own unfolding.

John O'Donohue

          
During her three-month visit to Jerusalem, Natalie Goldberg writes about her Israeli landlady, a woman in her fifties. The woman called a repairman to fix her broken TV.  It took the repairman four visits to fix the screen.

"But you knew even before he came the first time what was wrong," Natalie told her. "He could have brought the correct tube and fixed it immediately."
The landlady looked at her in astonishment. "Yes but then we couldn't have had a relationship, sat and drunk tea and discussed the progress of the repairs. "
Of course, Goldberg writes, the goal was not to fix the machine but to have a relationship. To make a connection--to touch, to see, to listen, to discover, to drink from the well of the day's gladness.

Which begs the question: How then do we measure?

What is important? Or essential? How do we decide (or using Plato's verb, honor) the things that really matter?

This all sounds like a very good idea. You know, rearrange our priorities and all that. Ducks in a row. And it is easy to resonate with the goal part. It provides needed ballast for that fragment of our psyche that requires closure.  So we're all in.  And if it comes with an easy to follow checklist, all the better. (Which is all well and good until someone changes the list.)

 

But what if measuring is not even about the list?

Is it possible that we are asking the wrong questions?   

During the Iraq War, a five-year-old boy watches the news with his father.

The boy keeps asking, "How big is this war? How did it start? What is war? Why are so many families, on the TV, so sad?"

The father tries to explain why countries go to war, why some people think wars are necessary, and other people believe that wars are wrong. But the boy keeps asking the same questions, night after night.

Finally, the father listens. And hears the real question. 

He holds his son tight and says to him, "You don't have to worry. We are safe here. Dad will keep you safe. And our family will be safe, and we will do whatever we can to help keep other families safe."

After his Dad spoke, the boy became peaceful, because it was the reassurance his heart had been asking for.


Here's the deal: the question is almost never the question.

And more often than not, fixing the broken TV is not the goal.

 

I wonder what happened in this culture to make our measurements so catawampus?  (We talk about and parade and live vicariously through so many skewed measurements for success.) I realize now that if my measurements are predicated solely on achievement or efficiency or accomplishment or resolutions or public opinion, then it is likely I will be removing myself from this present moment, not drinking from the well of the day; and I will miss the exquisite gifts of life. As adults, we think of measurement as a skill set. I'm smiling because even writing Sabbath Moment, after I have spent the afternoon in my garden, I am prone to ask, "What did I achieve? What did I accomplish? Was it successful?" (Did I get the TV fixed or not?)   

 

"Momma, momma, listen to me; but this time with your eyes!" The little boy said to his mom. And I say, Amen.


People have told me that pain will be my teacher. They just didn't tell me what I would learn. I can tell you this: with pain--or uncertainty or way-laid plans or fractures of the heart or broken TV sets--it is too easy to focus only on the fixing. Or the right path.

 

And in my urgency for resolve I can miss the spirit of life. Natalie's landlady gives me a jolt to my heart. In Eve Ensler's words, 

 

"Find freedom, aliveness, and power  

not from what contains, locates, or protects us,  

but from what dissolves, reveals, and expands us."

 

So if I'm honest I will admit that what I want is to manage life, not live it. I need permission to change the questions... permission to be carried by the surprise of life's unfolding. 

 

A friend sent me this... Some stories have a beginning, a middle, an end all tied up with twine and sealed with a kiss. These ones can be told with satisfaction, lessons drawn out like fresh honey from the hive. They're my favorite kind.

Some stories are larger, though, and we must make our homes right in the midst of the mystery.

I am ever grasping for a timeline too, wanting to know whether this is a short season to savor or a long one with hatches to be battened down.  I keep scrambling to arrange the scraps of my story into some semblance of cohesive narrative, a work that holds the tensions of grief and joy, longing and contentment. We live in a kingdom coming on earth as it is in heaven in a world where we see only through a glass dimly.

Story arcs are made of chapters,
are made of paragraphs,
are made of sentences,
are made of words,
are made of letters,
are made of single strokes of ink.

 

Today's story arc? It is sunny. The kind you bask in. And heavenly at this time of year. In a little over a month, dusk will set in by late afternoon. So today is a gift.

And it is enough.

Maybe this story doesn't need twine and a kiss. Although another kind of medicine is called for. I need a dose of the Liquidambar (Sweetgum). Have you seen their leaves this autumn?  Today, an inflamed or flushed red, against a cool blue sky. It's involuntary and spontaneous, this smile or grin that stretches across my face, altering my mood. I don't know how deep is today's well of gladness, but I do know there is enough to raise a glass to the sun as it sets beyond the steel blue Olympic Range.  

     

Visiting Joshua Tree National Park, children are given a guide with suggestions for enjoying the park. One of them says, "Find an oasis. In silence, spend ten minutes there. Ask yourself these questions: What did I hear? What did I see? What did I notice that surprised me?"

