From the Desk of Deborah Goldfarb

Hate Speech and Civil Discourse
February 23, 2010
Greetings!


Westboro1Recent events have left many Jewish community members wondering how to draw a line between freedom of speech and defending against hate.

Over the past two weeks the Long Beach/Orange County area has witnessed two disturbing events: protests by the anti-Semitic and homophobic Westboro Baptist Church (WBC) in Long Beach and aggressive heckling of Israeli Ambassador Michael Oren by Muslim Student Union members at UC Irvine. 
 
Earlier this month, UCI Muslim Student Union (MSU) members repeatedly interrupted Israeli ambassador Michael Oren, shouting and preventing his speech over a nine- minute period before being escorted out by police. Ultimately, 11 students were arrested.  UCI Chancellor Michael Drake issued a statement saying that the university will not accept attempts "to suppress the rights of others" to free speech, but it is not yet clear what additional steps university administrators will take.
 
Last weekend, in another display of hate, a small group of WBC members carried virulently anti-Semitic and homophobic picket signs at over ten appearances in the area, seven Jewish. Over a six-week period prior to their protest, the local ADL, Long Beach Police Department and Jewish Federation monitored their plans and advised Jewish organizations. The Jewish community chose to face this hate speech by marginalizing the group who was seeking publicity.
Westboro

While the Jewish Community was criticized by the Jewish Defense League, who showed up for one appearance of the WBC at the Alpert Jewish Community Center, the strategy proved positive. The general Long Beach community came out in strong support of our institutions and the GLBT community, and the Long Beach Police Department did an excellent job of working with us to ensure that protests would be peaceful.

 
Unfortunately, the press did not cover the positive aspects of support for the Jewish community, such as the nearly 250 people who danced and sang in peaceful counter protest near the Alpert Jewish Community Center, the 300 interfaith community leaders and members who attended a Shabbat service of unity at Temple Israel, or the neighbors who came out spontaneously to support Temple Israel, Temple Beth Shalom and Temple Beth David. 
 
While we as a community chose not to intervene by countering hate with hate, these events demonstrate the need for us to speak out, educate and promote appropriate civil discourse.  Our students on campus need our help to garner support in a hostel environment, just as the Long Beach community supported us.
 
The Jewish Federation of Orange County is circulating a petition to UCI administration asking them to take action in response to the recent attempts by radical students to suppress free speech rights on campus.  Please join us in supporting this effort by clicking here to sign on to the petition.

 
Westboro2 In similar efforts here our Federation community relations efforts will focus on encouraging CSULB administration to take a stand in promoting appropriate civil discourse during March "Apartheid" Week demonstrations on campus, when radical anti-Israel and anti-Semitic speakers spew their hate on campus and continue attempt to demonize and delegitimize Israel. For more information see www.israeliapartheidweek.com.
 
As we move forward on expanding our efforts, I welcome your thoughts.


Shabbat Shalom and Chag Purim Sameach,
Deborah's signature
Deborah Goldfarb
Executive Director of Jewish Federation of Greater Long Beach

Jewish Federation of Greater Long Beach and West Orange County

Facebook                                              Twitter Logo
                                                                                Check us out on twitter too!