Ask the Pastor
Pastor Paul answers your questions
Q) Do you think a large part of the New Testament is anti-Semitic, especially in that it blames Jews for the crucifixion of Christ when it was very likely instigated by Roman authorities? Do you think there has been or will be an increase in the persecution of Jews by the "Religious Right" and others with extreme viewpoints because the New Testament is pro-Semitic because of various verses, like Romans 1:16 and 11:28?
A) There are several questions here and more issues behind the questions.
I would not use the words anti-Semitic or pro-Semitic to label anything in the Bible, because these words carry strong emotional connotations associated with the holocaust of the 20th century. We need to read the Bible on its own terms and not cloud its message by looking at it through a lens of events that happened centuries after the Bible was written. For the same reason, I rarely use the words 'slavery' or 'slave' to talk about slavery in Biblical times, because for people living in the 21st century United States, 'slavery' and 'slave' carry emotional connotations from slavery in America; and slavery in Bible times was quite different from American slavery.
I would like to restate the question in this way: Who is responsible for the crucifixion of Jesus? And I'll give the historic Lutheran answer from some of our hymns.
"My Song Is Love Unknown" Evangelical Lutheran Worship ELW #343 stanzas 3 and 4:
Sometimes we strew his way and his sweet praises
sing
resounding all the day hosannas to our King.
Then "Crucify!" is all our breath and for his death
we thirst and cry
We cry out, we will have our dear Lord made away,
a murderer to save, the prince of life to slay.
Yet cheerful he to suffering goes that he his foes
from thence might free.
"Ah, Holy Jesus" ELW #349 stanza 2
Who was the guilty? Who brought this upon thee?
Alas, my treason, Jesus, hath undone thee.
'Twas I, Lord Jesus, I it was denied thee.
I crucified thee.
Since Jesus died for the sins of the whole world, we who are in this world can never point our fingers at somebody else and say "They crucified Jesus."
Finally, the New Testament does not support any kind of persecution of any part of God's creation.