Musings for primary teachers

About Me 

October 5, 2010
Dear Colleague,
 
Happy Tuesday! Did you know that you can find original writing tips on the Stenhouse Blog?  I was particularly impressed by this entry from Mark Overmeyer on the importance of teaching writing with joy.  We've all seen the power of joy in the classroom, and it's shared joy that helps build a community of eager, caring, engaged writers.
 
Joyful writing! 
  
 
Jennifer
 
Beware the Adjective

 

On Hand: Chart paper or whiteboard and a marker.

 

Mini-Lesson: "What do you do when students begin to overload their writing with details?" teachers often ask. I find that what primary teachers are referring to when they say "too much description" is frequently an overabundance of adjectives.

            Adjectives are not necessarily details. At times the right adjective can provide the perfect picture: yellow rubber boots, for example, but words like pretty, good, excellent, and awesome create absolutely no picture in our minds at all. I've witnessed many a teacher conduct a word choice lesson that encourages students to retire words like good only to see sentences like these follow:

 

My soccer team is really, really, really awesome!!!!

           

            Model the elimination of vague adjectives (and adverbs) where you can. Project an initial attempt:

 

            My sweet grandmother bakes the most awesome cookies!

 

Remind students of "show, don't tell" and rewrite:

 

"Oh, I'm so glad you're here!" my grandmother says as I walk through her back door. I have no sooner sat down when she puts a plate of chocolate peanut butter cookies down in front of me. I can tell that the centers are gooey and the edges are crisp-just the way I like them. I pick one up and it's still warm.

 

            Discuss the difference between the first sentence and the following paragraph. Point out that awesome doesn't make our taste buds water, whereas words like gooey just might.

 

Extension: Post a list titled "Beware of These Adjectives" and record those that are too general.

 
Adapted from NO MORE "i'M DONE!" FOSTERING INDEPENDENT WRITERS IN THE PRIMARY GRADES.
 
I would love to come to your school!  Please view my website to see if a teacher inservice or residency might fit your staff development needs.
 
I'm available for author visits too.

Writing Tip

It's time to bury the "Said Is Dead" chart

 

Believe it or not, most professional writers wouldn't be caught dead using all those synonyms for said. "The word said is invisible," an editor told me after reading a manuscript of my first picture book, "Use said whenever possible." It is commonly accepted that the overuse of replied, commented, exclaimed, and shouted is a sign of an amateur. (Sometimes beginning writers use synonyms that are terribly unlikely. Try giggling a sentence, for example.) Students will pick up the occasional synonym from their reading (great!) and will from time to time wish to indicate a whisper or a shout, but try not to encourage the scattering of said synonyms.
Quick Links
 
 
 
Join this Mailing List
 
No More I'm Done
 

No More "I'm Done!"  focuses on nurturing independent primary writers.  In addition to suggesting a classroom set-up and routines that support independence, a year of developmentally appropriate minilessons is provided.

Preview the text online here.
 
To listen to a podcast about the book go here.