TopS&S Horizontal Logo

In This Issue:
  
Quick Links:  
SpotlightAttorney Spotlight 
Michele Web Photo
Michele L. Courneya, Esq.

Michele heads up Starfield & Smith's Minneapolis, Minnesota branch office. She practices in the areas of banking, contracts, real estate and commercial law with an emphasis on SBA lending.

Michele is the former Minnesota District Counsel, Senior Franchise Counsel, Chair of the Authorization Committee and Chair of the Streamlining 504 Closing Committee for the U. S. Small Business Administration. During her 15 years with the SBA, Michele was instrumental in writing, editing, updating and automating the SBA's loan authorizations, the Agency's primary contracts with lenders. She developed and implemented internal control systems at the SBA to streamline program procedures and drafted and edited rules and regulations implementing new agency policies. In addition, she oversaw agency websites on franchises and advised on franchise eligibility issues. As a nationally recognized expert, Michele has extensive background assisting the lending community on legal issues related to all SBA programs including regulatory compliance, ethical issues, eligibility, and loan processing, closing, liquidation and litigation. Since joining the firm, she has assisted with the revisions to the SOP 50-10(5) and the new liquidation regulations.

Michele has taught seminars on loan closing, documentation, franchising and other legal issues related to SBA lending for the National Association of Development Companies (NADCO) and the National Association of Government Guaranteed Lenders (NAGGL), who named Michele "Instructor of the Year" for 2008. She is a member of NAGGL and an affiliate member of NADCO and is qualified as a designated closing attorney under the SBA 504 Program.

twitterStarfield & Smith, P.C. is on twitter! Follow us for links to our most recent news and articles. Click here to follow us:  
 
Follow me on Twitter
 
Back to Top

Best Practices: Guaranty Purchases

and the Materiality Standard

By Ethan W. Smith, Esq.

Ethan Smith
Ethan W. Smith, Esq.

               SBA lenders that are facing loan defaults are often daunted by the SBA guaranty purchase process.  Much of this uncertainty results from lenders' lack of familiarity with the guaranty purchase process utilized by the National Guaranty Purchase Center ("NGPC") in Herndon, VA.  In addition to the unfamiliarity with the process, lenders are often concerned about the standard of review that is employed by NGPC personnel in conducting their purchase reviews.  Of particular concern to lenders is how to address deficiencies that they identify in their files, and how to assess the magnitude of these deficiencies in determining how best to proceed.

 

                The standard of review employed by the NGPC is one of "materiality."  Simply put, the NGPC will only recommend repairs or denials of the SBA guaranty for deficiencies that are "material" in nature.  But what does "material" mean to the SBA?  Based upon conversations with Agency personnel, a deficiency is "material" if it caused or significantly contributed to the cause of the loss to the lender and/or the SBA.  Some examples of material deficiencies would be: failing to obtain the proper lien position on collateral; failing to properly verify the financial records and tax returns of the borrower and/or seller; failing to maintain hazard insurance on collateral that is subsequently destroyed; failing to perform a timely site visit after default where collateral is removed by the borrower or damaged; and other similar types of deficiencies.  Non-material deficiencies would include: failing to obtain an acknowledged collateral assignment of life insurance, where the insured did not die; failing to perfect a lien on collateral that has declined in value; failing to maintain hazard insurance on collateral that was not destroyed; and other "no harm - no foul" events.  Although the application of the materiality standard seems quite straightforward, there is one critical nuance that lenders must keep in mind in analyzing their loan files.

 

                Specifically, lenders must remember that the SBA does not apply the materiality standard to eligibility determinations.  For questions of eligibility, SBA employs a strict compliance standard, instead of a material compliance standard.  This means that from the SBA's standpoint, any deviation from the eligibility guidelines, however small, renders the loan ineligible, resulting in a recommendation for a complete denial of the guaranty.  In some instances this standard is easy to comply with: i.e. size standards; eligible types of businesses; personal resources.  In these situations it is usually quite easy to see what side of the eligibility line your loan falls on.  Other eligibility determinations are less clear, such as franchise/jobber/license eligibility determinations.  The subjective nature of a franchise eligibility analysis begs the question of whether a PLP lender should ever perform such an analysis on its own, since the chances that the SBA may reach a different conclusion as to the franchise's eligibility is quite high.  Until the SBA implements a materiality standard for franchise eligibility reviews, the only way for lenders to ensure that their non-registry franchise loans are eligible, is to submit them under General Processing. 

 

Whatever the issue, it is critical that lenders be precise and exacting in making eligibility determinations as the standards are so strict (strict compliance, not material compliance), the margin for error is so razor thin, and the consequences of an incorrect determination are so dire.  By employing the correct compliance standard in making eligibility determinations, lenders can preserve and protect the SBA guaranty and avoid denial recommendations.

 

                For more information on SBA guaranty preservation and guaranty purchase reviews, contact Ethan at esmith@starfieldsmith.com, or 215-542-7070.

 

 Back to Top
knowDid you know...

 Banner Stand
...that Starfield & Smith, P.C. will be at the NAGGL Annual Conference? Visit us at our booth in Anaheim, California October 26 - 28.
 
Please stop by Booth #22 to learn more about the services we provide to lenders nationwide!
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
SeminarsEventsUpcoming Seminars and Events
  
 
Presented by: NAGGL
Dates: October 25th, 2010
Location: Anaheim, CA - NAGGL Annual Conference
 
For more information about this event, please clock here.
Register online here.
 
The Guarantee Purchase Process
 
Presented by: NAGGL
Dates: October 26th, 2010
Location: Anaheim, CA - NAGGL Annual Conference
 
For more information about this event, please click here.
Register online here.

 
Starfield & Smith, P.C. is on Facebook!
 
Become a fan of Starfield & Smith, P.C.  on facebook to receive updates, articles, and news pertaining to SBA and lending related topics. Just click on the badge above to get started!
  
Not on facebook? Sign up for free here.
 
Ad Road No Info 
 
ContactInfo Starfield & Smith, P.C.
Pennsylvania Office
501 Office Center Drive,
Suite 350 | Ft. Washington, PA 19034
phone: (215) 542-7070 | fax: (215) 542-0723
 
Minnesota Office
1516 West Lake Street, Suite 303 | Minneapolis, MN 55408
phone: (612) 208-0877 | fax: (215) 542-0723

http://www.starfieldsmith.com
 
 Loan Documentation | Closing | SBA Guaranty Repurchase
Regulatory Compliance | Franchise Eligibility
Business Consulting
 
This email is an advertisement from Starfield & Smith, P.C. and is subject to this disclaimer.
 © 2009-2010 Starfield & Smith, P.C. All Rights Reserved