Georgia Budget & Policy Institute
This Week in the Georgia Legislature
engraved GA
House and Senate Calendar   
The House and Senate have finished 27 legislative days. The new calendar sets the 30th day (last day for a bill to pass from one chamber to another) on March 25th, and the 31st legislative day scheduled on March 29th. The last nine legislative days have not been scheduled.
The Ever Increasing Budget Shortfall
 
Yesterday the governor lowered the FY 2010 (current fiscal year) revenue estimate by $343 million and the FY 2011 (fiscal year beginning July 1) revenue estimate by $443 million. Due to the lower revenue estimates, moving Recovery Act funds from FY 2011 to FY 2010, and the Governor revising his plan to implement a fee on Hospitals and CMO's, an additional $1 billion shortfall in FY 2011 was created.
 
Revenues in February declined for the 15th consecutive month, 9.9 percent compared to Feburary 2009. Revenues for the first eight months of the fiscal year (FY 2010) are now down 12.7 percent overall compared to the first eight months of last fiscal year (FY 2009). The governor's original FY 2010 Amended Budget revenue estimate is based on a decline of 7.3 percent. 
 
The governor's new revised FY 2010 revenue estimate is based on a 9.3 percent revenue decline. The Governor proposed moving $343 million in ARRA funds previously budgeted in the FY 2011 education agency budgets into FY 2010 to avoid further budget cuts in FY 2010.  This move creates a $343 million hole in the FY 2011 budget.  The Revenue Shortfall Reserve, which is what is typically used at the end of fiscal year to balance the budget, totals only $103 million.  
 
The governor's original FY 2011 revenue estimate projected a 3.9 percent revenue increase over projected FY 2010 revenues. Now, the governor's revised revenue estimate projects a 3.7 percent increase over projected FY 2010 revenues.  
 
Every percentage point revenues come in below the governor's FY 2011 revenue estimate results in a $168 million shortfall.  
 
FY 2011 Additional Shortfall of $1 billion Caused by: 
 
  • Governor reduced FY 2011 General Funds revenue estimate  ($342 million).
  • Governor revised plan to implement new fees on Hospitals and managed care organizations ($345 million).
  • Transfer of Recovery Act funds budgeted in FY 2011 to FY 2010 in order to cover the FY 2010 shortfall ($343 million). 
 
Governor's Proposal to Close Additional $1 billion FY 2011 Shortfall
 
  • Additional budget cuts ($633 million)
    • Education agencies ($243 million)
    • Healthcare ($239 million)
    • All Other Agencies ($151 million)
  • New Revenues ($244 million)
    • Fee Increases ($96 million)
    • Lift sales tax exemption on certain hospitals and non-profit hospitals ($130 million)
    • Payment from Georgia Technology Authority ($18 million)
  • Other Actions ($161 million)
    • Additional Federal Medicaid Funds replace state funds ($84 million)
    • Use Tobacco Funds originally directed to One Georgia Authority to replace state funds in the Low-Income Medicaid program ($47 million)
    • Motor Fuel Funds to replace state funds in Debt Service ($26 million)
 
A more detailed analysis of the Governor's revised revenue estimate and his proposals to close the additional $1 billion shortfall will be released next week.
 
For analysis and fact sheets concerning the Governor's original Amended FY 2010 budget and FY 2011 proposals as well as revenue options please go to www.gbpi.org.
 
Fiscal and Tax Policy 
 
Ways and Means Passes Property Assessment Caps
 
House Resolution 1 passed the Ways and Means Committee on Thursday. The constitutional amendment would restrict growth in property assessments to the lesser of 3% or inflation, based on approval by voters. The Lincoln Institute of Land Policy provides an indepth analysis of the unintended consequences of these assessment caps in other states over the past 30 years. 
 
Transparency for Tax Breaks and User Fees 
 
Senate Bill 206, which would require an accounting of tax breaks currently in the tax code, was recommitted from the House Rules Committee to the House Appropriations Committee this week. The bill passed the Senate unanimously last year. Read GBPI analysis of the topic here.
 
