TCP Supports USA FREEDOM Act of 2015 Reining In NSA Domestic Surveillance

We will push to strengthen several provisions as the bill moves through the legislative process, and will oppose any efforts to extend the Patriot Act without meaningful reforms to end bulk collection.

Yesterday, a bipartisan group of lawmakers introduced legislation, called the USA FREEDOM Act of 2015, in the U.S. House and Senate to roll back domestic surveillance by the National Security Agency. 


The Constitution Project supports this significant step towards reining in the government's widespread, suspicionless surveillance of the American people, including the collection of our telephone call records as revealed by Edward Snowden nearly two years ago. This bipartisan bill attempts to protect fundamental civil liberties and privacy by prohibiting bulk collection of our private records, while still preserving the ability of the intelligence community to gather the targeted information it needs to help keep us safe.


The proposed legislation not only ends bulk collection, but also enhances transparency and accountability by improving reporting requirements to both Congress and the public regarding the scope of surveillance being conducted under certain laws.  It also includes important improvements to the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court.


As introduced, the USA FREEDOM Act of 2015 would:

  • end the bulk collection of Americans' records, including records collected under Section 215 of the Patriot Act, the FISA pen register statute, or National Security Letters, by requiring the government to narrowly tailor its collection;
  • increase transparency by allowing communications providers to disclose in more detail the number of surveillance orders they receive; 
  • require declassification of significant opinions issued by the secretive Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court (FISC), or preparation of a summary for the public if declassification is not possible; and
  • require the FISC to appoint a panel of security-cleared lawyers to advise the court in cases involving novel or significant interpretations of law. Among other duties, these "friends of the court" may present legal arguments that advance the protection of individual privacy and civil liberties. The Constitution Project released a report in May 2014 urging the appointment of such an advocate and setting forth requirements for making the advocate effective.

However, despite these meaningful reforms, there is more work to be done.  With your help, we will push to strengthen several provisions as the bill moves through the legislative process. We will also continue to oppose any efforts to extend the Patriot Act without meaningful reforms that put an end to bulk collection.


Similar surveillance reform legislation was introduced in the last Congress, but it stalled in the Senate on a procedural vote.  This new version enjoys even broader bipartisan support.  House Judiciary Chairman Bob Goodlatte (R-Va.), ranking member John Conyers (D-Mich.), and Reps. Jerrold Nadler (D-N.Y.) and Jim Sensenbrenner (R-Wisc.) -- the original author of the Patriot Act -- are all original cosponsors of the House version.  Senators Patrick Leahy (D-Vt.) and Mike Lee (R-Utah) are chief sponsors of the Senate version.


Unfortunately, Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) recently introduced legislation that would reauthorize the business records provisions of the Patriot Act without any reforms to surveillance programs or oversight mechanisms.  


TCP hopes that as the USA FREEDOM Act moves forward Congress will strengthen, not weaken, its provisions.  In particular, we urge Congress to enhance the government reporting provisions in the new bill by requiring the government to disclose the number of individuals whose information is collected under the business records provision of the Patriot Act, the FISA pen register/trap and trace statute, and Section 702 of FISA.  In addition, Congress should strengthen the provisions for a special advocate at the FISC by including a mandate to advance privacy and civil liberties.  Congress should also restore the provisions from last year's Senate bill that require the deletion of data on individuals who are not targets of an investigation or agents of a foreign power.


Regrettably, however, the new bill also contains an unrelated provision that would increase the maximum sentence for material support of foreign terrorist organizations from 15 years to 20 years. Cutting off support of terrorist activity is an important and legitimate part of the United States' counterterrorism strategy. But in providing the legal authority to prohibit and punish such conduct, it is essential that the law respect constitutional freedoms. As The Constitution Project Liberty and Security Committee outlined in its report on reforming the material support laws, the existing statute raises serious concerns under the First and Fifth Amendments because it defines "material support" so expansively and vaguely as to criminalize pure speech furthering only lawful, nonviolent ends. Congress should not exacerbate these problems by increasing the penalties without first addressing the statute's infringement on our constitutional rights.


We call on Congress to quickly pass the USA FREEDOM Act with these improvements, putting an end to the bulk collection of our phone records once and for all, and to then address other invasive surveillance programs, including the massive "incidental" collection of U.S. person communications under Section 702 of the FISA Amendments Act and Executive Order 12333, which govern surveillance of non-US persons abroad.


 

Sincerely,
 
Virginia E. Sloan


Support The Constitution Project

Created out of the belief that we must cast aside the labels that divide us in order to keep our democracy strong, The Constitution Project brings together policy experts and legal practitioners from across the political spectrum to foster consensus-based solutions to the most difficult constitutional challenges of our time through scholarship, advocacy, policy reform and public education initiatives. Established in 1997, TCP is based in Washington, D.C.  Help us further this crucial mission with your support today.