Leg Update head
Week of June 22, 2009 )
In this issue
  • Budget and Appropriations
  • ED Hosts Stakeholder Meeting
  • In Brief
  • Legislative Update, a weekly publication of ASCA, provides an executive summary of public policy issues affecting American education. This publication contains links to Internet sites for the convenience of World Wide Web users. ASCA is not responsible for the availability or content of these external sites, nor does ASCA endorse, warrant or guarantee the information, services, or products described or offered at these other Internet sites. ASCA is the school counseling division of the American Counseling Association.

    Please note, there will be no Legislative Update next week while ASCA staff is at the annual conference.


    Budget and Appropriations

    The House of Representatives also spent time last week debating the emergency supplemental war bill. Securing enough votes for passage after several months of contentious wrangling between Congress and the White House was considered a victory for House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) and the president. The bill moved to the Senate and was quickly adopted on Thursday, following a week of very public disagreements about provisions that apparently were resolved to most everyone's satisfaction. As is often the case, the disagreements had little to do with the substance of the legislation. Members argued about funding for the International Monetary Fund, the release of more controversial war photos and $1 billion for a so-called "cash for clunkers" bill designed to help struggling car dealers reduce their inventory.

    Also in the Senate, members met on Thursday afternoon to announce the 302B allocations for the 12 appropriations subcommittees in that chamber. This action tells subcommittee chairs how much money they have to divvy up among federal agencies. The Senate Labor, Health and Human Services and Education Subcommittee allocation of $163.1 billion was somewhat higher than the amount provided to its House counterpart, but writing a bill that satisfies Congress and the White House will remain a challenge. There simply will not be enough money to fund new priorities promoted by the president and preserve popular programs the president wants to eliminate but that enjoy support from legislators.

    Progress on the budget front was overshadowed by a mark-up of health care reform legislation in the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions (HELP) Committee. This was a highly partisan event as the Congressional Budget Office announced that the cost of the health care reform bill before the committee would approach a staggering $1.5 trillion and only increase the number of covered individuals by approximately 16 million. The House Education and Labor Committee had its own controversies to contend with as it spent the week working hard at drafting reconciliation legislation that will revamp the federal student loan program.

    Also of interest to education advocates was the selection of Rep. John Kline (R-Minn.) as the new ranking Republican on the House Education and Labor Committee. Kline is a staunch conservative who strongly supports full funding for special education and the expansion of charter schools. He is serving his fourth term in Congress, having been a consultant, a farmer and a member of the Marine Corps before his election to the House of Representatives.

    ED Hosts Stakeholder Meeting

    The Department of Education invited education stakeholders to a meeting last week to discuss progress on several initiatives, plans for coming weeks and months and to introduce the senior leadership of the department to the community.

    Secretary of Education Arne Duncan welcomed the group with remarks similar to those of recent months on the "unique opportunity" in front of education reformers before introducing his chief of staff, Margot Rodgers, who then introduced the agency's senior staff. Joe Conaty, director of the academic improvement and teacher quality programs in the Office of Elementary and Secondary Education, then gave the group an update on the Department of Education's progress to date on distribution of the funds made available for education in the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act.Those in the audience who had hoped for details around guidance and plans for awarding Race to the Top and the What Works and Innovation Funds beyond the ED press release from earlier in the week were disappointed. ED plans to hold similar stakeholder meetings monthly and promised more detail on those awards at the July meeting.

    Conaty did say that regarding the State Fiscal Stabilization Funds (SFSF), 41 states have applied, 32 applications have been approved, and ED expects to receive remaining applications by the July 1 deadline. As these applications are approved, they are posted on ED's Web site. He noted that of the SFSF funds going to states for education, states are investing 80 percent of the money they receive in K-12 education and 20 percent in higher education, on average. He also told attendees to expect a significant volume of notices and guidance to become available on ED's Web site in coming days and weeks.

    Carmel Martin, assistant secretary for planning, evaluation and policy development, gave the audience a broad overview of ED's FY 2010 budget request and the department's plans for reauthorization of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act. She said that ED leadership and allies on Capitol Hill are working toward enactment of a new bill by the end of the 111th Congress. She and her colleagues urged the stakeholders in the room to meet with ED and Hill staff to convey their concerns and recommendations as Duncan and his team, as well as long-time career staff at the agency, work to "raise the bar and close the gap at the same time." More info.

