Since this is the first Lens in some
time, I am going "big picture". This is one of the most exciting - and
perilous - times in the history of the wireless industry. We're seeing
major shifts in the balance of power and business model transformation,
at a time of financial precariousness for the some of the industry's
historic heavyweights and uncertainty about the economy. Here are five
key themes that I believe will define the evolution of the wireless
industry over the next few years. I will be commenting much more on
these topics in the coming months.
The first key theme is the growing need for what I call "connectivity ubiquity".
If you look at the evolution of the Internet over the past three years,
two game-changing things have happened. First is the pervasiveness of
broadband (70% of HH with PCs, even more in other countries). Have you
noticed how many aspects of our day-to-day lives involve the Internet
in some way? Second is the nearly threefold increase in throughput to
the average user, which has enabled the emergence of entirely new use
categories such as social networking and UGC.
This
is a good news/bad news story for wireless. On the positive side,
wireless will be an important part of the need for constant connectivity. We'll see continued robust growth of laptop cards and data
subscriptions. On the negative side, even with continual network
"upgrades" (Rev-A, HSUPA), and the approach of 4G, wireless will
continue to have to compromise on the network side, from the standpoint
of user expectations and RF economics. My rule of thumb: wireless will continue to be a generation or more behind fixed-line broadband.
To illustrate this point, today's 3G networks are fine for "remote
access", which was the overriding market requirement - three years
ago. But it's inadequate for many of the multimedia applications
becoming more prevalent today. This fact of life will be a continual
governor of what we can offer customers, how we price our services, and
what expectations we can set. Don't expect to see "broadband
displacement" on the same scale as "landline displacement".
Second, the game has shifted in the handset space.
Other than more memory and better battery life, we're starting to max
out on the core capabilities we can offer on a standard cellphone
(witness the growth in smart phones as a percentage of sales). The
game is now centered around providing a better user experience. The
iPhone is a catalyst, but it's certainly not nirvana. There's lots of
opportunity for more, and better. The traditional governors of the UI -
operators and device OEMs - are finding themselves out their element.
Note that the wireless devices with the best overall user experience -
the iPhone, the Sidekick, and the Blackberry - are delivered with a
tight integration of hardware and software, and have intimate linkages
with the user's PC world. Expect some game-changing relationships and
thinking over the next couple of years. Et tu, Motorola?
Third: Business model transformation, led by the discussion of "open access".
There were some important chess moves in 2007: Android, iPhone, VZW
"Any App, Any Device" announcement, and the 700 MHz C-block. Over the next three years, the mobile value chain will undergo its biggest changes in the history of this industry. Let me
say this about open access: it is not a zero sum game. Major
operators want to remain relevant in the content game, and will
continue to offer marquee, premium content and applications to their
subscribers and the benefits of a more complete service experience.
But they have also realized that the Internet is ten years beyond its
AOL era and that power is in the hands of the user. Even the large
operators have relatively small teams devoted to individual products
and content. They have realized they can no longer optimize the
potential of the wireless Internet by being at the center of every application decision, nor can they provide the most effective "go to market" for all but the big hitters. The struggle will be to strike the right balance between
a more open model, and avoiding the three principal "dangers" the
PC/Internet model poses to the wireless world: poor security,
inappropriate content, and the customer service morass. All while
recognizing the economics of wireless will continue to be different
than the Internet.
The fourth theme, which has been abundantly illustrated in the events of the past few weeks, is that pricing is back.
We had been in a steady state for about three years. But with voice
MOU growth plateauing, subscriber penetration maturing, and such a
large percentage of subs on family plans, a new trick is needed.
Operators are moving away from a la carte offerings ($5 for this, $10
for that) toward what I call "large group ARPU lift". The first phase
of this was family plans, which focused on household ARPU and has been
a huge factor in lowering churn. The next phase, which we are now in
the midst of, is "premium unlimited" plans, such as the $20 data plans
for unlimited messaging and browsing and the unlimited voice plans,
such as the $99 plan recently announced by Verizon Wireless and matched
by AT&T and T-Mobile. That brings the wireless business into the
same "flat rate" framework that consumers are have become accustomed to
in other segments of their digital universe. But while we are moving
toward unlimited voice, there will be hhesitancy to do anything especially disruptive with data
pricing. It still costs hundreds of times more to
deliver a MB of data wirelessly compared to wireline. The next couple of years will also feature a greater
role for advertising, which will likely invite some level of "value
exchange". Greater involvement by Google and Microsoft in the industry
will push the envelope here. Also part of this next phase will be how
pricing for off-portal is handled.
The final theme is that the overall growth of the wireless industry over the next several years will be driven by "two worlds".
One world is that of developed wireless economies, where voice ARPU and
subscriber penetration have plateaued. Growth opportunities are
increasingly focused on non-voice services. In developing countries,
however, there are still huge opportunities for organic subscriber
growth. Hundreds of millions - if not billions - of subscribers will
never experience a landline phone. And for many, their wireless phone
will also be their primary data/Internet access device. The best
companies will mine those opportunities while adjusting to vastly
varying demographics and levels of affordability.