Monday Musings for primary teachers

About Me 

August 9, 2010
Dear Colleague, 
 

            

 As you will recall from previous newsletters, I use a four-step process when conferencing with students.  I reflect their work back to them, point to what is working well, question students to lead them to new insights, and finally focus on ONE new skill, usually a convention. The skill taught is recorded on the student's checklist with the assumption that he or she will check work and apply the convention before coming to the next conference.

             Why not more than one skill? Because the young student will not retain the teaching, and I am not only wasting his or her time but also depriving the rest of my class of writing instruction.. When observing others' conference, I often detect a moment when the teacher has gone too far. It's the instant when the pencil has magically moved from the child's hand to the teacher's and he or she, sensing time is running out, is making marks all over the paper. The student is watching, but the light has gone out.

 
           In this newsletter,  I answer frequently asked questions about the teaching of conventions in writer's workshop. 
 

 
Happy writing!   
Jennifer

Frequently asked questions

 

Do you ever focus on more than one convention during a conference?

 

            Yes. Before a student takes work to publishing, we'll have an editing conference where we focus only on punctuation, grammar, and spelling. In this instance we will work for as long as the student is engaged and learning. Publishing is a time to celebrate success, so I'm careful not to cross that very fragile line from celebration to discouragement.  Focusing on too many conventions at once, even during an editing conference, can give the student the counterproductive message that writing has a gazillion rules to remember: So why bother?

 
 Do you publish student work with errors?
 
 No. I work with a student until he or she runs out of steam.  Then we'll publish the work with all errors corrected.
 

Consider setting up an area in your room where you (or better yet, a parent or high school volunteer) can work with individual students. The volunteer sits at the computer, and the child sits next to the volunteer and read his or her work. Volunteers (who you have trained) type the work using all of the proper conventions: punctuation, spelling, capitalization, proper grammar-keeping the child's original language whenever possible. If while reading, the student says, "Oh, I should have said . . ." The volunteer types what the child wished he or she written, thus reinforcing revision right up to the end.

            What do you do with the typed work? Here is a list of ideas:

 

1.       Place in a class anthology (3-ring binder with page protectors to hold published work.)

2.       Mount on a bulletin board

3.       Read over the intercom

4.       Include in school or class newsletters

5.       Post on a Web site

6.       Have child read in a podcast

7.       Record (audio or video) a class radio show

8.       Perform as a skit

9.       Read at an authors' tea

10.   Compile a class book around a single theme (poems, funny stories, holiday stories, etc.)

11.   Include in a class yearbook

12.   Include in the school literary magazine

13.   Submit to a student market or contest

14.   Give as a gift

 
 Do you ever teach conventions to the whole class?
 

 Yes.  We focus on conventions each and every day when reviewing the morning message. If you missed it, you can read my process for morning meeting and the daily message in the July 12 newsletter (archived newsletters can be accessed here).  Additionally, I teach occasional mini-lessons on conventions that many of the students are ready to grasp. I also recommend the use of formal spelling programs.  To read more about the teaching of spelling (and how to help students apply what they're learning, check out this blog post.

 

 

 

 

 

 

     Adapted from the upcoming study gudie for No More "I'm Done!" Fostering Independent Writers in the Primary Grades  by Jennifer Richard Jacobson

 

    

Writing Tip

 
Why is that we always focus on what's missing when it comes to conventions instead of what the student has done properly?  Next time you're conferencing with a student, give the student a "pat on the back" for each capital letter and end punctuation mark remembered.  Before long your students will be striving to get as many pats as possible.
Quick Links
 
 
 
Join this Mailing List
 
No More I'm Done
 

No More "I'm Done!"  focuses on nurturing independent primary writers.  In addition to suggesting a classroom set-up and routines that support independence, a year of developmentally appropriate minilessons is provided.

Preview the text online here.
 
To listen to a podcast about the book go here.
Response to Fiction

Have you seen this series?