40th CES CES Logo 40th CES
Coalition for Economic Survival
CES in the News 
March 2013


Daily News Logo
Federal Judge Won't Budge, Throws Out Lawsuit Fighting L.A. Superior Court Consolidation

by Christina Villacorte - Thursday, March 21, 2013

 

Without ruling on the merits of the case, a federal judge late Monday threw out a lawsuit by legal services and community organizations to block the Los Angeles Superior Court from drastically reducing the number of local courtrooms hearing eviction cases.

  

The plaintiffs, however, intend to continue fighting the so-called court consolidation  plan, which took effect Monday and they are deciding between appealing the decision or bringing the case to a state court instead.

 

In his order, US District Judge Terry Hatter said the federal court "abstains from considering plaintiffs' claims" but did not elaborate.

 

Neal Dudovitz, executive director of Neighborhood Legal Services, one of the organizations that filed the lawsuit, explained the federal judge abstained in the belief that a state court should hear the case instead.

 

"This is not a ruling on the merits of our claim at all," Dudovitz said. "(Hatter) just said we have to go somewhere else with it, and that's what we're going to do. "

 

"We cannot allow this (consolidation) policy to close the doors of justice in our client's faces," he added.

 

Larry Gross, executive director of the Coalition for Economic Survival, one of the plaintiffs in the case, vowed, "There will, most certainly, be a next step!"

 

"The courts cannot be allowed to move forward with this court closure and consolidation policy," he added. "The impact would be devastating to poor people and people living with disabilities.

 

Because the plaintiffs were not able to secure a temporary restraining order through the federal lawsuit, the Superior Court has begun scaling back its operations to close an $85-million dollar budget deficit by June 30, including reducing the number of courtrooms hearing eviction cases.

 

Last year alone, the Superior Court heard about 70,000 eviction cases in 26 courtrooms. Once consolidation is in place, only five courtrooms will hear eviction cases, forcing many tenants facing eviction to commute as far as 60 miles in the early morning hours to try to save their homes.

 

The Superior Court has also begun the first phase of closing eight courthouses and removing most court work from two other locations. Consolidation also means small claims cases will be heard in only six courthouses instead of current 26.

 

"The first phase of the court's consolidation plan began on March 18," Mary Hearn, spokeswoman for the Superior Court, said. "As of that date, new unlawful detainer cases, as well as new small claims, general civil personal injury, and limited civil cases must be filed at the courthouse locations described in the notices and the plan."

 

"Pending cases will continue to be heard at the courthouses where they originated until the parties receive notice that their cases have been transferred," she added.

 

Those who want to file new eviction cases in the San Fernando Valley can no longer do so in either the Van Nuys or Chatsworth courthouses. They have to go to either Santa Monica or Pasadena instead.         


Support the Work of CES
Make a Donation NOW!
Show you support for the work of CES by making a  Donation Now!

The economic justice victories that CES has won over the years such as rent control, creating the city of West Hollywood and winning numerous laws to combat slum housing, secure tenants' rights and preserve affordable housing has only been possible with the generous financial support from people like you. As CES begins its 40th Anniversary year, help make 2013 another year of victories by donating now. 
 

  Find Out Your About Your Renters' Rights
 
Tenants are welcome to come to CES' Tenants' Rights Clinic held every Wednesday evening at 7 pm and Saturday morning at 10 am in the Senior Center located in the Community Building in Plummer Park, 7377 Santa Monica Bl, West Hollywood (just west of La Brea, between Vista St. and Fuller St. at Martel Ave. ).

Tenants are assisted on a one-to-one basis by one of our experienced and knowledgeable volunteer attorneys and counselors. No appointment needed. First come, first serve.

Find Out More Details Here

 
Check Out and Subscribe to CES' Blog
Blog OT Logo

Get up to the minute news, analysis, information on events and reports on actions by subscribing to "Organizing Times," a Blog related to CES activities and more......  

 

  Click Here

 

 
CES is on Facebook
Shaking Out Tenants Check out the new CES Facebook page. Take a moment to go to our page and click 'JOIN."
You'll get up to the minute news and information.

 
Follow CES on Twitter
Follow CES on Twitter.

Click Here



Follow CES Exec Dir Larry Gross on Twitter
 
 

For information on broader progressive issues, news and activities.

 

Click Here  


Shaking Out Tenants
Coalition for Economic Survival (CES)
514 Shatto Place, Suite 270
Los Angeles, California 90020
Ph: (213) 252-4411
Email: [email protected]
Web Siwww.CESinAction.org
Join Our Mailing List

Support CES' Work by Joining or Making a Donation
Donate Now


    

Support CES' Work When You Shop for Your Groceries

Sign Up for Ralphs/Food-4-Less  Community Contribution Program:

RalphsFood4LessSupporting CES' work couldn't be easier: through the Ralphs/Food-4-Less Community Contribution Program, each time you use your Ralphs or Food-4-Less Rewards Card, a portion of your total purchase is donated to support CES' work. This donation does not take away from your individual rewards earning. Registering is quick, easy, and free.

 

Contact CES at (213) 252-4411 or [email protected] and we will explain how to register to support CES' work while you shop.