Dentists' Financial Poll and Newsletter 

3.08.2011         The Car Issue 

The Poll









Join Our Mailing List!



Access Carlsen Website








Find me on Facebook


The Business Climate Poll Report 

 

Business Tsunami 

 

I had several requests for a car poll---what  we drive; what we pay; how long we keep.  Therefore, this issue will be devoted to the automobile.  Next issue returns to diverse financial topics. Please let me know if you like or dislike....this newsletter is still in its infancy and I'm writing about what interests you!  

   

Please click on the left column to access this issue's Car Poll. All participants should now be able to view instant results when they participate.  I'll always report on the final results in the following issue.

 

These newsletter articles are written on a three-week time frame.  For up-to-the-day materials, please click on the <<<<<<< Facebook link to the left.  I provide links and comments on current financial information, along with photos of old dental farts....... 

    

 

Business Climate Results

 

My 2010 gross production vs. 2008 gross production was:

 

21-35% less       5%

11-20% less      18%

1-10%  less       36%

Even                 18%

1-10% higher    14%

11-20% higher    9%  

 

About half of us had less production in 2010 than 2008.  I used 2008 as reference, as most of us had worse years in 2009 and 2010.

 

Dental suppliers report that many offices, especially on the East and West Coasts, lost between 20-40% production in 2009 and 2010.  This survey does not support that.   

 

The mean production decline for this survey is around 5%.   

My net income for 2010 vs. 2008 was:

 

Over 35% less        5%

21-35%  less         10%

11-20% less            5%

1-10% less             28%

Even                       24%

1-10% higher          14%

11-20% higher        14% 

 

Again, about half had less net income.  The mean net income decline is about 3%---less than the average production loss of 5%.  This doesn't make statistical sense unless doctors with less production also lowered their overhead percentages.  That would be tough to accomplish without doctors consistently laying off employees.  Anecdotal evidence doesn't point in the direction that widespread layoffs occurred in the dental industry.   

 

My feeling is that many docs don't have final 2010 income figures yet and overestimated their 2010 income. Therefore, I would discount the net income data. 

 

The amount I plan to spend on major equipment purchases and office renovations in 2011 is:

 

None                53%

Up to $10K      18%

$11K-$25K      19%

$26K-$50K       5%

$51K-$100K     0%

Over $100K      5%

 

90% plan to spend $25K or less.  This would be expected.

 

I plan to change staff salaries and benefits in 2011 by:

 

Zero                           58%

Up to 2% more          18%

3-5% more                14%

Up to 2% less             5%

More than 2% less      5%

 

Most (76%) plan either no increase or very minimal. Again, this would be expected.

   

 

Please click here  or at the top of the left hand "poll" column to participate in the new Car Poll.  Results will be posted next newsletter.  Note that I do not view individual responses to any of these questions---all are anonymous.

 

 

 

 



                         Logo
To have me speak to your study club or dental society, please email me at drcarlsen@gmail.com or call 760-535-1621.  For information on products and services, please click on the above logo.

A Dentist's Guide to Auto Purchases   

 

 

Edsel 

An elderly man was driving his Buick down the freeway when his cell phone rang.

Answering, he heard his wife's voice urgently warning him, "Herman, I just heard on the news that there's a car going the wrong way on 280. Please be careful!"

 

"It's not just one car," said Herman. "It's hundreds of them!"  

 

 

I actually learned to drive on an Edsel that looked remarkably like the above. Yeah, they were considered ugly, even in the early 60s.

 

Much of our live revolves around the automobile.  Let's look at a process for a professional to find the best deal.

 

Find your car and options

 

Look at auto websites for the various models and options available for the cars you may wish to test drive. 

 

Join Consumer Reports online for either $5.95 for a month or $26 for a year. This is your most valuable $5.95 ever spent.  You'll see why as we go along......

 

Go online to Consumer Reports to look up reliability ratings.  Most dentists don't do this step and end up with a German auto that runs great for a couple years, then spends many lonely nights in the shop. BMW, Mercedes, and Volkswagen have had average to poor reliability ratings for the last decade.  Likewise, not all Toyotas have great reliability. 

 

Take test drives at the dealers of the models you are interested in.  This part is really fun these days because you will not even think of purchasing at this point. You will deal online almost exclusively. 

 

Make a short list of the autos and options you are interested in.

 

New Cars

 

Order a New Car Price Report from Consumer Reports.  You will receive bottom-line prices for all factory-installed options and all packages.  Most importantly, you will also receive dealer incentive and holdback information not found elsewhere.  Yes, you may be able to purchase below dealer invoice!  This step is a must for everyone.

 

Also order a trade-in report from Consumer Reports, whether you plan to trade in or sell your old auto privately.

 

CR also now offers a free new car pricing service for subscribers.  Certified dealers will send you quotes for the exact auto(s) you are interested in.  You can compare to your invoices.

