National Banner 2012 Chess Board
Vol. 3, Issue 10

Find Solutions & Strategies                              March 5, 2012

Workplace FrustrationThe Defense of Intentional Self-Injury

 

Russian Roulette, Workplace Frustration, Accidental Drug Overdose, and More

In This Issue
-INTENTIONAL SELF INJURY
-RESPONSIBLE EMPLOYER
-LARSON'S SPOTLIGHT: Firefighter's Rule, UIM Coverage, Denial of Medical Treatment, Presumption of Compensability
-BLOGS AT THE WCLC: Fraud, California, Delaware, Missouri
-NATIONAL NEWS
-STATE NEWS
-eNEWSLETTER ARCHIVES
A Note From The Editor
Robin Kobayashi 2010

Dear WC Professionals: 

 

To sign up for this free, weekly eNewsletter, email me your full name and email address, along with your request for the National Edition.

 

Sincerely,
Robin E. Kobayashi, JD
LexisNexis Legal & Professional Operations
Employment Law: Cases & Materials, Fifth Edition (2012)
3044 cover

Prof. Steven L. Willborn

Prof. Stewart J. Schwab

Prof. Emeritus John F. Burton, Jr.

Prof. Gillian L.  L. Lester 

 

Law School Educators:

Order Today.

  

* New coverage of Calif. apportionment of wc benefits

* Expanded review of OSHA penalties for job hazards 

* Coverage of dismissal standards

* Integration of new Restatement of Employment Law

intentional self injury

The Defense of Intentional Self-Injury: Russian Roulette, Workplace Frustration, Accidental Drug Overdose, and More. In a few cases, attempts have been made to invoke the intentional self-injury defense when, although the workers obviously did not really intend to harm themselves, their conduct was so rash that the defendants attempted to argue that it was the equivalent of intentional self-injury. Thus, where a grocery store cake decorator developed carpal tunnel syndrome and, following surgery, was told by her doctor not to decorate cakes. but did so at the request of her employer because it was understaffed, the employer could not then say the worsening of her condition was self-inflicted. Probably most people would agree that this decision was correct in rejecting such a fictitious extension of the plain meaning of "intentional." But what if a worker dies playing Russian Roulette? > Read the complete excerpt from Larson's Workers' Compensation Law.

the responsible employer

Longshore RopeResponsible Employer Determination in Cases Involving Multiple Traumatic Injuries: Seeking Analytical Clarity (in Longshore Act Cases), by Yelena Zaslavskaya, Senior Attorney for Longshore, Office of Administrative Law Judges, U.S. Department of Labor. Case precedent prescribes the rules for identifying the responsible employer/carrier in cases potentially involving multiple traumatic injuries or occupational exposures with sequential employers/carriers. It is well-settled that, in cases involving traumatic injuries, the determination of the responsible employer turns on whether the claimant's disabling condition is the result of the natural progression of an initial injury or an aggravation due to a subsequent injury. > Read more

  

Larson's spotlight: firefighter rule

Tom Robinson thumbnail

Firefighter's Rule Did Not Bar Tort Action Against Homeowner, by Thomas A. Robinson.The "firefighter's rule," an important exception to the usual third-party liability rules has arisen over time in a minority of jurisdictions. In those jurisdictions, a firefighter (or other first responder) may not recover in tort from a landowner or occupier who has been negligent in starting or failing to curtail a fire. Absent such a limiting doctrine, the firefighter would ordinarily be able to recover under the "rescue doctrine," initially formulated by Judge Benjamin Cardozo. While acknowledging that the State of New Hampshire followed the minority, fighter's rule, the state high court recently refused to extend the principle to bar a common law negligence action filed by a voluntary firefighter against homeowners for injuries sustained when the firefighter slipped and fell on an icy driveway as he attempted to retrieve a fire extinguisher at the direction of the lieutenant in charge.... > Read more about this case and other noteworthy cases.

blogs at the lexisnexis workers' comp law community

Fraud SignWorkers' Comp Fraud Blotter:  Injured Chef Keeps Cooking Corn For Two More Employers While Disabled, by LexisNexis Workers' Compensation Law Community Staff.  Read it.

 

 

 

Richard JacobsmeyerCalifornia: Labor Code Section 3208.3(h) Applied to Migraine Headaches, by Richard M. Jacobsmeyer, Esq. Read it.

 

 

 

 

Jen Jordan March 2010 thumbnailCalifornia WCMSA Case: Did Clinical Need for Medical Treatment Occur Faster Than CMS Process for Approving Medicare Set-Aside? by Jennifer C. Jordan, Esq. Read it. 


 
 

 

CassandraBody of Evidence: Delaware IAB Rules on Motion to Exclude Findings Gleaned From Covert Autopsy, by Cassandra Roberts, Esq. Read it.

 

 

 

 

CassandraChicken Impossible: Second Time's a Charm for Avian Flu Case in Delaware, by Cassandra Roberts, Esq. Read it.

 

 

 

 

Martin KlugMissouri: Working Doesn't Stop PTD Benefits for Claimant, by Martin Klug, Esq. Read it.

 

  

 

 

Martin KlugMissouri: Chasing Bad Guy Arises Out of Employment, by Martin Klug, Esq. Read it.

 

 
national news
state news

CA: SCIF Board of Directors Approves New Incentive Bonus Program for Employees.

CA: Dept. of Insurance Files Action Against Zurich for Alleged Illegal Agreements.

