Filipino SeafarersIndian Merchant Marine FamilyMilitary Sealift Command MarinerCrowley MarinerFemail US Mariner
March 19, 2010
Newsletter 9
Seafaers 2010SEAFARERS 2010:
GULF COAST REGIONAL CONFERENCE ON SEAFARER WELFARE ISSUES
In This Issue
Introduction Letter to Conference
Ship/Shore Access
Criminalization of Unintended Pollution
29-Day Rule
Seafarer Manslaughter Act
Admrial Allen's State of the Coast Guard
Quick Links
Our Sponsors
Seafaers 2010
Visit Our Sponsor
Greetings!

The conference went great last week. More than 65 people participated in the two-day event. They came from as far east as Washington, D.C., and as far west as Corpus Christi, and they were drawn from the shipping industry, governmental regulatory agencies, congressional staff, maritime trade unions, seafarer welfare agencies, maritime attorneys, ship agents, and facility security officers.

The organizers want to extend a special thanks to Congressman Gene Green who opened the conferernce, and for the attendance of staff from Congressmen Ted Poe and Ron Paul, and Senator Kay Bailey Hutchinson.

Because of the generous sponsorships that made Seafarer 2010 possible, we are able to make a contribution to a Gulf Coast seafarer center. So, we are pleased to congratulate the Houston International Seafarer Center for being the winner of our drawing. They will be receiving a check $200.00. Congratulations!

Below are five documents. The first is a cover letter putting the conference in context. That is followed by the four documents that were developed by the work groups, and then approved by the concensus of the conference.

Our hope is that these documents will stimulate discussion, and be used by national organizations and others to improve the lives of all seafarers.


Fr. Sinclair Oubre, J.C.L.
Diocesan Director

Apostleship of the Sea

2010 Seafarer Regional Conference

Houston, Texas

March 9&10, 2010

 

In 2009, the International Maritime Organization's Secretary-General Efthimios Mitropoulos declared 2010, The Year of the Seafarer. He calls on the international community to recognize the important role that mariners play in all our lives. Specifically he listed as some of the objectives of the Year of the Seafarer:

 

  1. To provide the maritime community with an opportunity to pay tribute to seafarers for their unique contribution to society and in recognition of the vital part they play in the facilitation of global trade;

 

  1. To reassure those working at the "sharp end" of the industry that those responsible for the international regulatory regime and those who serve shipping from ashore understand the extreme pressures that seafarers face and, as a result, approach their own work with a genuine sympathy for the work that seafarers carry out; and

 

  1. To convey to the 1.5 million seafarers of the world a clear message that the entire shipping community understands and cares for them - as shown by the efforts to ensure that seafarers are fairly treated when ships become involved in accidents; are looked after when abandoned in ports; are not refused shore leave for security purposes; are protected when their work takes them into piracy-infested areas; and also to ensure that they are not left alone when in distress at sea.

 

In response to the call of the IMO Secretary-General, members of shipping, maritime labor, seafarer welfare and ship agency communities in the Gulf Coast Region gathered in Houston on March 9 & 10, 2010. Seafarers 2010 was an opportunity to reflect on the importance of merchant sailors, recognize their importance in commerce, and speak out against policies and procedures fail to respect mariners' dignity, and in some cases, have criminalized situations that are considered civil issues in other arenas.

 

The conference addressed four issues:

 

1.       Ship/Shore Access

2.       29-Day Rule

3.       Criminalization of Unintended Pollution

4.       Seafarers Manslaughter Act

 

In the spirit of the Year of the Seafarer, the organizers of Seafarers 2010 offer the following four documents for reflection and action. We hope that our regional conference, and its products will be a catalyst for a national discussion, as well as the beginning of coordinated efforts to target and change policies, regulations and laws that fail to honor our merchant mariners.

 

These issues affect all seafarers. Some are affected more than others, but in the spirit of solidarity, we raise our voices with and for those who, because of their work and their status, can least protest.

 

The Organizers

Seafarer 2010

Houston Texas


Ship/Shore Access
2010 Sefarer Regional Conference
Houston, Texas
March 9&10, 2010


WHEREAS International Commerce is the foundation upon which the welfare of this country rests.