 

New car reports are $14 for the first and $12 for each additional.  Used car reports are $12. Click here or call 1-866-528-8742.

 

USAA offers a similar service for new and used cars.  Free membership is available for the service.  Financing may also be available from USAA.

 

Costco also provides a service for new and certified pre-owned cars.

 

I've heard good reports from all of these avenues.

 

For either the USAA or Costco programs, having the Consumer Reports New Car Price Report is still a must, as the report details dealer discounts and incentives not found on other pricing reports.

 

Remember to always deal from the CR dealer bottom line price.  Pay no attention to the sticker price.  Laugh at "Reduced $2,000" stickers.

 

Once you've chosen the dealer with the best price, no matter which of the programs above you use, or whether you deal on your own, you can still haggle the price.  You are under no obligation to accept the dealer's price offer.  Of course, you do need to provide some profit, normally in the $500+ range.

 

After coming to a price, you go to the dealer, sign the forms, and take your vehicle home!

 

Trade-in?  Discuss only after you have finished all else.  You have your pricing report on your vehicle, so know the range to expect.  Normally the dealer will severely low-ball you.  In that case, walk out.  Auto Trader works well today for personal selling of vehicles.

 

One final note:  always secure financing through your bank or credit union.  You will never get the best deal from the dealer.

 

Used cars

 

Test-driving isn't as simple, yet many "like" vehicles are found at dealers' used car departments. I prefer to test-drive at the dealers, rather than with private parties, as often you may find more than one car to test at a dealer. 

 

For pricing, I use NADA found at http://www.nadaguides.com/Cars. An easy menu guides you to proper pricing with various options and mileages.

 

To find your auto, you may use one of the above services from Costco or USAA, or use AutoTrader.com. AutoTrader is easy to negotiate to find a vehicle anywhere in the US.  Private, dealer, and "dealer certified pre-owned" are all listed. For autos with under the basic warranty mileage, normally 36,000, being "certified" isn't important.

 

I'm a big fan of buying the two-year old used vehicle.  Many one-year old vehicles are from the rental agencies and may be fairly beaten-up.  You can find if an auto has been a rental on the Car Fax certificate, normally found with other vehicle information on AutoTrader.  Anything but a rental is fine to purchase.  I've bought corporate fleet vehicles in the past with great success. 

 

If you look at private vehicles, always have a mechanic check.  This may cost $50, yet is well worth it.  For dealers, I don't think necessary if still on warranty. 

 

I normally will buy at a dealer, as they tend to detail the vehicles better and are under at least some local scrutiny. 

 

Certified pre-owned? There are two types of certified pre-owned vehicles: ones that are backed by the manufacturer and ones that are certified by a private party. Watch out for dealerships and independent used-car lots that simply slap a "certified" sticker on a windshield, then try to pass that vehicle off as having gone through the same checks dictated by a manufacturer's program.

 

Buying "certified" is OK, but I think overkill for newer models.  I've never bought "certified" and never had a problem.  It adds $500-$1,500 for non-luxury cars and up to $4,000 for luxury autos. If an extended warranty is included in the extra price, it may be worth considering.

 

Let's now look at how one may save a bundle on an exotic masterpiece.

 

The new 2011 Mercedes SL 550 Roadster may be yours for a mere $100K.  Would I ever recommend to spend that much?  Sure, if you pay cash and still fully fund your retirement plan. 

 

At the NADA website, I found a 2008 Mercedes SL 550 in clean condition with 30,000 miles would be dealer priced for an average of $56,000.  It has depreciated $14K per year those first three years!  Ouch!  In researching further, I found that if you kept the car ten years, it would be worth about $14K in 2021.  In other words, it will only depreciate $4K per year over its remaining lifetime.

 

Why buy a great looking car for $100,000 that will be worth $90,000 off the floor and $80,000 in a year when you can get a beautiful one still on warranty for 45% discount?

 

This is only a short primer on car purchasing.  Several other areas of research were not included.  Please go to Consumer Reports for a full guide on purchasing an auto.

 

  

Newsletter Archives

 
Click Here for Archives.


Education is the Key
                                                AGC Logo
Approved PACE Program Provider.
                                                             Provider FAGD/MAGD Credit.

                                                             Approval does not imply
                                                             acceptance by a state or
                                                             provincial board of dentistry
                                                             or AGD endorsement.
                                                              (8/1/2010) to (7/31/2011)


Please take note that all materials published in this newsletter are of an educational nature.   

 

I have no financial connection with any business or individual other than my wife. 

 

My mission is to provide educational resources for dentists to make prudent, not risky financial decisions.  Being an AGD/PACE approved program provider assists and amplifies the responsibility to help dentists succeed.

 

Please send comments and suggestions for future articles and polls to drcarlsen@gmail.com.  

 

Doug C.