Immigration Compliance Group
NewsFLASH from Immigration Compliance Group 
Business Immigration | Outstanding Results
                   October 15, 2012 


ICE Issues Guidance on Evaluating Electronic I-9 Systems During an Audit

For electronic I-9 users, questions have swirled around what exactly are you required  to produce within 72-hours in the event of a government audit, and what standards will ICE use to evaluate I-9 software?

On July 22, 2010, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) published a final rule relating to signatures and storage of electronic Form I-9s that went into effect August 23, 2010 (see our previous post ).  However, we have all been waiting on regulations concerning this very topic, particularly in light of the huge uptick in ICE I-9 audits in the last few years creating a very uncertain climate for employers, as well as recent  changes to E-Verify, and concerns over very severe consequences for non-compliance.


The new Memorandum provides guidance to Homeland Security Investigative (HSI) Agents and field offices, effective August 23, 2012, concerning how to evaluate electronically generated and stored I-9 records during an audit and the minimum standards for electronic audit trail requirements for use in establishing civil fines.


Let's summarize what ICE agents will expect from employers who are using an electronic I-9 system at the onset of an investigative audit:


1)      Audit Trails:  Whenever an electronic I-9 form is created, completed, updated,  modified, altered or corrected - a  secure and permanent record must be created (audit trail) that establishes the date accessed, who accessed it and what action was taken.

2)      Software Provider Information:  Upon service of an NOI (Notice of Inspection), special agents or auditors will request the name of the software  product being utilized and any internal business practices and protocols related to the generation of, use of, storage of, security of and inspection and quality assurance programs for the electronically generated I-9 Form.

3)      Indexing System:  The employer will also be asked to provide the indexing system identifying how the electronic information contained in the I-9 form is linked to each employee and documentation of the system used to capture the electronic signature, including the identity and attestation of the individual electronically signing  the form.

4)      Auditors will Request at least one printed, completed I-9 form to ensure compliance with the regulation.  Your system should permit you to download a PDF version of the I-9 form that syncs up with the required information on the actual fields of the -9 form.

5)      Lastly, auditors will request access to the system for a demonstration of the generation of an electronic I-9 form.


Once it's determined by the agents that the audit trails are in compliance, the auditors will be referring to the flow chart attached to the Memorandum (see link at the end of the post) and audit trail that illustrates the minimum acceptable standards (know that the auditors can request to see additional system data and documentation) of electronically generated I-9 forms.

We recommend that you discuss this Memorandum very specifically with your HR department, your I-9 electronic vendor to ensure that they comply with the regulations, and that you update  your standard  operating procedures to reflect  compliance with these new regulations.  We link to the Memorandum here  

Please refer to our list of compliance services and solutions as well as our Employer Resource Center at  


If you are a member of LinkedIn, you might wish to check out our I-9/E-Verify: Smart Solutions for Employers group.


Should you wish to consult with us, email, or call to speak with one of our immigration professionals 562 612.3996.

Immigration Compliance Group
562 612.3996

Immigration Compliance Group focuses its practice on corporate employment verification compliance and US and Canadian inbound business immigration.  Our team has a depth of experience in providing uniquely tailored services and solutions to assist our clients in accomplishing their immigration related objectives.  

Follow us on TwitterView our profile on LinkedIn
Quick Links

Recent Postings from our Employer Compliance Resource Center
Types of Immigration-Related Employment Discrimination
I-9 Audits       
USCIS Releases New Employee  


To increase awareness about employee rights during the employment eligibility process. It also contains a variety of educational materials such as E-Verify employee rights videos, informative fliers, brochures, and posters that will help you help others.

We like that this information that has been individually released, is now organized in one place. This is a good resource - you might wish to bookmark it.


For Employers 



Disclaimer/Reminder: This newsletter does not constitute direct legal advice and is for informational purposes only. The information provided should never replace informed counsel when specific immigration-related guidance is needed. Copyright 2007-2012 Immigration Compliance Group.