    In Brief

    Duncan Announces Funds for States to Develop Assessments Linked to Standards and Race to the Top Fund Timeline: On June 15, Secretary of Education Arne Duncan gave his second of four major policy speeches on the priorities for the Race to the Top Fund. During his speech to the nation's governors, Duncan announced that the Department of Education will commit up to $350 million of the Race to the Top Fund to support states in the creation of "rigorous assessments linked to the internationally benchmarked common standards being developed by states." He also applauded the 46 states and three territories that recently agreed to develop common standards as a means to prepare American students to compete and succeed in the global market place. Duncan will give two more major policy speeches leading up to the request for proposals. Duncan also announced that the Race to the Top Fund grants will be made in two rounds, which will allow states that miss the first round to reapply. In late July, the Department of Education will publish a notice of proposed rulemaking, inviting public comment for 30 days on the proposed grant application and evaluation criteria. In October, a notice inviting applications will be published in the Federal Register, and the first phase of applications will be due in December, with grants awarded in March 2010. In June 2010, the second phase of applications will be due, and grants will be awarded in September 2010. More info.

    AIR Releases Report on International Benchmarking: On June 16, the American Institutes for Research (AIR) released a new report, "The Second Derivative: International Benchmarks in Mathematics for U.S. States and School Districts." The report presents a new grading index that allows states and school districts to rank students with international peers using an easily comprehensible grading system. Dr. Gary Phillips, AIR vice president, outlined how the index was created, the findings and the implications for further research. This new indexing crosswalks scaled scores on well-known international tests of knowledge in mathematics, such as the Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study (TIMSS) and the Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA), to the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) test commonly used in the United States. By converting data reported on these three measures to well-understood letter grades scores of A, B, C, D and E, Phillips attempts to make this information more widely accessible to policymakers, educators, parents and students themselves. The news for the United States remains alarming, regardless of the reporting system. Fourth-graders in only a handful of states received a grade of B or B- when compared with students internationally. Moving to eighth-grade scores, grades for this same handful of states dropped to a C for all states except Massachusetts. Read the full report.

    Gates Enters the Post-secondary Realm: On June 16, the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation and the Library of Congress hosted a policy forum, "Beyond Access: Groups Unite to Put Completing College on the National Agenda." The event's purpose was to announce the Gates Foundation's new focus on ensuring post-secondary education results in a degree or certificate with genuine economic value. According to Hilary Pennington, director of education, postsecondary initiatives in the foundation's U.S. program, policy makers at the local, state and national levels need to focus on college success and not just college access. She highlighted the grim statistics that only about half of college students in the U.S. graduate within six years. The rate for low-income students is closer to 25 percent, and only about 20 percent of African American and Hispanics aged 25-34 have earned some kind of post-secondary degree. As a result, the foundation has set its goal "to help the nation double the number of low-income adults who earn postsecondary degrees or credentials by age 26 in order to gain employment that will adequately support their families." Joining in the discussion were new Gates' grantees: the American Enterprise Institute, The Center for American Progress, the Center for Law and Social Policy, The College Board, Excelencia in Education, and the Institute for Higher Education Policy. All these national organizations argued that college graduation rates must be considered in the context of a school's admission criteria and that institutions of higher education must do more to meet the needs of nontraditional students and first-generation families. While there is broad agreement that the cost of post-secondary education is a huge factor, the new Gates grantees argue it may not be the most important factor. Gates' efforts will initially be aimed at strengthening policies and practices across the range of post-secondary institutions that enroll the most low-income and minority students. In addition to focusing on improving the performance of the post-secondary education system, supporting young adult success and encouraging U.S. leaders to commit to helping students complete their degrees, Gates will also remain committed to improving and increasing data and information and supporting innovation to help transform the system. More info.

