Monday Mini-Lesson for primary teachers

About Me 

May 3, 2010
Dear Colleague,
 
Happy May!  We'll turn our attention now to sentence fluency -- a trait I believe is frequently misunderstood.  Sentence fluency is not about writing complete sentences, it is about writing sentences that sound wonderful to the ear -- sentences that sing!
 
Teaching sentence fluency at the primary grades (particularly kindergarten and grade 1) can be tricky business.  Many lessons in sentence fluency rightfully focus on using a variety of sentence beginnings, and sentence lengths, when most of our students have just begun to understand what a sentece is! (How many first grade teachers have asked students to number their sentences only to watch them place one number at the beginning of each line on the paper!)
 
But here is a favorite lesson that truly helps students grasp the goal of sentence fluency.  And as with all traits, they will be able to tell you whether or not it is present in sample texts. When we provide lessons like this one, we are giving our students an essental vision of success.
 
Happy writing!
 
Jennifer
 
 
P.S   Have you visited the blog Two Writing Teachers? It 's one of my all-time favorites! You can imagine how honored I was then  to be interviewed by Stacey Shubitz, one of the writing teachers, this week!

A Sweet Sounding Train

 

On Hand: Two samples of your own writing, one that lacks fluency and one that sings. (Write each sentence on a separate line so beginnings can be compared.)

 

Mini-Lesson: Project the writing sample that lacks fluency. Here is my example:

 

I have two little dogs.

They are named Kenzie and Hattie.

They are fun to walk.

They like to eat treats.

 

            Tell students that this first attempt at writing chugs along like a slow-moving train-one that's about to break down. Have students bend their arms at the elbow and, moving them simultaneously, imitate that old nearly broken-down train: "Chug . . . chug . . . chug . . ." Show them that this writing "chugs" because almost every sentence begins with the same word and all of the sentences are the same length. (Have students count the words in the sentence with you.)

            Now project your second piece of writing. Here is mine:

 

I have two little dogs name Kenzie and Hattie.

They're fun to walk in the park.

After they've zipped around, saying hello to all the  other dogs, they bounce back to me for a treat.

 

Ask students, "Which of these pieces sounds better to the ear?" Guide them to understand that the varied beginnings and sentence lengths help to make the second piece more pleasant sounding. When writing is fluent, tell them, it sounds like a steady moving train. Have them imitate the melodious sounds of a smooth running train: "Clickerty, clickerty, clack, clickerkty, clickerty. clack . . . " or even, "Cha-ch-sh, Cha-ch-sh, Cha-ch-sh . . ."

            Suggest they try to write sentences that flow like a sweet sounding train.

 

 

Extension: Read a book with train sound effects, such as The Train Goes . . . by William Bee (2007). Discuss the fluency of this text:

Here is the school class off on a trip,

and the children yell,

'Please, sir, please, ma'am . . . are we there yet?'

 

  Adapted fromNo More "I'm Done!" Fostering Independent Writers in the Primary Grades  by Jennifer Richard Jacobson
Writing Tip 
Before coming to a writing conference, ask students to read their writing aloud.   They can read it to themselves, a class mascot, or a friend.  "Whisper phones" (pvc pipes) also work well.  When students read their work aloud, they not only edit, they hear the musicality (or lack of musicality) in their sentences.  During the conference ask, "Which of your sentences really sings?"
Quick Links
 
 
 
Join this Mailing List
 
No More I'm Done
 

No More "I'm Done!"  focuses on nurturing independent primary writers.  In addition to suggesting a classroom set-up and routines that support independence, a year of developmentally appropriate minilessons is provided.

Preview the text online here.
 
To listen to a podcast about the book go here.
 
If you love this:
 
Reproducible Graphic Organizers  You're going to love this even more!
 
Graphic Organizers for Interactive White Board 
 
Same book but with a Smartboard disk!