Health Plans Expand Dental Benefits
Studies Linking Gum Disease To Health Problems Spur New Focus On Preventive Treatments
By M.P. MCQUEEN
September 19, 2006
Amid mounting evidence linking poor oral hygiene to
a range of expensive medical problems, health plans
are starting to cover more dental treatments and
preventive services.
The idea, insurers say, is that paying for certain
services now, such as additional cleanings, gum
treatments and prescription mouth washes, can reduce
the incidence of other health problems down the
road. A number of studies suggest that early
prevention and treatment of gum disease may result
in significantly improved outcomes for pregnancy,
heart disease and diabetes, often leading to
substantial medical-cost savings.
Many of the insurers' enhanced benefits are focused
on people with these health risks. Cigna Corp.'s
Oral Health Integration Program, implemented earlier
this year, covers additional deep cleanings known as
scaling and root planing during pregnancy at no
extra cost, or an additional regular cleaning (over
the usual two a year) for pregnant women who don't
require scaling and root planing. A similar benefit
is available for patients in Cigna's diabetes and
cardiac-care disease-management programs.
In March, Washington Dental Service, a member of the
Delta Dental Plans Association, introduced enhanced
benefits, including coverage of antimicrobial
mouthwashes for pregnant women, to its members in
2,000 companies in the state. Aetna Inc., with 8.8
million members who have both dental and medical
coverage, has conducted pilot programs designed to
get pregnant women and people with chronic disease
to visit a dentist. The company expects to offer a
third regular cleaning each year, or additional deep
cleanings as needed, to all such at-risk patients
next year.
"We can save medical costs by getting people to have
dental care at the right time in their lives," says
Glenn Melenyk, dental consultant at Blue Cross Blue
Shield of Michigan in Detroit. The insurer, with 1.1
million dental members, started pilot programs in
2005 that cover an additional regular cleaning per
year for diabetics and heart patients. In July, it
expanded the pilots to include pregnant women who
obtain a coupon from their obstetrician.
The enhanced benefits come at a time when many
employers are under pressure to cut medical costs.
But some big employers are signing on. Ford Motor
Co. and Kellogg Co. are among those offering
benefits in Michigan via Blue Cross Blue Shield, and
Pacific Research Laboratories and KCTS Public
Television are participating in Washington Dental's
enhanced benefits. Some health plans, including
Michigan Blue Cross, Washington Dental and MetLife
Inc., are offering the extra coverage at no
additional cost to employers or employees.
Washington Dental says it achieved this by cutting
back coverage of other services for which there is
less evidence of benefits, such as routine X-rays.
(Currently, insurers say, dental care makes up only
about 4% of employers' overall health-care budget.)
Costco Wholesale Corp. of Issaquah, Wash., earlier
this year participated in a pilot with Aetna Medical
& Dental, in which nurses called employees with
diabetes or heart disease or who were pregnant, to
encourage them to visit a dentist. Donna Sexton,
Costco's director of employee benefits, says nurses
reached about 2,200 of Costco's more than 153,000
Aetna members. About 36% of them have indicated they
would go see a dentist as a result. That is "pretty
good compared to other types of outreach," Ms.
Sexton says. "The bottom line is, if it helps the
health of the baby, or the health of an employee or
dependent improves, there will be an overall
reduction in costs."
Insurers who offer both dental and medical-care
coverage say they expect that spending more on
preventive dental care will yield big savings on the
medical treatment of costly chronic illnesses.
Insurers that offer only dental coverage expect to
save money on periodontal surgery. Stand-alone plans
also say they want to be more attractive to workers,
who increasingly have to pay all or part of their
dental-insurance costs themselves as more employers
make group dental a voluntary rather than an
employer-paid benefit.
The emphasis on preventive care is the result of an
increasing number of studies linking oral health to
general health and well being, dental specialists
and insurers say.
The reasons for the connection aren't fully
understood. In the case of preterm births, bacteria
around the tooth root may cause the body to produce
a substance that induces labor. The evidence
suggests that the same bacteria in the mouth can
provoke the body into producing factors that clog
arteries, worsening heart disease and stroke risk.
With diabetes, any inflammation in the body makes
controlling blood sugar more difficult, according to
Kenneth Krebs, president of the American Academy of
Periodontology.
A two-year study of 144,000 insured patients by
Aetna and the Columbia University College of Dental
Medicine released in March found that earlier
periodontal treatment reduced overall medical-care
costs by 9% for diabetes, 16% for coronary artery
disease, and 11% for cerebrovascular disease, or
stroke.
Another recent study of pregnant women with a
serious gum disease published in the Journal of
Periodontology found that early treatment with
scaling and root planing (which removes plaque and
tartar from around the tooth root) reduced preterm
births by 84%. Additional research is under way to
try to explain the association between these
illnesses and periodontal disease.
Gum disease is a common health problem in the U.S.
More than three-quarters of the adult population
over the age of 35 eventually suffer from some type
of it, ranging in severity from inflammation and
sensitivity, to advanced periodontitis, a serious
gum infection that can lead to tooth loss. Some
insures are also now covering topical or injected
antibiotics for gum disease.
In addition to preventive treatments, some insurers
have also begun offering more coverage of costlier
advanced treatments for missing or damaged teeth.
Some employers are looking to offer dental implants
and newer filling materials, say the insurers,
because workers are demanding the latest
technologies. Principal Financial Group Inc. will
introduce new supplemental benefits by mid-2007,
including coverage for dental implants, for
employers who pay for it, according to company
officials.
A number of insurers, such as Guardian Life
Insurance Co. and Cigna, have created new ways for
consumers to increase their coverage limit for
extraordinary expenditures such as root canals and
dentures -- for instance by allowing consumers to
"roll over" unused dental allowance from previous
years. More plans also cover composite or "white"
fillings at the same level as metal fillings, says
Sally Cram, a periodontist in Washington, D.C., and
spokeswoman for the American Dental Association.
Some insurers, including Guardian, Cigna and
Principal Financial Group, are offering to cover
dental implants as an alternative to traditional
partial dentures or bridges. Titanium dental
implants, which are tooth-root replacements
surgically placed in the jaw, have been regarded as
experimental though they have been used for more
than 20 years, and rarely were covered by most
health plans. Many plans have based payments on the
least-expensive treatment that can be used. A single
tooth implant costs $4,000 to $5,000 with surgical
placement and restoration; traditional bridgework to
replace a missing tooth costs about $3,000,
according to Richard Goren, national and group
dental director of Guardian.
But implants are in increasing demand because they
work better for people who have lost bone mass, or
who have only one or two missing teeth, and they
last longer than bridgework, dentists say. "More
than half our new customers [employers] have
requested it since June 2005," says Dr. Goren. Most
insurers that include implants cover them at 50% of
cost, says the American Academy of Implant Dentistry.
Send us your news and stories on access to oral
health care issues for future
Updates.
Send them, in electronic to the
e-mail address below. One or two digital pictures
and/or graphics
are also good.
About Connecticut Oral Health Initiative
The Connecticut Oral Health Initiative, or COHI for
short, is a state-wide collaborative of dental
professionals, business and community leaders. Our
Mission is Oral Health Care for All. We work to
persuade, educate and inform decision makers and the
general public about the important issues involving
oral health. We started in 1992 as a project of the
Connecticut State Dental Association and
incorporated as a separate 501(c)(3) non-profit
corporation in 2003. We are supported by your
tax-deductible contribution and grants from
progressive foundations and businesses.
|
Connecticut Oral Health Initiative
Marty Milkovic
Executive Director
phone:
860-246-COHI (2644)
|
|
|