WHEREAS more than 95% of US International Commerce is carried by sea.

WHEREAS the seafarers manning the vessels are proud, hard working and law abiding citizens who professionally fulfill the duties needed for International Commerce to continue.

WHEREAS International Commerce would be seriously impaired if even a few thousand seafarers refused to man the vessels.

WHEREAS the United States Coast Guard in Alcoast 108 / 08 recognized that, "Licensed and documented mariners are professionals who share our interests in a safe, secure and environmentally compliant industry".

WHEREAS the US Coast Guard has an existing program titled PTP (Prevention Through People), where they have specifically mentioned that the seafarer is one of the outer layers of defense under the marine domain awareness.

WHEREAS, in the Houston waterway alone, each year 170,000 International seafarers visit and contribute to the local economy if allowed free access to shore leave. Additionally, shore access issues potentially affect more than 1400 US mariners who call in the Houston waterway each day.

WHEREAS it is recognized that fatigue is a major contributing factor to maritime accidents, and it is recognized that shore leave is necessary for morale and as a remedy for fatigue and stress, it is in the public interest that seafarers not be fatigued and that a high level of morale while be maintained.

WHEREAS the United States is signatory to treaties and a party to international conventions (ISPS) that guarantee shore access.

WHEREAS the Regulations governing facility security have always provided for  access to shore.

WHEREAS the legal department of the USCG has reviewed the requirements and issued an opinion that such access is a requirement of an approved Facility Security Plan.

WHEREAS the United States Coast Guard has issued an ALCOAST 575 / 09 directing the USCG Sectors to review Facility Security Plans to include adequate access.

WHEREAS Admiral Allen stated on February 12, 2010, at the National Press Club in Washington, D.C., that this is a priority for him and the Coast Guard.

BE IT RESOLVED:

That Congress should approve the USCG Appropriations Bill, which, as in versions since 2004, directs the USCG to remedy access to shore leave at ". . . no cost to the seafarer".

That the USCG should direct each Facility Security Officer to clearly state that the Facility Security Plan meets the expectation of the USCG in providing access to Shore Leave, Seafarer Welfare organizations, Labor Unions, stores, bunkers and other services necessary for the normal operation of the vessel at no expense to the Seafarer.

Further, it should be recognized that the failure to provide for access is a contrary to the intent of the Code of Federal Regulations, International Treaty and standards of treatment of seafarers and should not be tolerated. Continued violation of the intent of the regulations to provide access should result in penalties to the violator.

Criminalization of Seafarers By Governments

In Light of Unintentional Pollution Incidents

 

WHEREAS merchant sailors transport needed commodities and goods to peoples around the world in very hostile and dangerous environments;

 

WHEREAS merchant sailors must be responsible stewards of the oceans and the environment.

 

WHEREAS in the course of performing their duties, accidents may occur that cause environmental pollution;

WHEREAS disturbing reports from Spain (M/V Prestige), Korea (M/V Hebei Spirit), the United States (M/V Cosco Buson) and Norway (M/V Full City) show a strong tendency to prosecute mariners under criminal pollutions legislation;

WHEREAS experienced merchant sailors are reevaluating their continued work in certain areas of the marine industry, and moving toward retirement to avoid potential criminal prosecution;

 

WHEREAS Efthimios Mitropoulos, Secretary-General of the International Maritime Organization, predicts a world-wide shortage of 40,000 mariners in 2011, and 53,000 mariners by 2013.*

 

WHEREAS the world maritime industry struggles to recruit and retain experienced merchant mariners, the criminal prosecution of unintended pollution acts will only exacerbate these shortages;

 

WHEREAS shipping companies, maritime labor unions, seafarer welfare agencies, and mariners interpret the recent prosecution of mariners as a stereotyping that assumes mariners are dangerous criminals, of whom authorities must take exceptional action, exercise special caution, and target special practices;

 

BE IT RESOLVED THAT after competent investigation, criminal prosecution of the merchant mariner be limited to pollution that is proximately caused by an intentional act or omission on the part of the merchant mariners.

