Berman Jewish Policy Archive @ NYU Wagner
Berman Jewish Policy Archive @ NYU WagnerNewsletter
November 2010

Dear Friends,

These past months have seen a great deal of public and Jewish discussion on LGBT issues. There have been political struggles around 'Don't Ask, Don't Tell' and Proposition 8, controversy over the publication of a gay wedding announcement in the New Jersey Jewish Standard, and, tragically, a recent spate of suicides by young men. With the help of some fantastic content-sharing with organizations such as Keshet, the Union for Reform Judaism, TransTorah, and the Institute for Judaism and Sexual Orientation at HUC-JIR, BJPA now contains over 130 documents on LGBT Issues in the Jewish community.

The issue of acceptance and marginalization of Lesbians and Gays has been on the American Jewish agenda for decades. The language of the Reform movement's National Federation of Temple Sisterhoods, the predecessor of Women of Reform Judaism, in their 1965 resolution on Homosexuality is both familiar - strongly resembling the recent Orthodox "Statement of Principles on the Place of Jews With a Homosexual Orientation in Our Community - and jarring : "...homosexuality may be a symptom of psychiatric disturbance which requires sympathetic understanding and psychiatric evaluation...We, therefore, deplore the tendency on the part of community authorities to harass homosexuals." Twenty years later, the Journal of Jewish Communal Service noted that 43% of straight Jews were disturbed by the "rise in visibility of gay Jews," while 49% were not.

In the 1970s and 1980s, communities began to address the religious responses to issues arising from social changes. For example, the Reform movement came down against the formation of Gay and Lesbian congregations (1973) and religious marriage for homosexuals (1985), but in favor of the acceptance of homosexual converts (1982) and in favor of an end to legal discrimination against homosexuals (1977). Our earliest reference to Gay and Lesbian families is a 1986 Reform responsum about the issue of lesbian parents at their child's bar mitzvah.


Starting in the late 70s, more Jewish organizations openly addressed and confronted the challenges brought about by changing social norms. As early as 1976, Chicago's Jewish Family and Community Service took proactive steps to adapt their professional skills and knowledge in response to "changing lifestyles" including an increase in the number of homosexuals seeking counseling. Gerald Bubis included "homophiles" in the category of "experimental families" to be considered in thinking about The Jewish Community Center's Responsibility for the Needs of the Jewish Family (1975). In Resolving Ethical Dilemmas in the Jewish Community Center, Norman Linzer recounts how the Centers came to the conclusion of offering programs "to the families of gays but not for the gays themselves." In 1997, the Journal of Jewish Communal Service explored the Ethics of Gay and Lesbian Adoptions and specifically the question of Jewish children being adopted into gay and lesbian homes. Just last week, Rabbi Shmuley Boteach explored the same question on The Huffington Post.


Several movements and organizations have moved toward greater recognition and acceptance. In 1989, the Union for Reform Judaism's resolution on Gay and Lesbian Jews stated: "Our union of congregations must be a place where loneliness and suffering and exile end." Since then, a growing collection of literature has emerged on how to create inclusive Jewish spaces, from the Jewish Reconstructionist Federation's "Becoming a "Kehillah Mekabelet" (a "welcoming congregation") (1998), to Rabbi Steven Greenberg's Inclusion and Welcoming Criteria for Orthodox Synagogues (2004), TransTorah's Making Your Jewish Congregation or Community More Transgender Friendly and the Union for Reform Judaism's 18 Ways to Make Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender Members Feel Welcome in Your Congregation 

Jewish organizations have also joined in on the political battles around LGBT issues, such as discrimination in the military (1991) and the Boy Scouts (2001). The Jewish community has been a particularly strong voice on the legislation of same-sex civil marriage. The Conservative (2006), Reform (1996), Reconstructionist (2004), and Humanistic (2004) movements have published resolutions in support while the Orthodox Union has consistently expressed concern (1999) and opposition (2006).

