Dear Friends and Neighbors,
I know that many of you are frantically getting
ready for the new school year, planning for that
last weekend get-away, or dreading the onslaught of
?deferred? meetings that always seem to consume
September. As you may have seen in the news, our
Special Session on transportation has been set to
start on September 27th. I appreciate the feedback
I have received on this issue ? which I know is
important to all of us.
Despite the fact that it is August, there is
still much going on in the legislative arena that I
want to share with you. On Monday, I went to
Richmond to vote on the Governor?s recommendations
to House Bill 5019 ? a controversial piece of
legislation that both repeals the estate tax in
Virginia while at the same time cutting Virginia?s
land conservation tax credit program. However, that
debate quickly became overshadowed when news was
released of an error in the adopted budget that, if
not corrected, will result in approximately $130
million less being provided to public school
systems.
While this error may not have been a problem if
caught earlier, it is a significant problem now that
schools have adopted their budgets based on
incorrect assumptions. If left uncorrected,
appropriations to the City of Fairfax and Fairfax
County will be reduced by about $300,000 and $17
million, respectively. How did such an error occur?
In Governor Warner?s introduced budget, he
recommended accelerating the reduction of the sales
tax on food items so that the full reduction would
take place in FY 2007. The General Assembly agreed
and eventually adopted the idea. However,
associated adjustments to the distribution formulas
were not made correctly (a portion of the sales tax
goes to education), which resulted in overstating
the amount due to localities. I take a certain
amount of pride that it was Fairfax County staff
that discovered the error.
I had an opportunity to hear Governor Kaine
discuss the issue before a meeting of the joint
money committees of the House and Senate, where he
accepted full responsibility as chief executive
(although there is blame enough to go around).
Regardless, it is critical to make sure that steps
are taken to ensure that such an error does not
occur in the future. I have no doubt that the
Appropriations Committee and the entire General
Assembly will ask the tough questions ? as well we
should.
Equally important, though, is to make sure that
our children are not penalized for the State?s
error. While there were many promises to correct
the error on both sides of the aisle, final action
was deferred until September 27th. This I think
this was unfortunate, and I voted against deferral.
Any responsible school system can?t rely on just a
promise and will need to start cutting back programs
now. Not only will our schools need to wait an
entire month, but debate over the error will now
take up valuable time that was to be used solely for
transportation.
Now back to the conservation tax credit. Based
on current growth rates, Virginia will develop more
in the next 40 years than the last 400 years
combined. As unbelievable as it seems, it is a
stark reality. The quality of life of future
generations rests on having the foresight to plan
this growth in a balanced way.
Virginia?s conservation tax credit program allows
a property owner to take a credit for 50% of the
value of a property if he/she places it under a
permanent conservation easement. This is not only
important for cash-poor/land-rich farmers in fast
growing areas but also for preserving historic
properties and open space in Northern Virginia. The
program?s success is also part of the problem, at
least according to a majority in the Senate. The
program did not originally have a cap, and last year
cost about $130 million. At the same time, while
the House has blocked attempts to scale back the
credit in the past, a majority of the House has been
seeking repeal of Virginia?s estate tax, a proposal
consistently blocked by the Senate.
And so, House Bill 5019 was born. As originally
proposed, the measure linked repeal of the estate
tax with a cap on the tax credit of $50 million the
first year and $75 million for subsequent years ?
effectively cutting the program in half. Since it
was part of the budget deal, both sides swallowed
hard and passed the measure ? although I voted
against the bill along with 25 of my House
colleagues.
Governor Kaine, who has set a goal of preserving
an additional 400,000 acres of open space by the end
of the decade, proposed amendments to maintain the
cap, but set it at $100 million. He kept provisions
to ensure that the program was not abused, while
streamlining the process to keep down bureaucracy.
The amendments garnered unanimous support in the
House. However, passage was not without
controversy. While the initial cap was set at $100
million, the amendments provided that this amount
would rise automatically each year based on a
formula. This ?indexing? is nearly unprecedented in
Virginia. I have mixed feelings on it. On the one
hand, Virginia is notorious for not revisiting caps
that after a few decades become laughably obsolete.
On the other hand, I am concerned that fiscal
integrity is compromised because indexing lets
programs sail along on automatic pilot. Several
promises were made to remove this provision next
year and I suspect it will disappear after the next
Session.
Finally, I am pleased to announce that I will be
holding informal office hours on the second Saturday
of the month from 9:00 to 11:00 AM at Main Street
Bagel ? starting September 9th. This will be an
opportunity to just chat or to ask questions about
legislation affecting our community. Hope to see
you there! If you have a specific issue to discuss,
I am always happy to arrange one-on-one meetings.
Have a safe and happy Labor Day weekend!
Sincerely,
David Bulova