A Market-Based Agenda for Louisiana Property Insurance Reform
Heartland Institute and Pelican Institute Offer Recommendations for 2010
New Orleans, LA -
March 30, 2010
Even in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina, Louisiana
has managed to retain a reasonably healthy private
insurance industry. Almost five years after Katrina's
landfall, insurance has remained available--although
expensive--in the state. Unlike Florida to its east and
Texas to its west, Louisiana has steered a moderate,
common-sense course in dealing with insurance. New
carriers writing property insurance have entered the
state, and even though Louisiana was the site of the
nation's largest natural disaster, premiums are actually
lower than in Florida or Texas.
Governors Kathleen Blanco and Bobby Jindal and
Insurance Commissioner James Donelon deserve
credit for this. Without leaving individuals in the lurch
or forcing homeowners of modest means to go without
insurance, they have implemented largely successful
reforms that have brought insurers back into the state.
Whereas major national insurance carriers have
withdrawn or cut back in states such as Florida and
Mississippi, they continue to do business in Louisiana.
Several serious problems remain, however, and elected
and appointed officials throughout Louisiana should set
their sights on solving them. Three stand out:
1. Louisiana Citizens Property Insurance Corporation, a
state-run entity that sells insurance, is the third-largest
entity of its type and did not shrink during 2009. Its
existence and size mean a significant number of people
simply cannot find private market insurance coverage. It
exposes the state to billions of dollars in potential liability.
2. By many accounts, there are insufficient incentives for
shrinking Louisiana Citizens. In many cases, agents and
private insurers are happy to allow people to remain in
Louisiana Citizens.
3. The state's property insurance rates, averaging
roughly $1,400 per year for residences, are the third
highest in the United States.
About the Pelican Institute for Public Policy
The Pelican Institute for Public Policy is a nonprofit,
nonpartisan research institute dedicated to the
principles of individual liberty, the free market and
limited, accountable government. Through research
papers, policy briefings, commentaries and
conferences, the Institute seeks to educate and inform
Louisiana's policymakers, news media and general
public.