CA: Arbitrator Hands Victory to Kansas City Chiefs for Ex- Players' Claims Filed in Calif.

CA: WCIRB Launches Workers Comp Inquiry Website.

CA: DLSE Announces Creation of Criminal Investigation Unit.

CA: Possible Cover Up Reported of Former Prosecutor of WC Fraud Cases.

CA: Attorney Scores $8.9M Workers Comp Settlement in Brain Injury Case.

CA: Transsexual Woman Sentenced for Stabbing Attorney in Relation to WC Dispute.

CT: Dept of Labor Issues 19 Work Stop Orders, Collects $250K in Fines.

DE: OWC Reminds Employers to Comply With Employer-Mandated Form.

FL: Large Political Contributions Connected to Fighting Repackaging Drug Bill.

FL: Senate Panel Keeps Repackaging Bill Alive for Now.

FL: Attorney Calls Attention to Questionable Use of Workers Comp Doctors.

FL: DWC Proposes Rule on Out-of-State Employers w/Construction Projects.

ID: Senate Committee Hears Testimony on Firefighters Cancer Presumption Bill.

IL: House Speaker Madigan Introduces Bill to Privatize Workers Comp for State Workers.

IL: Journal Star's WC Series Part 2: Illinois Ranks in Top 3 for High WC Costs.

IL: Journal Star's WC Series Part 3: Companies Moving to Right-to-Work States in South.

IL: IWCC Requires Date of Birth on Application for Adjustment of Claim.

KY: House Committee Approves Two Bills to Fight Drug Abuse.

LA: LWCC Policyholders to Receive $23.5M Dividend for 2011.

LA: HB 959 Would Create Medical Provider Networks (see also SB 560).

LA: SB 602 Would Create Workers Comp Benefits Review Board (see also HB 930).

LA: SB 576 Would Regulate Pro Athletes AWW Determination (see also SB 238; HB 542).

LA: HB 617 Would Provide a Reduction or Offset of Workers Comp for Pro Athletes.

LA: SB 470 Would Charge Employer Costs When Denying Treatment (see also HB 621).

LA: SB 440 Would Require VR Counselor to Verify Each Job Suitable for Disabled Worker.

LA: SB 431 Would Prospectively Apply Medical Treatment Schedule (see also HB 496).

LA: SB 293 Would Give OWC Jurisdiction Over WC Discrimination Claims (see also HB 666).

LA: SB 241 Would Hold Defense Fees in Trust Until Approved by Judge (see also HB 613).

LA: SB 205 Would Allow Captive Insurers to Provide Workers Comp Coverage.

LA: HB 498 Would Provide Access to Data From WC Insurers for Fraud Detection.

MD: HB 616 Would Require WCC to Approve Legal Fee in Specified Cases.

MA: Workers Comp Rates Could Increase Later This Year.

MO: State Auditor Releases Report of Missouri Employers Mutual Insurance.

MO: Arbitrator Hands Victory to Kansas City Chiefs Re Ex- Players' Claims Filed in Calif.

MO: Op-Ed Says State Should Get Out of the Insurance Business Re MEMI.

MO: House Committee Approves SB 572 Occupational Disease Workers Comp Bill.

MT: Jury Finds Montana Power Not Liable in Workers Comp Class Action Lawsuit.

NV: Insurance Commissioner Approves 1 Percent Increase in Workers Comp Loss Costs.

NM: Workers Comp Advisory Council to Hold Public Meeting 5/10/2012.

NM: WCA Accepting IME Provider Applications 3/1/2012 Through 4/30/2012.

OR: DCBS Reports Workplace Deaths on the Decline.

SC: WCC Proposes New Regulation on Mediations.

TX: TDI-TWC Launches Redesigned Home Page Site.

VA: Senate Approves HB153 to Limit Shipyard Workers Comp.

VT: House Committee Hears Testimony on H. 745 Prescription Monitoring System.

WA: L&I Accepting Applications for Statewide Workers Comp Medical Networks for 2013.

1439 2011 Edition
   Order 2011 Edition
Impairment Guides Resource Center
  Access here
4322 4th  Edition

Ohio Workers' Compensation Law

Order Fourth Edition

Top 25 Blogs 2011

View the honorees.

ENEWSLETTER ARCHIVES

Take a deep dive into our past eNewsletters for 2012 and prior...warning - some links to articles may not work...report any linking problems to Robin.E.Kobayashi@lexisnexis.com.

 

February 27, 2012: Workers' Comp Reform: Spotlight on North Carolina.

February 21, 2012: Workers' Comp Reform: Spotlight on Illinois.

February 13, 2012: Exclusivity & Intentional Torts Under LHWCA.

February 6, 2012: Chronic Pain Treatment: New Attitudes and Alternatives.

January 30, 2012: Impact of Workers' Comp Reform: NY and CA.

January 23, 2012: Economic Costs of Occupational Injuries.

January 17, 2012: U.S. Supreme Court Decision on Outer Continental Shelf.

January 9, 2012: Top 10 Bizarre Cases for 2011.

January 2, 2012: 10 Myths and Facts About Workers' Compensation.

ACCESS 2010-2011 ARCHIVES AND ARTICLES LIST HERE.

LexisNexis and the Knowledge Burst logo are registered trademarks of Reed Elsevier Properties Inc., used under license. Other products or services may be trademarks or registered trademarks of their respective companies.

Privacy & Security Copyright © 2012 LexisNexis, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.