fish report header

On the Hook: Reigning in Wasteful Fisheries Bycatch

April 7, 2014


The relationship between commercial fishers and their target fish species is rarely one-to-one. Commercial ocean fishing is often a wide-sweeping, messy affair, where dozens of non-target species can get caught in the crossfire - everything from fish and turtles, to sea lions and whales. As fishing gear has become less selective, fishers are throwing back massive volumes of animals that they don't want or can't sell - usually dead. Some accounts suggest this non-target "bycatch" makes up 40% of the world's fishing catch (Davies et al. 2009), and as many as 650,000 whales, dolphins, seals, and sea lions are killed in bycatch every year (Reed et al. 2005). A recent spate of reports and papers highlight the issue of bycatch, and call for solutions to address this collateral damage of the fishing industry. Not only does bycatch contribute to the decline of many species, it reflects the sheer wastefulness of some fishing practices, adding to the global threat of overfishing.


Humans aren't the only ones out to catch fish, so it's no surprise that our fisheries overlap with the feeding grounds of other animals. In fact, tuna fisheries used to deliberately set their nets around hunting dolphins
to catch the fish nearby - killing many dolphins in the process. Bycatch can also result from animals getting snared in lost gear still fishing at sea, known as "ghost fishing." A recent scientific paper in the journal

Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences

offers the most comprehensive picture of the global bycatch problem among marine megafaua, or the "air breathers," including sea birds, sea turtles, and marine mammals. The authors reviewed three common gear types, and concluded gillnets caused the highest bycatch "intensity" (a combination of fishing effort, bycatch rate, and species information), followed by longlines, then trawls. Sea turtles experienced the highest bycatch intensity, followed by marine mammals, then seabirds. The team also identified bycatch "hotpots" where cumulative effects of multiple gear types affect a range of species, including the Mediterranean Sea and southwest Atlantic Ocean. Without looking at bycatch holistically, the authors point out, changing fishing practices to protect one species could end up harming another.  

A recent report by the Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC) highlighted the extent of marine mammal bycatch that occurs in foreign fisheries exporting seafood to the United States. The authors call on the National Marine Fisheries Service to enforce a provision of the Marine Mammal Act that requires seafood imports to come from fisheries that do not kill marine mammals in excess of U.S. standards. The report reveals how fisheries in Canada, the Mediterranean, and Asia, among others, are catching marine mammals at a concerning rate. Bycatch is considered a main cause of population decline in many long-lived, slow maturing megafauna populations - and in some cases, is the number one threat, such as the rare vaquita porpoise in the Gulf of Mexico. The gold standard for monitoring bycatch is to institute independent observer programs, where onboard observers record the extent of bycatch. While such programs could prove costly in developing countries starting from scratch, the report argues that the multibillion dollar seafood industry ought to spare some resources to address these challenges.


Holding our international seafood suppliers to a higher standard would level the playing field for domestic fisheries, which have had relative success in reducing mammal bycatch. However, U.S. fisheries still have clean-up work to do when it comes to discards. Oceana recently released a report identifying the nine "dirtiest," or most wasteful, fisheries in the United States. Drift and set gillnet fisheries in California, as well as shrimp trawl and snapper longline fisheries in the Southeast, throw away a whopping 60% or more of what they catch. Instituting bycatch limits in all fisheries and providing incentives to switch to less destructive gear are some suggested solutions. And all the recent reports stress that more information is needed: accurate reporting will be a crucial step in understanding the true extent of bycatch and holding fisheries accountable. As Oceana's report suggests, it's time we start counting everything we pull out of the sea - because everything counts.

Follow Us! Like us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter View our photos on flickr View our videos on YouTube
email list
Recent Blog Posts
Hungry, hungry salmon?

We recently conducted a pilot-level study to investigate the diet of Chinook salmon parr and smolts on the Lower Sacramento River - and the number of prey items that we encountered in these little fish surprised us. The goal of the study is to document the diets of juvenile Chinook salmon during the latter portion of their migration to the estuary and ocean. We employed a technique called gastric lavage, which is a non-lethal method to sample gut contents in fish - essentially making the fish regurgitate its last meal. Preliminary findings from our gut analyses show that most of our sampled salmon had eaten between 5 and 15 food items; however, one stuffed individual contained nearly 200 food items, consisting mostly of Cladocerans (small crustaceans). The most common items were in the orders Diptera (midges), Ephemeroptera (mayflies) and the aforementioned Cladocerans.

A second component of the study is to investigate the amount and types of prey items that were available to the feeding salmon at the time we collected them. For this portion of the study, we deployed drift nets slightly upstream of fish sampling sites. The drift nets (like the one shown below) captured insects, crustaceans, very fine sediment, and often, high amounts of vegetation and woody debris. The first and most challenging step for processing these drift samples is to pick through all the debris to separate the prey items. Expect more to come on this part of our work! The early results of our study suggest that Chinook salmon outmigration...  Read more >
IN THE NEWS: Recent stories you might have missed...
California drought: Downpours fall far short of ending crisis  
San Francisco Chronicle

Snow surveyors are expected to tromp out into the Sierra powder Tuesday under a soft, steady patter of comforting precipitation, but the spring moisture is a cruel oasis in California's desert of drought, according to leading climate and weather gurus. The pounding rain along the coast and fluffy snow in the mountains this week won't come close to solving the state's mounting water crisis, which has forced the state to turn off the spigot in many communities... Read more > 

Courtland farmer explains opposition to proposed Delta dams
Central Valley Business Times
Courtland pear farmer Tim Neubarth, whose Steamboat Acres family farm is at the mouth of Steamboat Slough in the California Delta, believes the three barrier dams planned by the state are totally "for the benefit of the water users down south." That's what he told the Delta Protection Commission at their Stockton meeting this week. His comments, derived from a lifetime of living and observing the Delta waterways... Read more >
California water managers ease delta pumping limits
Los Angeles Times

Officials announced Tuesday that they are temporarily waiving an endangered species protection to enable water managers to send more Northern California water south. The move comes as fishery agencies are under increasing political pressure to take advantage of late winter storms and ramp up pumping from the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta, the center of the state's water distribution system... Read more > 

No Jeopardy to steller sea lions from proposed fishery management 

NOAA Fisheries 

Proposed changes to fishing restrictions in the Aleutian Islands are not likely to jeopardize the continued existence of the endangered western population of Steller sea lions or adversely modify Steller sea lion critical habitat, according to a biological opinion issued today by NOAA Fisheries under the Endangered Species Act. The agency estimates that the proposed fishery management changes would relieve roughly two-thirds of the economic burden... Read more > 

Should we close part of the ocean to keep fish on the plate?


For lovers of fatty tuna belly, canned albacore and swordfish kebabs, here's a question: Would you be willing to give them up for several years so that you could eat them perhaps for the rest of your life? If a new proposal to ban fishing on the open ocean were to fly, that's essentially what we might be faced with. It's an idea that might help restore the populations of several rapidly disappearing fish - like tuna, swordfish and marlin... Read more >