    DLC Hosts Discussion on Education Reform: The Democratic Leadership Council (DLC) hosted a panel discussion on education reform on June 17. Rahm Emanuel, White House chief of staff, gave opening remarks and highlighted President Obama's education and health care reform agendas. Emanuel called education reform a "quiet revolution" and said he believes the community college system is essential to getting more students through the higher education system and into high-quality jobs. Emanuel also strongly emphasized the president's commitment to early childhood education and preparatory education. Rep. Artur Davis (D-Ala.) agreed with Emanuel, saying, "The only consistent conveyer belt in American life that can take you from one class to another is the public education system." He believes that the "conveyer belt" has been under stress from the rising cost of a college education, the rising dropout rate and the increasing achievement gap between the races. Davis argued that successful education reform needs innovative ideas that are discussed and financed, saying, "New money simply cannot be thrown at an old problem." Harold Ford, DLC chairman, urged Americans to be open to the idea of charter schools. He expressed his hope that schools look to other schools, including charter schools, as role models and adopt the reforms and best practices that are working. Joe Williams, executive director of Democrats for Education Reform, agreed and said reform is happening and the administration is quietly redefining the role that the federal government will play in education reform. View a video of the discussion.

    CEP Releases Report on Student Achievement: On June 17, the Center on Education Policy (CEP) released its latest report on achievement since the enactment of No Child Left Behind (NCLB), "State Test Score Trends Through 2007-08 Part I: Is the Emphasis on 'Proficiency' Shortchanging Higher- and Lower-Achieving Students?" Jack Jennings, CEP founder, said this report is the first part of this year's version of the longitudinal study of state test scores and focused on: (1) if student achievement has increased under NCLB and (2) if NCLB is shortchanging high- and low-achieving students. CEP will release six more reports addressing other issues in the coming months. The report examines the math and reading achievements of students in elementary, middle and high school who are categorized by their states as "basic-and-above," "proficient-and-above" and "advanced." Findings show that under NCLB student achievement is increasing in all subjects, grade levels and achievement levels, although "proficient-and-above" students are improving slightly more than students in the other two groups. Jennings said that while it is possible this gap in improvement is because high- and low-achieving students are not receiving as much attention as their proficient peers from their teachers, statistical uncertainty precludes a definitive conclusion of whether high- and low-level students are being shortchanged. View the full report.

    HOPE Holds Global Financial Literacy Summit: Operation HOPE held its first Global Financial Literacy Summit in Washington, D.C., on June 17, bringing representatives together from around the world to discuss the importance of financial literacy during the current global economic crisis. As one of the world's largest nonprofit organizations committed to spreading financial literacy and helping to economically empower underserved communities, Operation HOPE held the summit to "promote financial literacy as a global civil right that can empower people worldwide and stabilize the global economy." Among the summit's many events, a "Global Town Hall" was held to discuss financial literacy models from around the world, as well as various views on the importance and methods of implementing financial literacy programs. Additionally, a briefing was held on "Financial Literacy and the Education System; Making Education Aspirationally Relevant." During this briefing, panelists representing various organizations and interest groups discussed the methods being used to spread the important message of financial literacy to elementary, secondary and higher education students and teachers. Panelists emphasized the importance of partnerships between the government and private institutions and encouraged educators to combine financial literacy with activities relating to kids' interests. The panelists also lauded the work done by the President's Advisory Council on Financial Literacy and recommended that it be charged with the task of developing a relevant financial literacy curriculum for teachers. More info.

    AACTE Hosts Briefing on Teacher Preparation Reform: On June 18, the American Association of Colleges for Teacher Education (AACTE) held a congressional briefing, "Innovation and Reform in Teacher Preparation." During the briefing, panelists examined new approaches in higher education and at the state level to recruit and train highly effective teachers. Lynne Weisenbach, vice chancellor of the P-16 initiatives for the Board of Regents of the University System of Georgia, discussed two of Georgia's successful innovations, including leveraging Web-based teaching and creating a residency program for teachers. Patricia Wasley, dean of the College of Education at University of Washington, discussed the National Assessment of Teacher Performance's assessment process, which contains three sub-assessments, allowing reviewers to determine how a new teacher works with children, with subject matter, and with disabled and ELL students. Mayra Bravo-Gonzalez, a teacher candidate in the Grow Your Own (GYO) Illinois program, stressed the importance of the GYO program in generating a diverse teaching workforce that wants teachers to remain in their communities. More info.

    New Publications and In the News

    Email Marketing by