fish report header

What's "Natural" in a Regulated River?

It's hard to find a "natural" river in California's Central Valley. Significant changes over the past century, such as dams and water use, have altered the daily, monthly, and annual variations in river flow, or the hydrographs, of the valley's rivers. At the same time, the landscape around those rivers has changed dramatically, shifting towards agriculture and urban development. In recent years, river managers worldwide have been striving to release more 'natural' river flows, or flows that mimic the natural hydrograph of a river system. But just what is a "natural hydrograph" in a river system that has been thoroughly, and in some cases permanently, altered? The University of California at Davis and the Delta Science Program hosted a seminar this month and invited a panel of local experts to address that question.


While the seminar speakers voiced different opinions, they agreed on a take-home message: in a highly modified system like the Central Valley, we can't use the hydrograph alone to restore our river ecosystems to a natural state. We also need corresponding changes to the way rivers connect with the landscape. Relying on river flow alone is like driving a car with only the steering wheel and no gas or brake pedals, one speaker described, pointing out the limitations of focusing on just one tool at a time. The panel speakers acknowledged that most landscape changes in the valley are irreversible, but were optimistic about opportunities to integrate the landscape and the hydrograph to benefit fish and wildlife. For example, researchers found that the rate of spring snowmelt in the Sierra Nevada Mountains is a naturally predictable cue for many species, such as frogs and Chinook salmon. Spring snowmelt recession rates are a relatively easy measurement to discuss with stakeholders, and can be modeled ecologically and economically for cost-benefit analysis under various water operation scenarios.


To broaden the perspective, one presentation offered examples of flow management from around the world, including an intriguing list of environmental flow management principles from South Africa. These included retaining continuous flow year round in naturally perennial rivers, and retaining certain floods at full magnitude and eliminating others, rather than preserving all floods at diminished levels. The keynote speaker, Dr. Geoffrey Petts from the University of Westminster, also reminded the panel that we must consider river management in a world of "uncertain environmental change." The United Kingdom is still reeling from a year of dramatic weather patterns that has left many in Britain wondering what climate change may bring.


The seminar follows on the heels of the publication of California's State Water Resources Control Board's preferred alternative changes to the Water Quality Control Plan for the San Francisco Bay-Sacramento/San Joaquin Delta Estuary, presented at the seminar. One of the goals of the State Board's flow objective for the San Joaquin River basin is to include "flows that mimic the natural hydrographic conditions to which native fish species are adapted." Clearly, the debate over what is natural will continue well into 2013. If you are curious about the SWRCB plan and you're feeling ambitious, dive into the full document, about 2,000-pages of information. Otherwise, you can stick to the Executive Summary, a mere 61 pages.

Follow Us!  Like us on Facebook  View our photos on flickr  View our videos on YouTube

email list
Recent Blog Post
The rabbit and the coyote brush   

Since we are pretty  fish-centric people here at FISHBIO, when we think of floodplains we tend to think of Chinook salmon and Sacramento splittail. But a recent visit to the San Joaquin River National Wildlife Refuge near Modesto with the organization River Partners reminded us that many other creatures make use of floodplain habitats as well. River Partners has been restoring wildlife habitat in the Central Valley for many years, and they focus on the bigger picture: how these habitats benefit the ecosystem as a whole. Their restoration projects in the refuge have taught them the importance of incorporating suitable habitat for various birds and terrestrial animals in floodplains. For example, the riparian brush rabbit (Sylvilagus bachmani riparius, shown above), an endangered native species that has been reintroduced to the refuge, needs to escape to higher ground during floods. As with many riparian areas in the Central Valley, "higher ground" often means levees. However, most levees are intentionally stripped of vegetation due to a controversial claim that plants destabilize the structures (see Levee improvements). This poses a problem for the rabbits: escaping floods means exposure to predators.


Like most extreme events in nature, floods are a double-edged sword that can prove a blessing to fish and a danger to rabbits... Read more > 

IN THE NEWS: Recent stories you might have missed...
Can governor broker a water peace treaty? 

The Sacramento Bee 

Gov. Jerry Brown is sure to highlight water in his State of the State address. Less clear are the answers to two key questions:  How much political capital is the governor willing to expend to resolve some long-standing water conflicts in California? In particular, how does he propose to break through the impasse over the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta that appears headed toward another epic legal battle? Water is crucial to California's economy... Read more>  

Sinking land makes levees unreliable 

The Fresno Bee   

In the spring seven years ago, the San Joaquin River filled with snowmelt after a big winter and threatened destruction across western Madera and Merced counties. Miles of earthen walls -- levees -- kept the river from ripping through millions of dollars worth of farmland, crops, barns and roads. But since that perilous spring, some of those earthen walls have sunk along with a swath of the west San Joaquin Valley landscape, due to farm water pumping... Read more>

Lots of herring hit Bay Area
San Francisco Chronicle

Great swirling schools of herring converged in San Francisco Bay this month, drawing fishermen, sea lions, harbor seals and thousands upon thousands of birds looking to fatten up for the winter.The menagerie of wildlife is a sign that the bay's once spectacular herring runs, which collapsed four years ago, are returning to their former glory. The San Francisco run is the last urban fishery in the United States in which people can actually sit on shore and watch.... Read more >
Short spring Chinook season likely in lower Columbia

The Columbian 

There's not likely to be much spring chinook salmon fishing in the lower Columbia River in April no matter how Washington and Oregon structure the season. Figure on being done downstream of Bonneville Dam by about April 5, maybe April 8. The bi-state Columbia River Recreational Fishery Advisor Group got a look at the spring chinook options on Wednesday. It's not pretty because spring chinook headed for upstream of Bonneville Dam are forecast to number 141,400, down significantly from an actual return of 203,100 in 2012... Read more >