Dear San Diego Redistricting Commissioners:
I am very concerned about some of the comments that were made by commissioners during the meeting on Saturday 7/9/11. Some of the comments seemed to reflect a lack of respect for or understanding of the requirements of the City Charter and the Voting Rights Act.
City Charter Article II, Section 5 and 5.1, specifically states that:
"Each redistricting plan shall provide fair and effective representation for all citizens of the City, including racial, ethnic, and language minorities, and be in conformance with the requirements of the United States Constitution and Federal statutes."
These are the guiding principles to which the Commission must adhere:
1. The Voting Rights Act CLEARLY requires the Commission to consider race in drawing district lines. The only restraint on that requirement is that race cannot be the only consideration in drawing district lines.
2. The plain language of the City Charter and the legislative history of Section 5 thereof make clear "fair and effective representation for all citizens of the City, including racial, ethnic, and language minorities" is a requirement above and beyond the minimum standards set by the Voting Rights Act.
3. The Commission must give weight and deference to the verbal and written testimony of the hundreds of citizens who have appeared before the Commission. To do otherwise is to make a mockery of the entire process.
The current plan 3 is the plan that most clearly reflects the extensive testimony from communities of interest. It is the plan that is most respectful of the requirements of the Voting Rights Act and the City Charter. This plan is not perfect and needs to be amended, but it is a reasonable and efficient place to begin discussions.
Sincerely,
[Name]
[Address or Neighborhood]
|