The Senate passed SB 381 on Monday to require an annual report of user fees, with information about what services are covered and the last change to the fee rate. The Department of Audits has found that several fees have not been adjusted in decades. Read GBPI analysis of the topic here.
 
House Bill 1023--The so-called JOBS Act Remains in House Rules
 
House Bill 1023 is almost identical legislation to the so-called JOBS Act the governor vetoed last session. The bill would provide a tax credit for hiring unemployed workers, give a holiday for business filing fees, eliminate the corporate net worth tax, create a $10 million angel investor tax credit, and reduce the tax on capital gains 50 percent.
 
The fiscal note for the bill indicates that the legislation would cause an $18 million drop in State General Fund revenues in FY 2011, growing to a $500 million revenue loss in FY 2013, depending upon the buildup of revenue reserve funds.
 
Proposed Bills Raise Revenue or Improve Fairness 
 
Several bills that would increase revenue or improve fairness are moving through the committee process:
  • HB 928/HR 1109 removes the sales tax exemption from lottery tickets and dedicates the new revenues to K-12 education.
  • HB 1066 adds a temporary, one percent surcharge on income over $400,000.
  • HBs 1065, 1067, and 1068 would temporarily reduce the value of tax credits by 15 percent.
  • HBs 982, 983, 986, 1093, and 1137, among others, improve tax collections through electronic data management, coordinate information sharing between state and local governments, and close a tax loophole.
Additionally, HB 39, which would raise the cigarette tax by $1 a pack, remains active from last session.
 
GBPI Resources About Taxes
Healthcare and Health Insurance Policy
 
Hospital and Managed Care Fees
 
The governor's original FY 2011 budget proposed a 1.6 percent fee on hospitals and managed care providers in Georgia to be directed to the state's Medicaid program. The budget projected $345 million in new revenue from these fees and directed them to 1) increase reimbursement rates paid to hospitals and Care Management Organizations (CMO) serving Medicaid and PeachCare; 2) provide funding to cover increased costs as a result of enrollment growth in FY 2011; and 3) replace one-time funding used in FY 2010 that is no longer available in FY 2011.
 
For more information about the governor's Medicaid budget proposal, including a further discussion of the provider fee proposal, read the Institute's analysis from 2009 and read Senior Healthcare Analyst Timothy Sweeney's testimony before a House subcommittee examining the proposal.

On March 11th, the governor released a revised budget proposal for FY 2011 that does not include the provider fees discussed above. Instead, the governor proposes to eliminate sales tax exemptions currently enjoyed by many hospitals that generates $130 million in new revenues for FY 2011 and makes several adjustments to the Medicaid and PeachCare budgets.

The proposed budget reduces Medicaid and PeachCare spending by $144.3 million by cutting reimbursement rates paid to Medicaid and PeachCare providers by 10.25 percent (excluding nursing homes, home and community based providers, and community mental health services). In addition, the budget eliminates $70.9 million in reimbursement rate increases included in the governor's original FY 2011 proposal that would have been funded with revenue from the originally proposed provider fee.

The new proposal also generates $2.2 million in savings in the PeachCare program by increasing monthly premiums by $5 per month for those currently paying premiums (families with incomes over 150 percent of the federal poverty threshold, or about $27,500 for a family of three). In addition, the governor's proposal assumes $23.6 million in savings by eliminating certain contracts and other efficiencies in DCH.

Finally, the new proposal generates general fund savings by recognizing $84 million in savings as a result of additional federal Medicaid funds available from the Recovery Act and by redirecting $47.1 million in Tobacco Settlement funding originally allocated to the OneGeorgia Account instead to fund the Medicaid program.
 
 
Health Insurance Regulation

 
Senate Bill 407 would allow insurance companies licensed and regulated in other states to sell health insurance policies in Georgia. Under these proposals, out-of-state insurers are exempted from state laws governing required benefits and consumer protections that apply to health insurers licensed in Georgia. This bill was favorably reported out of the Senate Committee on Insurance and Labor on March 9th.
 