   
Stay connected:

terry's schedule 

 Like us on FacebookView our videos on YouTubeFollow us on TwitterVisit our blog 

 

 

Poems and Prayers 
         
Toni Morrison (talking about The Bluest Eye) explains that it's interesting to watch what happens when a child walks into a room. She asks, "Does your face light up?" She explains, "When my children used to walk in the room when they were little, I looked at them to see if they had buckled their trousers or if their hair was combed or if their socks were up... You think your affection and your deep love is on display because you're caring for them. It's not. When they see you, they see the critical face. What's wrong now?" Her advice now is simple, a paradigm-shift: "Let your face speak what's in your heart. When they walk in the room my face says I'm glad to see them. It's just as small as that, you see?" 

 

               

A Gift

Just when you seem to yourself
nothing but a flimsy web
of questions, you are given
the questions of others to hold
in the emptiness of your hands,
songbird eggs that can still hatch
if you keep them warm,
butterflies opening and closing themselves
in your cupped palms, trusting you not to injure
their scintillant fur, their dust.
You are given the questions of others
as if they were answers
to all you ask. Yes, perhaps
this gift is your answer.

Denise Levertov

 
Blessed are You, O Lord our God,
Wellspring of all that is.
You are the sea on which we float,
You are the wind that fills our sails,
You are the storm that buffets us,
You are the calm that brings us peace.
Open our ears to hear Your word,
Open our eyes to see Your beauty,
Open our hearts to be warmed by Your love.
Free us from our lonely prisons of fear and selfishness,
And make us over, day by day, into bearers of Your peace.
Amen.
Richard Rosenberg
 
Be Inspired

Dougie MacLean and Kathy Mattea-- This Love Will Carry

 

Teach Your Children - Suzzy Bogguss, Kathy Mattea (Crosby, Stills and Nash cover) 


Andrew De Leon - Goth, Marilyn Manson-esque "countertenor" - America's Got Talent (Our expectations and assumptions may easily fool us)


Favorites from last week:

Going Home -- composed and performed in Night in London DVD Live by Mark Knopfler    

From Mao to Mozart -- the scene with Stern and the young violinist
Meryl Streep as Roberta Guaspari in Music of the Heart. The final piece from the movie.  Bach's Concerto in D Minor.  The story about Opus 118 Harlem School of Music. (This concert featuring Isaac Stern and Itzhak Perlman.)    

A Blessing of Solitude -- John O'Donohue

The Healing Day -- Bill Fay

Be at peace with yourself -- Bill Fay        

Dougie MacLean. This Love Will Carry   

Fred Rogers Accepts the Lifetime Achievement Award at the 24th Annual Daytime Emmy Awards.  In his speech he says, "So many people have helped me to come here to this night. Some of you are here, some are far away and some are even in Heaven. All of us have special ones who loved us into being. Would you just take, along with me, 10 seconds to think of the people who have helped you become who you are, those who cared about you and wanted what was best for you in life."    

Celebrate What's Right with the World -- Dewitt Jones. "Celebrate What's Right with the World is a film I made to help folks approach life with confidence, grace and celebration."
Living without FearThe truth about intimacy --Terry Hershey (Anaheim Convention Center) --2013 Religious Education Congress.
Notes from Terry... I invite you to... 
 
Join me in a city near you. And pass the word to a friend.
October 19.2013 -- Sisters of Charity, Cincinnati, OH. The Power of Pause.
October 20. 2013 -- Victory Noll Center, Huntington, IN.
March 14-15, 2014 -- Religious Education Congress, Anaheim, CA. (Open for registration now.)
Friday 10 am -- Making a Difference: Being Not Just the Best IN the World,
but the Best FOR the World
Saturday 10 am -- Scandalous Love: You Can't Get Away From a Love That
Won't Let You Go

 

Give to make Sabbath Moment possible. Your gift does make a difference. Thank you.

 

Sabbath Moment is available to everyone.  Please spill the light and forward Sabbath Moment...  

If you are uncomfortable using PayPal or the internet, please write me:
Terry Hershey
PO Box 2301, Vashon, WA 98070
Or call me: 800-524-5370
And I am always glad to hear from you... comments... stories... poems... YouTubes... please email me tdh@terryhershey.com

Talk with Terry... One-to-One

Every person needs a safe place to tell their story... Renew your passion / Find your voice / Practice self-nurture / Create balance / Embrace life-giving choices

 

Share Sabbath Moment. Here are the recent issues. Please forward the link, or cut and paste.  For archived issues, go to ARCHIVE

October. 6. 2013 -- In the Heart
September. 30. 2013 -- Racoons
September. 23. 2013 -- Sandwiches 

Pause with DailyPause -- an App for your iphone. It's free! And updated! Download it today
Or pause on Facebook with daily PAUSE reminders. Please hit the LIKE button... it doesn't hurt and it helps the cause. 

Invite me to be a part of your organizational event.
Call us today 1-800-524-5370.
Our Website

Find Products that inspire and help you on the journey.

Add Sabbath Moment to your organization's or church's newsletter.

Contact our office at customerservice.tdh@gmail.com or 800-524-5370.  

Contact me personally at tdh@terryhershey.com 

Invite Terry to your organization or church --Terry Speaking.

Copyright © 2011 Terry Hershey. All Rights Reserved. Please contact us for permission to reprint.  

Do you know someone who would enjoy this Sabbath Moment? Scroll down and click

Forward this Issue. Thanks for helping us grow!