 

AND THAT government agencies (local, state or federal) recognize the need for greater understanding of the uniqueness of the maritime industry.

 

AND THAT governmental efforts focus on determining the cause of the accident, the development of procedures that could prevent future accidents, and the improving of response methods and response time.

 

AND THAT a case of negligence to duty shall not be prosecuted in a criminal manner;

 

AND THAT as an alternative to pursuing individual merchant mariners, government agencies (local, state or federal) may pursue civil penalties against the responsible vessel owners, business entities, and individuals.

 

AND THAT when there is criminal intent, the full power of the law should be applied.

 

*Bahamas Maritime Authority Secretary General Call for Seafarers, by Genea Noel. The Freeport News, Freeport, Bahamas, February 12, 2010.


The 29 Day Rule Resolution

Seafarers Conference 2010

Port of Houston, Texas

 

Whereas international commerce is the foundation upon which the welfare of this country rests;


Whereas the crews manning vessels making foreign commerce possible for thousands of years are proud, hard-working, and honest ordinary citizens of their respective countries who take pride in their chosen profession;


Whereas international commerce would be non-existent without ocean transport and the crews to man the vessels;


Whereas 95% of foreign commerce is carried by sea;


Whereas U.S. Coast Guard Commandant Thad Allen in ALCOAST 108/08 expressed his expectations and clearly stated that, "licensed and documented mariners are professionals who share our interests in a safe, secure and environmentally compliant industry";


Whereas it is widely reported that crewmen arriving in the United States are being subjected to extra scrutiny and lengthy inspection procedures when presenting their D-1 visa at airports;


Whereas it is imperative that all countries contribute to the safe transportation of the world's commerce;


Whereas it is imperative that crews manning vessel carrying foreign commerce are trained and experienced;


Whereas it is recognized that fatigue is a major contributing factor to maritime accidents;


Whereas it is recognized that shore leave is the best remedy against fatigue and stress and maintains the morale onboard the vessel;

           

Whereas crewmen are professionals who should be recognized as such as any other foreign business person visiting the United States;

           

Whereas the 29 day rule has not been uniformly enforced to alien crewmen;

           

Whereas the 29-day rule has been in effect since 1953, permissions have as a usual practice been granted to allow crewmen to go ashore while their ship was in a U.S. port;

           

Whereas Customs and Border Protection has recently begun to enforce the rule inconsistently;

            

Whereas 8 C.F.R. 253 provides for parole of alien crewmen, 8 C.F.R. 253.1 (g) specifically provides that the CBP District Director may grant a parole to crewmen for emergent reasons or for reasons deemed strictly in the public interest;

           

Whereas crewmen who have unintentionally remained in the United States because their vessel's departure was delayed have had their visas revoked, contrary to the authority of  8 C.F.R. 253(g), causing an unnecessary hardship to a person who did not intentionally violate the law;

           

Whereas it is in the public interest that crewmen of vessels of all nationalities are well rested and not fatigued and maintain a high morale while onboard their vessel; and

           

Whereas the United States has a vested interest in promoting a positive opinion about our country and to that end should treat visitors with courtesy and respect.


Be it resolved:

           

That the maritime industry work together with the Commissioner of Customs and Border Protection to establish a protocol for parole to be applied consistently nationwide, as per 8 C.F.R. 253 (g), to an alien seafarer, who must unintentionally stay in the United States past 29 days for emergent reasons or for reasons deemed strictly in the public interest; and 

           

That the U.S. Department of State and the Commissioner of Customs and Border Protection issue a memorandum expressing an expectation that seafarers be treated with respect while visiting the United States and be granted all privileges they are entitled to and treated in a like manner as all other visitors.