SB 330 would eliminate the ability of insurance companies licensed in Georgia to impose lifetime or annual caps on benefits for patients. In addition, the bill would limit the ability of insurers to rescind existing policies or deny services in the case of misstatements or omissions on insurance applications.
 
Finally, the bill would allow dependent children to remain on their parent's health insurance policy through the age of 25, even if the dependent is not a full-time student. (It is likely that the protections added by this bill would not be required of out-of-state policies sold in Georgia under the provisions of SB 407.) This bill was favorably reported out of the Senate Committee on Insurance and Labor on March 9th.

SB 331 would allow small employers with 2 - 50 employees to pool with other small employers to purchase group health insurance policies, and would require all health insurers in Georgia to offer plans -- often called Association Health Plans -- designed for these arrangements. This bill is currently assigned to the Senate Committee on Insurance and Labor.

SB 443 creates a legislative oversight committee to review and evaluate the care management organizations that currently operate a portion of Georgia's Medicaid program. This bill was favorably reported out of the Senate Committee on Health and Human Services on March 10th.

House Bill 1184 differs from SB 407; however, it also seeks to allow insurance products licensed and regulated in other states to be sold in Georgia. This bill represents the governor's proposal and is currently in the Life and Health Subcommittee of the House Committee on Insurance. The bill received an initial subcommittee hearing on March 11th, however no action was taken. It is scheduled for another subcommittee hearing on March 17th.
 
Bills Related to National Health Reform
 
There are several bills and resolutions that seek to assert that Georgia could exempt itself from provisions in national health insurance reform proposals that legislators find objectionable. In particular, SB 317 would make it a state law that Georgians could not be compelled to "participate in any health care system," and that the purchase or sale of health insurance products and/or direct healthcare services could not be prohibited.
 
In addition, SR 794, SR 795, and HR 1086 seek to accomplish the same or similar goals through the constitutional amendment process, and as a result will require two-thirds majority in both the House and Senate to reach the ballot.
 
Although these bills are aimed at provisions in the national health insurance reform proposals in Congress that assess penalties for individuals who do not obtain health insurance (with exceptions related to affordability) through the federal income tax system, it is unclear as to whether these bills would enable Georgians to escape these federal rules if they are enacted.  
 
All of these Senate bills have been favorably reported from the Senate Committee on Insurance and Labor, and HR 1086 has been referred to the House Committee on Health & Human Services.
March 12, 2010
 
Alan's Signature
Please support GBPI's independent legislative analysis by making a tax-deductible gift.
 
 donate
 
"The choices [states] make about how to close those deficits have serious implications ... States that rely primarily on widespread budget cuts are harming residents and businesses that need immediate assistance; they also are reducing demand in the economy and impeding their state's economic recovery ...."
 
Read
the full report by Iris Lav of the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities
 
OP-ED by
Executive Director
Alan Essig
Published in AJC and Savannah Morning News 
 
New GBPI Report by
Sarah Beth Gehl
For more info and reports, please visit:
 
GBPI in the News
 
 Georgia, Oregon Become Economic Test Case 
Atlanta Journal Constitution
  
 
 Column by Jay Bookman of the AJC
 
 Can't Nibble Around the Edges on Revenue  
 
 Editorial Athens Banner-Herald
 
 
Georgia Should Raise its Taxes to Close the Budget Shortfall and Modernize the State  
 
 
The General Assembly and the State's Budget
 
Session 2010 Info:
 
white GBPI logo for footer 
The Georgia Budget and Policy Institute, the state's leading independent, nonprofit, non-partisan organization, seeks to build a more prosperous Georgia. We rigorously analyze budget and tax policies and provide education to inspire informed debate and responsible decision-making, advancing our vision of a state in which economic opportunity and well-being are widely shared among all.