In recent years, the community has begun the serious study of Gay and Lesbian Jews as a demographic, a topic I have had the opportunity to explore in my own work, including Gay, Jewish, or Both? Sexual Orientation and Jewish Engagement (2009) and Gays, Lesbians, and the Conservative Movement: The JTS Survey of Conservative Clergy, Students, Professionals, and Lay Leaders (2007). Other key publications on this subject include LGBT Alliance Study: Needs Assessment of the San Francisco Bay Area LGBT Jewish Community (2010) and We Are You: An Exploration of Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender Issues in Colorado's Jewish Community (2006).

Our communities have been and continue to be diverse in composition and in values, but I think that we share a commitment to the sacredness of life. The Berman Jewish Policy Archive @ NYU Wagner has endorsed Keshet's grassroots campaign, "Do Not Stand Idly By: A Jewish Community Pledge to Save Lives," launched in response to the suicides of Raymond Chase (age 19), Tyler Clementi (age 18), Justin Aaberg (age 15), Asher Brown (age 13), and Seth Walsh (age 13). The campaign calls on individuals and organizationt to commit to "ending homophobic bullying or harassment of any kind in our synagogues, schools, organizations, and communities." 

With best wishes,

Prof. Steven M. Cohen
Director, Berman Jewish Policy Archive @ NYU Wagner

Profiling the Professionals: Who's Serving Our Communities?
Earlier this month, BJPA and the JCSA released its new study, "Profiling the Professionals: Who's Serving Our Communities?" This groundbreaking report analyzes results of the first social scientific survey of self-selected Jewish communal professionals in the United States and Canada. In addition to looking at the demographics and attitudes of Jewish communal professionals, the study also highlights the disturbing gender pay inequality in this field.



Some of our newest publications include: 

November 2010 Issue of Sh'ma: A Journal of Jewish Responsibility, The Sh'ma Institute (November 2010)

New Insights on Jewish Political Behavior: What Can We Take Away from the November 2010 Elections? Steven Windmueller (November 2010)

Can the Jewish Community Encourage In-marriage and Welcome Jewish Families? Edmund Case (November 2010)


Resource Guide to the 2010 General Assembly of the Jewish Federations of North America, Berman Jewish Policy Archive (November 2010)


Picking a Needle out of a Haystack: Selecting for Social Entrepreneurs, Joshua Venture Group (November 2010)


Class Divide, by Yehudah Mirsky (November 2010)

AVI CHAI's Next (and last) Ten Years, Yossi Prager (November 2010)


Engaging Jewish Teenage Boys: A Call to Action, Moving Traditions (November 2010)


"doing Jewish stuff" - an Experiment Called Nita, Synagogue 3000 (November 2010) 


Journeys to Israel: the impact of longer-term programs upon Jewish engagement & Israel Attachment, Steven M. Cohen and Ezra Kopelowitz (October 2010)


Peoplehood -- Thin and Strong: Rethinking Israel-Diaspora Relations for a New Century, Yehudah Mirsky (October 2010)


Click HERE for new publications.

Click HERE for latest additions.



Rabbi Dr. Rachel Sabath Beit-Halachmi in conversation with Rabbi Dr. Elliot Cosgrove. Introduction by Rabbi Professor David Ellenson. 

Tuesday November 30, 4:00pm, Puck Building, 295 Lafayette St., 2nd floor. RSVP here.
Jewish spiritual leadership in an age of uncertainty, experimentation, and creativity has led rabbis across the denominational spectrum to seek significant additional training and spiritual development. What role is text study playing in these initiatives and how does it serve the rabbinic soul in our time? What role does scholarship play? Spiritual practice? Political/social action? Given the intensity of these initiatives and their indisputable impact on the rabbi, what is the impact on the communities they serve and on North American Jewry as a whole? 

Bookshelf & Bibliography

The bookshelf allows users to keep a personalized list of BJPA articles to make it easier to return to items of interest. The bibliography function allows users to generate multiple lists of citations, organize them, and share them with others.

Simply register for a account to access these tools. 

BJPA in the Press


And more!

Follow BJPA on Twitter and become our fan on Facebook!

BJPA is funded by the Mandell L. and Madeleine H. Berman Foundation and the Charles H. Revson Foundation.