A Resolution Addressing
the Criminalization of Seafarers
& The Application of the Seafarer Manslaughter Act

2010 Seafarer Regional Conference
Houston, Texas
March 9&10, 2010

 
 
WHEREAS there is growing concern over the increasing trend to criminalize maritime accidents;
 
WHEREAS the Council of American Master Mariners and the International Federation of Shipmasters' Associations have adopted several resolutions concerning this worrisome trend of criminalization of seafarers by port state control authorities; and calling  "upon the International Maritime Organization (IMO) and the International Labour Organization (ILO) and other maritime and regulatory interests to use professional and civil sanctions, rather than criminal action, to penalize simple negligence;
 
WHEREAS the burden of proof  for shipboard personnel to be found guilty under the Seafarer Manslaughter Act is currently interpreted as simple negligence;
 
WHEREAS other operaters of commercial carriers are not subject to this same standard;

WHEREAS IMO and ILO member States abide by the Guidelines on the Fair Treatment of Seafarers, adopted by the IMO Legal Committee in April 2006, there is great concern that foreign authorities will take retaliatory action against U.S. seafarers in similar circumstances;

RESOLVE, that the participants drawn from a varied group of maritime interests, including AMO, AOS USA, BIMCO, CAMM, IFSMA, ITF, MEBA, MM&P, Nautical Institute, Nautilus, NAMMA, and SIU* during its 2010 Seafarers Regional Conference in Houston, Texas, join their voices in an effort to ensure that simple negligence not be a sufficient burden of proof to hold seafarers criminally liable for maritime accidents; AND
 
RESOLVE, that the United States Congress review the Seaman's Manslaughter Act (US Code Title 18, Chapter 51, Sec. 1115) in light of the IMO Resolution Reg.3(91) of April 27, 2006, Guidelines for the Treatment of Seafarers in the Event of a Maritime Accident, and clarify that it be applied only to cases of willful, callous, reckless or other intentional misconduct.
 
RESOLVE, that the language of 18 USC 1115 be amended as follows:
 
18 USC 1115 - Sec. 1115. Misconduct of ship officers
Every captain, engineer, pilot, or other person employed on any steamboat or vessel, by whose willful, recklessness or other intentional misconduct the life of any person is destroyed, and every owner, charterer, inspector, or other public officer, through whose gross negligence, recklessness or other intentional misconduct, the life of any person is destroyed, shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than ten years, or both. When the owner or charterer of any steamboat or vessel is a corporation, any executive officer of such corporation, for the time being actually charged with the control and management of the operation, equipment, or navigation of such steamboat or vessel, who has knowingly and willfully caused or allowed such fraud, neglect, connivance, misconduct, or violation of law, by which the life of any person is destroyed, shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than ten years, or both.

Historical And Revision Notes
Based on title 18, U.S.C., 1940 ed., Sec. 461 (Mar. 4, 1909, ch. 321, Sec. 282, 35 Stat. 1144). Section restores the intent of the original enactments, R.S. Sec. 5344, and act Mar. 3, 1905, ch. 1454, Sec. 5, 33 Stat. 1025, and makes this section one of general application.
In the Criminal Code of 1909, by placing it in chapter 11, limited to places within the special maritime and territorial jurisdiction of the United States, such original intent was inadvertently lost as indicated by the entire absence of report or comment on such limitation.
AMENDMENTS 1994 - Pub. L. 103-322 substituted "fined under this title" for "fined not more than $10,000" in two places.

*List of Acronyms:

  1. AMO - American Maritime Officers
  2. AOS USA - Apostleship of the Sea of the United States of America
  3. BIMCO - Baltic & International Maritime Council
  4. CAMM - Council of American Master Mariners
  5. ISFMA - International Federation of Shipmasters' Association
  6. ITF - International Federation of Transport Workers
  7. MEBA - Marine Engineers' Beneficiary Associaiton
  8. MM&P - Master, Mates & Pilots
  9. NI - Nautical Institute
  10. Nautilus - Nautilaus Internationa
  11. NAMMA - North American Maritime Ministry Association
  12. SIU - Seafarers International Union
Admiral Allen at the National Press Club Admiral Thad Allen's State of the Coast Guard Address



More information will follow soon.

Sincerely,
 

Capt. Tom Hudson
President
Nautical Institute Gulf Brant

Fr. Sinclair Oubre, J.C.L.
Diocesan Director
The Apostleship of the Sea